The analysis of screening experiments based on nonregular designs can lead to a model selection problem in which the number of variables is large, the number of trials is small, and there are constraints on model structure. Common subset selection methods do not perform well in this setting. We propose a new approach particularly well suited to screening. The method uses an intentionally nonconvergent stochastic search to generate a large set of well-fitting models, each with the same number of variables. Model selection is then viewed as a feature extraction problem from this set. An easy-to-use graphical method and an automatic approach are proposed to determine the best models. Computer code and additional supplementary materials are available online.