Pr1 Activity Research Articles

A mycoviral infection drives virulence and ecological fitness of the entomopathogenic fungus Beauveria bassiana.

Entomopathogenic ascomycetes are important natural regulators of insect pest populations and an increasingly adopted microbial control option. Fungal virulence in entomopathogenic ascomycetes can be modified by mycoviruses, viruses that infect fungi, whereas the possible role of these viruses on the physical and biochemical properties of the virus-containing fungal strains and on their ecological fitness has remained largely unexplored. Here, utilizing a Beauveria bassiana strain naturally infected with two mycoviruses, Beauveria bassiana partitivirus 2 (BbPV-2) and Beauveria bassiana polymycovirus 1 (BbPmV-1), we found that the mycovirus-containing strain is hypervirulent towards the experimental insect Galleria mellonella and shows major physical and biochemical changes in spore size, isoelectric point, and Pr1 activity, but even more impactful, the mycoviral infection confers a significant environmental- abiotic and biotic stress tolerance to the fungus. Hence, mycovirus infection expanded the temperature range for fungal growth and germination, and improved tolerance to osmotic stress, water stress, and UV-B radiation. Similarly, the antagonistic activity of the mycovirus-containing strain against Trichoderma harzianum was increased as compared to the mycovirus-free one. Taken together, these data suggest for the first time a mycovirus related adaptation of key traits indicators of environmental competence of a beneficial fungus, rendering these mycoviruses as potent tools for entomopathogenic fungal strain selection and development as mycoinsecticides.

Influence of Synthesis Conditions on the Crystal, Local Atomic, Electronic Structure, and Catalytic Properties of (Pr1−xYbx)2Zr2O7 (0 ≤ x ≤ 1) Powders

The influence of Yb3+ cations substitution for Pr3+ on the structure and catalytic activity of (Pr1−xYbx)2Zr2O7 powders synthesized via coprecipitation followed by calcination is studied using a combination of long- (s-XRD), medium- (Raman, FT-IR, and SEM-EDS) and short-range (XAFS) sensitive methods, as well as adsorption and catalytic techniques. It is established that chemical composition and calcination temperature are the two major factors that govern the phase composition, crystallographic, and local-structure parameters of these polycrystalline materials. The crystallographic and local-structure parameters of (Pr1−xYbx)2Zr2O7 samples prepared at 1400 °C/3 h demonstrate a tight correlation with their catalytic activity towards propane cracking. The progressive replacement of Pr3+ with Yb3+ cations gives rise to an increase in the catalytic activity. A mechanism of the catalytic cracking of propane is proposed, which considers the geometrical match between the metal–oxygen (Pr–O, Yb–O, and Zr–O) bond lengths within the active sites and the size of adsorbed propane molecule to be the decisive factor governing the reaction route.

Cuticle degrading enzyme production by some isolates of the entomopathogenic fungus

Biochemical characterisation with different entomopathogenic fungal isolates showed that the maximum protease activity was recorded by Bb112 (0.98 U ml−1). Ma SBI (27.02 U ml−1) and Bb112 (26.18 U ml−1) and were on par in chitinase activity. Subtilisin (Pr1) activity was more with Bb112 (3.25 U ml−1) and Ma SBI (3.11 U ml−1).

Role of Pr-Vacancies and O-Interstitials on the Activity and Stability of (Pr1−xLnx)2NiO4 (Ln = La, Nd, Pm, Sm, Gd, Tb, Dy, and Ho) towards Oxygen Reduction Reactions: A DFT Study

Praseodymium nickelate, Pr2NiO4 (PNO), is a promising electrode to promote oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) in a solid oxide fuel cell, but it exhibits phase transformation during electrochemical operation. The origin of the simultaneous phase transformation and high electrochemical performance remains obscure. We carried out a systematic density functional theory study to elucidate the mechanism for this conjugated phenomenon. Charge, electronic structure, and normal-mode analysis suggest the presence of peroxide. Our study shows that the formation of peroxide (O2 2−) is attributed to both oxygen interstitials and Pr vacancies. The peroxide species limits the oxygen ion migration due to the additional energy required to break its O–O bond, which leads to a decrease in ORR activity. Subsequently, we investigate the diffusion paths of Pr-ions while comparing them with those of other Ln3+ ions (La, Nd, Pm, Sm, Gd, Tb, Dy, and Ho) in PNO. The formation energies for various Ln3+ cation occupancies are calculated, as well as segregation energies in CeO2(111) surfaces. Finally, criteria for effective Ln3+ dopants are developed. La, Nd, and Pm are proposed as potential substituents in PNO to obtain a stable structure.

