Presence Of Heterospecifics Research Articles

Density, Temperature, and Comingled Species Affect Fitness within Carrion Communities: Coexistence in Phormia regina and Lucilia sericata (Diptera: Calliphoridae)

Blow fly (Diptera: Calliphoridae) interactions vary between competition and facilitation. Female blow flies engage in aggregated egg-laying, resulting in larval feeding masses differing in density and species composition. Numerous species are abundant within the same season, and some oviposit near or directly on eggs of other species, modifying their oviposition location choice depending on the presence or absence of other species. The ability to coexist on carrion, a temporary resource, was successfully attributed to resource, spatial, and temporal heterogeneity. Despite these broad categorizations, the specific mechanisms of coexistence within blow fly communities require further investigation. This study investigates variation in temperature and larval density as potential mechanisms of coexistence between two forensically important blow fly species: Lucilia sericata Meigen and Phormia regina Meigen (Diptera: Calliphoridae). Larval density, species ratio mix, and ambient temperature during development were manipulated in the presence of conspecifics and heterospecifics in the laboratory, and the fitness of each species was measured. In heterospecific treatments, the survival and body size of P. regina increased even at high ambient temperatures. In contrast, the survival of L. sericata remained unaffected by density or presence of heterospecifics, whereas body size increased in L. sericata-dominated heterospecific treatments depending on temperature and density. The negative effects of density were observed at high ambient temperatures, suggesting that density impacts are a function of ambient temperature. Overall, species coexistence was dependent on temperature, which mediated the outcome of species interactions.

Females alter their mate preferences depending on hybridization risk.

Mating with another species is often maladaptive because it generally results in no or low-fitness offspring. When hybridization is sufficiently costly, individuals should avoid mating with heterospecifics even if it reduces their ability to mate with high-quality conspecifics that resemble heterospecifics. Here, we used spadefoot toads, Spea multiplicata, to evaluate whether females alter their preferences for conspecific male sexual signals (call rate) depending on heterospecific presence. When presented with conspecific signals against a background including both conspecific and heterospecific signals, females preferred male traits that were most dissimilar to heterospecifics-even though these signals are potentially associated with lower-quality mates. However, when these same females were presented with a background that included only conspecific signals, some females switched their preferences, choosing conspecific signals that were exaggerated and indicative of high-quality conspecific mates. Because only some females switched their preferences between these two chorus treatments, there was no population-level preference for exaggerated conspecific male signals in the absence of heterospecifics. These results show that hybridization risk can alter patterns of mate choice and, consequently, sexual selection on male signals. Moreover, they emphasize that the strength and expression of reproductive barriers between species (such as mate choice) can be context-dependent.

Neophobia and innovation in Critically Endangered Bali myna, Leucopsar rothschildi.

Behavioural flexibility can impact on adaptability and survival, particularly in today's changing world, and encompasses associated components like neophobia, e.g. responses to novelty, and innovation, e.g. problem-solving. Bali myna (Leucopsar rothschildi) are a Critically Endangered endemic species, which are a focus of active conservation efforts, including reintroductions. Gathering behavioural data can aid in improving and developing conservation strategies, like pre-release training and individual selection for release. In 22 captive Bali myna, we tested neophobia (novel object, novel food, control conditions), innovation (bark, cup, lid conditions) and individual repeatability of latency responses in both experiments. We found effects of condition and presence of heterospecifics, including longer latencies to touch familiar food in presence than absence of novel items, and between problem-solving tasks, as well as in the presence of non-competing heterospecifics than competing heterospecifics. Age influenced neophobia, with adults showing longer latencies than juveniles. Individuals were repeatable in latency responses: (1) temporally in both experiments; (2) contextually within the innovation experiment and between experiments, as well as being consistent in approach order across experiments, suggesting stable behaviour traits. These findings are an important starting point for developing conservation behaviour related strategies in Bali myna and other similarly threatened species.

