Protospacer Adjacent Motif Recognition Research Articles

Why Does the E1219V Mutation Expand T-Rich PAM Recognition in Cas9 from Streptococcus pyogenes?

Popular RNA-guided DNA endonuclease Cas9 from Streptococcus pyogenes (SpCas9) recognizes the canonical 5'-NGG-3' protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) and triggers double-stranded DNA cleavage activity. Mutations in SpCas9 were demonstrated to expand the PAM readability and hold promise for therapeutic and genome editing applications. However, the energetics of the PAM recognition and its relation to the atomic structure remain unknown. Using the X-ray structure (precatalytic SpCas9:sgRNA:dsDNA) as a template, we calculated the change in the PAM binding affinity in response to SpCas9 mutations using computer simulations. The E1219V mutation in SpCas9 fine-tunes the water accessibility in the PAM binding pocket and promotes new interactions in the SpCas9:noncanonical T-rich PAM, thus weakening the PAM stringency. The nucleotide-specific interaction of two arginine residues (i.e., R1333 and R1335 of SpCas9) ensured stringent 5'-NGG-3' PAM recognition. R1335A substitution (SpCas9R1335A) completely disrupts the direct interaction between SpCas9 and PAM sequences (canonical or noncanonical), accounting for the loss of editing activity. Interestingly, the double mutant (SpCas9R1335A,E1219V) boosts DNA binding affinity by favoring protein:PAM electrostatic contact in a desolvated pocket. The underlying thermodynamics explain the varied DNA cleavage activity of SpCas9 variants. A direct link between the energetics, structures, and activity is highlighted, which can aid in the rational design of improved SpCas9-based genome editing tools.

Molecular basis and engineering of miniature Cas12f with C-rich PAM specificity.

CRISPR-Cas12f nucleases are currently one of the smallest genome editors, exhibiting advantages for efficient delivery via cargo-size-limited adeno-associated virus delivery vehicles. Most characterized Cas12f nucleases recognize similar T-rich protospacer adjacent motifs (PAMs) for DNA targeting, substantially restricting their targeting scope. Here we report the cryogenic electron microscopy structure and engineering of a miniature Clostridium novyi Cas12f1 nuclease (CnCas12f1, 497 amino acids) with rare C-rich PAM specificity. Structural characterizations revealed detailed PAM recognition, asymmetric homodimer formation and single guide RNA (sgRNA) association mechanisms. sgRNA engineering transformed CRISPR-CnCas12f1, which initially was incapable of genome targeting in bacteria, into an effective genome editor in human cells. Our results facilitate further understanding of CRISPR-Cas12f1 working mechanism and expand the mini-CRISPR toolbox.

Engineering a Streptococcus Cas9 Ortholog with an RxQ PAM-Binding Motif for PAM-Free Gene Control in Bacteria.

The RNA-guided Cas9 endonucleases have revolutionized gene editing and regulation, but their targeting scope is limited by the protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) requirement. The most extensively used SpCas9 from Streptococcus pyogenes recognizes the NGG PAM via an RxR PAM-binding motif within its PAM-interaction (PI) domain. To overcome the strict PAM requirement, we identified and characterized a Cas9 ortholog from Streptococcus equinus HC5 (SeHCas9) that shows high sequence identity with SpCas9 but harbors a different RxQ PAM-binding motif. Complete PAM profiling revealed that SeHCas9 recognized an NAG PAM and accommodated NKG and NAW PAMs. We investigated the PAM interaction mechanism by identifying the crucial role of R1336 within the RxQ motif in determining PAM specificity, as well as the essentiality of two conserved residues (R1152 and Q1229) across Cas9 orthologs bearing the RxQ motif for PAM recognition. Further protein engineering created two variants, SeHdCas9-Q1229R and SeHdCas9-RR, that showed robust repression across an NNG and NNN PAM range, respectively. Our work proposes a novel Cas9 PAM interaction mechanism and establishes PAM-free Cas9 variants for bacterial gene control with almost no targeting restriction.

