Protective Services Research Articles

Navigating the labyrinth: exploring the experiences of Roma families with child protection services

This article presents findings regarding the experiences of Roma families interacting with child protection services. Using a mixed-methods approach grounded in critical realism, the research team explored the complex dynamics that shape these interactions. The study adopts a critical stance on child welfare, moving beyond dominant individualistic and risk-averse narratives to emphasise the need for contextualising child protection within a broader socio-economic and cultural landscape. Findings reveal that Roma families engaging with child protection services must navigate a labyrinthine institutional environment rooted in Anglocentric values often ill-equipped to support minoritised populations. These interactions, deeply entrenched in socio-economic disparities and cultural biases, routinely place Roma families in adversarial positions with state agents. Rather than being isolated incidents, these systemic barriers exacerbate the already challenging circumstances faced by Roma families.

Importance of Community Context in Understanding Substance Use Among Adolescents With Allegations of Maltreatment

This study examined the association between community disadvantage and substance use among adolescents referred to child protective services (CPS) and the interaction role of race/ethnicity in the association between community disadvantage and adolescent substance use. Findings revealed that higher county-level alcohol/drug mortality rates were associated with a higher risk of substance use across non-Hispanic Black, non-Hispanic white, and Hispanic adolescents. An interaction test showed that the association between county-level alcohol/drug mortality rates and risk of substance use was particularly stronger for non-Hispanic Black adolescents compared to non-Hispanic white adolescents. However, county-level vacant housing rates and low median household income did not show a significant association with adolescent substance use across all racial/ethnic groups. Results suggest that practitioners should screen for community-level substance risk levels to prevent substance use among historically marginalized racial-ethnic adolescents involved in CPS.

Tiaki Taoka, designing a Kāi Tahu Māori organisation to work with child protection

In 2019 Aotearoa New Zealand added an amendment to the child protection legislation that required the state to partner with Māori. This paper looks at a case study of the development of one of the services developed under the legislative amendment. Section 7 AA, Tiaki Taoka. Tiaki Taoka was designed as a Māori service response for Kāi Tahu, the iwi, tribe of the greater area of Te Waipounamu (the South Island). The service was mandated by Kāi Tahu and funded through the state to provide partial child protection services devolved from the state. The design was “by Māori, for Māori and of Māori” culturally nuanced in Kāi Tahu knowledge and experience. The co-design of the service model, Te Rereka Toroa, with Kāi Tahu community is shared alongside important relational work with the child protection system, Oranga Tamariki. Tensions in Māori and state relationships are provided with a critique on the maintenance of power and control by the colonial state and the current political challenges.

Occurrence of plant-parasitic nematodes on rice (Oryza sativa) in Kenya with a focus on Hirschmanniella oryzae

Summary Rice ranks as the third most important staple cereal food crop in Kenya, following maize and wheat. The demand for rice has been increasing at a faster rate than most cereals, occasionally requiring imports to meet local needs. In response, the Kenyan government has been implementing a programme to increase rice production by expanding irrigated lowland rice schemes from 32 988 to 171 676 ha, while increasing rain-fed upland production areas four-fold to 42 000 ha by 2030. However, with continued rice monocropping in irrigated lowland fields and intensification in rain-fed upland ecosystems, there is a growing concern that plant-parasitic nematodes may emerge as a significant problem across rice ecosystems. This study characterised the nematode genera associated with rice in Kenya and assessed their diversity and distribution across rice ecosystems, with a focus on Hirschmanniella species. Eleven nematode genera were identified in both ecosystems, indicating a relatively high diversity. These genera, ranked by prominence, included Hirschmanniella, Hoplolaimus, Pratylenchus, Helicotylenchus, Meloidogyne, Ditylenchus, Trichodorus, Xiphinema, Rotylenchus, Longidorus and Paratylenchus. The family Tylenchidae was also found to be an important component of the nematofauna. Both morphological and molecular analyses confirmed the presence of Hirschmanniella oryzae in irrigated lowland and rain-fed upland rice, which represents the first documented report for Kenya. A notably large molecular variation was also observed for these Kenyan populations on the 18S region, with intraspecific variation up to 10 bp difference. Understanding the diversity, distribution, and species composition of nematodes in rice ecosystems is important for raising awareness among plant protection services, farmers, cooperatives and extension agents about plant-parasitic nematodes and their challenges in rice production. Future research should build on this knowledge to support extensive studies on population dynamics and damage threshold, focusing on local rice cultivars to develop effective management strategies, including breeding programmes and other cultural practices.