Behavioural plasticity in a native species may be related to foraging resilience in the presence of an aggressive invader.

Competition between invasive and native species can result in the exploitation of resources by the invader, reducing foraging rates of natives. However, it is increasingly recognized that multiple factors can enhance the resilience of native species competing for limiting resources with invaders. Although extensively studied in terrestrial species, little research has focused on behavioural plasticity in aquatic ecosystems and how this influences native species resilience. Here, we examined the role of behavioural plasticity in interactions between a native Australian fish, Pseudomugil signifer, and a widespread invasive fish, Gambusia holbrooki. To determine whether P. signifer displays behavioural plasticity that may mitigate competition with G. holbrooki, we first quantified social behaviours (aggression, submission and affiliation) and shoal cohesion for each species in single- and mixed-species groups. Second, we compared the feeding rates of both species in these groups to ascertain if any modulation of social behaviours and cohesion related to foraging success. We found that aggressive and submissive behaviours of G. holbrooki and P. signifer showed plasticity in the presence of heterospecifics, but social affiliation, shoaling and, most importantly, foraging, remained inflexible. This variation in the degree of plasticity highlights the complexity of the behavioural response of a native species and suggests that both behavioural modulation and consistency may be related to sustaining foraging efficiency in the presence of an invader.

Assessment of interspecific interactions between the invasive red-claw crayfish (Cherax quadricarinatus) and the Mozambique tilapia (Oreochromis mossambicus).

The Australian red-claw crayfish, Cherax quadricarinatus, has been introduced for aquaculture purposes worldwide and consequently colonized natural environments, where it might cause ecosystem services losses or adversely affect native species and the local environment. This species was first found in Pequenos Libombos Reservoir in Maputo Province, Southern Mozambique in the late 2009 and is linked to reduction in tilapia fisheries. This study, conducted in 2015 under controlled conditions, aimed to assess the interspecific relationships between the Mozambique tilapia (Oreochromis mossambicus) and the alien crayfish. For both species, no significant differences in growth and survival rates were found between animals reared in the presence versus the absence of heterospecifics, indicating no direct deleterious interspecific effects. Behavioural observations revealed that fish and crayfish competed for shelter and food. Both species reduced the foraging in the presence of heterospecifics during feeding period, in the daytime. Crayfish seemed to have an advantage in competition for shelter, suggesting that they may interfere with tilapia sheltering activity and make tilapia vulnerable to predators in natural habitats.

Honey bees adjust colour preferences in response to concurrent social information from conspecifics and heterospecifics

Bees efficiently learn asocial and social cues to optimize foraging from fluctuating floral resources. However, it remains unclear how bees respond to divergent sources of social information, and whether such social cues might modify bees' natural preferences for nonsocial cues (e.g. flower colour), hence affecting foraging decisions. Here, we investigated honey bees', Apis mellifera , inspection and choices of unfamiliar flowers based on both natural colour preferences and simultaneous foraging information from conspecifics and heterospecifics. Individual honey bees' preferences for flowers were recorded when the reward levels of a learned flower type had declined and novel-coloured flowers were available where they would find either no social information or one conspecific and one heterospecific bumble bee, Bombus terrestris , each foraging from a different coloured flower (magenta or yellow). Honey bees showed a natural preference for magenta flowers. They modified their inspection of both types of flowers in response to conspecific and heterospecific social information. The presence of a conspecific demonstrator on the less-preferred yellow flower increased honey bees' inspection of yellow flowers and the likelihood of foraging on them, thus outweighing the original preference for magenta flowers. The presence of a heterospecific on a magenta flower increased honey bees' inspection of magenta flowers, but this effect was not observed when bumble bees fed on yellow flowers. Our results indicate that flower colour preferences of honey bees are rapidly adjusted in response to both conspecific and heterospecific presence, in different ways, with a preference for conspecific information possibly favouring the transmission of adaptive foraging information within species. • Honey bees' colour preferences are influenced by conspecifics and heterospecifics • Honey bees' colour preferences are overridden by conspecific social information. • Honey bees discriminate conspecific from bumble bees when making foraging decisions. • Conspecific social information is prioritized in a foraging context.