The construction of a PAM-less base editing toolbox in Bacillus subtilis and its application in metabolic engineering

The necessity of a specific protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) greatly limited the editing scope and the application range of Cas9-dependent base editors. Here, we showed that SpRY breaks the PAM recognition barrier in Bacillus subtilis with a preference toward NRN than NYN while the PAM specificity is slightly distinct from other organisms. We developed a highly efficient PAM-less base editing toolbox for B. subtilis based on a variant of Cas9 nickase, nSpRY, yielding PAM-less adenine and/or cytosine base editors (PLABE/PLCBE/PLACBE) for A-to-G and/or C-to-T conversions. The conversion efficiency was optimized to 100% at high-activity sites and the editing window was refined to 1–2 nucleotides at pre-selected sites. Multiplexed editing for double, triple, and quadruple genes was validated simply by one cycle of editing. As a proof of concept, PLCBE was utilized to introduce premature stop codons for yielding gene knockouts and PLABE was applied to change start codons from ATG to GTG for realizing translation control. A website was designed to accelerate the inactivation of any genes of interest in B. subtilis by incorporating PAM specificity information for identifying the high-efficiency sites. Facilitated by multiplexed PAM-less editing, we successfully obtained a diversified library of strain variants for chemical production with multi-level regulations in central and competing metabolism pathways. We recruited this library to modulate metabolic fluxes in B. subtilis, achieving up to a 26.3% increase in acetoin production with a final titer of 20.8 g/L in shake-flask fermentation. By enabling in situ base editing of nearly all As and Cs in the Bacillus genome, this toolbox shows great potential in applications of metabolic engineering and codon expansion.

Anti-CRISPR AcrIIC5 is a dsDNA mimic that inhibits type II-C Cas9 effectors by blocking PAM recognition.

Anti-CRISPR proteins are encoded by phages to inhibit the CRISPR-Cas systems of the hosts. AcrIIC5 inhibits several naturally high-fidelity type II-C Cas9 enzymes, including orthologs from Neisseria meningitidis (Nme1Cas9) and Simonsiella muelleri (SmuCas9). Here, we solve the structure of AcrIIC5 in complex with Nme1Cas9 and sgRNA. We show that AcrIIC5 adopts a novel fold to mimic the size and charge distribution of double-stranded DNA, and uses its negatively charged grooves to bind and occlude the protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) binding site in the target DNA cleft of Cas9. AcrIIC5 is positioned into the crevice between the WED and PI domains of Cas9, and one end of the anti-CRISPR interacts with the phosphate lock loop and a linker between the RuvC and BH domains. We employ biochemical and mutational analyses to build a model for AcrIIC5's mechanism of action, and identify residues on both the anti-CRISPR and Cas9 that are important for their interaction and inhibition. Together, the structure and mechanism of AcrIIC5 reveal convergent evolution among disparate anti-CRISPR proteins that use a DNA-mimic strategy to inhibit diverse CRISPR-Cas surveillance complexes, and provide new insights into a tool for potent inhibition of type II-C Cas9 orthologs.

De novo PAM generation to reach initially inaccessible target sites for base editing.

Base editing by CRISPR crucially depends on the presence of a protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) at the correct distance from the editing site. Here, we present and validate an efficient one-shot approach termed 'inception' that expands the editing range. This is achieved by sequential, combinatorial base editing: de novo generated synonymous, non-synonymous or intronic PAM sites facilitate subsequent base editing at nucleotide positions that were initially inaccessible, further opening the targeting range of highly precise editing approaches. We demonstrate the applicability of the inception concept in medaka (Oryzias latipes) in three settings: loss of function, by introducing a pre-termination STOP codon in the open reading frame of oca2; locally confined multi-codon changes to generate allelic variants with different phenotypic severity in kcnh6a; and the removal of a splice acceptor site by targeting intronic sequences of rx3. Using sequentially acting base editors in the described combinatorial approach expands the number of accessible target sites by 65% on average. This allows the use of well-established tools with NGG PAM recognition for the establishment of thus far unreachable disease models, for hypomorphic allele studies and for efficient targeted mechanistic investigations in a precise and predictable manner.

Identification of SaCas9 orthologs containing a conserved serine residue that determines simple NNGG PAM recognition.

