Conformational B-cell Epitope Prediction Research Articles

Computational Methods to Predict Conformational B-Cell Epitopes.

Accurate computational prediction of B-cell epitopes can greatly enhance biomedical research and rapidly advance efforts to develop therapeutics, monoclonal antibodies, vaccines, and immunodiagnostic reagents. Previous research efforts have primarily focused on the development of computational methods to predict linear epitopes rather than conformational epitopes; however, the latter is much more biologically predominant. Several conformational B-cell epitope prediction methods have recently been published, but their predictive performances are weak. Here, we present a review of the latest computational methods and assess their performances on a diverse test set of 29 non-redundant unbound antigen structures. Our results demonstrate that ISPIPab performs better than most methods and compares favorably with other recent antigen-specific methods. Finally, we suggest new strategies and opportunities to improve computational predictions of conformational B-cell epitopes.

SEMA 2.0: web-platform for B-cell conformational epitopes prediction using artificial intelligence.

Prediction of conformational B-cell epitopes is a crucial task in vaccine design and development. In this work, we have developed SEMA 2.0, a user-friendly web platform that enables the research community to tackle the B-cell epitopes prediction problem using state-of-the-art protein language models. SEMA 2.0 offers comprehensive research tools for sequence- and structure-based conformational B-cell epitopes prediction, accurate identification of N-glycosylation sites, and a distinctive module for comparing the structures of antigen B-cell epitopes enhancing our ability to analyze and understand its immunogenic properties. SEMA 2.0 website https://sema.airi.net is free and open to all users and there is no login requirement. Source code is available at https://github.com/AIRI-Institute/SEMAi.

DL-TCNN: Deep Learning-based Temporal Convolutional Neural Network for prediction of conformational B-cell epitopes.

Prediction of conformational B-cell epitopes (CBCE) is an essential phase for vaccine design, drug invention, and accurate disease diagnosis. Many laboratorial and computational approaches have been developed to predict CBCE. However, laboratorial experiments are costly and time consuming, leading to the popularity of Machine Learning (ML)-based computational methods. Although ML methods have succeeded in many domains, achieving higher accuracy in CBCE prediction remains a challenge. To overcome this drawback and consider the limitations of ML methods, this paper proposes a novel DL-based framework for CBCE prediction, leveraging the capabilities of deep learning in the medical domain. The proposed model is named Deep Learning-based Temporal Convolutional Neural Network (DL-TCNN), which hybridizes empirical hyper-tuned 1D-CNN and TCN. TCN is an architecture that employs causal convolutions and dilations, adapting well to sequential input with extensive receptive fields. To train the proposed model, physicochemical features are firstly extracted from antigen sequences. Next, the Synthetic Minority Oversampling Technique (SMOTE) is applied to address the class imbalance problem. Finally, the proposed DL-TCNN is employed for the prediction of CBCE. The model's performance is evaluated and validated on a benchmark antigen-antibody dataset. The DL-TCNN achieves 94.44% accuracy, and 0.989 AUC score for the training dataset, 78.53% accuracy, and 0.661 AUC score for the validation dataset; and 85.10% accuracy, 0.855 AUC score for the testing dataset. The proposed model outperforms all the existing CBCE methods.

Critical review of conformational B-cell epitope prediction methods.

Accurate in silico prediction of conformational B-cell epitopes would lead to major improvements in disease diagnostics, drug design and vaccine development. A variety of computational methods, mainly based on machine learning approaches, have been developed in the last decades to tackle this challenging problem. Here, we rigorously benchmarked nine state-of-the-art conformational B-cell epitope prediction webservers, including generic and antibody-specific methods, on a dataset of over 250 antibody-antigen structures. The results of our assessment and statistical analyses show that all the methods achieve very low performances, and some do not perform better than randomly generated patches of surface residues. In addition, we also found that commonly used consensus strategies that combine the results from multiple webservers are at best only marginally better than random. Finally, we applied all the predictors to the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein as an independent case study, and showed that they perform poorly in general, which largely recapitulates our benchmarking conclusions. We hope that these results will lead to greater caution when using these tools until the biases and issues that limit current methods have been addressed, promote the use of state-of-the-art evaluation methodologies in future publications and suggest new strategies to improve the performance of conformational B-cell epitope prediction methods.

B-Cell Epitope Predictions Using Computational Methods.