Habitat-specific inter and intraspecific behavioral interactions among reef sharks.

Behavioral interactions such as dominance are critical components of animal social lives, competitive abilities, and resulting distribution patterns with coexisting species. Strong interference competition can drive habitat separation, but less is known of the role of interference if agonistic interactions are weak. While most theoretical models assume interference abilities to be constant in an environment, few consider that the extent of interference can vary by habitat and change model predictions. Using baited underwater cameras, we show a consistent dominance status between two sympatric reef sharks at an uninhabited Pacific atoll. Blacktip reef shark (Carcharhinus melanopterus) and gray reef shark (Carcharhinus amblyrhyncos) relative abundance showed an inverse relationship to each other but the strength of this relationship varied by habitat. Reef shark relative abundance declined more rapidly in the presence of heterospecifics on forereef habitats as opposed to backreefs. In all habitats, gray reef sharks were more likely to bite bait cages than blacktips when both species were present, and appeared to be the dominant species. Intraspecific interactions were also apparent, with individual willingness to bite bait decreasing as the number of conspecifics increased. Gray reef sharks may exert differential control over blacktip foraging success in different habitats. Habitat-specific behavioral interactions may partially explain patterns of spatial separation between competing species where interference is weak.

Baseline activity and shoal type determine antipredator behaviors in bluegill from a southern Ontario lake

Shoaling is an evolved behavior in fishes that has several adaptive advantages, including allowing individuals to avoid predation through risk dilution. However, factors such as size disparity and the presence of heterospecifics may influence the behavior of individual fish within shoals following exposure to elevated predation risk. Using bluegill Lepomis macrochirus as a model species, we measured changes in area use, shoaling index, and movement of a focal individual in isolation, in single-species shoals with two conspecifics, or in mixed-species shoals with two congeneric pumpkinseed L. gibbosus. The experimental shoals were exposed to one of three chemical cues selected to present graded levels of risk: lakewater controls (lowest risk), Northern pike Esox lucius predator odor (kairomones; intermediate risk), or conspecific chemical alarm cues (highest risk). Within the individual bluegill, we found that the multivariate response of area use and post-stimulus activity (line crosses) of the focal fish was significantly influenced by pre-stimulus activity, but not by cue type or fish size. As univariate responses, post-stimulus activity varied positively with pre-stimulus activity. Post-stimulus activity was greater in single-species shoals compared to mixed-species shoals, and again varied positively with pre-stimulus activity. Contrary to predictions, bluegill did not demonstrate graded antipredator responses to the chemical cues. Our findings suggest that prey fish may alter their risk-aversive behaviors in response to chemical stimuli based on shoal composition and provide further insight into the role of intra-prey guild interactions in response to predators in co-occurring prey species. When faced with predation, individuals in groups may experience lower levels of risk than solitary individuals. Using bluegill as a model organism, we examined how antipredator behaviors, in response to chemical cues indicating different levels of risk, varied between focal individuals as singletons and in single- and mixed-species shoals. Contrary to our prediction of graded stepwise responses indicative of differing levels of risk posed by the cues, we found that individuals with greater baseline activity levels demonstrated weaker antipredator responses independent of cue type, while fish in single-species shoals had higher post-stimulus activity levels than fish in mixed-species shoals. Our results suggest that studies examining changes in antipredator and shoaling behaviors will benefit from including ecologically relevant scenarios involving sympatric prey guild members.

Influence of interspecific competitors on behavioral thermoregulation: developmental or acute plasticity?