Due to different nucleotide preferences at target sites, no single Cas9 is capable of editing all sequences. Thus, this highlights the need to establish a Cas9 repertoire covering all sequences for efficient genome editing. Cas9s with simple protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) requirements are particularly attractive to allow for a wide range of genome editing, but identification of such Cas9s from thousands of Cas9s in the public database is a challenge. We previously identified PAMs for 16 SaCas9 orthologs. Here, we compared the PAM-interacting (PI) domains in these orthologs and found that the serine residue corresponding to SaCas9 N986 was associated with the simple NNGG PAM requirement. Based on this discovery, we identified five additional SaCas9 orthologs that recognize the NNGG PAM. We further identified three amino acids that determined the NNGG PAM requirement of SaCas9. Finally, we engineered Sha2Cas9 and SpeCas9 to generate high-fidelity versions of Cas9s. Importantly, these natural and engineered Cas9s displayed high activities and distinct nucleotide preferences. Our study offers a new perspective to identify SaCas9 orthologs with NNGG PAM requirements, expanding the Cas9 repertoire.

Structural insights into target DNA recognition and cleavage by the CRISPR-Cas12c1 system.

Cas12c is the recently characterized dual RNA-guided DNase effector of type V-C CRISPR-Cas (clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats and CRISPR-associated protein) systems. Due to minimal requirements for a protospacer adjacent motif (PAM), Cas12c is an attractive candidate for genome editing. Here we report the crystal structure of Cas12c1 in complex with single guide RNA (sgRNA) and target double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) containing the 5'-TG-3' PAM. Supported by biochemical and mutation assays, this study reveals distinct structural features of Cas12c1 and the associated sgRNA, as well as the molecular basis for PAM recognition, target dsDNA unwinding, heteroduplex formation and recognition, and cleavage of non-target and target DNA strands. Cas12c1 recognizes the PAM through a mechanism that is interdependent on sequence identity and Cas12c1-induced conformational distortion of the PAM region. Another special feature of Cas12c1 is the cleavage of both non-target and target DNA strands at a single, uniform site with indistinguishable cleavage capacity and order. Location of the sgRNA seed region and minimal length of target DNA required for triggering Cas12c1 DNase activity were also determined. Our findings provide valuable information for developing the CRISPR-Cas12c1 system into an efficient, high-fidelity genome editing tool.

Molecular Mechanism of D1135E-Induced Discriminated CRISPR-Cas9 PAM Recognition.

The off-target effects of Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (SpCas9) pose a significant challenge to harness it as a therapeutical approach. Two major factors can result in SpCas9 off-targeting: tolerance to target DNA-guide RNA (gRNA) mismatch and less stringent recognition of protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) flanking the target DNA. Despite the abundance of engineered SpCas9-gRNA variants with improved sensitivity to target DNA-gRNA mismatch, studies focusing on enhancing SpCas9 PAM recognition stringency are quite few. A recent pioneering study identified a D1135E variant of SpCas9 that exhibits much-reduced editing activity at the noncanonical NAG/NGA PAM sites while preserving robust on-target activity at the canonical NGG-flanking sites (N is any nucleobase). Herein, we aim to clarify the molecular mechanism by which this single D1135E mutation confers on SpCas9 enhanced specificity for PAM recognition by molecular dynamics simulations. The results suggest that the variant maintains the base-specific recognition for the canonical NGG PAM via four hydrogen bonds, akin to that in the wild type (WT) SpCas9. While the noncanonical NAG PAM is engaged to the two PAM-interacting arginine residues (i.e., R1333 and R1335) in WT SpCas9 via two to three hydrogen bonds, the D1135E variant prefers to establish two hydrogen bonds with the PAM bases, accounting for its minimal editing activity on the off-target sites with an NAG PAM. The impaired NAG recognition by D1135E SpCas9 results from the PAM duplex displacement such that the hydrogen bond of R1333 to the second PAM base is disfavored. We further propose a mechanistic model to delineate how the mutation perturbs the noncanonical PAM recognition. We anticipate that the mechanistic knowledge could be leveraged for continuous optimization of SpCas9 PAM recognition specificity toward high-precision demanding applications.