VIOLÊNCIA SEXUAL CONTRA CRIANÇAS E ADOLESCENTES: O OLHAR DA PSICOLOGIA SOB O VIÉS SOCIAL

Taking into account that sexual violence against children and adolescents in addition to the emotional and psychological damage constitutes a violation of this public duty, this study aims to point the psychologist in the psychosocial care of child and adolescent victims of sexual violence. Among the specific objectives, present concepts related to the phenomenon of violence, highlighting its main characteristics, type, statistics in order to highlight one of its forms, sexual violence against children and adolescents; Identify significant psychological harm of sexual violence process in childhood and adolescence; Characteristic of the social psychology emphasizing how was the insertion of psychologists in social protection services. The methodology is bibliographical, from the Virtual Library database in Health Psychology (BVS-Psi), in addition to statistical sources, books and technical guidance documents to professional psychology. It is concluded that the look of psychology under the psychosocial bias shows that the psychologist in cases of sexual violence against children and adolescents is not based solely on psychic phenomena, but through joint work with the Social Protection Service, the psychologist seeks to understand the breaks these subjects and meet their needs through psychosocial approach as well, through the implementation of strategies aimed at minimizing the damage suffered, restore ties and prevent occurrences.

Risk factors for unintentional injury hospitalisation among Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal children in Australia's Northern Territory: A data linkage study.

Unintentional injuries are a leading cause of hospitalisation for children. This study investigated the incidence and associated risk factors for unintentional injury hospitalisation (UIH) among Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal children aged under 5 years in Australia's Northern Territory. This was a retrospective cohort study using linked data from a perinatal register, hospital admissions, school enrolment and child protection services. The outcome variable was a first UIH. Potential risk factors included gender, pregnancy and birth outcomes, maternal education level, child protection service contact and geographic remoteness. Modified Poisson regression was used for multivariate modelling. A cohort of 21,189 children (54.0% Aboriginal) born between 2000 and 2010 were followed to the age of 5 years. The overall incidence of first UIH was 25.8 per 1,000 person-years, which was 28.6% higher among Aboriginal than non-Aboriginal children (28.8 and 22.4 per 1000 person-years, respectively). Risk factors identified in the full model included: being male (incidence rate ratio (IRR) 1.26, 95%CI: 1.17-1.36); living in a remote (IRR 1.26, 95%CI: 1.14-1.40) or very remote area (IRR 1.44, 95%CI: 1.29-1.59); having a notification or substantiated notification for abuse (IRR 1.42, 95%CI: 1.27-1.58 and IRR 1.60, 95%CI: 1.41-1.82, respectively); or neglect (IRR 1.32, 95%CI: 1.17-1.48 and IRR 1.28, 95%CI: 1.11-1.47, respectively). After adjustment, there was no difference in UIH rates between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal children. In both stratified models, being male, living in remote or very remote areas and having a notification or substantiated notification for child maltreatment were identified as risk factors. Our study found high UIH incidence rates and evidence for an association between UIH and child maltreatment. This suggests child maltreatment and UIH have shared determinants and points to the need for clinicians to be aware of the overlap between these conditions and the importance of cross-agency collaboration in prevention and management.

Beyond child abuse: the array of family problems brought to the child welfare system

ABSTRACT The majority of children referred to child protective services (CPS) system are not suspected of physical or sexual abuse but face other risks, often captured under neglect. This population-based study analyzed data for 145,745 children referred to the Pennsylvania’s child welfare system in 2021. Parental substance use (28%), child behavioral concerns (24%), and unmet material needs (23%) were the most common allegations. Half of referrals included multiple concerns, but only 34% were valadated, indicating service intervention. Child behavioral health was the most frequent standalone concern (14%). Increasing access to mental health and substance use treatment may reduce CPS referrals.

