Primitive Achondrites Research Articles

Quantitative analysis of spectral properties and composition of primitive achondrites (acapulcoites, lodranites and winonaites)

The establishment of robust meteorite-asteroid links has been a major focus of planetary exploration, and a major driver of asteroid sample return missions. Reflectance spectroscopy has been shown to be a powerful tool for this purpose. For the meteorites dominated by silicate minerals, quantitative analysis of spectral absorption features caused by the Fe2+-bearing minerals (mainly olivine and pyroxene) is a common method to determine mafic silicate mineralogy and end member abundances, and establish the relationship between them and possible parent bodies. In this study, the reflectance spectra of 22 primitive achondrites (acapulcoites, lodranites and winonaites) from NASA RELAB database were analyzed to determine their positions in the plot of the band area ratio (BAR) and 1 μm band center (Band I center). We found that Band I center and BAR of acapulcoites and lodranites are in roughly the same range. Acapulcoite-lodranite partially overlap with the field of H chondrites in the plot of the BAR and Band I center. This overlap means that spectral calibrations (also referred to as mineralogical formulas) based on the two types of meteorites needs to be applied with caution. The 2 μm band center of acapulcoite–lodranite is significantly lower than that of H chondrites, which is consistent with the conclusion of previous studies and provides a means to separate these two groups. In addition, the choice of spectral parameter analysis techniques may be a potential error source in similar studies. We provide generalized spectral fields of primitive achondrites in the plot of the BAR and Band I center derived from two widely used technologies.

First widespread occurrence of rare phosphate chladniite in a meteorite, winonaite Graves Nunataks (GRA) 12510: Implications for phosphide–phosphate redox buffered genesis in meteorites

Abstract The first widespread occurrence of rare Na-, Ca-, and Mg, Mn, Fe-bearing phosphate chladniite was observed in meteorite Graves Nunataks (GRA) 12510, which is a primitive achondrite that sits within the winonaite class. Numerous 1–500 µm chladniite grains were found, often on the margins between silicate clasts and the kamacite portions of the large metal veins that permeated through the sample. The largest chladniite grains are associated with merrillite, kamacite, taenite, troilite, albite, forsterite, diopside, and enstatite, with a few tiny chladniite grains and an apatite grain enclosed within merrillite. GRA 12510s average chladniite composition is Na2.7Ca1.25(Mg10.02Mn0.69Fe0.20)Σ10.91(PO4)9. Electron backscattered diffraction (EBSD) patterns indicate varying degrees of nucleation and growth of chladniite grains. Additionally, the first pure Raman spectrum of chladniite is described here, revealing primary ν1 bands at 954, 974, and especially 984 cm–1. The co-occurrence and close association of merrillite, apatite, chladniite, and P-bearing metallic phases within GRA 12510 suggests that the fO2 of IW-2 to IW-4 is an intrinsic property of the precursor chondritic material, and the phosphate-phosphide reaction may have buffered the final winonaite and IAB iron meteorite phase assemblages. Altogether, chladniite appears to form alongside other phosphates, with their chemistries reflecting the diverse environment of their formation. Meteoritic chladniite likely formed through subsolidus oxidation of schreibersite, scavenging Na from albite, Ca from diopside, Mg from enstatite/forsterite, Fe from kamacite/taenite, and Mn from alabandite/chromite when available. A P0-P5+ redox-buffered environment also has implications for thermometry and fast cooling rates, although more experiments are needed to extrapolate powder reaction rates to those of larger crystals. Furthermore, phosphide-phosphate buffered experiments may aid in investigating equilibrium chemistry at fO2 values between IW-2 and IW-4, which have been challenging to explore experimentally due to the limited availability of solid metal-metal oxide buffers between IW (Fe-FeO) and IW-5 (Cr-Cr2O3) at temperatures and pressures relevant to planetary interiors. Future investigations of phosphide-phosphate redox-buffered genesis at fO2 values between IW-2 and IW-4 have important implications for primitive meteorite constituents (e.g., CAI values), partially differentiated planetesimals and planets, including Mercury and core formation on Earth.

