Post-transcriptional Base Modifications Research Articles

Hopeful monsters: unintended sequencing of famously malformed mite mitochondrial tRNAs reveals widespread expression and processing of sense-antisense pairs.

Although tRNA structure is one of the most conserved and recognizable shapes in molecular biology, aberrant tRNAs are frequently found in the mitochondrial genomes of metazoans. The extremely degenerate structures of several mitochondrial tRNAs (mt-tRNAs) have led to doubts about their expression and function. Mites from the arachnid superorder Acariformes are predicted to have some of the shortest mt-tRNAs, with a complete loss of cloverleaf-like shape. While performing mitochondrial isolations and recently developed tRNA-seq methods in plant tissue, we inadvertently sequenced the mt-tRNAs from a common plant pest, the acariform mite Tetranychus urticae, to a high enough coverage to detect all previously annotated T. urticae tRNA regions. The results not only confirm expression, CCA-tailing and post-transcriptional base modification of these highly divergent tRNAs, but also revealed paired sense and antisense expression of multiple T. urticae mt-tRNAs. Mirrored expression of mt-tRNA genes has been hypothesized but not previously demonstrated to be common in any system. We discuss the functional roles that these divergent tRNAs could have as both decoding molecules in translation and processing signals in transcript maturation pathways, as well as how sense–antisense pairs add another dimension to the bizarre tRNA biology of mitochondrial genomes.

Modulation of Bacterial sRNAs Activity by Epigenetic Modifications: Inputs from the Eukaryotic miRNAs.

Trans-encoded bacterial regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) are functional analogues of eukaryotic microRNAs (miRNAs). These RNA classes act by base-pairing complementarity with their RNA targets to modulate gene expression (transcription, half-life and/or translation). Based on base-pairing, algorithms predict binding and the impact of small RNAs on targeted-RNAs expression and fate. However, other actors are involved such as RNA binding proteins and epigenetic modifications of the targeted and small RNAs. Post-transcriptional base modifications are widespread in all living organisms where they lower undesired RNA folds through conformation adjustments and influence RNA pairing and stability, especially if remodeling their ends. In bacteria, sRNAs possess RNA modifications either internally (methylation, pseudouridinylation) or at their ends. Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide were detected at 5′-ends, and polyadenylation can occur at 3′-ends. Eukaryotic miRNAs possess N6-methyladenosine (m6A), A editing into I, and non-templated addition of uridines at their 3′-ends. Biological functions and enzymes involved in those sRNA and micro RNA epigenetic modifications, when known, are presented and challenged.

Unveiling structural and functional divergences of bacterial tRNA dihydrouridine synthases: perspectives on the evolution scenario.

Post-transcriptional base modifications are important to the maturation process of transfer RNAs (tRNAs). Certain modifications are abundant and present at several positions in tRNA as for example the dihydrouridine, a modified base found in the three domains of life. Even though the function of dihydrourine is not well understood, its high content in tRNAs from psychrophilic bacteria or cancer cells obviously emphasizes a central role in cell adaptation. The reduction of uridine to dihydrouridine is catalyzed by a large family of flavoenzymes named dihydrouridine synthases (Dus). Prokaryotes have three Dus (A, B and C) wherein DusB is considered as an ancestral protein from which the two others derived via gene duplications. Here, we unequivocally established the complete substrate specificities of the three Escherichia coli Dus and solved the crystal structure of DusB, enabling for the first time an exhaustive structural comparison between these bacterial flavoenzymes. Based on our results, we propose an evolutionary scenario explaining how substrate specificities has been diversified from a single structural fold.

Post-transcriptional nucleotide modification and alternative folding of RNA

Alternative foldings are an inherent property of RNA and a ubiquitous problem in scientific investigations. To a living organism, alternative foldings can be a blessing or a problem, and so nature has found both, ways to harness this property and ways to avoid the drawbacks. A simple and effective method employed by nature to avoid unwanted folding is the modulation of conformation space through post-transcriptional base modification. Modified nucleotides occur in almost all classes of natural RNAs in great chemical diversity. There are about 100 different base modifications known, which may perform a plethora of functions. The presumably most ancient and simple nucleotide modifications, such as methylations and uridine isomerization, are able to perform structural tasks on the most basic level, namely by blocking or reinforcing single base-pairs or even single hydrogen bonds in RNA. In this paper, functional, genomic and structural evidence on cases of folding space alteration by post-transcriptional modifications in native RNA are reviewed.