Identifying protein antigenic epitopes that are recognizable by antibodies is a key step in immunologic research. This type of research has broad medical applications, such as new immunodiagnostic reagent discovery, vaccine design, and antibody design. However, due to the countless possibilities of potential epitopes, the experimental search through trial and error would be too costly and time-consuming to be practical. To facilitate this process and improve its efficiency, computational methods were developed to predict both linear epitopes and discontinuous antigenic epitopes. For linear B-cell epitope prediction, many methods were developed, including PREDITOP, PEOPLE, BEPITOPE, BepiPred, COBEpro, ABCpred, AAP, BCPred, BayesB, BEOracle/BROracle, BEST, LBEEP, DRREP, iBCE-EL, SVMTriP, etc. For the more challenging yet important task of discontinuous epitope prediction, methods were also developed, including CEP, DiscoTope, PEPITO, ElliPro, SEPPA, EPITOPIA, PEASE, EpiPred, SEPIa, EPCES, EPSVR, etc. In this chapter, we will discuss computational methods for B-cell epitope predictions of both linear and discontinuous epitopes. SVMTriP and EPCES/EPCSVR, the most successful among the methods for each type of the predictions, will be used as model methods to detail the standard protocols. For linear epitope prediction, SVMTriP was reported to achieve a sensitivity of 80.1% and a precision of 55.2% with a fivefold cross-validation based on a large dataset, yielding an AUC of 0.702. For discontinuous or conformational B-cell epitope prediction, EPCES and EPCSVR were both benchmarked by a curated independent test dataset in which all antigens had no complex structures with the antibody. The identified epitopes by these methods were later independently validated by various biochemical experiments. For these three model methods, webservers and all datasets are publicly available at http://sysbio.unl.edu/SVMTriP , http://sysbio.unl.edu/EPCES/ , and http://sysbio.unl.edu/EPSVR/ .

In-Silico Structural Modeling and Prediction of Conformational B-Cell Epitopes of Potential Vaccine Candidate Pre-Binding Protein

Malaria is a life threatening infectious disease causes by Plasmodium species, wherein Plasmodium falciparum being the most lethal causes severe malaria. Plasmodium parasites have a complex life cycle and employed several immunity evading mechanism that enable the parasite to multiply and survive avoiding the host immunity. The rise in drug-resistant Plasmodium parasites and the unavailability of an effective vaccine lead to major challenges in controlling the parasite. Therefore, it is of utmost important to identify novel potential targets that can be directed for therapeutic intervention. In the present study, conservancy, localization, and the antigenicity of PREBP was determined by using different bioinformatics tools. The 3D structure of PREBP was modeled and conformational B-cell epitopes of the protein were predicted using Ellipro. The resulted epitopes might be of great importance as a vaccine sub-unit in the development of an effective malaria vaccine and the generated 3D structure of the protein can be further used for other structural analysis.

Epitope3D: a machine learning method for conformational B-cell epitope prediction.

The ability to identify antigenic determinants of pathogens, or epitopes, is fundamental to guide rational vaccine development and immunotherapies, which are particularly relevant for rapid pandemic response. A range of computational tools has been developed over the past two decades to assist in epitope prediction; however, they have presented limited performance and generalization, particularly for the identification of conformational B-cell epitopes. Here, we present epitope3D, a novel scalable machine learning method capable of accurately identifying conformational epitopes trained and evaluated on the largest curated epitope data set to date. Our method uses the concept of graph-based signatures to model epitope and non-epitope regions as graphs and extract distance patterns that are used as evidence to train and test predictive models. We show epitope3D outperforms available alternative approaches, achieving Mathew's Correlation Coefficient and F1-scores of 0.55 and 0.57 on cross-validation and 0.45 and 0.36 during independent blind tests, respectively.

Structural and immunological characterization of an epitope within the PAN motif of ectodomain I in Babesia bovis apical membrane antigen 1 for vaccine development.

