Prey Size Preference Research Articles

The Effect of Prey Size and Prey Density on Paralarval Feeding Success of the Common Sydney Octopus, Octopus tetricus

ABSTRACTGlobal demand for octopus seafood has been increasing over the past 30 years. This demand is projected to increase further as coastal communities and seafood consumers seek alternative sources of protein as finfish stocks decline. The establishment of a sustainable octopus aquaculture would have the potential to alleviate fishing pressures from wild populations. Commercial‐scale octopus aquaculture, however, has not been achieved due to the difficulty of successfully rearing octopus paralarvae on an efficacious diet. This study investigated the prey size and density preferences of Octopus tetricus paralarvae to understand the characteristics that improve food acquisition during rearing. Groups of octopus paralarvae from multiple broods were observed for a range of feeding behaviour including positioning, attack, capture loss, successful capture and handling time when given different treatments of Artemia prey. Prey size experiments used treatments of Artemia with total lengths of < 0.5, 0.9–1.0 and 1.4–1.6 mm, while prey density experiments used 0.2, 0.6, 1.0, 1.4, 1.8 and 2.2 Artemia mL−1. Increased numbers of successful feeding behaviours (e.g., positionings, attacks and successful captures) were directly observed with increasing prey size. Octopus paralarvae performed 52% more positionings, 100% more attacks and 175% more successful captures when given large Artemia (1.4–1.6 mm) than when given small Artemia (< 0.5 mm). Likewise, the number of observed successful feeding behaviours tended to increase with increasing Artemia density but sharply decreased at the highest density treatment (2.2 Artemia mL−1). Paralarvae performed up to 109% more positionings, 307% more attacks and 300% more successful captures when given prey densities of 1.0–1.8 Artemia mL−1 than when given lower prey density treatments and 2.2 Artemia mL−1. The results from this study indicate that prey size and density are crucial for the successful feeding of octopus paralarvae. Based on the greatest numbers of successful feeding behaviours, O. tetricus paralarvae prefer prey between 1.4 and 1.6 mm in length and at densities between 1.0 and 1.8 prey mL−1. The use of these optimal prey characteristics can be used to promote efficient paralarval octopus prey capture and feeding to greatly increase food intake in octopus paralarvae when reared in aquaculture.

In Situ Videography Quantifies Temporal and Spatial Variation in Prey Consumption and Energy Intake by Stream‐Dwelling Bull Trout (Salvelinus confluentus)

ABSTRACTIn stream ecosystems, invertebrates are a principal source of prey for many fishes, but their abundance as a food source depends on the predator's ability to exploit them in time and space. Although salmonid fishes are commonly thought of as daytime drift‐feeding predators of invertebrates in streams, they exhibit great flexibility in foraging behaviour and may also consume prey from the benthos and at night. Char species, (Salvelinus sp.), in particular, may be better adapted to forage under low light conditions due to greater scotopic sensitivity than other salmonids. In this study, we used in situ or in place videography to quantify the foraging behaviour of bull trout (Salvelinus confluentus) and determine when and where they capture prey. We found that bull trout were primarily daytime predators of invertebrates drifting in the water column, and that they rarely captured prey from the benthos or foraged at night. We did observe size‐related differences and seasonal declines in foraging rate from summer to fall months. A modelled estimate of energy intake indicates that daytime drift‐feeding by small size classes of bull trout was above that needed for a maximum daily ration under a range of assumptions about prey size and prey retention rates. Energy intake rates for larger fish were more dependent on assumptions of preferred prey size and prey retention rates. Our data indicate that daytime measures of invertebrate drift abundance and size are the most inclusive measure of food abundance for stream‐dwelling bull trout.

