Reviewed by: Making the Best of It: Women and Girls of Canada and Newfoundland during the Second World War ed. by Sarah Glassford and Amy Shaw Charlotte Bennett Making the Best of It: Women and Girls of Canada and Newfoundland during the Second World War. Edited by Sarah Glassford and Amy Shaw. Vancouver: UBC Press, 2020. xii + 293 pp. Cloth $89.95, paper $35.95. Making the Best of It: Women and Girls of Canada and Newfoundland during the Second World War is a fitting sequel to Sarah Glassford and Amy Shaw's equally impressive edited collection on the First World War (A Sisterhood of Suffering and Service, UBC Press, 2012). Here, Glassford and Shaw aim "to do justice to the diversity in the female populations of Canada and Newfoundland," bringing [End Page 474] together essays by twelve historians who have used a "granular approach" to explore specific wartime communities and/or facets of collective experience (5). These contributions are grouped into four sections prefaced by brief introductions that signal common themes. Essays in "Part 1: Women, Children, and the War" emphasize the importance of age in shaping girls' identities and experiences (Barbara Lorenzkowski; Claire L. Halstead; Lisa Moore) as well as how conceptions of childhood determined the support available for working mothers (Lisa Pasolli). In "Part 2: Women and the War at Home," essays highlight how religion, class, and race contributed to gendered tensions inherent within Jewish women's work activities (Jennifer Shaw) and wider consumer culture (Graham Broad; Joseph Tohill). In "Part 3: Women and Overseas Humanitarian Work," Marlene Epp and Sarah Glassford reveal the practical and emotional difficulties faced by Mennonite relief workers and Red Cross workers who traveled to Europe. Finally, "Part 4: Women in Wartime Nursing, Paid War Work, and the Armed Forces" illuminates nursing experiences in northern Newfoundland and Labrador (Heidi Coombs), portrayals of female military dead (Sarah Hogenbirk), and perceptions of beauty and the female body in industrial workplaces (Sarah Van Vugt). Glassford and Shaw more than deliver on their aspirations for Making the Best of It, "mov[ing] the historiographical conversation into new territory, while also drawing attention to the many topics that await scholarly study" (17). This collection brings new research questions and analytical frameworks to the fore, transcending simple assessments as to whether the war was "good" or "bad" for women and/or liberated them in some way. Historians of children and youth will be particularly enthused to see girlhood treated as a "distinct subset of female experience," especially scholars of regions that have not yet witnessed the same "steady growth in the children's history subfield" apparent in North America (16). Lorenzkowski's chapter on emotional geographies and practices of feeling in Atlantic Canada "render[s] legible a history written in invisible ink," using recent insights from the history of emotions to scrutinize the oral histories of women who grew up in wartime Halifax and Saint John (36). Halstead meticulously situates the experiences of British evacuees within their transnational imperial context, uncovering personal ties of friendship that emerged between these "didactic symbols of the war" and their Canadian hosts (59). Moore applies a comparative framework to records from three private girls' schools in Montreal, illuminating divergences in francophone and anglophone expressions of agency and civic identity. These child-centered explorations of female experience greatly enrich the collection as a whole, substantiating the inclusion of "girls" as a key subject in its subtitle. [End Page 475] Due to its remarkable breadth and depth, Making the Best of It will likely become a core reference book for undergraduates and researchers studying Second-World-War Canada and Newfoundland. That said, it is unlikely to have the final word on the subject, a state of affairs refreshingly recognized by the editors themselves (17). Making the Best of It was limited by the responses received to a call for papers; few submissions explored francophone experiences in Quebec, only one related to Newfoundland, and none explicitly addressed Indigenous women. Glassford and Shaw also confirm up front that members of only a limited number of ethnic and religious minorities appear in the volume, presumably for similar reasons. It is hoped that Making the Best of It...
Read full abstract