Primary Health Care System Research Articles

Pharmacists in global primary healthcare systems: A comprehensive model for community health empowerment

Pharmacists play an increasingly important role in global primary healthcare systems, evolving from traditional dispensers to active participants in patient-centered care. This paper advocates for the stronger integration of pharmacists into healthcare teams to improve patient outcomes, medication adherence, and overall healthcare delivery. Through a comprehensive review, we examine the evolving role of pharmacists, the key challenges to their full integration, and the substantial opportunities they present, particularly in managing chronic diseases, providing preventative care, and enhancing patient education. We propose a model for empowering pharmacists to contribute more effectively to community health, especially in underserved areas. The paper also highlights the potential global impact of pharmacists in reducing healthcare costs, improving disease management, and promoting public health initiatives. Lastly, recommendations for future policy reforms, education enhancements, and research directions are offered to support the continued expansion of pharmacists' roles in primary healthcare systems worldwide.

Challenges And Strategies For Implementing Performance-Based Capitation In Indonesian Community Health Center : A Scoping Review

This study examines the implementation and challenges of performance-based capitation (KBK) at Community Health Centers (Puskesmas) in Indonesia, as a part of the National Health Insurance Program, aiming to improve the efficiency and quality of primary health services. Despite its potential, the implementation of KBK faces various challenges including inadequate human resources, limited infrastructure, and insufficient monitoring systems. The study uses a scoping review framework based on the Public Health Care Monitoring Conceptual Framework by WHO, analyzing 11 selected studies from 2021 to 2024. Findings indicate that internal factors such as management capacity, health worker competence, and organizational culture significantly impact the effectiveness of KBK. External factors like local government support, funding policies, and infrastructure availability also play crucial roles. Technological barriers, particularly in remote areas, hinder optimal policy implementation. The study emphasizes the need for clear regulations, consistent policy dissemination, and effective monitoring to ensure successful KBK implementation. Recommendations include strengthening leadership, training health workers, improving infrastructure, and enhancing digital health technology utilization. These strategies aim to optimize resource allocation, enhance service access, and improve patient satisfaction in Indonesia’s primary health care system.

Exploring methodologies and frameworks for best practice transfer at the primary care level

Abstract Background In Feb 2023, the EU’s Joint Action on the transfer of best praCtices In pRimary CarE (CIRCE-JA) was launched with the objective of effectively transferring and implementing six best practices (BPs) among Member States (MS). Transferability from one primary care (PC) setting to another can be challenging given organizational, legal, cultural, social, economic, and environmental factors, requiring robust a methodological framework to guide the transfer process. A scoping review was conducted to identify conceptual models and methodological frameworks for context-relevant and evidence-informed BP transfer in PC settings. Methods The study aimed to identify models or frameworks to guide BP transfer in PC settings, whilst maximizing transferability. The JBI methodology was used, and an extensive search was conducted in PubMed (time limit: Jan ‘13-May ‘23). All publications of original research, systematic reviews, and text and opinion papers in English were eligible for inclusion. Key exclusion criteria were set, i.e., intervention type, level of care and reporting quality. The search was supplemented by gray literature review. Results From a total of 369 publications, 9 met eligibility criteria, reporting on 10 conceptual and methodological models/framework largely varying. These included transfer models applicable to all BPs as well as elements specific to some BPs, i.e., addressing integration, patient-centered care, care coordination, and health promotion. Strengths and weaknesses were identified for all. Conclusions Transferability of health interventions is complex, requiring systematic consideration of setting and intervention characteristics to inform and support local adaptation, implementation, and decision-making. Key elements identified can support the CIRCE-JA BP transfer and are largely relevant for further BP transfer across PC settings in EU MS, incl. for local adaptation, stakeholder engagement and effective implementation monitoring. Key messages • Innovative BPs are successfully deployed in many EU MS. To best support transformation for strong EU primary care and resilient health systems, it is important to ensure evidence-informed BP transfer. • This review reports on the selection of appropriate frameworks and models, and key elements thereof, to allow successful transfer of CIRCE-JA BPs and other BP transfer across PC settings in Europe.