Transforming learning for adult protective services caseworker certification training: program evaluation of simulation training

ABSTRACT This study assesses the first statewide program to provide simulation training conducted via videoconference to all new caseworkers. The simulation training in Illinois was conducted at a mock house. A mock family played by standardized clients is physically present, and trainees participate remotely. The program evaluation team implemented a survey that asks trainees to rate their confidence in different skills at multiple timepoints, to appraise the quality of feedback and debriefing of the training team, and to write text responses to the questions regarding their learning experience. Analysis of quantitative data over the course of the training showed statistically significant linear increases in trainees’ confidence for all the 14 skills. Their text responses indicated that they received feedback they appreciated and felt they gained ability on a range of different skills. The simulation training makes a valued and effective contribution to the certification training.

The Three-Dimensional Chess for Parents Facing a Child Protective Services Investigation: Navigating the Child Welfare Exception to the Constitution

The Three-Dimensional Chess for Parents Facing a Child Protective Services Investigation: Navigating the Child Welfare Exception to the Constitution

BIDIRECTIONAL ASSOCIATIONS BETWEEN WELL-BEING AT SCHOOL, PSYCHOSOCIAL PROBLEMS AND PTSS IN CHILDREN EXPOSED TO FAMILY VIOLENCE

BackgroundChildren exposed to family violence are more likely to have lower well-being at school, more psychosocial problems and more post-traumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) than children not exposed. ObjectiveWe examined whether well-being at school, psychosocial problems, and PTSS affect each other over time in children exposed to family violence. Participantsand Setting: 332 Dutch children aged 8-17 years exposed to family violence (and their parents) who were reached through child protection services (CPS). MethodsParticipants completed questionnaires on well-being at school, psychosocial problems, PTSS, and family violence shortly after being reported to CPS and again one year later. A cross-lagged panel model was conducted to examine the relationships between well-being at school, psychosocial problems, and PTSS over time. FindingsPTSS at Time 1 predicted psychosocial problems at Time 2 (β = .14, p < .05), no other cross-lagged effects were significant. Lower well-being at school was concurrently associated with more psychosocial problems and more PTSS at both time points, and more psychosocial problems was also concurrently associated with more PTSS at both occasions. ConclusionMore PTSS in children exposed to violence appears to be related to more psychosocial problems one year later. The concurrent associations between lower well-being at school, more psychosocial problems and more PTSS at both time points, suggest that these aspects do not appear to be independent, but rather interrelated and co-developing over time. The results highlight the importance of paying attention to children’s well-being at school among children exposed to family violence.

Analysis Of Mental Health Services For Child Victims Of Sexual Violence At The Integrated Service Center Of The Department Of Women's Empowerment And Child Protection Of Labuhan Batu Selatan Regency

Background: Sexual violence is any act carried out with the aim of obtaining sexual acts or other acts directed at a person's sexuality using coercion regardless of their relationship status with the victim..Objectives: analyzing Mental Health Services for Child Victims of Sexual Violence at the Integrated Service Center of the Women's Empowerment and Child Protection Service of South Labuhan Batu Regency.Research method: This research is a qualitative descriptive research. This research was conducted qualitatively.Results: The results of this study are From the results of the study conducted by the researcher that the form of mental health services applied at the integrated service center for women's empowerment and child protection in South Labuhan Batu Regency is the approach and assistance model, From the results of the study conducted by the researcher that the mental health service model applied at the integrated service center for women's empowerment and child protection in South Labuhan Batu Regency is individual counseling and the results of the study conducted by the researcher with respondents that the factors that influence the mental health of children who are victims of sexual violence at the Integrated Service Center for Women's Empowerment and Child Protection in South Labuhan Batu Regency are the emergence of feelings of shame and not wanting to socialize with their surroundings

Enhancing Climate Resiliency Through Improving Ecosystem Services in Shoreline Municipalities – Lessons from Canada