Diet Composition and Feeding Habits of Fish Larvae of Five Species in the Burullus Lake, Egypt

Feeding habits of fish larvae were analysed in a comparative study of five species (Oreochromis niloticus, O. aureus, Tilapia zilli, Mugil cephalus and Liza ramada) from the Burullus Lake. We investigated the potential influence of larvae size on their feeding and looked for common patterns in larval prey preference. Gut contents of a total of 1068 larvae were examined. The feeding habits of the examined larvae shared some characteristics. As larvae of the five species grew, the preferred prey size and the number and diversity of prey in the gut increased. On the other hand, larval feeding also differed in several aspects, especially differences in the composition of preferred prey items. For Cichlidae larvae, the dominant prey was the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis followed by copepodite stages. For M. cephalus larvae, the copepods Paracalanus sp and Acartia sp were the most important diets, while for L. ramada, decapod larvae were the most important. The Mugilidae larvae consumed significantly larger prey than the cichlid larvae, which could be related to their morphology, especially the mouth size. Ivlev’s selectivity index calculated for larvae showed positive selection for particular prey. In all the species, copepods were the most selected, particularly for Mugillidae larvae, but for Cichlidae larvae, the rotifer Brachionus competed with copepods as a selected prey. This dietary study of fish larvae of these important species is essential for the development of fisheries and can be implemented in further related studies of other areas.

Prey size preference in the tokay gecko (Gekko gecko).

The optimal foraging theory posits that animals aim to maximize energy intake while minimizing predation and handling costs during foraging. Most observed animal behaviour supports this theory, but occasional deviations provide insights into the ecological factors that shape foraging decisions. We tested prey-size preference using a two-choice test between different prey sizes in tokay geckos. We expected geckos to prefer larger prey and decision latencies to be longer when discrimination was more difficult and when small prey was offered. Geckos preferred larger prey when the size difference was large, although decision latency remained consistent. This aligns with prior research on sit-and-wait predators. Together with previous findings showing freezing behaviour after prey capture in tokay geckos, our findings suggest a strong influence of predator avoidance on foraging decisions opening up a new avenue for future research investigating the link between decision making and predator avoidance in tokay geckos.

Allometry of Defense: Predator Shift Alters Ontogenetic Growth Patterns in an Antipredator Trait.

Predation is a major factor driving prey trait diversification and promoting ecological speciation. Consequently, antipredator traits are widely studied among prey species. However, comparative studies that examine how different predators shape the ontogenetic growth of antipredator traits are scarce. In larval dragonflies, abdominal spines are effective traits against predatory fish in fish lakes, which prefer larger prey. However, defensive spines increase mortality in habitats dominated by invertebrate predators (invertebrate lakes), which prefer smaller prey. Thus, species from fish lakes may accelerate spine growth at a later body size compared to species from invertebrate lakes when growing into the preferred prey size range of predatory fish. In this study, we constructed the allometric relationship between spine length and body size and compared the inflexion point of those growth curves in five species of Leucorrhinia dragonfly larvae. We found that fish-lake Leucorrhinia species accelerated spine growth at a larger body size than congenerics from invertebrate lakes. Further, rather than extending spine length constantly through development, fish-lake species rapidly accelerated spine growth at a larger body size. This is likely to be adaptive for avoiding invertebrate predation at an early life stage, which are also present in fish lakes, though in smaller numbers. Our results highlight that comparative studies of ontogenetic patterns in antipredator traits might be essential to develop an integrated understanding of predator-prey interactions.

The costs and trade-offs of optimal foraging in marine fish larvae.