Impactor identification with spallogenic Cr isotopes: The Wabar impact craters (Saudi Arabia)

AbstractPrecise measurements of Cr isotopic composition of terrestrial impactites have successfully provided evidence for the presence of extraterrestrial material and have, in some cases, allowed the identification of the type of impactor responsible for the formation of the impact structure. The high Cr abundance in most meteorite groups aids in detecting extraterrestrial contamination while their distinct isotopic compositions can help with the identification of the nature of the projectile. However, this common approach of detection and identification of extraterrestrial contamination using mass‐independent 53Cr and 54Cr variations fails when the impactor type is an iron meteorite because of their low Cr abundances (which are in a similar range to terrestrial rocks). The present study demonstrates the viability of a spallogenic Cr contribution in iron meteorites (resulting from their long cosmic ray exposure times), which compensates for their low Cr abundances and facilitates the identification of iron‐meteoritic contamination in terrestrial impactites. Thus, it broadens the scope of impactors (and impactites) that can be investigated using mass‐independent Cr isotopes from solely chondrites and primitive achondrites to include iron meteorites. The Wabar impact craters are an optimal candidate for this study, characterized by low weathering, diverse impactites, partial meteorite survival, substantial impactor material contamination, and a felsic target lithology with low background Cr concentration. The Cr isotopic composition of the Wabar background sand, which represents the target lithology, is indistinguishable from the terrestrial Cr isotopic composition range, whereas the Wabar iron meteorites show coupled spallogenic excesses in ε53Cr and ε54Cr. The Cr isotopic compositions of Wabar impactites show resolved deviations from the terrestrial Cr isotopic composition, thereby indicating the presence of Wabar meteoritic contamination. Moreover, the study demonstrates that even an impactor with a non‐carbonaceous chondritic origin, such as a IIIAB iron meteorite, can have a carbonaceous chondrite‐like signature in ε54Cr anomalies due to spallogenic Cr contamination. The study advocates for a comprehensive investigation combining platinum group elements and Cr (and/or Ni, Ru) isotopes to accurately characterize impactor types.

A Petrological and Microstructural Study of Ten Brachinites: A Cumulate Texture?

AbstractBrachinites are igneous, ultramafic and unbrecciated primitive achondrites mainly composed of olivine and pyroxene, with a partial melt residue or cumulate origin that is still debated. This study presents a petrological and microstructural study of 10 brachinite meteorites to identify igneous and deformation processes responsible for their formation. Detailed microstructural analyses were performed using secondary electron microscopy, electron probe microanalysis, and electron backscatter diffraction. The olivine‐spinel and two‐pyroxene closure temperatures of these brachinites ranged from 814 ± 27 to 909 ± 20°C. Olivine [001] axes coincide with the elongation of olivine grains and the crystallographic preferred orientations (CPO) of clinopyroxene [001] axes, which led us to infer lineation as olivine [001] axes parallel to X for all samples. Olivine CPO displays a strong or medium concentration of [001] axes parallel to X and [010] axes parallel to Z pointing to a B‐type fabric. Limited internal deformation of olivine grains and slip systems identified from low‐angle boundary misorientation analyses are inconsistent with the CPO and grain misorientation distributions are close to those found in untextured rocks. Olivine B‐type fabrics may therefore result not from plastic deformation but rather from rigid crystal rotation or preferential crystal growth during compaction. Olivine subgrain boundary misorientation axes imply limited activation of [001](100) and [100](001) slip systems, which could be due to primary plastic deformation during or after crystal settling. These new results reveal that brachinites developed a cumulate texture and accommodated only weak plastic deformation during early differentiation processes in the parent body.