Exposure to a sublethal menadione concentration modifies the mycelial secretome and conidial enzyme activities of Metarhizium anisopliae sensu lato and increases its virulence against Rhipicephalus microplus

Menadione (MND) is known to induce oxidative stress in fungal cells. Here, we explore how exposure to this molecule alters conidial enzyme activities, fungal efficacy against Rhipicephalus microplus, and mycelial secretion (secretome) of an isolate of Metarhizium anisopliae sensu lato. First, the fungus was exposed to different MND concentrations in potato-dextrose-agar (PDA) to determine the LC50 by evaluating conidia germination (38μM). To ensure high cell integrity, a sublethal dose of MND (half of LC50) was added to solid (PDA MND) and liquid media (MS MND). Changes in colony growth, a slight reduction in conidia production, decreases in conidial surface Pr1 and Pr2 activities as well as improvements in proteolytic and antioxidant (catalase, superoxide dismutase, and peroxidase) conidial intracellular activities were observed for PDA MND conidia. Additionally, PDA MND conidia had the best results for killing tick larvae, with the highest mortality rates until 15 days after treatment, which reduces both LC50 and LT50, particularly at 108 conidia mL−1. The diversity of secreted proteins after growth in liquid medium + R. microplus cuticle (supplemented or not with half of MND LC50), was evaluated by mass spectrometry-based proteomics. A total of 654 proteins were identified, 31 of which were differentially regulated (up or down) and mainly related to antioxidant activity (catalase), pathogenicity (Pr1B, Pr1D, and Pr1K), cell repair, and morphogenesis. In the exclusively MS MND profile, 48 proteins, mostly associated with cellular signaling, nutrition, and antioxidant functions, were distinguished. Finally, enzymatic assays were performed to validate some of these proteins. Overall, supplementation with MND in the solid medium made conidia more efficient at controlling R. microplus larvae, especially by increasing, inside the conidia, the activity of some infection-related enzymes. In the liquid medium (a consolidated study model that mimics some infection conditions), proteins were up- and/or exclusively-regulated in the presence of MND, which opens a spectrum of new targets for further study to improve biological control of ticks using Metarhizium species.

Investigation of thermal, electrical, and electrochemical properties of Pr1−xSrxFe1−yCoyO3 (0 < x < 0.4; y = 0.2, 0.5) cathode materials for SOFC

The new cathode materials Pr1−xSrxFe1−yCoyO3 (0 ≤ x ≤ 0.4; y = 0.2, 0.5) for SOFC have been studied. The materials were synthesized by the self-propagating high-temperature synthesis method. It was shown that the chemical activity of Pr1−xSrxFe1−yCoyO3 (PSFC) with respect to Zr0.84Y0.16O2−δ (YSZ) electrolyte increases with increasing concentration of Sr and Co, whereas the interaction with Ce0.73Gd0.27O2−δ (GDC) electrolyte was not found. The thermal expansion of praseodymium ferro-cobaltite nonlinearly depends on the Sr content with a minimum at x = 0.3. The conductivity of the investigated materials increases with an increase of Sr and Co content. The cathode materials in contact with YSZ have a high polarization resistance (a few Ω cm2 at 850 °C) due to their chemical interaction. Replacement of YSZ electrolyte with GDC results in the reduction of the polarization resistance by an order of magnitude. The Pr0.6Sr0.4Fe0.8Co0.2O3 in contact with GDC has the lowest polarization resistance of 0.05 Ω cm2 at 850 °С.

Влияние совместной обработки эндофитным штаммом бактерий Bacillus thuringiensis B-5351 и салициловой кислотой на устойчивость растений картофеля к Phytophthora infestans (Mont.) de Bary

Влияние совместной обработки эндофитным штаммом бактерий Bacillus thuringiensis B-5351 и салициловой кислотой на устойчивость растений картофеля к Phytophthora infestans (Mont.) de Bary

Expression of PR genes in tomato tissues infected by nematode Meloidogyne incognita (Kofoid et White, 1919) Chitwood, 1949.