In a warming world, both the metabolic rates of ectotherm predators and the phenology of their prey organisms is subject to change. Knowledge on how intrinsic and extrinsic factors govern predator-prey interactions is essential in order to understand how the environment regulates the vital rates of consumers. Controlled experiments, however, simultaneously testing behavioural and growth responses of the larvae of fish and other ectotherm organisms in different feeding regimes are scarce. Prey size (PS) selection was determined for young Atlantic herring Clupea harengus L. larvae offered 100- to 850-μm copepods Acartia tonsa at five different concentrations. In separate, 4- (13°C) or 7-day (7°C) trials, the effect of prey size on larval foraging behaviour, specific growth rate (SGR) and biochemical condition (RNA:DNA, RD, a proxy for individual instantaneous growth) was tested. Preferred (selected) PS was similar at all prey concentrations but increased from 3% to 5% predator length with increasing larval size. At various temperatures, dome-shaped relationships existed between PS and larval RD (and accordingly SGR). Compensatory changes in foraging behaviour (pause and feeding strike frequencies) existed but were not adequate to maintain positive SGR when available prey were substantially smaller than those preferred by larvae. A physiology-based model predicted that larvae depended more heavily on optimal prey sizes at the colder versus warmer temperature to grow well and that the profitable prey niche breadth (the range in prey sizes in which growth was positive) increased at warmer temperatures. Seemingly subtle match-mismatch dynamics between ectotherm predators and their preferred prey size can have large, temperature-dependent consequences for rates of growth and likely survival of the predator. To the best knowledge, this was the first study to directly quantify the "costs and trade-offs" of optimal foraging in marine fish larvae.

Size Preference of Live Fish Prey in the Pellet-Consuming Pikeperch

The production of pikeperch in a recirculation aquaculture system (RAS) is of growing importance. However, the use of combined technologies may also be justified, especially in countries with larger pond areas. However, this requires the most effective adaptation of pellet-consuming individuals to pond conditions. Foraging training, a form of environmental enrichment to compensate for the poor environment in hatchery rearing, can play a major role in this. The aim of our study was to investigate the prey size preference already observed in wild pikeperch, during prey capture by intensively reared naive individuals. We investigated predation success, latency, number of attempts during the process, and size distribution, in a total of 152 foraging trials of 38 pikeperch fingerlings (mean TL = 90.65 mm) at three different prey sizes (predator–prey length ratio (PPR): 0.11, 0.22, 0.33). Although predation on medium–large prey was more successful overall, it was achieved in more attempts and with greater latency. Small prey was captured with the fewest attempts. These results suggest that when calculating prey size in the foraging training of pikeperch, it is recommended to use a 0.11–0.22 PPR less than the optimal PPR described for wild individuals.

Prey preference of a wasp determined by nest size supports the role of natural selection in body size evolution in Cassidinae leaf beetles

Abstract The prey preference of a predator can impose natural selection on prey phenotypes, including body size. Despite evidence that large body size protects against predation in insects, the determinants of body size variation in Cassidinae leaf beetles are not well understood. We examined the prey preference of the digger wasp Cerceris albofasciata, a specialist predator of adult Cassidinae leaf beetles, and found evidence for natural selection on prey body size. The wasp hunted prey smaller than the size of their nest entrance. However, the wasp preferred larger prey species among those that could be carried into their nest. Thus, the benefits of large prey and the cost associated with nest expansion might determine the prey size preference. As expected from the prey species preference, the wasp preferred small individuals of the largest prey species, Thlaspida biramosa, and large individuals of the smallest prey species, Cassida piperata, resulting in natural selection on body sizes. In intermediate-sized prey species, however, there was no evidence for selection on body size. Natural selection on body size might explain the variation of prey morphologies that increase body size, such as explanate margins, in this group.

Prey size and species preferences in the invasive blue crab, Callinectes sapidus: Potential effects in marine and freshwater ecosystems

The blue crab, Callinectes sapidus is an invasive species in the Mediterranean region. In Ebro Delta bays, it poses an important risk for the cultivation of Mediterranean mussel (Mytillus galloprovincialis) and Pacific oyster (Crassostrea gigas). Besides, the species thrives in the Ebro River hosting abundant populations of apple snail (Pomacea maculata) and Asian clam (Corbicula fluminea). Food-preference experiments were conducted to assess the effect of predator and prey sizes and prey type (M. galloprovincialis vs. C. gigas and P. maculata vs. C. fluminea) in predation patterns and its possible causes. Our results show that except for the Pacific oyster, which attains protection at sizes of 50–70 mm and was little consumed (0–16%), the other preys are readily predated, at variable rates (mussels: 38–96%; apple snail: 58–93%, and Asian clam: 67–100%), depending on predator and prey sizes. Juveniles and young blue crab adults showed greater consumption of small and medium mussels and a similar trend occurred with Asian clam. In contrast, large and medium apple snails were more heavily predated by adult blue crabs. Species comparisons also showed higher predation of mussels than oysters (71 vs. 8%), and of apple snail than Asian clam (99 vs. 72%). Once the shell barrier was removed, preference for mussels was still preserved, suggesting a nutritional preference. Our results point the need of fishing blue crab in marine areas to prevent losses in mussel production and highlight the potential control exerted over undesired invasive mollusk species.

