West African (WA) migrants in Europe have higher hypertension rates than the host populations. For African migrants, guidelines recommend diuretics and/or calcium channel blockers (CCB) for primary cardiovascular disease prevention, but data on antihypertensive medication (AHM) prescription patterns or related hypertension control rates are lacking. We assessed AHM prescription patterns and its relation to hypertension control among hypertensive WA migrants in the Netherlands compared to the host population. Cross-sectional data from WA or Dutch origin participants from the HELIUS study were used. Participants with treated hypertension and without diabetes, cardiovascular disease, or microalbuminuria were selected. We used logistic and linear regression analyses to assess the association between AHM categories and hypertension control rates (systolic blood pressure (BP) ≤ 140 mmHg and diastolic BP ≤ 90 mmHg) and the systolic BP levels. We compared 999 WA participants and 314 Dutch participants. Hypertension control rates were lower in the WA origin compared to Dutch origin participants (44.3% versus 58.0%, p < 0.001). For WA participants, prescription rates for any AHM category were: CCB (54.8%), diuretics (18.5%) beta-blocking agents (27.3%) and renin-angiotensin system blockers (52.6%). Prescription rates were higher for CCB and similar for diuretics compared to the Dutch participants. Neither CCB nor diuretics were associated with better control rates. Compared to Dutch participants, West African participants had similar diuretic prescriptions but significantly higher prescriptions for CCB. However, neither medications was associated with better hypertension control. Future research should explore physician and patient factors to improve hypertension control.