Many ectotherms reduce their exposure to changing thermal conditions using behavioral thermoregulation. The effectiveness of behavioral thermoregulation in maintaining ectotherm body temperatures within the target range is influenced not only by environmental (operative) temperatures but also by the presence of other con- and heterospecific individuals. How species’ interactions affect behavioral thermoregulation is largely unknown. Theory predicts that species’ interactions could affect the plasticity of behavioral thermoregulation in two ways, i.e., by developmental plasticity of a preferred temperature range or by an acute shift in body temperatures. Empirical tests of these predictions are scarce. We examined the developmental and acute effects of heterospecific social interactions on the accuracy and effectiveness of thermoregulation in the larvae of two competing species, Ichthyosaura alpestris and Lissotriton vulgaris. The presence of heterospecifics during larval development had no effect on preferred body temperatures but it modified later acute thermoregulatory responses to heterospecifics. Ichthyosaura alpestris larvae from heterospecific tanks increased their thermoregulatory accuracy and effectiveness, while L. vulgaris larvae from conspecific tanks relaxed their thermoregulatory efforts. The thermal dependence of somatic growth suggests that modified behavioral thermoregulation has the potential to accelerate growth in competitively dominant I. alpestris. Acute thermoregulatory responses are affected by heterospecific social interactions in newt larvae, but not conspecific. A developmental plastic response modified body temperatures not the target thermoregulatory range, which shows that the influence of heterospecific social interactions is more complex than predicted by theory. Species interactions complicate estimating an ectotherm’s vulnerability to ongoing climate change. Many ectothermic animals control their body temperature through behavioral thermoregulation. Their thermoregulatory decisions are influenced not only by environmental temperatures, but also by the presence of other species. We show that the current thermoregulatory effort in interacting newt larvae is affected by previous experience with competing species. The influence of heterospecific social interactions is more complex than predicted by theory, which complicates estimating an ectotherm’s vulnerability to ongoing climate change.

No trade-offs in interspecific interference ability and predation susceptibility in newt larvae.

Coexistence of species with similar requirements is allowed, among others, through trade‐offs between competitive ability and other ecological traits. Although interspecific competition is based on two mechanisms, exploitation of resources and physical interference, trade‐off studies largely consider only species’ ability to exploit resources. Using a mesocosm experiment, we examined the trade‐off between interference competition ability and susceptibility to predation in larvae of two newt species, Ichthyosaura alpestris and Lissotriton vulgaris. In the presence of heterospecifics, L. vulgaris larvae slowed somatic growth and developmental rates, and experienced a higher frequency of injuries than in conspecific environments which suggests asymmetrical interspecific interference. During short‐term predation trials, L. vulgaris larvae suffered higher mortality than I. alpestris. Larvae of the smaller species, L. vulgaris, had both lower interference and antipredator performance than the larger I. alpestris, which suggests a lack of trade‐off between interference competition ability and predator susceptibility. We conclude that interference competition may produce a positive rather than negative relationship with predation susceptibility, which may contribute to the elimination of subordinate species from common habitats.

Females trade off the uncertainty of breeding resource suitability with male quality during mate choice in an anuran

In many species, females may be particularly selective about the expected direct benefits of choosing a potential mate or the male's genetic contribution to their offspring. Growing evidence suggests that female choosiness can also be influenced, for instance, by local abiotic factors, the social environment or the presence of heterospecifics. In amphibians that breed in highly temporary ponds with limited trophic resources (such as the yellow-bellied toad, Bombina variegata), competition during larval development may have a strong impact on the fitness of offspring. Accordingly, one might expect females to apply hierarchical decision making, balancing intraspecific competition risks during larval growth against the relative indirect benefits associated with the quality of the male. To investigate this issue, we conducted experiments in seminatural enclosures to test whether the preference of yellow-bellied toad females for good call attractiveness (determined by fundamental frequency) is affected by the risk of larval competition within the pond occupied by the callers. Overall, our results showed that females have a preference for low-frequency calls when prior information does not enable them to assess the relative quality of ponds. However, when prior information enables females to unambiguously determine relative pond quality, females appear to apply hierarchical decision making in which the quality of a pond prevails over call cues related to the quality of the male.