Expanding PAM recognition and enhancing base editing activity of Cas9 variants with non‐PI domain mutations derived from xCas9

The recognition of protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) is a key factor for the CRISPR (i.e. clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats)/CRISPR-associated 9 (Cas9) system to distinguish foreign DNAs from the host genome, and also significantly restricts the targeting scope of the system during genome-editing applications. Structurally, the PAM interacting (PI) domain, which usually is located in the C-terminus of Cas9 proteins, directly binds to PAM and plays a key role in determining the recognition specificity. However, several lines of evidence showed that other regions of Cas9 protein beyond the PI domain might also play roles in PAM interaction. Here, we constructed a mosaic SpCas9 protein (xCas9-NG) by fusing the PI domain of SpCas9 PAM variant, Cas9-NG with the non-PI fragment of xCas9 protein that contains multiple amino acid substitutions. We found that non-PI fragment of xCas9 expanded PAM recognition of the Cas9-NG PI domain. In addition, xCas9-NG showed an improved editing efficiency in the majority of targets harboring xCas9 and Cas9-NG PAMs. Importantly, this finding was also successfully extended to other Cas9 variants, including SpRY and the non-G SpCas9 series. Together, our work expands the target scope of SpCas9 editing system and demonstrates the notion that the non-PI domain fragment plays an important role in PAM restriction.

CABE-RY: A PAM-flexible dual-mutation base editor for reliable modeling of multi-nucleotide variants

Multi-nucleotide variants (MNVs) represent an important type of genetic variation and have biological and clinical significance. To simulate MNVs, we designed four dual-mutation base editors combining hA3A(Y130F), TadA8e(V106W), and protospacer adjacent motif (PAM)-flexible SpRY and selected cytosine and adenine base editor-SpRY (CABE-RY), which had the best editing performance, for further study. Characterization and comparison showed that CABE-RY had a smaller DNA editing window and lower RNA off-target edits than the corresponding single base editors. Thus, we have established a versatile tool to efficiently simulate MNVs over the genome, which could be very useful for functional studies on MNVs in humans.

Structure-based optimization and design of CRISPR protein xCas9

Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (SpCas9) has become a powerful genome editing tool, but has a limited range of recognizable protospacer adjacent motifs (PAMs) and shows off-target effects. To address these issues, we present a rational approach to optimize the xCas9 mutant derived from SpCas9 by directed evolution. Firstly, energy minimization with the Rosetta program was applied to optimize the three-dimensional structure of Cas9 to obtain the lowest energy conformation. Subsequently, combinatorial mutations were designed based on the mutations sites of xCas9 acquired during the directed evolution. Finally, optimal mutants were selected from the designed mutants by free energy ranking and subjected to experimental verification. A new mutant yCas9 (262A/324R/409N/480K/543D/694L/1219T) with multiple PAM recognition ability and low off-target effects was obtained and verified by DNA cleavage experiments. This mutant recognizes the NG, GAA and GAT PAMs and shows low off-target DNA cleavage activity guided by mismatched sgRNA, thus provides a gene editing tool with potential applications in biomedical field. Furthermore, we performed molecular dynamics simulations on the structures of SpCas9, xCas9 and yCas9 to reveal the mechanisms of their PAM recognition and off-target effects. These may provide theoretical guidance for further optimization and modification of CRISPR/Cas9 proteins.

SpRY greatly expands the genome editing scope in rice with highly flexible PAM recognition

BackgroundPlant genome engineering mediated by various CRISPR-based tools requires specific protospacer adjacent motifs (PAMs), such as the well-performed NGG, NG, and NNG, to initiate target recognition, which notably restricts the editable range of the plant genome.ResultsIn this study, we thoroughly investigate the nuclease activity and the PAM preference of two structurally engineered SpCas9 variants, SpG and SpRY, in transgenic rice. Our study shows that SpG nuclease favors NGD PAMs, albeit less efficiently than the previously described SpCas9-NG, and that SpRY nuclease achieves efficient editing across a wide range of genomic loci, exhibiting a preference of NGD as well as NAN PAMs. Furthermore, SpRY-fused cytidine deaminase hAID*Δ and adenosine deaminase TadA8e are generated, respectively. These constructs efficiently induce C-to-T and A-to-G conversions in the target genes toward various non-canonical PAMs, including non-G PAMs. Remarkably, high-frequency self-editing events (indels and DNA fragments deletion) in the integrated T-DNA fragments as a result of the nuclease activity of SpRY are observed, whereas the self-editing of SpRY nickase-mediated base editor is quite low in transgenic rice lines.ConclusionsThe broad PAM compatibility of SpRY greatly expands the targeting scope of CRISPR-based tools in plant genome engineering.