Implementing a pilot primary care program: Armenia’s steps toward universal health coverage

Abstract Problem Armenia has struggled to transform its ineffective primary healthcare (PHC) system into one that can address the non-communicable disease burden, which causes 93% of mortality. To address this issue, Armenia aims to establish universal health coverage and invest in high-quality primary care. Description In 2023, the Armenian Ministry of Health signed a multisectoral policy to implement a pilot primary care program to trial a multitude of reforms related to diabetes (DM) and hypertension (HTN). Pilot interventions include pathways for screening/diagnosis, provider training, free medications and diagnostics, and new provider financial incentives. The key question to be answered is if these pilot interventions cause DM and HTN health outcomes to improve. Beginning in 2024, the program is being piloted in a primary care clinic in Dsegh. Results As a result of the 2023 Ministerial policy, multisectoral stakeholders designed and implemented this pilot program. Baseline focus groups found that the pilot addresses the financial barriers that community members noted lead to delays in seeking care and that providers perceive the pilot to be beneficial to their patients. Although final results are not yet available, the pilot has already positively changed features in the national EMR and brought together stakeholders in a way never done before. Lessons The pilot’s innovation comes from it being the first time that hypertension and cholesterol medications are provided by the government for free, provider bonuses are based on outcome indicators, indicator targets are set this high, a point-of-care A1c machine is utilized, and a robust monitoring and evaluation (M&E) plan is implemented, all of which are currently shaping discussions on national policy. For countries similarly working on strengthening primary care, it is recommended to pilot specific reforms and establish mechanisms through M&E systems that allow pilots to inform evidence-based decision making. Key messages • To move towards universal health coverage, pilot programs designed with multi-sectoral stakeholders are needed to trial suggested healthcare reforms. • It is essential to invest in monitoring and evaluations systems to generate the data necessary to develop evidence-based policies.

Introduction of wastewater surveillance of SARS-CoV-2 in Ukraine

Abstract Since the Russian invasion, Ukraine has faced humanitarian crises and challenges in diseases surveillance. The primary healthcare (PHC) system struggled with growing numbers of internally displaced and wounded people. In October 2022, the PATH-led, USAID-funded Support TB Control Efforts in Ukraine (STBCEU) project, supported implementation of wastewater surveillance (WWS) for SARS-CoV-2 in four oblasts on request of the Ministry of Health (MoH), expanding to 18 oblasts by October 2023. Samples were collected from 64 sites twice per week and tested for SARS-CoV-2 and influenza A/B using BioExtract® Premium Mag test kits in regional laboratories. From October 2022 to April 2024, 4,784 samples were collected at municipal aqueducts, with SARS-CoV-2 delta and omicron variants detected across all regions. WWS sample results were compared with routine surveillance to assess trends in concentrations and reported cases among population. Gradual decrease in SARS-CoV-2 concentration to zero by May 29, 2023, coincided with a decrease in morbidity. In the last week of August 2023, the concentration of the SARS-CoV-2 in wastewater began its gradual increase with the beginning of new cases registration among the population within 2 weeks, by mid-September. From October 2023, SARS-CoV-2 dominated in 96.6% of positive WWS testing results; in other specimens, influenza and respiratory viruses have been identified. The implementation of WWS in Ukraine highlighted its effectiveness as a public health tool in settings where traditional surveillance methods are disrupted, providing timely data on the viral pathogens for outbreaks prediction and responses, underscoring its role in preventive health measures. The MOH of Ukraine recommended extending the method nationwide for routine surveillance of SARS-CoV-2 and other pathogens, enhancing Ukraine’s capacity to manage public health threats and strengthen the resilience of its health system against future crises. Key messages • WWS in Ukraine underscores its effectiveness as a public health tool, providing timely data on viral pathogens for outbreak prediction and response in disrupted settings. • Notable decline in SARS-CoV-2 concentration in wastewater correlates with reduced morbidity, highlighting WWS’s predictive value.