The dynamics of expression of PR1 and PR6 genes, which are involved in the defense response of plants infected with the root-knot nematode Meloidogyne incognita, was studied in the "tomato-root-knot nematode" parasitic system. The invasion of the resistant plants was accompanied by an increased accumulation of transcripts of PR genes, which reflects their fast response to the penetration of nematode juveniles with subsequent development of an adequate defense response. In the susceptible plants, changes in the PR1 and PR6 gene activity induced by the nematode invasion were insignificant, which may be one of the causes of the disease. An exogenous salicylic acid treatment of the susceptible plants increased the PR1 and PR6 genes activity and led to the development of resistance of these plants to nematode invasion.

Effects of sub-culturing on genetic and physiological parameters in different Beauveria bassiana isolates

Beauveria bassiana is a fungus which is widely used as a biological insecticide to control a number of economically important insect pests. Knowledge of the genetic diversity of the isolates, understanding the underlying nature of these evolutionary phenomena and finding appropriate and simple screening tools play an important role in developing effective biocontrol agents. Here, we monitored changes of electrophoretic karyotype of small molecules of extrachromosomal DNAs, presumably mitochondrial DNA or plasmids in several individual isolates of B. bassiana during the forced in vitro evolution by continual subculture on artificial media and then we evaluated these changes on the virulence of the isolates. Through agarose gel electrophoresis of the small extrachromosomal DNAs molecules, we found that mutations accumulate quickly and obvious changes take place in extrachromosomal DNAs of some isolates, although this did not always occur. This plasticity in response to culturing pressure suggests that buffering capacity of fungal genome against mutations is isolate dependent. Following the forced evolution by sub-culturing, five discriminable electrophoretic karyotype of extrachromosomal DNAs was observed among isolates. The results showed that some isolates are prone to deep mutations, but during enforced sub-culturing some others have efficiently conserved genome. These differences are influensive in screening appropriate isolates for mass production as a keystone in biocontrol program. To determine the effects of these changes on isolate traits, virulence, germination rate and spore-bound Pr1 activity were assessed parallel to sub-culturing. The results clearly revealed that parallel to sub-culturing and in correlation with karyotypic changes, isolates significantly suffered from virulence, germination rate and spore-bound Pr1 activity deficiencies.

Effect of Beauveria bassiana infection on the feeding performance and antioxidant defence of red palm weevil, Rhynchophorus ferrugineus

The entomopathogenic fungal infection of target hosts depends on pathogen fitness and host defence mechanisms. Pathogen-host interactions in red palm weevil, Rhynchophorus ferrugineus larvae are poorly understood. In order to explore this interaction, 4th, 8th, and 12th instar red palm weevil larvae were immersed in conidial suspensions of four isolates of Beauveria bassiana. Significant differences in the virulence of the tested isolates were revealed by LT50 values. Conidia of B8463, a highly virulent isolate, showed 33.53 % higher relative hydrophobicity and twice as much Pr1 activity than conidia of B8465. Growth indices, calculated after 72 h of incubation, revealed significant differences in the food utilization efficiencies of all studied larval instars infected with different isolates. Conidial infection with B8463 caused 39–45 % reduction in efficacy of consumption of ingested food (ECI) and 55–61 % reduction in digested food (ECD). The least virulent isolate, B8465, caused the smallest reduction in ECI (2–4 %) and ECD (3–9 %). Furthermore, enhanced expression of target antioxidant genes (catalases and peroxidase) was observed in larvae infected with virulent isolates. Similarly, approximate digestibility showed an opposite trend, with the highest values being recorded from samples infected with the most virulent conidia (B8463) at each studied larval instar. In conclusion, isolate B8463 significantly affected the growth and development of red palm weevil larvae and has good potential for use in eco-friendly R. ferrugineus management.