Larval competition risk shapes male–male competition and mating behavior in an anuran

Mate preference was long assumed to be static and open-ended. However, a growing body of evidence actually suggests that the predominant factor in mate choice fluctuates due to the context dependence of the factors involved in sexual selection. In particular, fluctuation in the local environment, the density of individuals, and the presence of heterospecifics can all alter the strength, form, or direction of sexual selection by shaping the fitness costs and benefits of the traits that mediate male–female interactions. Amphibians constitute useful biological models to examine context dependence in sexual selection as the availability of suitable breeding resources may significantly impact the cost–benefit trade-off between mating strategies. Using an experimental approach, we examined how the risk of larval competition in breeding ponds affects pond occupancy, male–male spacing behavior, and spawning decisions in an anuran, the yellow-bellied toad (Bombina variegata). Then, we examined how female mate choice is affected by male body condition and how the risk of larval competition might influence females when choosing a mate. Our results indicate that male pond preference is strongly affected by the presence of conspecific tadpoles. Males preferentially selected ponds free of tadpoles, and spawning mainly occurred in these same ponds. This preference influenced male spacing behavior by enhancing the proximity of competing males when the availability of good-quality sites was experimentally manipulated, which had further significant consequences on females’ choice of mate. The article also discusses the evolutionary causes and consequences of such context-dependent mate choice in amphibians and beyond.

Competition between the phytophagous stink bugs Euschistus heros and Piezodorus guildinii in soybeans.

The abundance and contribution of the neotropical brown stink bug, Euschistus heros (F.), and the redbanded stink bug, Piezodorus guildinii (West.), to the composition of insect pests of soybean, Glycine max (L.), fields have changed both spatially and temporally in neotropical soybean production areas. Therefore, we assessed the competitiveness of each species in direct competition experiments following an additive series. We performed mixed (adult) insect infestations in soybean plants and evaluated the fitness of each species and the soybean yield. While the competitive ability of E. heros was significantly compromised by increments in conspecifics and heterospecifics (i.e. P. guildinii), the competitive ability of P. guildinii was compromised by the presence of heterospecifics (i.e. E. heros). The reproductive output of P. guildinii remained unaffected by increments in E. heros or of P. guildinii. Intriguingly, despite the fact that P. guildinii apparently lost the competition with E. heros, almost no pod production was observed in any plant colonised by the former. The higher abundance of E. heros in neotropical soybean fields seems to result from higher competitive ability than its heterospecific competitor P. guildinii, which may prevent the higher losses caused by P. guildinii. © 2016 Society of Chemical Industry.

Sniffing out the competition? Juvenile coral reef damselfishes use chemical cues to distinguish the presence of conspecific and heterospecific aggregations

Aquatic animals commonly rely on chemical cues to provide information regarding their surroundings. They can respond either by being attracted to (potential mates, preferred habitats) or avoiding (predators, competitors) the source of the stimuli. Coral reef fishes use chemical cues to detect habitats, avoid predators and recognise conspecifics. However, the extent to which chemical cues are used to detect and respond to potential competitors, has received little attention. Here we test olfactory preferences for conspecifics and heterospecifics in newly settled juvenile coral reef fishes. Juveniles of 4 common coral-associated damselfish species: Dascyllus melanurus, Dascyllus reticulatus, Chrysiptera arnazae and Pomacentrus moluccensis, were subjected to olfactory choice tests. Three of the 4 species (excluding P. moluccensis) demonstrated preferences for waterborne conspecifics odours. All species exhibited an avoidance towards heterospecific odours; this aversion was consistently greatest towards P. moluccensis. A neutral response toward heterospecifics was only evident in two instances (1) between the two congeneric Dascyllus species, with D. melanurus toward D. reticulatus, and (2) with C. arnazae toward D. melanurus. While it is already known that the presence of conspecifics plays a vital role in settlement site selection, we show here that the presence of heterospecifics may also be key in determining the spatial distributions of juveniles across areas of coral reef.