Starting Right, an evidence-based assessment of children in municipalities healthcare centers

Abstract During the last century, children’s health has evolved significantly, with mental health issues becoming a prominent public health concern. Childhood health problems profoundly impact quality of life (QoL), development, school functioning, and social interactions, affecting society broadly. In Norway, child and school health services offer free comprehensive care within the municipal primary health care system, prioritizing health promotion and prevention to address social health inequalities. The Norwegian Starting RightTM project recruits’ children aged 6 months to16 years and their parents, emphasizing early intervention and support to reduce health inequalities and promote well-being. In the Starting RightTM project, online proxy- and child-reported questionnaires are used to support public health nurses (PHNs) in assessing children’s health and development in routine follow- up. Parents and children receive an SMS text message asking them to answer an online questionnaire before attending their regular appointments in child or school health services. Validated instruments measure the development (ASQ, ASQ-SE), mental health (SDQ) and health-related quality of life (HRQoL), (KIDSCREEN -27). By mapping children and adolescents’ health and through discussions with PHNs, parents and children may be more involved in children’s health and development and may increase their Health Literacy. The primary objective of the proposed project is to develop child and school health services and improve children’s health and HRQoL. The ongoing project is the first to systematically assess development, health and HRQoL in children and adolescents in Norway through ordinary services, and to do so longitudinally. At present, >2000 children have been included. The large sample size combined with a broad multi- and interdisciplinary approach is unique from a national perspective. The upcoming workshop will showcase findings from this innovative study.

The state of primary health care systems in ten high-income countries

Abstract Primary care systems in high-income countries perform comparatively better than the U.S. system in large part due to decades of investment, an adequate workforce supply, and universal healthcare. This research identifies successes and areas of improvement of 10 high-performing primary care systems in four areas of care: 1) access, 2) continuity, 3) comprehensiveness, 4) and coordination. Cross-national comparisons using primary data from the 2022 CMWF International Health Policy Survey of Primary Care Physicians (N ranged from 321-2,092) and the 2023 CMWF International Health Policy Survey on the General Population (N ranged from 750-4,820). Countries included: Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Netherlands, New Zealand, Sweden, Switzerland, the U.K., and the U.S. • More than 90% of adults in all surveyed countries reported having a regular primary care doctor except Sweden, the U.S., and Canada. • Less than 5% of physicians reported high telehealth use in their patient encounters, except for in the U.K. and New Zealand where over 10% reported high use. • Over a quarter of physicians in the U.S., Germany, and France report screening patients for social needs, compared to just 8% in the Netherlands. • Care coordination with social services was a major challenge in all surveyed countries, with over 75% of physicians in the U.K., Australia, and France reporting major challenges. Primary care systems in 10 other high-income countries outperform the U.S. system, particularly when it comes to access to care and care continuity. Policy options to consider for U.S. policymakers include narrowing the wage gap between generalist and specialist physicians and rewarding and holding providers accountable for continuity of care. On the other hand, countries like Sweden and the Netherlands can learn from the U.S. on how to adequately coordinate care between primary care physicians, specialists, and hospitals. Key messages • Investment in primary care yields better health outcomes, greater equity and lower costs. • Many high-income countries in Europe have high performing primary care systems, something the U.S. system can learn from.