Factors controlling the migration phenology of Siberian Phylloscopus species

The timing of annual events in migratory species is determined by the position of breeding and wintering grounds, length of the breeding season, the occurrence of their preferred diet or the timing of moult in birds. Previous studies found significant differences in the migration phenology of Asian Phylloscopus warbler species, a group of long-distance migratory passerines. However, the factors that influence the observed differences in migration phenology have not been studied yet. Here, we analyze the effect of the above-mentioned factors on the migration timing of seven Phylloscopus species at a stopover site in the Russian Far East. We found that spring migration phenology was best explained by moult strategy and the preferred prey size, while autumn migration phenology was linked to the southernmost wintering latitude of the species. Interspecific differences in migration timing were much higher in autumn than in spring. The duration of the species-specific migration periods was also longer in autumn than in spring, most likely caused by higher competition during spring to arrive early at the breeding grounds. Our results contribute to the understanding of migration ecology in songbirds moving along the little-studied East Asian flyway.

Comparing Trophic Niches of Sympatric Raptors in Agricultural Landscape in Central Poland

According to basic ecological principle, species that share the same niche do not occupy the same environment for a long time, and sympatry of two or more such species provides an interesting field for the analysis of their trophic niche differentiation. To examine the potential differences in the dimensions of the trophic niche we studied the diet of three sympatric avian predators that prey on colonial Microtus rodents. The study area in central Poland is located in an agricultural landscape, composed of crop fields, as well as meadows and pastures located within a small river valley. The pellets of long-eared owl (Asio otus), barn owl (Tyto alba) and kestrel (Falco tinnunculus) were collected from the 750 m2 study site including church building and its surrounding in the spring of 2016 and 2017. The analysis of pellets provided data on a total of 4128 vertebrate prey individuals (1914 from barn owl, 1749 from long-eared owl, and 465 from kestrel). The most important prey group of all three predators were small mammals (90%, 14 species) and the most frequently preyed species was Microtus arvalis (making up 72% of vertebrate prey of long-eared owl, 59% of kestrel and 53% of barn owl). Despite the general similarity in the diet composition, there were differences in the contribution of several prey species (e.g. Soricomorpha, M. arvalis, Mus musculus, Rattus norvegicus, and Apodemus spp.) and the diversity of the diet between the predators. We conclude that the trophic niches of the studied sympatric species differ in several dimensions, including diel activity, prey size and taxon-specific feeding preferences.

Otter diet changes in a reservoir during a severe autumn drought

Abstract Eurasian otters (Lutra lutra) are known to make extensive use of reservoirs in the Iberian Peninsula, where they forage preferentially on small-size fish (10–20 cm). We hypothesized that the usual consumption of small-size fish by otters in reservoirs is not due to prey size preference, but rather to a higher level of difficulty in capturing larger prey. We studied otter diet in a reservoir that experienced an abrupt drop in stored water caused by an unusually severe drought. We compared relative prey size, hunting success, and diving times between the year of the drought (2017) and two standard rainfall years (2015 and 2016). Otters ate a similar proportion of small and large fish during the drought instead of predominantly eating small fish. Mean diving time during the drought was similar to that of the standard climatic years, indicating a similar physiological cost of capture between small and large fish. Otters had higher hunting success in the drought year (89%) than in the standard years (63%) regardless of prey size. This suggests a higher level of catchability of both fish size classes during the drought as the water level was lower. Results suggest that the usual consumption of small-sized fish by otters in reservoirs could not be related to preference or relative abundance but rather to the difficulty of capturing large-size fish when water levels are high.