Virulence determination of Beauveria bassiana isolates on a predatory hemipteran, Andrallus spinidens Fabricius (Hemiptera: Pentatomidae)

Virulence of the two isolates of Beauveria bassiana, BB2 and AM-118, were evaluated on adults of a predatory hemipteran, Andrallus spinidens Fabricius by conidial bioassay and enzymatic activities. Results of the bioassay revealed LC50 of 37×104 and 15×103 spore/ml for isolates BB2 and AM-118, respectively. Activities of chitinase, lipase and ALP showed the higher activity in the media inoculated by AM-118 while no statistical differences were observed in activity of ACP. Although no statistical differences were found in general protease and Pr1 activities but activity of Pr2 in AM-118 was significantly higher than that of BB2. Activity of general esterases demonstrated no statistical differences when α- and β-naphtyl acetate were used as substrates but activity of glutathione S-transferase in AM-118 was higher than that of BB2 by using CDNB and DCNB as specific reagents. Results of the current study indicated higher virulence of isolate AM-118 against adults of A. spinidens by lower LC50 value and higher activities of the enzymes involved in pathogenicity. Recruiting of these isolates against C. suppressalis must be considered by their adaptability of A. spinidens. Moreover, AM-118 has been isolated from rice fields of northern Iran, so it may somehow indicate a type of host-microorganism interaction.

The influence of conidial Pr1 protease on pathogenicity potential of Metarhizium anisopliae senso latu to ticks.

Pr1 is a subtilisin-like protease produced by Metarhizium spp. entomopathogenic fungi, and it is recognized as heavily involved in the initial steps of the fungal invasion of arthropod-host cuticles. In the current study, correlation was sought between mortality of tick larvae and conidial Pr1 levels of one Metarhizium anisopliae senso latu (s.l.) isolate (CG 148). Conidia with different levels of pr1 gene expression and enzymatic activity were obtained by producing them on either artificial medium (to yield low Pr1 activity) or on Rhipicephalus microplus cadavers (to yield high Pr1 activity). Conidial proteolytic activity was assessed using N-suc-ala-ala-pro-phe-ρNA as the chromogenic substrate, and pr1 expression was profiled by qPCR using three genes (gpd, try, and tef) as reference genes. Pr1 enzymatic (proteolytic) activity on conidia obtained from tick cadavers was 36 U mg(-1) in comparison to 4 U mg(-1) on conidia from PDA medium. Also, pr1 gene expression level was ten times higher in conidia from tick cadavers compared to PDA medium. Bioassays of M. anisopliae s.l. CG 148 spores with elevated Pr1 proteolytic activity and gene expression levels did not demonstrate increased virulence (= significant change percent mortality of tick larvae). The minimal levels of Pr1 on conidia produced on artificial medium was adequate to afford high levels of virulence, and the elevated amounts of the enzyme on tick-cadaver-produced conidia did not induce elevated larval mortality. As long as some Pr1 activity was present, fungal virulence of isolate CG 148 against tick larvae was not elevated by increased levels of conidial Pr1.

Characterisation of Isaria fumosorosea isolates and their virulence toward the Diamondback Moth, Plutella xylostella

Some morphological and physiological characteristics of an Isaria fumosorosea isolate with diminished virulence, IFCF01-D, and its parent isolate, IFCF01, were evaluated and laboratory bioassays were performed to assess their virulence against Plutella xylostella. The relationship among these traits and virulence against P. xylostella is discussed. There were no significant differences in conidial viability, spore production and the time required for 50% germination (GT50). Spore viability after incubation for 24 h at 25°C was greater than 98% for both isolates tested. Spore production on potato dextrose agar after 14 days incubation at 25°C was 4.68 × 108 and 4.59 × 108 conidia/mL for IFCF01 and IFCF01-D, respectively. When exposed to high temperatures (40, 45, 50 or 55°C) through a water bath for 10 min, conidial germination ranged from 0.83% to 84.0% for IFCF01 and 0% to 86% for IFCF01-D. Germination rate showed a negative relationship with the exposure temperature for both isolates. The per cent germination of isolate IFCF01 24 h after ultraviolet (UV) radiation (18 W, 240–260 nm) varied from 0% to 92% and 0% to 81% for IFCF01-D. Germination rate and the exposure time exhibited a negative correlation for both isolates tested. Conidial surface hydrophobicity of IFCF01 (60%) was significantly higher than that of isolate IFCF01-D (53%). Subsequently, using the cicada exuviae as the substrate for enzymatic analysis, Pr1 and chitinase activity demonstrated the contrasting virulence traits: higher specific activities for the more virulent IFCF01 and lower enzymatic levels for isolate IFCF01-D.

Correlation between Pr1 and Pr2 gene content and virulence in Metarhizium anisopliae strains.