Driving innovation in primary healthcare though co-creation with stakeholders in Switzerland

Abstract Issue/problem Primary healthcare systems worldwide face challenges such as socio-demographic shifts, increasing chronic diseases, rising costs, and workforce shortages, demanding innovative solutions for the future of primary care. Description of the problem Addressing the complex challenges of creating a resilient primary healthcare model involves considering interdependent factors such as health policies, funding, workforce training, technology, and evolving diseases, alongside diverse stakeholder interests. To tackle this, the ‘Health2040: Co-creation of a Future Outpatient Primary Healthcare Model in Switzerland’ project was launched in 2023 to develop a forward-looking model by integrating insights from various stakeholders. Results The project involved 40 stakeholders, including patients, researchers, healthcare professionals, policy-makers, and insurers, in two full-day workshops aimed at co-creating a vision and actionable framework for Switzerland’s future primary care. The first workshop focused on developing and visualizing potential models, while the second targeted the transition to these new models and the creation of an implementation plan. These sessions were underpinned by a comprehensive literature review on emerging primary care models, providing a scientific foundation for the discussions. Lessons Successful co-creation requires significant preparatory efforts and innovative creativity techniques, such as Future Newspapers, brainstorming, games, and user personas. Engaging stakeholders throughout various stages of the project helped to enhance relevance. Feedback from a steering group on the workshop’s concept, methodologies, and evidence synthesis was instrumental. Healthcare practitioners also contributed their insights on patient personas, ensuring the models developed were pertinent to actual healthcare practices. Stakeholder engagement process was essential for fostering innovative ideas and ensuring stakeholder buy-in for the developed solutions. Key messages • Co-creation with stakeholders is a promising way to develop innovative solutions for health systems. • Integrating stakeholder input is crucial at all the project stages, from preparation to evaluation.

General Practitioner Availability and Accessibility in Serbia Before and During the Pandemic

Abstract Background During the COVID-19 pandemic in Serbia, state-owned primary health centres’ general practitioners (GPs) served as the first point of care for adults (the population aged 19 years and older) and gatekeepers of the health system. The study highlights changes in the overall availability, accessibility, and workload of GPs during the pandemic. Methods We used routine health facility data at the national level to describe the changes in GPs over the past three years, before the pandemic (2017-2019) and during the pandemic (2020-2022). Specifically, we looked at the total number of GPs, the percentage of specialists, the average number of citizens per GP, the services used per capita, the average number of visits per GP, and the leading causes of morbidity. Results The study found a decrease in the total number of GPs in both periods (before: -10%, during: -9%) and in the number of specialists (before: -2%, during: -3%). During the pandemic, the average number of citizens per GP varied. In 2022, the average number of visits per GP decreased noticeably to 3557 GPs, of which 37% were specialists. In the same year, each GP received 6661 annual visits and served 1509 citizens on average. However, these figures exhibit considerable regional and geographical differences. Circulatory and respiratory diseases were the most common reasons for visiting a GP (about 14% and 13% of all visits, respectively). Up to 10% of all visits resulted in either a diagnosis of external factors that influence health status or in ill-defined symptoms, clinical and laboratory findings. Conclusions This study’s findings underscore the critical reductions in availability, accessibility, and workload of general practitioners in the Serbian public sector and emphasize the importance of strengthening the primary healthcare system to better respond to future challenges. Key messages • Public health officials should prioritize the development of effective strategies and policies that focus on improving the quality and accessibility of primary health care services in Serbia. • A greater investment in general practice is necessary to ensure it can effectively meet the population’s needs during health emergencies.

A qualitative study on rehabilitation services at primary health care: insights from primary health care stakeholders in low-resource contexts