The accelerated impacts of climate change in waterfront areas and the proven inefficacy of the aging hardened shoreline infrastructure have driven shoreline management practices to evolve toward the enhancement of ecosystem services at the land-water interface. Gaining momentum as an adaptive approach in regenerative projects, living shorelines are comprised of natural ecosystem components used in combination or in place of traditional hard engineering methods to provide coastal protective services and erosion mitigation. The success of living shorelines in protecting shoreline property and ecosystem integrity varies based on the biogeomorphology and hydrology of the region and is also heavily reliant on social acceptance of the chosen approach and best practice for implementation. The relatively lower lifecycle cost and associated co-benefits of living shorelines have well positioned them as a promising alternative approach in theory. There are, however, gaps in regional long-term datasets and evidence-based guidelines. This research provides an overview of the underlying geopolitical readiness for integrating nature-based solutions in climate adaptation strategies within shoreline municipalities based on a comprehensive literature review complimented by expert interviews. The synthesized data can inform decisions for minimizing the destructive effects of traditional shoreline erosion prevention approaches and encourage successful implementation of solutions that offer ecological, health, social, and economic benefits.

Analisis Perlindungan Hukum Terhadap Anak Korban Kekerasan Seksual di Dinas Pemberdayaan Perempuan dan Perlindungan Anak Kota Tanjungbalai

The aim of this research is to find out how the Office of Women's Empowerment and Child Protection has attempted to implement legal protection in accordance with Law Number 35 of 2014 concerning Amendments to Law Number 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection against cases of sexual violence against children, as well as to find out efforts made by the Tanjung Balai City Women's Empowerment and Child Protection Service to help child victims of sexual violence. This research was conducted at the Women's Empowerment and Child Protection Service in Tanjungbalai City, North Sumatra. The method used in this research is a qualitative descriptive research method. The qualitative descriptive method has the main characteristics, namely conducting research involving direct involvement in the field, acting as an observer, creating categories of actors, observing phenomena, recording them in an observation book, not manipulating variables, and focusing on scientific observation. The data collection technique used to obtain data is through interviews and documentation. The results of this research found that the efforts of the Tanjung Balai City Women's Empowerment and Child Protection Department have been running optimally, in accordance with Law Number 35 of 2014 concerning Amendments to Law Number 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection against cases of sexual violence against children. The form of legal protection used is in the form of preventive and repressive legal protection. One of the programs being implemented is synchronizing and coordinating the prevention of violence against children, which is expected to reduce the number of cases of sexual violence against children in Tajung Balai City.

Evaluating bias of child maltreatment referrals in encounters for unintentional ingestions

BackgroundUnintentional ingestions commonly result in presentation to the pediatric emergency department (PED). No standardized recommendations exist regarding when to call Child Protective Services (CPS) for unintentional ingestions, which allows for the possibility of biased decision-making. ObjectiveIdentify patient and visit level characteristics associated with CPS referral status in unintentional ingestion encounters. Participants and SettingRetrospective cross-sectional study of children ≤6 years old presenting with unintentional ingestion to a metropolitan PED from 2015 to 2021. MethodsICD-10-CM codes were used to identify unintentional ingestion visits in the electronic health record. CPS referral was determined by manual chart review. Bivariable and multivariable logistic regression models identified patient and visit level characteristics associated with CPS referral. Socioeconomic status (SES) was classified based on zip code, the Child Opportunity Index data, and insurance. ResultsOf 3,836 charts reviewed, 808 met inclusion criteria. CPS referrals were made in 109 (13.5%) visits. Compared to non-Hispanic white patients, non-Hispanic Black patients had 7.37 (95% CI:1.38, 39.26) higher adjusted odds of being referred to CPS after adjusting for triage level, age, and ingestion type. Patients in the Lowest SES group had a 3.01 (95% CI:1.42, 6.40) higher adjusted odds when compared to the Middle/Highest SES group. ConclusionThis study found that CPS referrals in unintentional ingestions occur more often in those identifying as non-Hispanic Black and in those in the Lowest SES group, suggesting clinician bias may impact the decision regarding referrals. To mitigate subjective decision-making, we propose creating standardized, objective CPS referral criteria for unintentional ingestions.

Associations between child protective services workers’ attitudes toward kinship foster care placement, sociodemographic characteristics, and job characteristics

ABSTRACT When necessary to separate children from their parents, placing a child with kin leads to better outcomes. Child Protective Services (CPS) staff attitudes toward kinship foster care placements are an understudied factor that may influence decision-making and vary based on staff characteristics. Using February 2023 survey data from 2,861 CPS staff and multivariate linear regression analyses, we assessed associations between staff’s sociodemographic and occupational characteristics and attitudes toward kinship placement. Gender, race, position, work unit, and employment duration with CPS were significantly associated with staff attitudes. Understanding how staff view kinship placement is an important step toward removing barriers to its use.

