Postoperative Vocal Outcomes Research Articles

Management of Contralateral Reactive Vocal Fold Lesions, a Retrospective Study

To evaluate the anatomical and voice results of conservative management of patients diagnosed with contralateral reactive lesions (CRL) in our voice unit. A retrospective chart review was conducted of all new adult patients with benign vocal fold lesions with or without CRL, treated in the voice unit at Universidad Católica Clinical Hospital between 2015 and 2019. Patients were divided into two groups, without CRL (group A) and with CRL (group B). Analysis of preoperative and 1 month after surgery videostroboscopy, GRBASI, Voice Handicap Index-10 (VHI-10), Voice Related Quality of Life (VRQOL) surveys and management of CRL was conducted. A total of 62 patients were included, 45 (72.6%) had CRL. When compared, bivariate and multivariate analysis revealed that age was significantly associated as a mild protective factor of presenting a CRL (P < 0.05). No significative differences were found between preoperative group A and B perceptual voice analysis or voice surveys. In terms of CRL management, 30 (66.6%) were injected, conservative management with observation was performed in 12 patients (26.7%) and, three (6.7%) were surgically resected. After 1 month follow-up, 32 (71.1%) had complete CRL resolution, eight (17.8%) had CRL persistence and, five (11.1%) had CRL recurrence. Postoperative vocal outcomes, GRBASI, VHI-10 and VRQOL showed significative improvement as compared with preoperative data for each group. No differences were seen between group A and B in terms of postoperative vocal outcomes. CRL are prevalent, and their management is controversial. On our study 72.6% of BFVL presented with CRL and 93.3% of them were conservatively managed. Improvement in perceptual voice analysis and quality of life surveys were similar in both groups.

Use of the montgomery implant system in medialization thyroplasty: postoperative vocal outcomes

Use of the montgomery implant system in medialization thyroplasty: postoperative vocal outcomes

The role of voice rest after micro-laryngeal surgery for benign vocal fold lesions

To compare post-operative vocal outcomes of a voice rest regimen versus no voice restrictions following micro-laryngeal surgery for benign glottic lesions. This was a combined prospective and retrospective cohort study on 167 patients who underwent micro-laryngeal surgery for benign focal fold lesion removal. Participants were divided into two regimens: standard voice rest (n = 92) or no voice restriction (n = 75). The primary outcome was post-operative vocal improvement, evaluated using voice handicap index questionnaire (VHI-10), GRBAS scale, and computerised acoustic analysis (shimmer, jitter, and the harmonic-to-noise ratio). The secondary outcome was emergence of vocal fold mucosal abnormalities in the immediate post-operative period. Parameters were collected at baseline and at the last clinical visit. There was no statistically significant difference between the voice rest and no-voice rest groups regarding baseline parameters of age, gender, laryngeal pathology, and voice use. Improvement in GRBAS scale values and VHI-10 scores between pre- and post-operative periods between groups did not demonstrate any statistically significant differences (P = 0.5303 and P = 0.1457, respectively). Similarly, the results of computerized voice analysis also showed no differences between groups in terms of shimmer (P = 0.9590), jitter (P = 0.5692), and harmonic-to-noise ratio (P = 0.1871). No correlation was found between the post-operative vocal fold's mucosal abnormalities and the type of voice rest regimen. Voice quality and wound healing were similar regardless of the type of voice rest regimen applied. No voice rest at all was as good as voice rest after micro-laryngeal surgery.

Our Approach for Optimizing Vocal Outcomes in Transoral Laser Microsurgical Resection of Early Glottic Carcinoma

ABSTRACT Objectives To assess oncologic and functional outcomes of early glottic cancer cases treated with transoral laser microsurgical resection (TLMR) and to outline the principles for optimizing vocal outcomes in these cases. Materials and methods Sixty six patients with early glottic cancer (7 CIS, 43 T1a, 15 T1b, 1 T2) underwent TLMR. Postoperatively, voice quality was assessed by Oates Russell Voice Profile. Results Local control was achieved in 95.08% of the cases and larynx was preserved in 98.3%. Residual disease developed in 3 patients. There were eight local recurrences. Single patient of T1b lesion was lost to follow-up and came back with stridor and underwent total laryngectomy. Conclusion Early glottic cancers can be effectively treated by TLMR with good oncologic outcome. Depth of infiltration of lesion is the most critical factor affecting the postoperative vocal outcome. In our study near-normal conversational voice to moderate change in voice was found after type I, II, and III cordectomies. Surprisingly, type VI cordectomy also gave a serviceable vocal outcome with moderate change in voice. In our opinion, type IV cordectomy does not give a serviceable vocal outcome even if performed unilaterally. Thus radiotherapy should be strongly considered in such cases for better vocal outcome. How to cite this article Nerurkar NK, Deshmukh S. Our Approach for Optimizing Vocal Outcomes in Transoral Laser Microsurgical Resection of Early Glottic Carcinoma. Int J Phonosurg Laryngol 2016;6(2):68-72.