BackgroundThe chasm between rehabilitation needs and available rehabilitation services is widening. In most low-resource contexts, there are inadequate rehabilitation professionals at primary health care (PHC), leaving nonrehabilitation primary care providers’ (PCPs) and district rehabilitation professionals and managers to address patients’ rehabilitation needs. This study explored rehabilitation and non-rehabilitation PCPs’ and managers’ perspectives on the situation of rehabilitation service provision in PHC settings and the challenges experienced in providing rehabilitation care.MethodsIn this descriptive, exploratory qualitative study, individual semi-structured interviews and focus group discussions were conducted with purposefully sampled PCPs in Manicaland, Zimbabwe and Eastern Cape, South Africa. The transcripts were analysed thematically using Atlas.ti. version 22.2®.ResultsThirty-six PCPs (29 nonrehabilitation and 7 rehabilitation) and one district manager participated in the study. The current PHC rehabilitation services in the two low-resource contexts were described as inadequate, if not nonexistent. District rehabilitation professionals attempted to fill the gap through outreach and home visits, but resource limitations, particularly in Zimbabwe, often hampered this strategy. The nonrehabilitation PCPs took on task-shifting roles in the identification, referral, and education of patients with rehabilitation needs in the absence of rehabilitation professionals at PHC. Challenges encountered in providing rehabilitation care at PHC included unsupportive leadership, human resource shortages, lack of comprehensive PHC rehabilitation guidelines, no or delayed rehabilitation referral, lack of clear communication strategies, and users’ low demand for PHC rehabilitation.ConclusionTailored approaches, including context-specific rehabilitation guidance for existing task-shifting models, increased investment in rehabilitation and increased rehabilitation awareness, are needed to establish basic rehabilitation services in the described contexts because they are mostly absent. Importantly, the PHC systems in which rehabilitation is to be nested need to be strengthened.

Organizational innovations related to Primary Care Access Points (GAP) for unattached patients in Quebec: a multi-case qualitative study

BackgroundBeing attached to a primary care (PC) provider is at the core of a strong primary health care system. Centralized waiting lists (CWL) for unattached patients have been implemented in eight provinces of Canada to support the attachment process. In Quebec, the Ministry of Health mandated the implementation of Primary Care Access Points (GAP) across the province to help unattached patients navigate the health system while awaiting attachment through the CWL. Several local health territories developed complementary innovations to the GAP to respond to local population needs. This paper aims to describe five organizational innovations implemented locally.MethodsThis multi-case qualitative study was conducted in four local health territories in the province of Quebec. Fifty-two semi-structured interviews with healthcare managers, nurses, physicians, other health professionals and administrative staff were conducted between April 2023 and April 2024. An interview guide was developed based on existing frameworks on the implementation of innovations and the evaluation of the GAP. Thematic analysis was conducted using NVivo software. Inductive and deductive approaches were used to develop relevant codes and themes. Logic models were built to describe the organizational innovations.ResultsFive organizational innovations are described. First, a multidisciplinary clinic aimed at responding to patients with mental health issues was implemented. Second, a nurse clinic was implemented to provide temporary care for patients with unstable chronic illnesses. The third innovation is a mobile proximity clinic where unattached GAP patients are first evaluated by a paramedic before receiving care from a nurse. Fourth, a pharmacist trajectory was implemented to increase engagement of community pharmacists to respond to GAP patients. The last innovation is a decentralized GAP offering in-person nursing care to unattached GAP patients.ConclusionsDescriptions of these five innovations are key to inform other territories and provinces on ways to improve access for unattached patients while they are waiting to be attached. The introduction of the GAP and the organizational innovations, suggests a transition where access to PC services does not rely solely on attachment status.

Review on the Global Healthcare System and the Posture of the Nigerian Primary Healthcare System

Review on the Global Healthcare System and the Posture of the Nigerian Primary Healthcare System

Primary health care as the main guarantor of a healthy population in the country and a global challenge in the world: a systematic review