Agency support for at-risk families: service provision, challenges and effective elements for intervention

ABSTRACT There is an urgent need to locate effective interventions for parents involved with child protection services (CPS), Oranga Tamariki in Aotearoa New Zealand. This article describes a qualitative research study that sought to understand: (1) the nature of service provision to families; (2) workers’ perceptions of challenges and effective treatment components in delivering intervention; and (3) effective practices for working with Māori. Participants were staff members working within NGOs, providing interventions to families with ongoing Oranga Tamariki involvement. Data comprised responses to semi-structured interviews (n = 9), interpreted using thematic analysis. Findings highlighted that all participants worked within family homes to deliver intervention, and drew on Te Whare Tapa Whā. Challenges included ongoing child maltreatment concerns and participants’ sense of responsibility for keeping children safe whilst being unable to do so adequately within their non-mandated roles. Perceived effective elements were: strong relationships, transparency, and having courageous conversations when needed. For indigenous clients, self-determination and the effects of colonisation were of prime importance. Themes highlighted responsive practice, with a pragmatic understanding that family priorities may not always align with professional views. This is consistent with international findings regarding challenges in delivering parenting interventions and identifies potential essential components for effective practice. HIGHLIGHTS Practitioners’ perceptions of essential elements to effective practice included: strong relationships, honesty, reciprocity, and directness regarding child protection concerns. Effective practices seen to be particular to working with Māori families were trusting, reciprocal relationships and ensuring self-determination and autonomy. Ethical tensions and a sense of complicity and helplessness at times were described, with ongoing child protection concerns evident during intervention for some families. Practitioners took a holistic approach to their work, expressing non-judgment, sympathy for, and understanding of the complex circumstantial and personal challenges faced by Oranga Tamariki-involved parents. Glossary of Māori terms: awhi: embrace, cherish; kaimahi: staff members; kanohi ki te kanohi: face to face; karakia: blessing; kaupapa Māori: Māori approach; kete: basket; kōrero: to speak; mana: prestige; manaakitanga: hospitality; mana whenua: people with rights over the land; marae: meeting house; Pākehā: New Zealander of European descent; pepeha: introduction; pēpi: baby; pono: true; pōwhiri: welcome ceremony; tamariki: children; tangata: people; tika: correct; tikanga: custom; tutū: mischevious; waiata: song; whakapapa: genealogy; whānau: family; whanaungatanga: relationship; whare: house.

Maternal Downward Neighborhood Income Mobility and Newborn Discharge to Child Protective Services

This cohort study examines whether there is an association between a mother moving into a neighborhood with lower income between births and newborn custody by child protective services at birth.

Gendered administrative burden: regulating gendered bodies, labor, and identity

Abstract Gendered burdens are experiences of coercive and controlling state actions that directly regulate gendered bodies, labor, and identity. Burdens are not simply about preventing access to rights and benefits, they're about control and coercian. Gendered burdens generate gender inequality through four mechanisms. First, administrative burdens regulate reproductive bodies, legitimating the state’s direct control over reproductive health care, including abortions, with consequent implications for peoples’ health. Second, burdens require reproductive labor, shifting unpaid and underpaid reproductive labor onto women as the policies that support such labor tend to have high administrative burdens that impede access. Third, gendered burdens restrict reproductive labor, impeding the right to provide such care labor with dignity, by exerting control over how, and sometimes whether, care is performed, including in rights-granting venues, like redistributive benefits, and rights-depriving venues, like the supervision of families by child protective services. Fourth, burdens regulate gendered identities, reinforcing heteronormative and cis-normative constructions of gender, including by directly controlling gender identification. While gendered burdens are not only experienced by women, they are most strongly applied to poor and racially marginalized groups of women. These claims provide a basis for public administration scholarship to connect with feminist theory by illustrating the centrality of administrative processes and related experiences to structural patterns of inequality.