Mapping the redox state of the young Solar System using ytterbium valence state

We have determined the valence state of Ytterbium (Yb) in a collection of meteorites covering 4–5 orders of magnitude in oxygen fugacity (fO2) by X-ray absorption near-edge structure (XANES) spectroscopy at the Yb L2 edge. In the studied meteorite minerals, Yb abundance was between 1 and 30 ppm. The data were obtained from merrillite grains (theoretical formula Ca18Na2Mg2(PO4)14) from two equilibrated ordinary chondrites (one H6 and one LL6), on oldhamite grains (theoretical formula CaS) from three EH enstatite chondrites (from EH3 to EH5) and four EL enstatite chondrites (from EL3 to EL6), on one merrilite grain and one stanfieldite grain (theoretical formula Ca4(Mg,Fe,Mn)5(PO4)6) from a pallasite, on merrillite grains from a eucrite, and in a phosphorous-bearing phase from an ungrouped primitive achondrite (NWA 11119). The obtained Yb XANES spectra were compared to those measured in terrestrial apatites (containing 17–79 ppm Yb) and in synthetic materials (metallic Yb, YbS, Yb2S3, Yb2O3). In terrestrial apatites, as well as in ordinary chondrites, in the eucrite, in the pallasite, and in the ungrouped achondrite NWA 11119, Yb is present as Yb3+ only. In enstatite chondrites, about half of the Yb in CaS is in the Yb2+ form and the fraction of Yb2+ may be slightly higher in EH compared to EL. It appears that Yb redox state can be used to build a redox scale for the most reduced objects of the Solar System as shown by this slight difference between EH and EL. However, the absence of a strong difference in Yb redox state between EH and EL chondrites suggests that the observed difference in Yb abundance anomalies in oldhamites found between EH and EL is not due to oxygen fugacity prevailing during parent-body equilibration but rather to fractionation related to volatility.

The H-poor nature of incompletely melted planetesimals: The view from acapulcoites and lodranites

The abundance of H in planetary building blocks is of fundamental importance for constraining the evolution of the terrestrial planets. It is commonly assumed that chondrites are the principal sources of Earth’s H; however, recent studies have suggested that primitive achondrites and achondrites may retain a small complement of H. There are few constraints on the H budgets of primitive achondrites, which represent the transition from unmelted to melted planetesimals, but prior work suggests that bulk parent body H contents are several orders of magnitude lower than typical chondritic values. Therefore, to provide further constraints on H retention during the transition from unmelted to melted planetesimals, we have measured the H contents of olivine, orthopyroxene, clinopyroxene, and plagioclase from a suite of acapulcoite-lodranite clan meteorites. Acapulcoite-lodranite clan meteorites represent the “prototypical” primitive achondrite parent body and have bulk major element compositions more akin to the Earth than previously studied primitive achondrites (e.g., the ureilites). We find that the H2O contents of olivine (∼5–12 µg/g H2O), orthopyroxene (∼3–10 µg/g H2O), and clinopyroxene (∼5–8 µg/g H2O) are broadly similar, while plagioclase (∼2.5–5 µg/g H2O) tends to be offset to lower values. Using a simple, single-stage batch-melting model, we calculate a preferred maximum acapulcoite-lodranite parent body H2O content of 38 µg/g, which is similar to other estimates for primitive achondritic and achondritic parent bodies. Furthermore, assuming chondrite-like precursor materials, our data are consistent with efficient loss of H prior to or during the onset of melting of early-formed planetesimals. This requires that Earth’s H-budget was dominated by building blocks that underwent minimal thermal processing.

Magnetism of the Acapulco Primitive Achondrite and Implications for the Evolution of Partially Differentiated Bodies

AbstractPrimitive achondrites like the acapulcoites‐lodranites (AL) clan are meteorites that formed on bodies in the process of forming a metallic core, providing a unique window into how early solar system processes transformed unmelted material into differentiated bodies. However, the size and structure of the parent body of ALs and other primitive achondrites are largely unknown. Paleomagnetism can establish the presence or absence of a metallic core by looking for evidence of a dynamo field. We conducted a magnetic study of the Acapulco acapulcoite to determine its ferromagnetic minerals and their recording properties. This is the first detailed rock magnetic and first paleomagnetic study of a primitive achondrite group. We determined that metal inclusions inside silicate grains consist of two magnetic minerals, kamacite and tetrataenite, which have robust recording properties. However, the mechanisms and timing by which these minerals acquired any natural remanent magnetization are unknown. Despite this, Acapulco has not been substantially remagnetized since arriving on Earth and therefore should retain a record dating to 4.55 billion years ago. Future studies could characterize this record by using high‐resolution magnetometry measurements of individual populations of grains and developing an understanding of how and when they became magnetized. Our discovery of tetrataenite in ALs provides the first mineralogical evidence for slow cooling [<∼5–10 × 103°C per million years (Ma−1)] of the AL parent body at low temperatures (∼320°C). Its presence suggests the AL parent body is unlikely to have been catastrophically disrupted at AL peak temperatures (∼1,200°C) without subsequent reaccretion.

