Abstract Introduction/Objective Investigation of a clinical problem using steps of evidence-based practice (EBP) led to the development of a recommendation submitted for Choosing Wisely consideration. The prevalence of asymptomatic bacteriuria (ASB) in pregnancy is between 2-15%. ASB may be a concern in pregnancy because of its capacity for association with adverse outcomes, namely preterm delivery, low birthweight, and possible progression to pyelonephritis. Screening and treatment may reduce the risks of adverse outcomes, but data is not current. A point-of-care urine dipstick is low cost and commonly used at routine obstetrician clinic visits to screen for ASB. The urinalysis dipstick is associated with high false-positive and false-negative rates as compared to the gold standard urine culture. Some providers make the decision to treat ASB given a positive urinalysis screen without ordering a follow-up culture. Such practice could lead to overtreatment of the patient and poor antibiotic stewardship. Research question Is a urinalysis without culture sufficient for diagnosis and treatment of ASB during pregnancy? Methods/Case Report Laboratory Medicine Best Practices A-6 steps of Ask, Acquire, Appraise, Apply, Analyze, and Assess were utilized to develop an appropriate and relevant clinical question, collect literature, determine evidence value, assign ratings, implement into practice, and evaluate outcomes. During appraisal, six selected articles were graded according to study rating, practice, measures, and results, further including the final rating and effect size rating. Consistency and overall strength of the evidence were analyzed. Results (if a Case Study enter NA) Each evidence study demonstrated final ratings between 8 and 10, a rating of “Good,” and an effect size rating of “Substantial.” Consistency leads to a “High” overall strength among the body of evidence. Conclusion Obtain a urine culture if routine prenatal point-of-care dipstick urinalyses have findings consistent with asymptomatic bacteriuria. Urinalyses are limited as screening due to low sensitivity and specificity for bacteriuria. Positive urinalysis dipstick results should be neither the sole basis for diagnosis nor decision to treat.
Read full abstract