Distribution and oviposition site selection by predatory mites in the presence of intraguild predators

When intraguild prey and intraguild predators feed and reproduce in the same habitat and relatively immobile juveniles are the vulnerable stage, predation risk depends on oviposition site selection by the adult females. We studied how the availability of oviposition sites affected the distribution of two predatory mite species, Neoseiulus cucumeris (Oudemans) and Iphiseius degenerans (Berlese), over two patches that both contained food. The two plant-inhabiting species feed on pollen and thrips, prey on each other's juveniles, and prefer to oviposit on hairy parts of the leaf. When an artificial oviposition site was provided on one of two connected patches, both predator species strongly preferred this patch. Whereas the distributions of adults and eggs of N. cucumeris over the two patches were not affected by the presence of heterospecifics, the proportions of adults and eggs of I. degenerans on the patch with an oviposition site were reduced by the presence of N. cucumeris. A similar change in distribution was induced by cues of N. cucumeris on the oviposition site, without these mites being present. Hence, intraguild prey can weaken the strength of intraguild predation through patch selection, which in turn may promote coexistence of the two predator species.

Overlapping home ranges and microhabitat partitioning among Canyon Wrens (Catherpes mexicanus) and Rock Wrens (Salpinctes obsoletus)

ABSTRACT Patterns of animal space use may vary according to species identity, presence of conspecifics, presence of heterospecifics, and resource availability. We evaluated joint space use by Canyon Wrens (Catherpes mexicanus) and Rock Wrens (Salpinctes obsoletus) by comparing home range sizes, home range overlap, and foraging behavior. Canyon and Rock wrens are ecologically similar species which frequently co-occur along rocky cliffs where members of both species feed on terrestrial invertebrates. Interactions between Canyon and Rock wrens provide information about avian space use and foraging strategies in understudied cliff habitats. We estimated home range for each species using ArcGIS, and quantified foraging microhabitat use. Canyon Wren home ranges were widely spaced, did not overlap conspecifics, and were significantly larger than those of Rock Wrens. Rock Wrens occurred at higher densities and home ranges overlapped conspecifics in 33% of cases by an average of 19%. Canyon and Rock wren home rang...

The influence of host competition and predation on tick densities and management implications

Host community composition and biodiversity can limit and regulate tick abundance which can have profound impacts on the incidence and severity of tick-borne diseases. Our understanding of the relationship between host community composition and tick abundance is still very limited. Here, we present a novel mathematical model of a stage-structured tick population to study the influence of host behaviour and competition in the presence of heterospecifics and the influence of host predation on tick densities. We examine the influence of specific changes in biodiversity that modify the competition among and the predation on small and large host populations. We find that increasing biodiversity will not always reduce tick populations, but depends on changes in species composition affecting the degree and type competition among hosts, and the host the predation is acting on. With indirect competition, tick densities are not regulated by increasing biodiversity; however, with direct competition, increased biodiversity will regulate tick densities. Generally, we find that biodiversity will regulate tick densities when it affects tick-host encounter rates. We also find that predation on small hosts have a limited influence on reducing tick populations, but when the predation was on large hosts this increased the magnitude of tick population oscillations. Our results have tick-management implications: while controlling large host populations (e.g. deer) and adult ticks will decrease tick densities, measures that directly control the nymph ticks could also be effective.