Light noble gases in 11 achondrites: Cosmic ray exposure ages, gas retention ages, and preatmospheric sizes

AbstractWe report light noble gas (He, Ne, and Ar) concentrations and isotopic ratios in 11 achondrites, Tafassasset (unclassified primitive achondrite), Northwest Africa (NWA) 12934 (angrite), NWA 12573 (brachinite), Jiddat al Harasis (JaH) 809 (ureilite), NWA 11562 (ungrouped achondrite), four lodranites (NWA 11901, NWA 7474, NWA 6685, and NWA 6484), NWA 2871 (acapulcoite), and Sahara 02029 (winonaite), most of which have not been previously studied for noble gases. We discuss their noble gas isotopic composition, determine their cosmogenic nuclide content, and systematically calculate their cosmic ray exposure (CRE) and gas retention ages. In addition, we estimate their preatmospheric radii and preatmospheric masses based on the shielding parameter (22Ne/21Ne)cos. None of the studied meteorites shows evidence of contribution from solar cosmic rays (SCRs). JaH 809 and NWA 12934 show evidence of 3He diffusive losses of >90% and 40%, respectively. The winonaite Sahara 02029 has lost most of its noble gases, either during or before analysis. The average CRE age of Tafassasset of ~49 Ma is lower than that reported by Patzer et al. (2003), but is consistent with it within the uncertainties; this confirms that Tafassasset and CR chondrites are not source paired, CR chondrites having CRE ages from 1 to 25 Ma (Herzog & Caffee, 2014). The ureilite JaH 809 has a CRE age of ~5.4 Ma, which falls into the typical range of exposure ages for ureilites; the angrite NWA 12934 has a CRE age of ~49 Ma, which is within the main range of exposure ages reported for angrites (0.2–56 Ma). We calculate a CRE age of ~2.4 Ma for the brachinite NWA 12573, which falls into a possible “cluster” in the brachinite CRE age histogram around ~3 Ma. Three lodranites (NWA 11901, NWA 7474, and NWA 6685) have CRE ages higher than the average CRE ages of lodranites measured so far, NWA 11901 and NWA 6685 having CRE ages far higher than the CRE age already reported by Li et al. (2019) on NWA 8118. The measured 40K‐40Ar gas retention ages fit well into established systematics. The gas retention age of Tafassasset is consistent, within respective uncertainties, with that previously calculated by Patzer et al. (2003). Our study indicates that Tafassasset originates from a meteoroid with a preatmospheric radius of ~20 cm, however discordant with the radius of ~85 cm inferred in a previous study (Patzer et al., 2003).

Hydrogen in acapulcoites and lodranites: A unique source of water for planetesimals in the inner Solar System