The molecular basis for recognition of 5\u2032-NNNCC-3\u2032 PAM and its methylation state by Acidothermus cellulolyticus Cas9

Acidothermus cellulolyticus CRISPR-Cas9 (AceCas9) is a thermophilic Type II-C enzyme that has potential genome editing applications in extreme environments. It cleaves DNA with a 5′-NNNCC-3′ Protospacer Adjacent Motif (PAM) and is sensitive to its methylation status. To understand the molecular basis for the high specificity of AceCas9 for its PAM, we determined two crystal structures of AceCas9 lacking its HNH domain (AceCas9-ΔHNH) bound with a single guide RNA and DNA substrates, one with the correct and the other with an incorrect PAM. Three residues, Glu1044, Arg1088, Arg1091, form an intricate hydrogen bond network with the first cytosine and the two opposing guanine nucleotides to confer specificity. Methylation of the first but not the second cytosine base abolishes AceCas9 activity, consistent with the observed PAM recognition pattern. The high sensitivity of AceCas9 to the modified cytosine makes it a potential device for detecting epigenomic changes in genomes.

A catalogue of biochemically diverse CRISPR-Cas9 orthologs

Bacterial Cas9 nucleases from type II CRISPR-Cas antiviral defence systems have been repurposed as genome editing tools. Although these proteins are found in many microbes, only a handful of variants are used for these applications. Here, we use bioinformatic and biochemical analyses to explore this largely uncharacterized diversity. We apply cell-free biochemical screens to assess the protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) and guide RNA (gRNA) requirements of 79 Cas9 proteins, thus identifying at least 7 distinct gRNA classes and 50 different PAM sequence requirements. PAM recognition spans the entire spectrum of T-, A-, C-, and G-rich nucleotides, from single nucleotide recognition to sequence strings longer than 4 nucleotides. Characterization of a subset of Cas9 orthologs using purified components reveals additional biochemical diversity, including both narrow and broad ranges of temperature dependence, staggered-end DNA target cleavage, and a requirement for long stretches of homology between gRNA and DNA target. Our results expand the available toolset of RNA-programmable CRISPR-associated nucleases.

Catalytic-state structure and engineering of Streptococcus thermophilus Cas9

Cas9 nucleases recognize and cleave their target DNA through base pairing of a guide RNA with a spacer adjacent to a protospacer adjacent motif (PAM). Streptococcus thermophilus Cas9 (St1Cas9), a smaller Cas9 orthologue than Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9, enables robust genome editing in diverse organisms. Here we report high-resolution structures of St1Cas9 in complex with a single-guide RNA and different PAM-containing DNAs. All of the structures represent an HNH catalytic state that is rarely observed in other Cas9 structures, clearly depicting the active conformation. A unique wing region in the REC domain forms intensive interactions with the HNH domain, playing a key role in regulating St1Cas9 DNA cleavage activity and probably stabilizing the active conformation. Furthermore, St1Cas9 applies a strategy distinct from those of other Cas9 orthologues for PAM recognition. Structure-guided engineering of St1Cas9 substantially expanded its targeting scope. These molecular-level characterizations will facilitate the rational engineering of St1Cas9. CRISPR–Cas9 systems have revolutionized the field of genome editing. This work reports rare structures of a Cas9 enzyme (St1Cas9) in its HNH catalytic state, providing mechanistic insights related to DNA recognition and cleavage, and structure-guided engineering is used for expansion of the PAM recognition.

Efficient Multiplex Genome Editing in Streptomyces via Engineered CRISPR-Cas12a Systems.