Background Primary health care (PHC) is a fundamental aspect of healthcare systems globally, playing a crucial role in maintaining the health of the population. Despite its importance, there are still gaps in the delivery of PHC services. This study aims to analyze the healthcare system and the existing gaps to develop strategies for improving PHC services. Methods This study is a mixed method a combination of documentary analysis and narrative synthesis as an alternative to meta-analysis. For our systematic review, we primarily focused on articles published within the last 10 years. However, we also included some older articles (published between 2003 and 2009) that provided valuable insights into the historical context and evolution of primary healthcare systems. Data of each article reviewed during the review - Study, Article, Study setting, Study design, Study assessment, Study suggestions are presented in Table 1. A total of 38 articles were reviewed. The data sources include peer-reviewed articles and other relevant literature on PHC services. With appropriate keywords. Results The study identifies gaps in PHC services, including issues with access to care, affordability, and quality of care. It provides insights into the challenges faced by PHC systems worldwide, highlighting the need for strategies to address these issues. Conclusions The study contributes to a better understanding of the challenges faced by PHC systems worldwide and provides insights for policymakers and healthcare providers to improve healthcare services. The systematic review, which focuses on PHC, was conducted following the PRISMA guidelines. The PRISMA diagram of study selection was used to illustrate the process of article inclusion and exclusion. Table 1 provides a summary of the key information from the selected articles.

A holistic approach to address female genital schistosomiasis in Ghana and Madagascar: the FGS Accelerated Scale Together Package

Women and girls who have been infected with the blood fluke Schistosoma haematobium can experience the chronic form of urogenital schistosomiasis, called female genital schistosomiasis (FGS). Some FGS symptoms resemble sexually transmitted infections. As a result, women and girls seeking treatment are often misdiagnosed and stigmatized. The FGS Accelerated Scale Together (FAST) Package project implemented a holistic approach to address FGS combining proven interventions in training, mass drug administration, diagnosis, and treatment as well as community awareness to address FGS in four selected districts in Ghana and Madagascar. The FAST Package was supported by an FGS National Committee who provided guidance on integration at the national level. Using an implementation research design, researchers worked closely with government counterparts in the programs for neglected tropical diseases in both countries. Baseline cross-sectional surveys and qualitative methodologies collected information on schistosomiasis and FGS awareness, experience with health seeking behaviors and knowledge of schistosomiasis prevention amongst community members and teachers. FAST Package interventions included healthcare provider training delivered in online and in person formats; development of an Educators’ booklet to support schistosomiasis/FGS awareness creation among teachers, healthcare providers and community members; suspected FGS case detection; and advocacy for the provision of praziquantel in the primary health care system. Endline results included a cross-sectional survey and qualitative methodologies amongst community members and teachers, including Photovoice for women of reproductive health age exposed to FGS. This paper presents a description of the FAST Package project, the value of its holistic approach, and selected results from both countries. It discusses the lessons learnt highlighting some of the challenges and opportunities for integration within the health system.

Persons with Disabilities Living in Rural Areas of Bangladesh: An Exploration of Their Mental Health and Experiences in Accessing Support During the COVID-19 Pandemic

ABSTRACT The COVID-19 pandemic has presented a major public health challenge across the world, including in Bangladesh. Little scholarly work has explored the mental health experiences of persons with disabilities in rural areas of Bangladesh during the pandemic. A qualitative case study was conducted in the rural areas of Narayanganj, Gazipur, and Narsingdi. A total of 13 in-depth interviews (IDIs) with persons with disabilities and 13 key informant interviews (KIIs) with different stakeholders and caregivers were conducted. Thematic analysis was used to analyse the data. The findings revealed five major themes: lockdown-induced mental health problems, including fear of infection, symptoms of anxiety and depression, sleep disturbance, suicidal ideation, and domestic violence; perceived attitude towards mental health issues, including stigma and discrimination; perceived vulnerability was observed in relation to gender, age, and type of disability; barriers to seeking mental health care including distance, financial burden, and indifference towards mental health care; and finally, availability of mental health care which reaffirms a lack of mental health care in rural areas. The findings highlight the importance of integrating mental health into the primary healthcare system with a focus on persons with disabilities to minimise mental health repercussions during times of emergency.