Discovery of a Gene Family Critical to Wyosine Base Formation in a Subset of Phenylalanine-specific Transfer RNAs

A large number of post-transcriptional base modifications in transfer RNAs have been described (Sprinzl, M., Horn, C., Brown, M., Ioudovitch, A., and Steinberg, S. (1998) Nucleic Acids Res. 26, 148-153). These modifications enhance and expand tRNA function to increase cell viability. The intermediates and genes essential for base modifications in many instances remain unclear. An example is wyebutosine (yW), a fluorescent tricyclic modification of an invariant guanosine situated on the 3'-side of the tRNA(Phe) anticodon. Although biosynthesis of yW involves several reaction steps, only a single pathway-specific enzyme has been identified (Kalhor, H. R., Penjwini, M., and Clarke, S. (2005) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 334, 433-440). We used comparative genomics analysis to identify a cluster of orthologous groups (COG0731) of wyosine family biosynthetic proteins. Gene knock-out and complementation studies in Saccharomyces cerevisiae established a role for YPL207w, a COG0731 ortholog that encodes an 810-amino acid polypeptide. Further analysis showed the accumulation of N(1)-methylguanosine (m(1)G(37)) in tRNA from cells bearing a YPL207w deletion. A similar lack of wyosine base and build-up of m(1)G(37) is seen in certain mammalian tumor cell lines. We proposed that the 810-amino acid COG0731 polypeptide participates in converting tRNA(Phe)-m(1)G(37) to tRNA(Phe)-yW.

A Pathogenesis-associated Mutation in Human Mitochondrial tRNA Leu(UUR) Leads to Reduced 3′-End Processing and CCA Addition

Point mutations in mitochondrial tRNAs can cause severe multisystemic disorders such as mitochondrial encephalomyopathy with lactic acidosis and stroke-like episodes (MELAS) and myoclonus epilepsy with ragged-red fibers (MERRF). Some of these mutations impair one or more steps of tRNA maturation and protein biosynthesis including 5′-end-processing, post-transcriptional base modification, structural stability, aminoacylation, and formation of tRNA-ribosomal complexes. tRNA Leu(UUR), an etiologic hot spot for such diseases, harbors 20 of more than 90 disease-associated mutations described to date. Here, the pathogenesis-associated base substitutions A3243G, T3250C, T3271C, A3302G and C3303T within this tRNA were tested for their effects on endonucleolytic 3′-end processing and CCA addition at the tRNA 3′-terminus. Whereas mutations A3243G, A3302G and C3303T reduced the efficiency of 3′-end cleavage, only the C3303T substitution was a less efficient substrate for CCA addition. These results support the view that pathogenesis may be elicited through cumulative effects of tRNA mutations: a mutation can impede several pre-tRNA processing steps, with each such reduction contributing to the overall impairment of tRNA function.

Nuclear Control of Cloverleaf Structure of Human Mitochondrial tRNA Lys

The evolutionary loss in eukaryotic cells of mitochondrial (mt) tRNA genes and of tRNA structural information in the surviving genes has led to the appearance of mt-tRNAs with highly unusual structural features. One such mt-tRNA is the human mt-tRNA Lys, which relies on post-transcriptional base modification to achieve correct three-dimensional structure. It has been shown that the in vitro transcript of human mt-tRNA Lys adopts a particular, non-cloverleaf structure when devoid of modified bases, while the native, fully modified tRNA shows the expected cloverleaf structure. Furthermore, a methyl group at position A9- N 1, introduced chemically in an otherwise unmodified mt-tRNA Lys transcript, was found to induce a stable cloverleaf conformation, raising the question of how the specific methyltransferase recognizes the unmodified transcript. In order to shed light on this unusual case of tRNA maturation, the tRNA modification enzymes contained in protein extracts from either highly purified HeLa cell mitochondria or HeLa cell cytosol were first identified and compared, and then used to analyze the mt-tRNA Lys. An initial screening for modification activities, using as substrates unmodified in vitro transcripts of tRNA genes with well characterized structures, namely yeast cytosolic tRNA Phe, human cytosolic tRNA Lys 3, and human mt-tRNA Ile, revealed the presence of nine and 11 modification activities in the mitochondrial and cytosolic protein extracts, respectively, the mitochondrial extract including a tRNA (adenine-9, N 1)-methyltransferase activity. The comparison of the level and kinetics of A9- N 1 methylation and other secondary modifications in the unmodified, misfolded mt-tRNA Lys and in a cloverleaf-shaped structural mutant, engineered to adopt the tRNA Lys cloverleaf structure without post-transcriptional modifications, suggested strongly that the methylation of A9- N 1 in tRNA Lys proceeds via a cloverleaf-shaped intermediate. Therefore, it is proposed that this intermediate is present in the in vitro transcript as part of a dynamic equilibrium, and that the mitochondrial protein extract contains an activity that stabilizes, by secondary modification, such a transient cloverleaf-shaped intermediate. Thus, countering the evolutionary loss of structural information in mt-tRNA genes, the mt-tRNA structure is maintained by a modification enzyme encoded in nuclear DNA.