BackgroundBovine babesiosis caused by Babesia bovis (B. bovis) has had a significant effect on the mobility and mortality rates of the cattle industry worldwide. Live-attenuated vaccines are currently being used in many endemic countries, but their wide use has been limited for a number of reasons. Although recombinant vaccines have been proposed as an alternative to live vaccines, such vaccines are not commercially available to date. Apical membrane antigen-1 (AMA-1) is one of the leading candidates in the development of a vaccine against diseases caused by apicomplexan parasite species. In Plasmodium falciparum (P. falciparum) AMA-1 (PfAMA-1), several antibodies against epitopes in the plasminogen, apple, and nematode (PAN) motif of PfAMA-1 domain I significantly inhibited parasite growth. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to predict an epitope from the PAN motif of domain I in the B. bovis AMA-1 (BbAMA-1) using a combination of linear and conformational B-cell epitope prediction software. The selected epitope was then bioinformatically analyzed, synthesized as a peptide (sBbAMA-1), and then used to immunize a rabbit. Subsequently, in vitro growth- and the invasion-inhibitory effects of the rabbit antiserum were immunologically characterized.ResultsOur results demonstrated that the predicted BbAMA-1 epitope was located on the surface-exposed α-helix of the PAN motif in domain I at the apex area between residues 181 and 230 with six polymorphic sites. Subsequently, sBbAMA-1 elicited antibodies capable of recognizing the native BbAMA-1 in immunoassays. Furthermore, anti-serum against sBbAMA-1 was immunologically evaluated for its growth- and invasion-inhibitory effects on B. bovis merozoites in vitro. Our results demonstrated that the rabbit anti-sBbAMA-1 serum at a dilution of 1:5 significantly inhibited (p < 0.05) the growth of B. bovis merozoites by approximately 50–70% on days 3 and 4 of cultivation, along with the invasion of merozoites by approximately 60% within 4 h of incubation when compared to the control groups.ConclusionOur results indicate that the epitope predicted from the PAN motif of BbAMA-1 domain I is neutralization-sensitive and may serve as a target antigen for vaccine development against bovine babesiosis caused by B. bovis.

A novel conformational B-cell epitope prediction method based on mimotope and patch analysis

A B-cell epitope is a group of residues on the surface of an antigen that stimulates humoral immune responses. Identifying B-cell epitopes is important for effective vaccine design. Predicting epitopes by experimental methods is expensive in terms of time, cost and effort; therefore, computational methods that have a low cost and high speed are widely used to predict B-cell epitopes. Recently, epitope prediction based on random peptide library screening has been viewed as a promising method. Some novel software and web-based servers have been proposed that have succeeded in some test cases. Herein, we propose a novel epitope prediction method based on amino acid pairs and patch analysis. The method first divides antigen surfaces into overlapping patches based on both radius (R) and number (N), then predict epitopes based on Amino Acid Pairs (AAPs) from mimotopes and the surface patch. The proposed method yields a mean sensitivity of 0.53, specificity of 0.77, ACC of 0.75 and F-measure of 0.45 for 39 test cases. Compared with mimotope-based methods, patch-based methods and two other prediction methods, the sensitivity of the new method offers a certain improvement. Our findings demonstrate that this proposed method was successful for patch and AAPs analysis and allowed for conformational B-cell epitope prediction.

The Relationship between B-cell Epitope and Mimotope Sequences.

B-cell epitope is a group of residues which is on the surface of an antigen. It invokes humoral responses. Locating B-cell epitope is important for effective vaccine design, and the development of diagnostic reagents. Mimotope-based B-cell epitope prediction method is a kind of conformational B-cell epitope prediction, and the core idea of the method is mapping the mimotope sequences which are obtained from a random phage display library. However, current mimotope-based B-cell epitope prediction methods cannot maintain a high degree of satisfaction in the circumstances of employing only mimotope sequences. In this study, we did a multi-perspective analysis on parameters for conformational B-cell epitopes and characteristics between epitope and mimotope on a benchmark datasets which contains 67 mimotope sets, corresponding to 40 unique complex structures. In these 67 cases, there are 25 antigen-antibody complexes and 42 protein-protein interactions. We analyzed the two parts separately. The results showed the mimotope sequences do have some epitope features, but there are also some epitope properties that mimotope sequences do not contain. In addition, the numbers of epitope segments with different lengths were obviously different between the antigen-antibody complexes and the protein-protein interactions. This study reflects how similar do mimotope sequence and genuine epitopes have; and evaluates existing mimotope-based B-cell epitope prediction methods from a novel viewpoint.

Positive-unlabeled learning for the prediction of conformational B-cell epitopes.