Acapulcoites and lodranites are primitive achondrites, sampling a common planetesimal formed a few million years after calcium-aluminium rich inclusions in the inner Solar System, that provides information into melting and differentiation processes in the early inner Solar System. The chemistry and mineralogy of their chondritic parent body lies in between enstatite and ordinary chondrites. As they record a range in planetary differentiation degree, from 1% up to 20% partial melting, with lodranites experiencing the most melt extraction, we investigate (i) the behaviour of hydrogen in terms of abundance and isotopic composition during the early stages of planetary differentiation and (ii) the source(s) of hydrogen for the acapulcoite-lodranite parent body in order to place it in our current understanding of the source(s) of water in the inner Solar System. In this study, we analysed water content and hydrogen isotopic composition of phosphates and nominally anhydrous minerals in a range of acapulcoite and lodranite meteorite samples. While apatites seemed to have recorded a degassing signature, no such variations were observed in the H2O–δD systematics of the nominally anhydrous minerals suggesting that subsequent to their crystallisation, acapulcoites and lodranites experienced minimal modifications to their volatile composition during thermal metamorphism and partial melting. The low abundance of water in acapulcoite and lodranite nominally anhydrous minerals (i.e., average 5.2±1.6 μg/g H2O) suggests that their parent body was much drier than what has been estimated for enstatite and ordinary chondrite parent bodies. We estimated a bulk water content for the acapulcoite-lodranite parent body of 3 to 19 μg/g H2O, similar to the ureilite parent body. The hydrogen isotopic composition of nominally anhydrous minerals in acapulcoites and lodranites (–211±145‰), and in particular for the two falls Acapulco and Lodran (–239±149‰), matches with the hydrogen isotopic composition recorded by nominally anhydrous minerals in ordinary chondrite falls, eucrites, S–type asteroid Itokawa, consistent with a common source of water for the inner Solar System planetesimals, isotopically distinctive to bulk carbonaceous chondrites.

Highly siderophile element fractionation during chondrite melting inferred from olivine-rich primitive achondrites

Metal-silicate segregation is one of the most fundamental mechanisms in planetary differentiation, with primitive achondrites offering important constraints on this process. Brachinites and brachinite-like achondrites (BLA) are olivine-dominated primitive achondrites that experienced up to ∼20% partial melt removal under relatively oxidized (ΔIW ∼ −1) conditions within an initially chondritic parent body and represent residues after inefficient metal-loss. We present bulk rock and in situ lithophile and highly siderophile element (HSE) abundance systematics as well as 187Re-187Os data for five olivine-rich primitive achondrites. These new data confirm classification of Reid 013 as a brachinite, three of the samples as BLA (Northwest Africa [NWA] 6874, NWA 7499, and Miller Range 090805), and the final sample as an ungrouped primitive olivine-rich achondrite (NWA 7680). An aliquot of MIL 090805 shows amongst the highest total HSE contents (>35 ppm) and the highest Pt content (∼23 ppm) of any primitive achondrite. Compiled HSE data for brachinites and BLA show correlations between total HSE abundance, Pt enrichment, and average olivine Fo. This correlation can be explained by variable melting (∼10–20%) of an H ordinary chondrite-like protolith, with retention of both Fe-metal and a Pt-rich alloy phase distinct from the observed Fe-metal phases in more depleted residues. Such a Pt-alloy phase is likely stabilized by elevated abundances of the HSE during chondrite melting and the low solubility of HSE in melts. Rhenium-Os isotope data in the studied samples has been modified by recent mobilization of Re during terrestrial weathering, with the limited range of measured 187Os/188Os in brachinites and BLA supporting minor fractionation of Re/Os during melting and an ancient (∼4.5 Ga) partial melting event to explain their compositions. These results indicate that models of planetary differentiation should consider the low solubility of Pt in chondrite melts and the potential for alloy formation to modify HSE abundances of silicate mantles.

