BackgroundIsolated tracheo-esophageal fistulas (TEF) are rare and challenging, possibly leading to severe complications. We evaluated the outcomes in a large series of patients treated in 9 referral Centers for airway surgery, and suggested an ideal management algorithm. MethodsA multicentric retrospective study on TEF was performed. Results186 cases were collected. Among 101 patients with recurrent TEF after EA repair, 1 was treated successfully with thoracoscopy, 23 with open surgery with TEF division and tissue interposition, with 15 complete resolution (65 %), 2 TEF recurrence (9 %) and 6 other complications (26 %), and 77 received TCA endoscopic cauterization, with complete resolution in 61 (79 %). Among 54 patients with congenital H-type fistula, 1 received conservative treatment with resolution; 4 underwent thoracoscopy (50 % resolution); 6 had endoscopic cauterization (33 % resolution); 44 received open surgery, with 43 (98 %) successes. In the last group, the majority of TEF was ligated and divided with tissue interposition. Among 26 post-traumatic fistulas (mechanical trauma, battery or caustic ingestion), 6 patients received endoscopic procedure and 5 of them (83 %) reached complete resolution. The other 19 received open surgery (trans-tracheal direct FTE closure with tracheal resection), and 12 had complete resolution (63 %). Two patients eventually died and complication rate was 23 %. Other 5 cases (3 Bronchial-Esophageal Fistulas and 2 TEF after cleft repair) were treated endoscopically or with open approach. ConclusionEndoscopic cauterization can be the preferred treatment for recurrent TEF after EA, while for the congenital H-type and post-traumatic TEF the open approach remains our first choice.