The tRNA-like Domains of E. coli and A. aeolicus Transfer–Messenger RNA: Structural and Functional Studies

Transfer–messenger RNA (tmRNA, 10Sa RNA or ssrA) acts to rescue stalled bacterial ribosomes while encoding a peptide tag added trans-translationally to the nascent peptide, targeting it for proteolysis. The understanding at molecular level of this ubiquitous quality control system in eubacteria requires structural information. Here, we describe the purification and structural analysis of a functional fragment of both Aquifex aeolicus and Escherichia coli tmRNA, recapitulating their tRNA-like domain, which were expressed in vivo from synthetic genes. Both recombinant RNA are correctly processed at both 5′ and 3′ ends and are produced in quantities suitable for structural analysis by NMR and/or X-ray crystallography. The sequence and solution structure of the tRNA-like domains were analysed by various methods including structural mapping with chemical and enzymatic probes and 2D NMR spectroscopy. The minimalist RNAs contain two post-transcriptional base modifications, 5-methyluridine and pseudouridine, as the full-length tmRNA. Both RNAs fold into three stems, a D-analogue, a T-loop and a GAAA tetra-loop. 2D NMR analysis of the imino proton resonances of both RNAs allowed the assignment of the three stems and of a number of tertiary interactions. It shows the existence of interactions between the TΨC-loop and the D-analogue, exhibiting a number of similarities and also differences with the canonical tRNA fold, indicating that RNA tertiary interactions can be modulated according to the sequence and secondary structure contexts. Furthermore, the E. coli minimalist RNA is aminoacylatable with alanine with a catalytic efficiency an order of magnitude higher than that for full-length tmRNA.

TRNA-guanine transglycosylase from Escherichia coli: recognition of noncognate-cognate chimeric tRNA and discovery of a novel recognition site within the TpsiC arm of tRNA(Phe).

tRNA-guanine transglycosylase (TGT) is a key enzyme involved in the posttranscriptional modification of tRNA across the three kingdoms of life. In eukaryotes and eubacteria, TGT is involved in the introduction of queuine into the anticodon of the cognate tRNAs. In archaebacteria, TGT is responsible for the introduction of archaeosine into the D-loop of the appropriate tRNAs. The tRNA recognition patterns for the eubacterial (Escherichia coli) TGT have been studied. These studies are all consistent with a restricted recognition motif involving a U-G-U sequence in a seven-base loop at the end of a helix. While attempting to investigate the potential of negative recognition elements in noncognate tRNAs via the use of chimeric tRNAs, we have discovered a second recognition site for the E. coli TGT in the TpsiC arm of in vitro-transcribed yeast tRNA(Phe). Kinetic analyses of synthetic mutant oligoribonucleotides corresponding to the TpsiC arm of the yeast tRNA(Phe) indicate that the specific site of TGT action is G53 (within a U-G-U sequence at the transition of the TpsiC stem into the loop). Posttranscriptional base modifications in tRNA(Phe) block recognition by TGT, most likely due to a stabilization of the tRNA structure such that G53 is inaccessible to TGT. These results demonstrate that TGT can recognize the U-G-U sequence within a structural context that is different than the canonical U-G-U in the anticodon loop of tRNA(Asp). Although it is unclear if this second recognition site is physiologically relevant, this does suggest that other RNA species could serve as substrates for TGT in vivo.