Feasibility test of WORK-ON: a vocational rehabilitation intervention for people with chronic inflammatory arthritis

BackgroundPeople with chronic inflammatory arthritis (IA) often have a reduced work ability. Consequently, they are at high risk of losing their jobs and being permanently excluded from the labor market. Therefore, we developed a new context-specific vocational rehabilitation intervention for people with IA based on the Medical Research Council’s framework for complex interventions. This intervention is called “WORK-ON” and consists of: (1) Initial assessment and goal setting by an occupational therapist experienced in rheumatology rehabilitation; (2) coordinated support from the same occupational therapist, including assistance in navigating the primary and secondary healthcare and social care systems; (3) group sessions for peer support; and (4) individually tailored consultations with physiotherapists, nurses, and/or social workers. This study investigates the feasibility of WORK-ON.MethodsA 6-month single-arm feasibility study with a pre-test post-test design was conducted to evaluate recruitment, intervention fidelity and delivery, data collection, and possible outcome measures. Work ability was the primary outcome, and sick leave, quality of life, fatigue, pain, physical activity, sleep, and well-being were the secondary outcomes evaluated.ResultsIn total, 19 participants (17 women and 2 men) with a median age of 55 years (range, 34–64) participated and completed WORK-ON. Of these, 17 participants completed patient-reported outcomes at baseline and follow-up, and the results indicated a tendency to improvement in work ability, quality of life, level of physical activity, decrease in pain, and increase in days of sick leave during the 6-month intervention period. The rehabilitation clinicians spent an average of 15.3 h per participant, and the participants spent an average of 13.5 h in the intervention.ConclusionsWORK-ON is considered feasible and has the potential to increase work ability among people with IA who are concerned about their future ability to keep working. Though, an adjustment of the intervention is needed before testing in a randomized controlled trial.

Racial Disparities in Foot Examination among People with Diabetes in Brazil: A Nationwide Survey, 2019.

To assess the absence of diabetic foot examination in Brazil and how ethnicity affected this outcome. This is an analysis of a nationwide survey held in Brazil in 2019. Participants with diabetes and that were 15 years of age or older were eligible for inclusion in the analysis. Adjusted Poisson regression with robust variance was used to calculate prevalence ratios (PRs) and 95% confidence intervals (95% CIs) of never having had the foot examined, with separate models according to ethnicity. Stata 14.2 was used for all calculations. We included 6216 individuals with diabetes; 52.1% (95%CI: 50.0%-54.2%) reported never having had their feet examined by a health care professional and 61% self-declared as Black (Black and Brown [Brazilian mixed race]). A higher frequency of negligence was observed among Black individuals (55.3%; 52.5%-58.1%) than among White individuals (48.2%; 45.0%-51.5%). Negligence was higher between 15- to 39-year-old participants (PR = 1.34, 1.14-1.57), lower educational level (PR = 1.37, 1.13-1.65), higher alcohol consumption (PR = 1.18, 1.06-1.31), fair health status (PR = 1.11, 1.01-1.21), and diabetes diagnosis of up to 10 years (PR = 1.42, 1.28-1.57). Among Blacks, tobacco use and other factors increased the frequency of the outcome, whereas participation in the Brazilian Unified Health System primary care program was a protection factor (P<.05). Black Brazilians with diabetes had higher negligence of foot examination by health care professionals. Strengthening primary care would help mitigate systemic racism in Brazil.

CDSS Adoption and the Role of Artificial Intelligence in Saudi Arabian Primary Healthcare

The integration of advanced Clinical Decision Support Systems (CDSS) is crucial in healthcare, especially in developing countries. However, the challenges to CDSS implementation in these settings are often overlooked, leading to implementation gaps. This study investigates the adoption of CDSS in primary healthcare facilities in Saudi Arabia through in-depth interviews with general practitioners. The advancement of primary healthcare systems in developing nations necessitates appropriate technological solutions to address issues such as equitable access, service quality, and patient satisfaction. The adoption of CDSS can potentially improve patient satisfaction and enhance medical consultations. Artificial intelligence -driven technologies like the Velys robot are transforming the medical field by assisting doctors in surgical procedures. In healthcare, Artificial intelligence (AI) can address issues related to complex diseases, aging populations, and workforce shortages. AI solutions can streamline patient flow, improve care coordination, and support personalized healthcare management. By assessing the impact of AI on patient care, healthcare efficiency, and effectiveness can be enhanced. This research highlights the challenges and opportunities in CDSS adoption in developing countries, with implications for healthcare improvement in Saudi Arabia.