Mass-dependent nickel isotopic variations in achondrites and lunar rocks

We present high-precision mass-dependent nickel isotopic data for a comprehensive suite of achondrites and lunar rocks, providing key insights into the early planetary differentiation and Earth-Moon system formation. The primitive achondrites display high Ni contents and invariant Ni isotopic compositions. Incomplete core-mantle differentiation in primitive achondrite parent bodies resulted in the retention of metal in the mantle, which dominated the Ni budget and accounted for the bulk chondritic Ni isotopic values. The highly reduced differentiated achondrites, aubrites and an ungrouped achondrite (NWA 8409), have variable, and extremely light Ni isotopic compositions. Acid leaching experiments demonstrate that the sulfides are a significant host of light Ni isotopes in aubrites. The most extreme Ni isotope values of aubrites may be due to large Ni isotope fractionation accompanied by silicate-sulfide-metal separation during differentiation of the parent bodies, and subsequent global disruptive collision and reassembly with variably high proportions of sulfides enriched in the mantle. The howardite-eucrite-diogenite (HED) meteorites show Ni isotopic variations that are positively correlated with Ni/Co ratios, a feature that cannot be produced by igneous differentiation. Late accretion of high-Ni and high-Ni/Co chondritic materials after core formation of their likely parent body, Vesta, could have accounted for this correlation. Thus, the primitive silicate mantle of Vesta may have sub-chondritic Ni isotopic compositions, implying possible Ni isotope fractionation during core-mantle differentiation of small planetary bodies. The lunar breccia meteorites have homogenously chondritic Ni isotope values, together with their high Ni/Co of bulk rock and metals therein, suggesting impact contamination. Lunar basalt meteorites have low Ni/Co ratios and are systematically isotopically lighter than the breccias, displaying a positive correlation between Ni isotope value and Ni/Co ratio, as that seen in the HEDs. Therefore, the Ni isotopic systematics in lunar rocks also indicates the effect of late accretion, with the primitive lunar mantle having sub-chondritic Ni isotope values. This implies that the Moon-forming impactor, Theia, was likely an aubrite-like differentiated planetary body whose mantle was enriched in light Ni isotopes. We suggest that there was significant Ni isotope fractionation between core and mantle during differentiation of early formed small planetary bodies, but this signature can be obscured by late accretion in the bulk achondrite records.

Melt migration in rubble-pile planetesimals: Implications for the formation of primitive achondrites

Primitive achondrites represent residual mantle material of planetesimals from which up to 20% partial melts were extracted. Melting experiments on chondritic compositions suggest that melts produced by ≲20% partial melting are rich in silica and alkali elements. Such melts are highly viscous (≳103Pa⋅s), and percolation models predict that they would only migrate negligible distances over timescales of 1–10Myr. After these timescales, a planetesimal would either be melted into a magma ocean by radiogenic heating from Al26, if it formed early; or it would cool below solidus, if it formed relatively late. However, melt migration is also controlled by permeability, which could be high for aggregates of rock boulders (compared to those of mineral grains). Specifically, the theory of planet formation suggests that collisions occurred frequently between planetesimals in the early solar system. These collisions may have shattered the planetesimals into fragments with sizes of meters to tens of meters, which would have accreted gravitationally into one or more daughter bodies. We develop a model to investigate melt migration in “rubble-pile” planetesimals; in particular, the melt exchange between partially molten rock boulders and the void space between them. The results suggest that, with typical properties of primitive achondrite materials at the conditions of low-degree partial melting, melts may have been squeezed into the voids between boulders, and migrated rapidly through these channels. Therefore, primitive achondrites may record melt migration in rubble-pile bodies reaccreted from fragments of partially molten planetesimals.