Requirements for editing in the genomic RNA of hepatitis delta virus

Hepatitis delta virus is a satellite of the hepatitis B virus which provides the surface antigen for the viral coat. The genome of the hepatitis delta virus consists of a single-stranded, circular RNA of 1679 nucleotides which forms a rod structure due to a high extent of self homology and which replicates via synthesis of an antigenomic RNA in a rolling circle mechanism similar to plant viroids. The antigenomic RNA contains the open reading frame for the δ-antigen which exists in two isoforms, p24 and p27. The formation of these two isoforms is explained by RNA editing at nucleotide 1012 which changes the stop translation codon UAG at amino acid residue 196 into the codon UGG for tryptophan and extends the open reading frame for the synthesis of p27. In order to investigate whether the editing occurs contranscriptionally during RNA replication or is a posttranscriptional base modification in the genomic or antigenomic RNA, replication defective deletion mutants of the HDV genome were constructed and expressed in COS-7 cells. Editing was demonstrated in non-replicating fragments of genomic HDV RNA but not in antigenomic HDV RNA fragments. The sequences from nucleotide position 337–1200 of the genomic RNA were sufficient to enable low levels of editing. Editing at position 1012 required the opposite strand of the RNA rod from nucleotide position 337–783. Replicating circular HDV RNA was much more efficiently edited than non-replicating full length genomic HDV RNA. Expression of δ-antigen in trans did not complement the low editing efficiency of replication defective genomic HDV RNA. These results demonstrate posttranscriptional U to C editing in the genomic HDV RNA and exclude misincorporation during HDV RNA replication as the editing mechanism. The minimal structural requirements for HDV RNA editing reside between nucleotide position 337–1200.

Effects of post-transcriptional base modifications on the site-specific function of transfer RNA in eukaryote translation

The site-specific function in translation of several naturally occurring mammalian transfer RNAs has been studied in a series of investigations with some similarities to studies in other laboratories of tRNAs in suppression. Equal amounts of aminoacyl-tRNA isoacceptors with contrasting isotopes were added in pairs to reticulocyte lysates and allowed to incorporate their amino acids into rabbit globin. Rates of incorporation from unlimiting amounts of each isoacceptor into the corresponding amino-acid-containing sites were determined. The tRNAs of each isoacceptor pair differed as to post-transcriptional base modifications. The natural occurrence of these isoacceptors can be correlated with rates of cellular division, with more rapidly dividing and neoplastic cells containing hypomodified tRNA. The overall incorporation of lysine into globin from a fully modified tRNA Lys that decodes AAG is faster by 25 to 30% than from the corresponding hypomodified tRNA Lys. There is considerable scatter in values for incorporation ratios at different lysine-containing sites, with the hypomodified isoacceptor even being preferred at one site. The AAG decoding isoacceptors are capable of translating AAA although much more slowly than AAG. In translating AAA, in contrast to translating AAG, the hypomodified tRNA Lys isoacceptor is preferred. A Y base-deficient hypomodified tRNA Phe isoacceptor found only in some kinds of rapidly dividing tumor cells donates its phenylalanine preferentially to globin in competition with the fully modified Y-containing tRNA Phe of liver by 15 to 17%. There is a considerable range of incorporation ratios at the different phenylalanine-containing sites of the globin subunits. No correlation can be made between the isoacceptor preferred and the phenylalanine codon being translated. The incorporation of histidine from a fully modified tRNA His-containing Q base in its anticodon, compared with that from the hypomodified counterpart isoacceptor that lacks Q base and that occurs in rapidly dividing cells, showed no difference in their ability to incorporate overall or into individual histidine-containing sites. There is little evidence that adjacent bases or codons in messenger RNA affect the tRNAs preferred in the translation of most sites. A striking pattern of tRNA preference was observed in three cases in which there are tandem codons, with the same codon appearing twice in succession. In each case the first codon is translated by the pair of tRNAs with the isoacceptor preference observed generally. In the translation of the second codon the alternative tRNA is preferred. It appears that the previously selected tRNA is a determinant of the next tRNA selected. The concept of “reading context” must include the effect of the previously selected tRNA. Our results indicate that the post-transcriptional modifications of tRNA have effects on tRNA function that could, particularly in the absence of a preferred tRNA isoacceptor, have significant and specific effects on gene expression.