Prey size selection in invasive (Hemigrapsus sanguineus and H. takanoi) compared with native (Carcinus maenas) marine crabs

AbstractIntroductions of predators can have strong effects on native ecosystems and knowledge of the prey size selection of invasive predators is pivotal to understand their impact on native prey and intraguild competitors. Here, we investigated the prey size selection of two invasive crabs (Hemigrapsus sanguineus and Hemigrapsus takanoi) recently invading European coasts and compared them with native shore crabs (Carcinus maenas) which are known to feed on similar prey species. In laboratory experiments, we offered different size classes of native blue mussels (Mytilus edulis) to different size classes of the crab species in an effort to identify the respective prey size preferences and potential overlap in prey size range of native and invasive crabs. In all three species, the preferred prey size increased with crab size reflecting general predator–prey size relationships. Prey size preference did not differ among the crab species, i.e. crabs showed similar mussel size preference in relation to carapace width. Given that additional morphological measurements showed that both of the invasive crab species have much larger claws relative to their body size compared with the native species, this finding was surprising and may relate to differential claw morphologies or structural strength. These results suggest that the invasive crabs exert predation pressure on the same size classes of native mussels as the native crabs, with potential effects on mussel population dynamics due to the high densities of the invaders. In addition, the overlap in prey size range is likely to result in resource competition between invasive and native crabs.

Evidence for resource partitioning by ontogeny and species in calanoid copepods

In marine ecosystems, copepods provide an important link between primary producers and secondary consumers. However, resource partitioning in copepods within the water column remains unknown. We investigated inter- and intraspecific differences in resource utilization and feeding migration ranges among five species of filter-feeding copepods: Calanus sinicus, Mesocalanus tenuicornis, Metridia pacifica, Neocalanus cristatus, and N. plumchrus, within the epipelagic zone (0–200 m depth) in the East Sea (Japan Sea) during autumn using stable isotope analysis. In the study region, the numerical abundances of these copepods accounted for over 87% of the total number of copepods. Trophic relationships between these copepods and the vertical profiles of three types of cell-size-fractionated organic matter (POM) including pico- (<2 μm), nano- (2–20 μm), and micro-POM (20–200 μm) indicated inter- and intraspecific differences in prey-size preference and feeding migration range. The prey-size preferences of copepods appeared to be closely related to their body size. Moreover, the feeding migration ranges of C. sinicus, M. tenuicornis, and N. cristatus were confined to the surface layer during the developmental progression of copepodid stages, whereas those of M. pacifica and N. plumchrus extended from the surface to deeper layers. Therefore, we suggest that coexistence of these copepods is determined primarily by size-dependent prey-size preference, and inter- and intraspecific differences in the patterns of feeding migration.

Top–down limits on prey populations may be more severe in larger prey species, despite having fewer predators

Variation in the vulnerability of herbivore prey to predation is linked to body size, yet whether this relationship is size‐nested or size‐partitioned remains debated. If size‐partitioned, predators would be focused on prey within their preferred prey size range. If size‐nested, smaller prey species should become increasingly more vulnerable because increasingly more predators are capable of catching them. Yet, whether either of these strategies manifests in top–down prey population limitation would depend both on the number of potential predator species as well as the total mortality imposed. Here we use a rare ecosystem scale ‘natural experiment’ comparing prey population dynamics between a period of intense predator persecution and hence low predator densities and a period of active predator protection and population recovery. We use three decades of data on herbivore abundance and distribution to test the role of predation as a mechanism of population limitation among prey species that vary widely in body size. Notably, we test this within one of the few remaining systems where a near‐full suite of megaherbivores occur in high density and are thus able to include a thirtyfold range in herbivore body size gradient. We test whether top–down limitation on prey species of particular body size leads to compositional shifts in the mammalian herbivore community. Our results support both size‐nested and size‐partitioning predation but suggest that the relative top–down limiting impact on prey populations may be more severe for intermediate sized species, despite having fewer predators than small species. In addition we show that the gradual recovery of predator populations shifted the herbivore community assemblage towards large‐bodied species and has led to a community that is strongly dominated by large herbivore biomass.