Streptomyces strains produce a great number of valuable natural products. With the development of genome sequencing, a vast number of biosynthetic gene clusters with high potential for use in the discovery of valuable clinical drugs have been revealed. Therefore, emerging needs for tools to manipulate these biosynthetic pathways are presented. Although the clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats/CRISPR-associated protein 9 (CRISPR/Cas 9) system has exhibited great capabilities for gene editing in multiple Streptomyces strains, it has failed to work in some newly discovered strains and some important industrial strains. Additionally, the protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) recognition scope of this system sometimes limits its applications for generating precise site mutations and insertions. Here, we developed three efficient CRISPR-FnCas12a systems for multiplex genome editing in several Streptomyces strains. Each system exhibited advantages for different applications. The CRISPR-FnCas12a1 system was efficiently applied in the industrial strain Streptomyces hygroscopicus, in which SpCas9 does not work well. The CRISPR-FnCas12a2 system was used to delete large fragments ranging from 21.4 to 128 kb. Additionally, the CRISPR-FnCas12a3 system employing the engineered FnCas12a mutant EP16, which recognizes a broad spectrum of PAM sequences, was used to precisely perform site mutations and insertions. The CRISPR-FnCas12a3 system addressed the limitation of TTN PAM recognition in Streptomyces strains with high GC contents. In summary, all the CRISPR-FnCas12a systems developed in this study are powerful tools for precise and multiplex genome editing in Streptomyces strains.

A Cas9 with PAM recognition for adenine dinucleotides

CRISPR-associated (Cas) DNA-endonucleases are remarkably effective tools for genome engineering, but have limited target ranges due to their protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) requirements. We demonstrate a critical expansion of the targetable sequence space for a type II-A CRISPR-associated enzyme through identification of the natural 5^{prime}-NAAN-3^{prime} PAM preference of Streptococcus macacae Cas9 (SmacCas9). To achieve efficient editing activity, we graft the PAM-interacting domain of SmacCas9 to its well-established ortholog from Streptococcus pyogenes (SpyCas9), and further engineer an increased efficiency variant (iSpyMac) for robust genome editing activity. We establish that our hybrids can target all adenine dinucleotide PAM sequences and possess robust and accurate editing capabilities in human cells.

PAM recognition by miniature CRISPR-Cas12f nucleases triggers programmable double-stranded DNA target cleavage.

In recent years, CRISPR-associated (Cas) nucleases have revolutionized the genome editing field. Being guided by an RNA to cleave double-stranded (ds) DNA targets near a short sequence termed a protospacer adjacent motif (PAM), Cas9 and Cas12 offer unprecedented flexibility, however, more compact versions would simplify delivery and extend application. Here, we present a collection of 10 exceptionally compact (422–603 amino acids) CRISPR–Cas12f nucleases that recognize and cleave dsDNA in a PAM dependent manner. Categorized as class 2 type V-F, they originate from the previously identified Cas14 family and distantly related type V-U3 Cas proteins found in bacteria. Using biochemical methods, we demonstrate that a 5′ T- or C-rich PAM sequence triggers dsDNA target cleavage. Based on this discovery, we evaluated whether they can protect against invading dsDNA in Escherichia coli and find that some but not all can. Altogether, our findings show that miniature Cas12f nucleases can protect against invading dsDNA like much larger class 2 CRISPR effectors and have the potential to be harnessed as programmable nucleases for genome editing.

A Cas12a ortholog with stringent PAM recognition followed by low off-target editing rates for genome editing

BackgroundAsCas12a and LbCas12a nucleases are reported to be promising tools for genome engineering with protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) TTTV as the optimal. However, the C-containing PAM (CTTV, TCTV, TTCV, etc.) recognition by Cas12a might induce extra off-target edits at these non-canonical PAM sites.ResultsHere, we identify a novel Cas12a nuclease CeCas12a from Coprococcus eutactus, which is a programmable nuclease with genome-editing efficiencies comparable to AsCas12a and LbCas12a in human cells. Moreover, CeCas12a is revealed to be more stringent for PAM recognition in vitro and in vivo followed by very low off-target editing rates in cells. Notably, CeCas12a renders less off-target edits located at C-containing PAM at multiple sites compared to LbCas12a and AsCas12a, as assessed by targeted sequencing methods.ConclusionsOur study shows that CeCas12a nuclease is active in human cells and the stringency of PAM recognition could be an important factor shaping off-target editing in gene editing. Thus, CeCas12a provides a promising candidate with distinctive characteristics for research and therapeutic applications.