Metarhizium anisopliae is a widely studied model to understand the virulence factors that participate in pathogenicity. Proteases such as subtilisin-like enzymes (Pr1) and trypsin-like enzymes (Pr2) are considered important factors for insect cuticle degradation. In four M. anisopliae strains (798, 6342, 6345, and 6347), the presence of pr1 and pr2 genes, as well as the enzymatic activity of these genes, was correlated with their virulence against two different insect pests. The 11 pr1 genes (A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, and K) and pr2 gene were found in all strains. The activity of individual Pr1 and Pr2 proteases exhibited variation in time (24, 48, 72, and 96 h) and in the presence or absence of chitin as the inductor. The highest Pr1 enzymatic activity was shown by strain 798 at 48 h with chitin. The highest Pr2 enzymatic activity was exhibited by the 6342 and 6347 strains, both grown with chitin at 24 and 48 h, respectively. Highest mortality on S. exigua was caused by strain 6342 at 48 h, and strains 6342, 6345, and 6347 caused the highest mortality 7 days later. Mortality on Prosapia reached 30% without variation. The presence of subtilisin and trypsin genes and the activity of these proteases in M. anisopliae strains cannot be associated with the virulence against the two insect pests. Probably, subtilisin and trypsin enzyme production is not a vital factor for pathogenicity, but its contribution is important to the pathogenicity process.

Metarhizium anisopliae (Deuteromycetes: Moniliaceae) Pr1 activity: biochemical marker of fungal virulence in Rhipicephalus microplus (Acari: Ixodidae)

In the present study, the subtilisin-like protease Pr1 activity of five Metarhizium anisopliae s.l. isolates was evaluated together with their virulence against Rhipicephalus microplus females. Bioassays were performed with engorged females, and Pr1 activity was evaluated with the chromogenic substrate N-succinyl-Ala-Ala-Pro-Phe ρ-nitroanilide. All isolates were virulent to R. microplus, although the isolates CG 629, CG 148 and CG 32 caused higher mortality (P ≤ 0.05) than isolates CG 112 and CG 347 after eight days. No mortality was observed in the control group. Enzymatic assays revealed that the protease activity was greater in isolates CG 629, CG 148 or CG 32 than in isolates CG 112 or CG 347 after cultivation for 48 and 72 h. Based on these results, we suggest that the Pr1 activity may be used as a biochemical tool for screening the virulence among M. anisopliae s.l. isolates, and then selecting promising candidates for biocontrol of R. microplus ticks.

English

The sugarcane borer, Diatraea saccharalis, is one of the worst pests in Brazilian sugarcane crop, causing high levels of financial losses every year. Beauveria bassiana is an entomopathogenic fungus widely used in the biological control of several agricultural pests. The aims of this study were to: (1) evaluate the pathogenicity of&nbsp; B. bassiana strains against&nbsp; D. saccharalis &nbsp;(2) investigate the production of proteases and chitinase by B. bassiana in the presence&nbsp; of the cuticle of sugarcane borer; and, (3) evaluate the relation between the production of enzymes and pathogenicity of the strains. All isolates tested were pathogenic to D. saccharalis and the mortality ranged from 36 to 88%. The production of enzymes was higher in the medium containing cuticle, showing that the process is stimulated by specific components found in the cuticle of the host. Pr1 activity was higher than Pr2 and both were produced at 24 h.&nbsp; The highest production of chitinase was obtained at 96 h of culture for all strains tested. Levels of specific cuticle-degrading enzymes such as proteases correlated positively with specific virulence parameters. B. bassiana URM2915 showed promising features to be used in a biological control program of D. saccharalis. &nbsp; Key words: Biological control, sugarcane, subtilisin-like protease,&nbsp; trypsin-like protease, chitinase.