BackgroundThe incomplete ground truth of training data of B-cell epitopes is a demanding issue in computational epitope prediction. The challenge is that only a small fraction of the surface residues of an antigen are confirmed as antigenic residues (positive training data); the remaining residues are unlabeled. As some of these uncertain residues can possibly be grouped to form novel but currently unknown epitopes, it is misguided to unanimously classify all the unlabeled residues as negative training data following the traditional supervised learning scheme.ResultsWe propose a positive-unlabeled learning algorithm to address this problem. The key idea is to distinguish between epitope-likely residues and reliable negative residues in unlabeled data. The method has two steps: (1) identify reliable negative residues using a weighted SVM with a high recall; and (2) construct a classification model on the positive residues and the reliable negative residues. Complex-based 10-fold cross-validation was conducted to show that this method outperforms those commonly used predictors DiscoTope 2.0, ElliPro and SEPPA 2.0 in every aspect. We conducted four case studies, in which the approach was tested on antigens of West Nile virus, dihydrofolate reductase, beta-lactamase, and two Ebola antigens whose epitopes are currently unknown. All the results were assessed on a newly-established data set of antigen structures not bound by antibodies, instead of on antibody-bound antigen structures. These bound structures may contain unfair binding information such as bound-state B-factors and protrusion index which could exaggerate the epitope prediction performance. Source codes are available on request.

LRC: A new algorithm for prediction of conformational B-cell epitopes using statistical approach and clustering method

Identifying of B-cell epitopes from antigen is a challenging task in bioinformatics and applied in vaccine design and drug development. Recently, several methods have been presented to predict epitopes. The physicochemical or structural properties are used by these methods. In this paper, we propose a more appropriate epitope prediction method, LRC, that is based on a combination of physicochemical and structural properties. First, we construct a graph from the surface of antigen, then by using the logistic regression, we model the physicochemical and structural properties and weight each vertex of the graph. Finally, we utilize a clustering method, MCL, to cluster the graph. The effectiveness of the proposed method is benchmarked using several antibody–antigen PDB complexes. The results of LRC algorithm are compared with other methods (DiscoTope, SEPPA and Ellipro) in terms of sensitivity, specificity and other well-known measures. Results indicate that applying the LRC algorithm improves the precision of prediction epitopes in comparison with the mentioned methods. Our LRC program and supplementary material are freely available from http://bs.ipm.ir/softwares/LRC/.

Analysis of Conformational B-Cell Epitopes in the Antibody-Antigen Complex Using the Depth Function and the Convex Hull.

The prediction of conformational b-cell epitopes plays an important role in immunoinformatics. Several computational methods are proposed on the basis of discrimination determined by the solvent-accessible surface between epitopes and non-epitopes, but the performance of existing methods is far from satisfying. In this paper, depth functions and the k-th surface convex hull are used to analyze epitopes and exposed non-epitopes. On each layer of the protein, we compute relative solvent accessibility and four different types of depth functions, i.e., Chakravarty depth, DPX, half-sphere exposure and half space depth, to analyze the location of epitopes on different layers of the proteins. We found that conformational b-cell epitopes are rich in charged residues Asp, Glu, Lys, Arg, His; aliphatic residues Gly, Pro; non-charged residues Asn, Gln; and aromatic residue Tyr. Conformational b-cell epitopes are rich in coils. Conservation of epitopes is not significantly lower than that of exposed non-epitopes. The average depths (obtained by four methods) for epitopes are significantly lower than that of non-epitopes on the surface using the Wilcoxon rank sum test. Epitopes are more likely to be located in the outer layer of the convex hull of a protein. On the benchmark dataset, the cumulate 10th convex hull covers 84.6% of exposed residues on the protein surface area, and nearly 95% of epitope sites. These findings may be helpful in building a predictor for epitopes.

Conformational B-cell epitope prediction method based on antigen preprocessing and mimotopes analysis.

Identification of epitopes which invokes strong humoral responses is an essential issue in the field of immunology. Various computational methods that have been developed based on the antigen structures and the mimotopes these years narrow the search for experimental validation. These methods can be divided into two categories: antigen structure-based methods and mimotope-based methods. Though new methods of the two kinds have been proposed in these years, they cannot maintain a high degree of satisfaction in various circumstances. In this paper, we proposed a new conformational B-cell epitope prediction method based on antigen preprocessing and mimotopes analysis. The method classifies the antigen surface residues into “epitopes” and “nonepitopes” by six epitope propensity scales, removing the “nonepitopes” and using the preprocessed antigen for epitope prediction based on mimotope sequences. The proposed method gives out the mean F score of 0.42 on the testing dataset. When compared with other publicly available servers by using the testing dataset, the new method yields better performance. The results demonstrate the proposed method is competent for the conformational B-cell epitope prediction.

Tertiary structure-based prediction of conformational B-cell epitopes through B factors.