Flexible microhabitat partitioning between hemi-sessile congeners

ABSTRACT: Microhabitat partitioning is a widespread mechanism that reduces competition andthus facilitates the coexistence of species. The extent to which microhabitat partitioning occursdepends on a variety of environmental parameters and biotic interactions. In the present study, wemanipulated factors (animal density, presence of heterospecifics, and presence of predator cues)that potentially influence the differential use of microhabitats by 2 hemi-sessile congeners thatcoexist on small spatial scales at very high densities: the amphipod crustaceans Jassa marmorata and J. herdmani . In both species, the presence of heterospecifics had a clear effect on which partof an offered macroalga was preferably colonized, suggesting that the extent of microhabitatpartitioning depends on the presence/absence of heterospecifics. Furthermore, ‘predatory fishcues’ in the seawater induced an avoidance behaviour, which should reduce the extent of habitatpartitioning and inevitably increase competition between the species. The results clearly showsome flexibility of habitat selection in, and thus habitat segregation between, the studied species,allowing for a trade-off between interspecific competition and predation pressure.KEY WORDS: Amphi poda · Coexisting species · Interspecific competition · Intraguild interference ·Marine fouling · Microhabitat partitioning · Predator avoidance

Sex differences in developmental plasticity and canalization shape population divergence in mate preferences.

Sexual selection of high-quality mates can conflict with species recognition if traits that govern intraspecific mate preferences also influence interspecific recognition. This conflict might be resolved by developmental plasticity and learned mate preferences, which could drive preference divergence in populations that differ in local species composition. We integrate field and laboratory experiments on two calopterygid damselfly species with population genetic data to investigate how sex differences in developmental plasticity affect population divergence in the face of gene flow. Whereas male species recognition is fixed at emergence, females instead learn to recognize heterospecifics. Females are therefore more plastic in their mate preferences than males. We suggest that this results from sex differences in the balance between sexual selection for high-quality mates and selection for species recognition. As a result of these sex differences, females develop more pronounced population divergence in their mate preferences compared with males. Local ecological community context and presence of heterospecifics in combination with sex differences in plasticity and canalization therefore shape population divergence in mate preferences. As ongoing environmental change and habitat fragmentation bring formerly allopatric species into secondary contact, developmental plasticity of mate preferences in either or both sexes might facilitate coexistence and prevent local species extinction.

A multi-method hierarchical modeling approach to quantifying bias in occupancy from noninvasive genetic tagging studies

Detecting ecological change in mammalian communities requires large volumes of data collected across large landscapes. Noninvasive genetic tagging (NGT) can provide such data and is a common method of estimating species occupancy, distribution, and abundance. Methods to correct errors in genetic analysis exist, but estimating and accounting for detection error in NGT studies—specifically, detection error during hair trapping—has received less attention. If detectability varies with an ecological characteristic that is instead attributed to occupancy, detection error may lead to spurious conclusions. We demonstrate how multi-method occupancy models informed by camera-trapping data can quantify error, partition sources of variability, and estimate occupancy from NGT studies. We surveyed marten (Martes americana), fisher (Pekania pennanti), and wolverine (Gulo gulo) occurrence via hair trapping and camera trapping for 3 repeated monthly surveys at 66 sites in the Rocky Mountains of Alberta, Canada. Camera traps photographed the hair traps and surrounding sampling site. We used multi-method occupancy models to estimate site occupancy, probability of detection, and conditional occupancy at a hair trap. We tested the predictions that detection error in NGT studies could be induced by temporal variability and behavioral variability arising from the presence of heterospecifics. Models indicated that NGT via hair trapping consistently underestimated occupancy of marten, fisher, and wolverine compared to cameras. The magnitude of bias varied, but at worst underestimated occupancy by half. The presence of a heterospecific affected a species' detection at hair traps. Wolverine presence increased marten detection, whereas marten decreased fisher detection at NGT traps. For all species, detection error was reduced through successive monthly surveys, although heterogeneity induced by other mustelids remained. Detection error from multiple sources can bias NGT occupancy estimates, with implications for population estimation, ecological inference, species' legal status assessments, and conservation decisions. We recommend that NGT studies quantify and correct for detection error using independent survey methods and multi-method occupancy models, to improve the ability to answer ecological questions and make conservation decisions in the face of ecological change. © 2014 The Wildlife Society.