Advantages of social foraging in crab spiders: Groups capture more and larger prey despite the absence of a web

AbstractAmong group‐living spiders, subsocial representatives in the family of crab spiders (Thomisidae) are a special case, as they build protective communal leaf nests instead of extensive communal capture webs. It could thus be inferred that antipredator benefits (e.g., enhanced protection in larger nests) rather than foraging‐related advantages (e.g., capture of more and larger prey) promote sociality in this family. Nonetheless, subsocial crab spiders do share prey, and if this behaviour does not reflect mere food scramble but has a cooperative character, crab spiders may offer insights into the evolution of social foraging applicable to many other cooperative predators that hunt without traps. Here, we performed a comparative laboratory feeding experiment on three of the four subsocial crab spider species—Australomisidia ergandros, Australomisidia socialis and Xysticus bimaculatus—to determine if crab spiders derive advantages from foraging in groups. In particular, we tested artificially composed groups of five sibling spiderlings vs. single siblings in terms of prey capture success and prey size preference. Across species, groups had higher prey capture success (measured in terms of capture rates and capture latency) and were more likely to attack large, sharable prey—dynamics leading to reduced food competition among group members in favour of living and foraging in groups. Within groups, we further compared prey extraction efficiency among the three applied social foraging tactics: producing, scrounging and feeding alone. In A. ergandros, individuals were exceptionally efficient when using the non‐cooperative scrounger tactic, which entails feeding on the prey provided by others. Thus, our multispecies comparison confirms foraging advantages in maintaining a cooperative lifestyle for crab spiders, but also demonstrates the relevance of research into exploitation of cooperative foraging in this family.

Colony size, habitat structure, and prey size shape the predation ecology of a social pseudoscorpion from a tropical savanna

Predation strategies are driven by habitat structure, prey’s nutritional value, and/or by predator characteristics such as developmental stage. Here, we evaluated the feeding habits of the social pseudoscorpion Paratemnoides nidificator in two areas of a Brazilian Cerrado savanna. These pseudoscorpions live under tree bark trunks of varying sizes; habitat structure could interfere with pseudoscorpion ambushing behavior and prey accessibility. We therefore assessed the hypotheses that (i) small and large colonies of P. nidificator will capture prey of distinct amounts and sizes; (ii) habitat structure will limit the captured prey size; (iii) there will be an age-dependent prey choice in P. nidificator. We evaluated the prey items, colony composition, and habitat structure of pseudoscorpions and determined whether P. nidificator presents age-dependent feeding preferences by offering prey items of different sizes. Colonies with more individuals captured more prey items and those prey presented a wider size variety. P. nidificator can capture a high variety of prey sizes by using openings in tree bark as a trap; however, only tree barks of intermediate size amplitude may be used for trapping most prey. Nymphs showed no preference for prey size, while adults mainly fed on larger ants. Tree bark may play a role as a phenotype extension by easing the process of large prey capture, which is considered a crucial factor for social species. Small prey might be a complementary food resource for nymphs, reducing intraspecific competition and their exposure to larger, dangerous prey. Habitat structure and prey’s traits such as size affect the predation strategies of several animals. How these features interfere in the feeding habits and prey accessibility of social arachnids is a matter of question. We showed that habitat structure and colony size drive the prey size preference of a social pseudoscorpion. Paratemnoides nidificator lives under tree trunk barks that vary in size, depth, and shape. The tree bark openings may play a crucial role by easing the capture process of different prey sizes, including large prey, which is considered a crucial factor for social species. According to the prey size hypothesis, social species require, collectively, higher amounts of food energy. Thus, we propose that the bark openings are related to the evolution of P. nidificator’s social behavior as they potentially allow the capture of larger and more nutritious prey.