Tracking and dating incipient melting of a new grouplet of primitive achondrites

Primitive achondrites, representing ‘transitional’ samples between chondrites and differentiated achondrites, provide a great opportunity to decode the thermal histories of planetesimals in the early solar system. In this work, we report a comprehensive study of petrography, mineralogy, O-Cr isotopes and 53Mn-53Cr systematics of four ungrouped primitive achondrites, Northwest Africa (NWA) 12869, NWA 3250, NWA 11112, and Tafassasset. High resolution X-ray tomographic microscopy (HR-XTM) observations yield the 3D spatial distributions of metal, sulfide, and plagioclase, providing the direct petrologic evidence for incipient melting. In NWA 12869, NWA 3250, and NWA 11112, only FeNi-FeS eutectic melting occurs, with small fractions of metal and sulfide melt and amalgamate sporadically. As for Tafassasset, in addition to common metal and sulfide melt, plagioclase (±pyroxene) extensively melts and interconnects to form networks, with the generation of basaltic melts. The 53Mn-53Cr systematics in NWA 12869 [initial 53Mn/55Mn of (3.24 ± 0.32) × 10−6] and Tafassasset [initial 53Mn/55Mn of (3.48 ± 0.20) × 10−6] are determined with mineral separates and bulk samples. When anchored to the D’Orbigny angrite, NWA 12869 has a 53Mn-53Cr age of 4563.4 ± 0.6 Ma, while Tafassasset has an age of 4563.8 ± 0.4 Ma. The Mn-Cr ages of NWA 12869 and Tafassasset record the time of incipient melting within their parent bodies.Considering that NWA 12869, NWA 3250, and NWA 11112 exhibit the same olivine-dominated (47–69 vol%) mineral assemblages with recrystallized textures and a great similarity in mineral chemistry (olivine: Fa35–38; pyroxene: Fs27–30Wo3.0–3.5; plagioclase: An47–50; chromite: Cr#: 74–76; Mg#: 14.0–14.6), oxygen fugacity (IW-2 to IW-1), as well as 54Cr nucleosynthetic anomalies (ε54Cr: 1.01 ± 0.09 to 1.44 ± 0.18) and oxygen isotopes (Δ17O: −1.72 to −1.78 ± 0.05‰), we first classify them into a new grouplet of primitive achondrites, different from Tafassasset. This grouplet does not share a parent body with CR chondrites, but rather derives from incipient melting of a carbonaceous chondrite parent body which formed in a nebular reservoir physically close to that sampled by CR chondrites. More chondrite, differentiated achondrite, and/or iron samples associated with this new grouplet would provide further constraints on the rate and onset time of accretion, as well as the interior structure of the planetesimal in the outer solar system.

Tissemouminites: A new group of primitive achondrites spanning the transition between acapulcoites and winonaites

AbstractThe Northwest Africa (NWA) 090 meteorite, initially classified as an acapulcoite, presents petrological, chemical, and isotopic characteristics comparable to a group of seven primitive winonaites: Dhofar 1222, NWA 725, NWA 1052, NWA 1054, NWA 1058, NWA 1463, and NWA 8614. Five of these samples were previously classified as acapulcoites or ungrouped achondrites before being reclassified as winonaites based on their oxygen isotopic compositions. These misclassifications are indicative of the particular compositional nature of these primitive achondrites. All contain relict chondrules and a lower closure temperature of metamorphism of 820 ± 20 °C compared to other typical winonaites, as well as mineral elemental compositions similar to those of acapulcoites. The oxygen isotopic signature of these samples, δ17O of 1.18 ± 0.17‰, δ18O of 3.18 ± 0.30‰, and Δ17O of −0.47 ± 0.02, is in fact resolvable from both acapulcoites and winonaites. We investigate the relationship between these eight primitive achondrites, typical winonaites, and acapulcoites, to redefine petrological, mineralogical, and geochemical criteria of primitive achondrite classification. Distinguishing between winonaites, acapulcoites, and this group of eight primitive achondrites can be unambiguously done using a combination of several mineralogical and chemical criteria. A combination of olivine fayalite content and FeO/MnO ratio, as well as plagioclase potassium content allow us to separate these three groups without the absolute necessity of oxygen isotope analyses. NWA 090 as well as the other seven primitive achondrites, although related to winonaites, are most likely derived from a parent body distinct from winonaites and acapulcoites–lodranites, and define a new group of primitive achondrites that can be referred to as tissemouminites.

Quantitative Mineral Analysis of Ordinary Chondrites and Primitive Achondrites Using Reflectance Spectroscopy

AbstractVisible and near‐infrared spectroscopy is a widely used method to determine the mineral compositions of meteorites and asteroids. In this study, we first investigated the association of multiple spectral parameters with mineral compositions using published laboratory spectra and mineral analysis of ordinary chondrites and primitive achondrites. New models for deriving the abundances of mafic silicate minerals were determined. Second, the influence of different mineral compositions on the 1.25 μm region is discussed. Finally, a method to distinguish the ordinary chondrites from primitive achondrites is developed. Our results suggest that the 1.25–1 μm band depth ratio (BDR 1.25) and 1 μm band width (BW I) are mainly associated with mineral abundances and to a lesser extent, compositions. Olivine is the dominant mafic mineral phase that affects the 1.25 μm region in ordinary chondrites and primitive achondrites. The plot of the BDR 1.25 versus the BW I is a useful method for correctly distinguishing about 90% of the primitive achondrites from ordinary chondrites. It relies largely on differences in olivine abundance and olivine/pyroxene ratios and to a lesser extent, olivine composition. The quantitative mineral analysis in this study based on the correlation between the spectra and mineralogy of ordinary chondrites and primitive achondrites provides a chance for understanding the petrology and geochemistry of S‐type asteroids. This study can also distinguish the partially melted S‐type asteroids (parent body of primitive achondrites) from the unmelted S‐type asteroids (parent body of ordinary chondrites).