Motivation: B-cell epitope is a small area on the surface of an antigen that binds to an antibody. Accurately locating epitopes is of critical importance for vaccine development. Compared with wet-lab methods, computational methods have strong potential for efficient and large-scale epitope prediction for antigen candidates at much lower cost. However, it is still not clear which features are good determinants for accurate epitope prediction, leading to the unsatisfactory performance of existing prediction methods.Method and results: We propose a much more accurate B-cell epitope prediction method. Our method uses a new feature B factor (obtained from X-ray crystallography), combined with other basic physicochemical, statistical, evolutionary and structural features of each residue. These basic features are extended by a sequence window and a structure window. All these features are then learned by a two-stage random forest model to identify clusters of antigenic residues and to remove isolated outliers. Tested on a dataset of 55 epitopes from 45 tertiary structures, we prove that our method significantly outperforms all three existing structure-based epitope predictors. Following comprehensive analysis, it is found that features such as B factor, relative accessible surface area and protrusion index play an important role in characterizing B-cell epitopes. Our detailed case studies on an HIV antigen and an influenza antigen confirm that our second stage learning is effective for clustering true antigenic residues and for eliminating self-made prediction errors introduced by the first-stage learning.Availability and implementation: Source codes are available on request.Contact: jinyan.li@uts.edu.auSupplementary information: Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

An ensemble method for prediction of conformational B-cell epitopes from antigen sequences

Epitopes are immunogenic regions in antigen protein. Prediction of B-cell epitopes is critical for immunological applications. B-cell epitopes are categorized into linear and conformational. The majority of B-cell epitopes are conformational. Several machine learning methods have been proposed to identify conformational B-cell epitopes. However, the quality of these methods is not ideal. One question is whether or not the prediction of conformational B-cell epitopes can be improved by using ensemble methods. In this paper, we propose an ensemble method, which combined 12 support vector machine-based predictors, to predict the conformational B-cell epitopes, using an unbound dataset. AdaBoost and resampling methods are used to deal with an imbalanced labeled dataset. The proposed method achieves AUC of 0.642–0.672 on training dataset with 5-fold cross validation and AUC of 0.579–0.604 on test dataset. We also find some interesting results with the bound and unbound datasets. Epitopes are more accessible than non-epitopes, in bound and unbound datasets. Epitopes are also preferred in beta-turn, in bound and unbound datasets. The flexibility and polarity of epitopes are higher than non-epitopes. In a bound dataset, Asn (N), Glu (E), Gly (G), Lys (K), Ser (S), and Thr (T) are preferred in epitope regions, while Ala (A), Leu (L) and Val (V) are preferred in non-epitope regions. In the unbound dataset, Glu (E) and Lys (K) are preferred in epitope sites, while Leu (L) and Val (V) are preferred in non-epitiopes sites.

Prediction of conformational B-cell epitopes.

Conformational B-cell epitopes play an important role in the epitope-based vaccine design. The increase of available data promotes the development of computational methods. Compared with the wet experiments, the computational methods are faster and more economic. In the past few years, a number of computational methods (especially the machine learning-based methods) have been developed to predict the conformational B-cell epitopes. In this chapter, we introduce important data resources and computational methods, which are publicly available. Moreover, we introduce our ensemble learning-based method that can predict the conformational epitopes from sequences. These promising methods may assist immunologists in identifying potential vaccine candidates.

Conformational B-Cell Epitope Prediction on Antigen Protein Structures: A Review of Current Algorithms and Comparison with Common Binding Site Prediction Methods

Accurate prediction of B-cell antigenic epitopes is important for immunologic research and medical applications, but compared with other bioinformatic problems, antigenic epitope prediction is more challenging because of the extreme variability of antigenic epitopes, where the paratope on the antibody binds specifically to a given epitope with high precision. In spite of the continuing efforts in the past decade, the problem remains unsolved and therefore still attracts a lot of attention from bioinformaticists. Recently, several discontinuous epitope prediction servers became available, and it is intriguing to review all existing methods and evaluate their performances on the same benchmark. In addition, these methods are also compared against common binding site prediction algorithms, since they have been frequently used as substitutes in the absence of good epitope prediction methods.

Phage Display Informatics

Phage Display Informatics

Bioinformatics Resources and Tools for Conformational B-Cell Epitope Prediction

Identification of epitopes which invoke strong humoral responses is an essential issue in the field of immunology. Localizing epitopes by experimental methods is expensive in terms of time, cost, and effort; therefore, computational methods feature for its low cost and high speed was employed to predict B-cell epitopes. In this paper, we review the recent advance of bioinformatics resources and tools in conformational B-cell epitope prediction, including databases, algorithms, web servers, and their applications in solving problems in related areas. To stimulate the development of better tools, some promising directions are also extensively discussed.