The differential diagnosis for multiple intracranial lesions in a young adult is broad and includes demyelinating, neoplastic, and infectious etiologies. In this report, we describe the case of a 19-year-old immunocompetent woman presenting with progressive headaches and aphasia. MRI of the brain revealed multiple, large supratentorial lesions with concentric bands of alternating T2 signal intensities and peripheral contrast enhancement. Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) analysis was overall bland with negative oligoclonal bands. Serum antibody testing for neuromyelitis optica (NMO) and myelin-oligodendrocyte associated disease (MOGAD) were negative. A broad infectious work-up was also unrevealing. A definitive diagnosis was ultimately obtained after brain biopsy and the patient was started on appropriate therapy. This case highlights a diagnostic framework in evaluating immunocompetent patients presenting with multiple intracranial lesions and progressive neurological decline. The main differential diagnoses for this constellation of radiological and clinical findings are discussed and a literature review is performed on the revealed diagnosis. Lastly, both acute and long-term therapeutic approaches are reviewed.