Supplementary Material for "Melt migration in rubble-pile planetesimals: Implications for the formation of primitive achondrites"

Supplementary Material for "Melt migration in rubble-pile planetesimals: Implications for the formation of primitive achondrites"

The H2O content of the ureilite parent body

The fate of highly volatile elements (H, C, F, Cl and S) during planetary accretion and differentiation is debated. Recent analyses of water in non-carbonaceous chondrites (RC, OC, EC) and achondrites (angrites, eucrites) have been used to argue that inner solar system parent bodies accreted and retained their highly volatile element budgets from their primary feedstock without substantial loss during accretion, metamorphism and differentiation. An alternative model posits that differentiated inner solar system parent bodies (e.g., the angrite parent body, 4 Vesta, Earth) derived the majority of their water from a carbonaceous chondrite-like source, delivered during the final stages of accretion.In order to add new constraints to this debate, we have measured water in nominally anhydrous minerals, melt inclusions, and interstitial glass in ureilites, the largest group of primitive achondrites in the terrestrial meteorite collection. Primitive achondrites did not experience global melting and homogenization. Therefore, these meteorites capture part of the transition from chondritic to achondritic parent bodies, allowing us to constrain the fate of water during the earliest stages of differentiation. Our nano-scale secondary ion mass spectrometry (nanoSIMS) analyses allow us to assess the viability of ureilite-like material as a potential source of terrestrial water. Analyses of pigeonite in main group ureilites yield a range of 2.0 – 6.0 µg/g H2O, and analyses of high-Ca pyroxene and glass (glassy melt inclusions and interstitial glass) in the Almahata Sitta ureilitic trachyandesite yield ranges of 13 – 19 µg/g H2O and 44 – 216 µg/g H2O, respectively. Mass balance, incremental melting, and batch melting calculations yield a preferred ureilite parent body H2O content of 2 – 20 µg/g, similar to previous estimates of water in the eucrite parent body (4 Vesta), but lower than estimates of Earth’s water budget. With these data, we demonstrate that 1) the ureilite parent body is H2O-depleted relative to the Earth; 2) ureilite-like material is unlikely to be a primary source of H2O to the Earth; 3) C and H are not necessarily coupled elements during planetary accretion and thermal processing; and 4) accretion, heating, partial melting, and degassing of rocky planetesimals likely results in significant depletion of H2O.

Early formation of primitive achondrites in an outer region of the protoplanetary disc

Early formation of primitive achondrites in an outer region of the protoplanetary disc

On the cooling rate evolution of asteroid fragments

Recent observations of rapid cooling rates at high temperatures in several ordinary chondrite and primitive achondrite meteorite groups suggest the fragmentation of their parent bodies near peak temperatures. We use analytic models for conductive cooling of collisional fragments to show that the actively cooling part of a fragment experiences similar cooling rates over a large range of temperatures. This characteristic cooling rate decays inversely with time and the larger a fragment the longer this decay continues. Measurements of high temperature cooling rates therefore place a lower bound on the cooling time and size of collisional fragments. Applying this model to the cooling rates in H chondrites, which vary from 101 to 10−2 °C/yr at temperatures between 700 to 850 °C, we estimate cooling times of at least 101 and 104 years in fragments at least 102 to 103 m in radius.

Edward R. D. Scott (1947–2021): A tribute to an exceptional scientist and wonderful man

Edward R. D. Scott (1947–2021): A tribute to an exceptional scientist and wonderful man