Trophic overlap between expanding and contracting fish predators in a range margin undergoing change

Climate change is predicted to cause a freshening of the Baltic Sea, facilitating range expansions of freshwater species and contractions of marine. Resident marine flounders (Platichthys flesus) and expansive freshwater roach (Rutilus rutilus) are dominant consumers in the Baltic Sea sublittoral where they occur in partial sympatry. By comparing patterns of resource use by flounders and roach along a declining resource gradient of blue mussels (Mytilus trossulus) our aim was to explore predator functional responses and the degree of trophic overlap. Understanding the nature of density-dependent prey acquisition has important implications for predicting population dynamics of both predators and their shared prey. Results showed a highly specialized diet for both species, high reliance on blue mussels throughout the range, similar prey size preference and high trophic overlap. Highest overlap occurred where blue mussels were abundant but overlap was also high where they were scarce. Our results highlight the importance of a single food item - the blue mussel - for both species, likely promoting high population size and range expansion of roach. Findings also suggest that range expansion of roach may have a top-down structuring force on mussels that differ in severity and location from that originating from resident flounders.

What should I eat? Experimental evidence for prey selection in grey seals

Understanding the responses of predators, such as seals, to variations in prey availability is key to understanding their role in marine ecosystems. Individual variation in prey preference is likely to be important but we have little information on this aspect of predator behaviour. Operant conditioning techniques and an underwater feeding apparatus were used to test the prey species and size preferences of five captive grey seals, Halichoerus grypus, in a series of paired choice trials. The experimental procedure was designed to present simple foraging choices to remove as many potentially confounding variables as possible. Results suggest that individual grey seals exhibit prey preferences. When presented with different numbers of items of the same species, seals generally selected the larger number of prey items. When presented with choices between two species, seals apparently showed consistent preferences for particular species. However, the apparent species preferences may be simply explained in terms of size selection.

Predator–prey mass ratio revisited: does preference of relative prey body size depend on individual predator size?

Summary Quantifying predator–prey body size relationships is key to understanding food webs. Food web models often assume that all individuals of predator species prefer the same relative body size of prey, using a single constant called preferred predator–prey mass ratio (preferred PPMR). In contrast, empirical studies have shown that relative prey body size in diet varies with individual predator size, challenging the food web models based on size‐invariant preferred PPMR and their predictions. We point out that this apparent inconsistency arises because empirical PPMR in those previous studies has been measured only through dietary data (i.e. realized PPMR rather than preferred PPMR) without considering the effects of environmental prey availability, suggesting the possibility that preferred PPMR may be in fact independent of individual predator size. Here, we present a new approach to revisit the assumption of size‐invariant preferred PPMR in food web models. The approach compares two measures of PPMR calculated from prey compositions in predator diet and environmental prey composition, respectively (i.e. realized PPMR vs. environmental PPMR). The deviations between realized and environmental PPMRs are considered as a proxy of individual variations in relative prey size preference (i.e. preferred PPMR). We apply this idea to long‐term dietary data of an omnivorous predatory fish species collected from a lake ecosystem over four decades. Our results showed that the preferred PPMR is independent of individual predator size when the foraging mode (i.e. the major prey type) of the predator is considered while the realized PPMR is size‐dependent regardless of the foraging mode, especially when analysed analogously to previous empirical studies. We suggest that the apparent inconsistency between theoretical assumption and empirical observation of PPMR is due to the conceptual and methodological confusion and could be resolved by distinguishing between preferred and realized PPMRs. Further, in contrast to the previous arguments based on realized PPMR, we provide the first empirical support for size‐invariant preferred PPMR. Future studies are encouraged to apply our ideas to other species/systems to test the robustness of size‐invariant preferred PPMR and to better describe food web models. A lay summary is available for this article.