23 Probing bias: Understanding the experiences of Black, Indigenous and People of Colour (BIPOC) caregivers for children with developmental disabilities and their involvement with child protection

Abstract Background In Canada and abroad, a disproportionate number of Black Indigenous and Persons of Colour (BIPOC) experience referral to child protective services (CPS). Children with developmental disabilities, including Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD) and intellectual disabilities (IDD), are also disproportionately CPS-involved. Recent Canadian research has suggested that almost a quarter of children from a complex care paediatric program are CPS-involved, however there is no known research for ASD/IDD populations seen in a general paediatric clinic. Further, intersections of race/ethnicity and ASD/IDD and CPS involvement have not been examined. Objectives We are conducting a mixed methods study to explore the intersections of race, developmental disabilities and involvement with CPS for our paediatric population. Design/Methods Phase 1: We completed a retrospective cohort study of 349 patients (0-18 years of age) who were seen by a paediatrician and social worker at a large, hospital-based paediatric clinic in Toronto, Canada in 2019. Electronic medical record data was reviewed and the following binary variables (yes/no) coded CPS-involved or referral made, 1+ caregiver identify as BIPOC, and primary language of caregiver(s) not English. Results Preliminary analyses indicate that 11.7% of our sample is CPS-involved. Contrary to over-representation of BIPOC families in the general CPS population, we found that the proportion of families involved with CPS was lower for BIPOC than non-BIPOC families. A similar pattern was observed for primary language, with a trend towards caregivers who reported English as a second language being less likely to be CPS-involved. In our presentation, we will present analyses regarding the type and intensity of CPS involvement and include other demographic characteristics of the family. These findings will be interpreted with findings from Phase 2 (currently underway), which explores lived experiences of 40 caregivers involved with CPS drawn from Phase 1. Conclusion Within an ASD/IDD patient sample, BIPOC families were less likely to be involved with CPS than non-BIPOC families. This finding is in stark contrast to provincial rates that suggest a 2.2 times greater likelihood of CPS-involvement for Black youth. While these results on the surface suggest equity, they may still reflect bias. It is possible that the concerns of BIPOC families are being downplayed in comparison to non-BIPOC families, reducing their access to supportive services.

Mental health-related hospitalisations of adolescents and their contact with child protection services to age 11 years, South Australia: a whole-of-population descriptive study.

To investigate the number of mental health-related hospitalisations of adolescents (12-17 years) in South Australia by level of contact with the child protection system (0-11 years). Whole-of-population descriptive study; analysis of de-identified linked administrative data from the Better Evidence Better Outcomes Linked Data (BEBOLD) platform. Adolescents born in South Australia, 1991-1999; linked SA Department for Child Protection, Admitted Patient Care (SA Health), and South Australian Perinatal Statistics collection (SA Department for Health and Wellbeing) data. Proportion of adolescents (12-17 years) hospitalised with mental health-related diagnoses; proportion of mental health-related hospitalisations of adolescents, by level of child protection contact (0-11 years) (no contact, notification but not screened in, screened-in notification but not investigated, investigation but not substantiated, substantiation, and out-of-home care). Of 175 115 adolescents born during 1991-1999, 5646 (3.2%) had been hospitalised with mental health conditions, and 27 203 (15.5%) had histories of contact with child protection services. The proportion of adolescents admitted to hospital with mental health-related diagnoses increased with the level of prior child protection contact, from 3366 of 147 912 adolescents with no contact (2.3%), to 398 of 6645 with notifications (6.0%), to 209 of 1191 who had been placed in out-of-home care (17.5%). Contact with child protection services was recorded for 2280 of 5646 adolescents admitted to hospital with mental health-related diagnoses (40.4%); 4477 of 10 633 mental health-related hospitalisations (44.9%) were of adolescents with histories of child protection services contact, including 1285 hospitalisations (12.1%) of adolescents for whom substantiated maltreatment (but not out-of-home care) was recorded, and 568 hospitalisations (5.3%) of adolescents who had been placed in out-of-home care. About 45% of mental health-related hospitalisations of 12-17-year-old adolescents were of people who had had contact with child protection services by the age of 11 years, although only 15.5% of all adolescents had histories of child protection contact. The trauma associated with a history of child protection can have longer term sequelae, and this should be considered when adolescents are hospitalised with mental health conditions.