In photosystem II (PSII), D1-Tyr246 and D2-Tyr244 are symmetrically located at the binding site of the bicarbonate ligand of the non-heme Fe complex. Here, we investigated the role of the symmetrically arranged tyrosine pair, D1-Tyr246 and D2-Tyr244, in the function of PSII, by generating four chloroplast mutants of PSII from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: D1-Y246F, D1-Y246T, D2-Y244F, and D2-Y244T. The mutants exhibited altered photoautotrophic growth, reduced PSII protein accumulation, and impaired O2-evolving activity. Flash-induced fluorescence yield decay kinetics indicated a significant slowdown in electron transfer from QA•− to QB in all mutants. Bicarbonate reconstitution resulted in enhanced O2-evolving activity, suggesting destabilization of bicarbonate binding in the mutants. Structural analyses based on a quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical approach identified the existence of a water channel that leads to incorporation of bulk water molecules and destabilization of the bicarbonate binding site. The water intake channels, crucial for bicarbonate stability, exhibited distinct paths in the mutants. These findings shed light on the essential role of the tyrosine pair in maintaining bicarbonate stability and facilitating efficient electron transfer in native PSII.