Attenuation of the entomopathogenic fungus Beauveria bassiana following serial in vitro transfers

Stability of pathogenicity in continuous in vitro cultivation is desirable for the purpose of large-scale production of a mycoinsecticide. Fungal biocontrol agents may lose virulence when maintain on artificial media, resulting in products of commercially inferior quality. In this research, two isolates (DEBI007 and DEBI008) of entomopathogenic fungus Beauveria bassiana were investigated for their stability following fifteen serial in vitro transfers assaying virulence to mealworm larvae, conidiation, and hyphal development on artificial culture as some fungal virulence determinants. Moreover, role of insect cuticle on fungal virulence restoration and protease 1 (Pr1) activity was considered as the most important factor. Although radial hyphal development and colony colour on in vitro culture was not affected following serial transfers, conidiation and Pr1 activity of both fungal isolates were reduced remarkably after fifteen transfers compared with control. Similarly, mean lethal concentration (LC50) values were increased as the number of serial transfers on artificial diet increased, although these increases were not statistically significant in both isolates as the confidential limits of LC50 values were overlapping. Our results revealed that attenuation of entomopathogenic fungi following serial in vitro transfers is a combination of interconnected factors. Other probable components such as pathogenicity determinants in this interaction should be explored in next researches.

Successive subculturing alters spore-bound Pr1 activity, germination and virulence of the entomopathogenic fungus, Beauveria bassiana

One of the hurdles in the development of entomopathogenic fungi such as Beauveria bassiana is loss of virulence when successively maintained in vitro. This may result in products of inferior quality in mass production programs. Also, there are many contradicting data and unclear points in this case. Three isolates of B. bassiana were subcultured successively 15 times. Spore-bound Pr1 activity, germination rate, and virulence of conidia against mealworm (Tenebrio molitor L.) larvae were studied. Results showed that isolates normally retained their virulence during 10 subculturings. However, they clearly offered decreased virulence (elevated LT50 values and lower percent mortality). The activity of Pr1 bound to conidia declined as subculturing continued; the lowest spore-bound activity and germination potential of conidia was recorded for the 15th subculture. Virulence data were in agreement with Pr1 activity and germination rate as there was a positive correlation between germination rate and spore-bound Pr1 activity with fungal virulence. This explains that at least a part of attenuation in fungal virulence can be explored in enzymatic activity, especially in the important cuticle-degrading protease, Pr1.

In vivo passages of heterologous Beauveria bassiana isolates improve conidial surface properties and pathogenicity to Nilaparvata lugens (Homoptera: Delphacidae)

In entomopathogenic hyphomycetes, desired candidates against the brown planthopper, Nilaparvata lugens (a sap-sucking rice pest in Asia), are lacking. In this study, 21 Beauveria bassiana isolates from heterologous host insects showed low pathogenicity to third-instar nymphs sprayed at the high concentration of ∼1000 conidia/mm 2, causing only 2–23% mortalities. Of those, three isolates killed significantly more nymphs (up to 45–62%) after two in vivo passages but no more after further passage. Conidial hydrophobicity rates ( H r), zeta potentials ( P z), and subtilisin-like protease (Pr1) activities ( A p) of these isolates showed the same trends in the three host passages ( N: 0–3). In multivariate correlation, the variables N, H r and P z were found contributing 89% to the mortality variation ( r 2 = 0.89). Significant positive correlations were also found between H r and N ( r 2 = 0.64), P z and N ( r 2 = 0.52), A p and N ( r 2 = 0.51), H r and A p ( r 2 = 0.45), and P z and A p ( r 2 = 0.57), respectively. However, irregular changes of H r and P z occurred in four other isolates, whose pathogenicity to N. lugens was not enhanced by repeated host passages, resulting in no correlation between the variables. Our data indicate that the conidial surface properties H r and P z associated with cuticle adhesion reflect the heterologous host-induced adaptation and help to select fungal candidates against N. lugens from repeated in vivo passages.

Cuticle-Degrading Proteases Produced by Metarhizium anisopliae and Their Induction in Different Media

Protease production by fourteen M. anisopliae isolates differing in geographical origin and host insect were investigated. Highest protease activity was observed during 4-8days of culture incubation. Pr1 and Pr2 activity was investigated in various media containing different carbon and nitrogen source to evaluate the induction mechanism of these enzymes. Basal levels of Pr1 and Pr2 activity were observed in minimal medium suggesting constitutive production. Casein (1%) as an exogenous protein supplement was not able to induce significant release of Pr1 and Pr2 enzymes, whereas high levels of activity were observed in the medium containing colloidal chitin (2%) as sole carbon and nitrogen source. The pH, ammonia and oxalic acid production in in vitro conditions was also investigated and the alteration in pH for protease production was not significant in the different media used except for the medium containing casein (1%) as a supplement.