Hydrogenation of organic molecules requires sequential addition of two H atoms to the substrate. So far, two pathways have been identified for this reaction on transition metal particles in water: conventional hydrogenation (CH) and proton coupled electron transfer (PCET). Typically, CH takes place in thermocatalytic hydrogenation (TCH) in which organic substrate reacts with adsorbed H atom on the surface of transition metal (Rxn. 1). PCET is a classic pathway occurring in electrocatalytic hydrogenation (ECH) by the simultaneous or sequential attack of hydronium ions with electrons to organic substrate on an electrode under a negative overpotential (Rxn. 2).Phenol* + H*→ H-Phenol* + * (CH) Rxn. 1Phenol* + H+ + e-→ H-Phenol* (PCET) Rxn. 2In water, a metal particle itself is a hydrogen electrode in presence of H2 and at a certain pH, having a so-called open circuit potential (OCP). In this work, we will use the hydrogenation reaction of phenol on Pt to explore whether the OCP on a transition metal can induce a PCET pathway, in particular at which conditions PCET overtakes CH pathway at OCP.Figure 1(a) shows the turnover frequency of phenol hydrogenation catalyzed by carbon nanotube (CNT) supported Pt catalyst under different pH. The turnover frequency shows a clear increasing trend, growing by an order of magnitude as pH decreasing from 5.3 to 2. In order to determine the reaction pathway, kinetic experiments were designed based on the difference between two pathways. The H atom added to phenol molecule in CH pathway (Rxn. 1) is from dissociative adsorption of gaseous H2, whereas that in PCET pathway is from hydronium ions in water (Rxn. 2). If the reaction undergoes the CH pathway, a kinetic isotope effect (KIE) would be observed when changing reductant from H2 to D2; whereas if PCET pathway dominates, a KIE would be observed via replacing H2O by D2O. Figure 1(b) shows that the dominated pathway is CH under pH 5.3, a KIE of kH2/kD2 was obtained when changing between H2 and D2, while the dominated route under pH 2 shown in Figure 1(c) is PCET due to KIE of kH2O/kD2O when changing between H2O and D2O. The mentioned results reveal that both CH and PCET pathways participate in phenol hydrogenation, with the dominated route transforming from CH to PCET as pH decreasing. It should be noted that all the reactions were carried out in absence of over potential, that only OCP drove the PCET pathway.In conclusion, hydrogenation rate of phenol is greatly enhanced by decreasing pH in water. Two reaction routes, CH and PCET, are turned out to be involved in the reaction. As pH decreasing from 5.3 to 2, the main reaction pathway shifts from CH to PCET. The reaction rate of PCET is promoted by decrease of pH because of the largely increased hydronium ion concentration. These results demonstrate that an electrocatalytic hydrogenation reaction can still occur under OCP. Figure 1. TOFs of phenol hydrogenation at 313-333 K with 10 bar H2 on 1 wt% Pt/CNT (5 mg) in 100 mL H2O (0.106 M phenol) plotted as a function of pH (a). Comparison of TOF of phenol hydrogenation in H2O-H2, H2O-D2, D2O-H2, D2O-D2 on 1 wt% Pt/CNT (50 mg) under pH 5.3 (no HClO4) (b) and 1 wt% Pt/CNT (10 mg) under pH 2 (HClO4) (c),10 bar H2 or D2, 30 mL H2O or D2O, 313 K, 0.106 M phenol. Figure 1
Read full abstract