Changing the System: of Wolff. Edited by Stephen Chase and Philip Thomas. Burlington, VT: Ashgate, 2010. [xxiii, 259 p. ISBN 9780754666806. $114.95.] examples, illustrations, list of works, bibliography, discography, index. has long been recognized as an important figure of the New York School alongside John Cage, Morton Feldman, and Earle Brown. However, as the youngest member of the and the least likely to loudly promote his own music, he has largely been overlooked in scholarship to date, despite the fact that devoted musicians have kept his music central to the avant-garde concert scene. SEM Ensemble, lead by Petr Kotik, and the Calithumpian Consort, directed by Stephen Drury, are two here in the United States that have championed Wolff's music, and there are others, especially in England and Germany. This collection of essays, Changing the System: of Wolff, edited by Stephen Chase and Philip Thomas, is a first-of-its-kind book-length study of Wolff's music. book is divided into four parts: Reception, History; The Music; Politics; and Performance. All essays touch on the issue of as a socially and politically aware composer and how his experimental sounds, ensembles, notations, and performance requirements speak to a kind of political engagement. book also includes a list of works, bibliography, and discography. Michael Hicks's essay 'Our Webern': and Feldman's Devotion to Wolff sets the tone for the collection by strongly arguing for 's central position in the New York School, not simply as a student of Cage but as an original composer equally learning from and influencing his peers. Hicks unpacks what it meant for and Feldman to compare to Webern, going beyond the superficial parallels between their biographies to real compositional affinities. Hicks also identifies specific compositional ideas central to Cage's later works that originate with Wolff, especially musical discontinuity as unexpected continuity (p. 12), and an approach to composition that was process oriented instead of organized by segments of time (p. 13). Amy Beal brilliantly weaves together recent material from extensive interviews with with transcripts of his historic Darmstadt talks for her essay Christian in Darmstadt, 1972 and 1974. essay reveals a conflicted Darmstadt community split over issues of politics, relevancy, reception, funding, notation, and performance. At Darmstadt, introduced the music of Rzewski, Cage, Oliveros, Lucier, and Glass to his seminar participants, who were quite vocal in their critiques. was the first American composer at Darmstadt in 1972 since Babbitt in 1964, and this American presence was controversial. Philip Thomas's For Pianist: Solo Piano Music and James Saunders's Mutual Effects: Organization and Inter - action in the Orchestral of Wolff both examine repertoires for specific instrumentation. Thomas describes Wolff's literature for piano in light of specific performers, other composers, and Wolff's writing for his own performance. Saunders looks at Wolff's compositions for large in light of the issues of individual freedom, decision making, improvisation, indeterminacy, and the politics of employing such an ensemble as an orchestra. Both are valuable resources for performers of this repertoire as both give strong detailed descriptions of how the scores work and how key pieces are constructed. Christopher Fox's essay Exercising the Ensemble: Some Thoughts on the Later of similarly approaches a specific repertoire, this time for chamber orchestra, examining Instrumental Exercises with Peace March 4 (1985) and Apartment House Exercises (2002). While Fox's analysis of referentiality (to source materials or to earlier compositional techniques) is interesting, Fox's reliance on his own experience as a performer of these works is less so, especially when he makes overarching, dismissive conclusions about the nature of professional ensembles and experimental notation (p. …
Read full abstract