Effective integration of COVID-19 vaccination with routine immunization: A case study from Kinshasa, DRC

BackgroundIn response to the challenge of maintaining COVID-19 vaccination coverage amidst the pandemic, VillageReach, in collaboration with the Ministry of Public Health Prevention and Hygiene in Kinshasa, DRC, integrated COVID-19 vaccination with routine immunization services at two primary healthcare facilities. This initiative, launched in July 2022, represented the first of its kind in the DRC, aiming to assess the effectiveness and scalability of a multimodal vaccination approach. MethodsThrough a rapid appraisal involving key informant interviews and analysis of pre- and post-integration service delivery data, this case study explores the operational dynamics and outcomes of integrating COVID-19 and routine immunizations. ResultsResults demonstrated that the integrated approach not only maintained COVID-19 vaccine coverage but also significantly enhanced routine immunization uptake, particularly among under-immunized and zero-dose children. Overall, the vaccination sites, outreach, and integrated health facilities administered 229,983 (33 %) of COVID-19 vaccines in Kinshasa, of which 53 % were referred by community health workers. Additionally, 998 under-immunized children received routine immunizations, of whom 126 were zero-dose children. Key success factors included sustained community health worker engagement, neighborhood-specific strategies, accessible vaccination points, and robust data management. The findings suggest that such integrative strategies can effectively bolster immunization coverage in urban poor communities, offering valuable insights for similar initiatives in the DRC and beyond. ConclusionThis study advocates for sustained investment in innovative immunization models to strengthen primary healthcare systems post-pandemic.

Assessment of the compliance with minimum quality standards by public primary healthcare facilities in Nigeria

Achieving universal health coverage (UHC) and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) by 2030 relies on the delivery of quality healthcare services through effective primary healthcare (PHC) systems. This necessitates robust infrastructure, adequately skilled health workers and the availability of essential medicines and commodities. Despite the critical role of minimum standards in benchmarking PHC quality, no global consensus on these standards exists. Nigeria has established minimum standards to enhance healthcare accessibility and quality, including the Revised Ward Health System Strategy (RWHSS) by the National Primary Health Care Development Agency (NPHCDA). This paper outlines the evolution of PHC minimum standards in Nigeria, evaluates compliance with RWHSS standards across all public PHC facilities, and examines the implications for ongoing PHC revitalization efforts. The study used a cross-sectional descriptive design to assess compliance across 25 736 public PHC facilities in Nigeria. Data collection involved a national survey using a standardized assessment tool focussing on infrastructure, staffing, essential medicines and service delivery. Compliance with RWHSS minimum standards was found to be below 50% across all facilities, with median compliance scores of 40.7%. Outreach posts had a median compliance of 32.6%, level 1 facilities 31.5% and level 2+ facilities 50.9%. Key findings revealed major gaps in health infrastructure, human resources and availability of essential medicines and equipment. Compliance varied regionally, with the North-west showing the highest number of facilities but varied performance across standards. The lessons learned underscore the urgent need for targeted interventions and resource allocation to address the identified deficiencies. This study highlights the critical need for regular, comprehensive compliance assessments to guide policy-makers in identifying gaps and strengthening PHC systems in Nigeria. Recommendations include enhancing monitoring mechanisms, improving resource distribution and focussing on infrastructure and human resource development to meet UHC and SDG targets. Addressing these gaps is essential for advancing Nigeria’s healthcare system and ensuring equitable, quality care for all.