Effect of Endotracheal Tube Size on Vocal Outcomes After Thyroidectomy

The optimum size of endotracheal tube (ETT) for general anesthesia remains unresolved. Choice of ETT size may be of particular relevance to thyroid surgery because of the increased risk of laryngeal trauma and concerns regarding postoperative vocal outcomes. To test our hypothesis that intubation with a smaller ETT would lead to reduced postoperative vocal impairment and associated reduced laryngoscopic evidence of laryngeal trauma compared with intubation with a standard-size ETT. This double-blind randomized clinical trial studied patients 18 years and older undergoing elective thyroidectomy at an academic teaching hospital from October 15, 2012, through June 13, 2013. Patients were randomized to group 1 (standard-size ETT, 8.0 mm for men and 7.5 mm for women; n = 24) or group 2 (small ETT, 7.0 mm for men and 6.5 mm for women; n = 25). Patients were assessed preoperatively and at 24 hours and 3 weeks postoperatively. Fiberoptic videolaryngoscopy with modified scoring system, voice assessment using the GRBAS (grade, roughness, breathiness, asthenia, strain) rating scale, vocal self-assessment using the 30-item Voice Handicap Index, and subjective pain score. At 24 hours, no significant differences were found between patients in groups 1 and 2 in change in GRBAS scores, change in laryngoscopic score (1.71 vs 1.76, P = .90), or postoperative pain score (3.3 vs 3.2, P = .91). At 3 weeks, no significant differences were found in changes in the 30-item Voice Handicap Index score (-2.2 vs -1.3, P = .74), GRBAS scores, or laryngoscopic score (0.25 vs 0.16, P = .67). We did not find evidence that smaller ETT size for thyroidectomy has any significant effect on postoperative vocal outcomes, incidence of laryngeal trauma as assessed by laryngoscopy, or pain scores. However, because of the small sample size, our study may have been underpowered to detect small differences. clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT02136459.

Longitudinal Voice Outcomes Following Advanced CO2 Laser Cordectomy for Glottic Cancer

CO2 laser cordectomy for glottic carcinoma offers excellent oncologic control on a per stage basis as compared with primary radiotherapy. We aim to further investigate the fluctuations of postoperative vocal outcomes following extended laser cordectomy for glottic cancer. Single center retrospective cohort study. Eleven patients with glottic squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) who received CO2 laser cordectomy European Laryngological Society type III-IV with complete datasets at preoperative, immediate postoperative (within 4 months), and delayed (greater than 6 months) time points were included. All patients (n=11) received cordectomy as their primary treatment. Tumor stage was divided evenly between T1 and T2. One patient was referred for post-cordectomy thyroplasty. Mean Voice Handicap Index (VHI) scores increased in the immediate postoperative period (43.3-46.2) but did not reach significance (P>0.05). Delayed postoperative VHI (23.3) demonstrated substantial improvement from both pre- and immediate postoperative levels (P=0.047). Objective voice rating significantly declined initially (P=0.03; Grade, P=0.01; Breathiness) and recovered to similar preoperative levels. Maximum phonation time (MPT) showed substantial decreases at the initial postoperative period (P=0.007). Although significant improvement was made at the delayed postoperative point (P=0.009), MPT remained below the preoperative level (P=0.028). No significant changes were seen in phonatory subglottic pressures. Patients undergoing extended CO2 laser cordectomy for glottic cancers can experience initial decline in voice quality; however, vocal function routinely returns to preoperative levels following the initial healing period. A small percentage of extended cordectomy patients may require further vocal interventions.

Partial Cutting of Sternothyroid Muscle during Total Thyroidectomy: Impact on Postoperative Vocal Outcomes

Background. Cutting the sternothyroid (ST) muscle is a useful technique to expose the superior pole of thyroid gland during thyroidectomy. In this study, we evaluated the impact of partial cutting of the ST muscle on postoperative vocal outcomes after total thyroidectomy. Methods. A retrospective review of 57 patients who underwent total thyroidectomy with central neck dissection for micropapillary thyroid carcinoma was conducted. Group A (n = 26) included those without cutting the ST muscle, while group B (n = 31) included patients whose muscle was partially cut at the superior pole. All patients underwent voice analysis before the operation and 2 weeks and 1 month after the surgery, and the outcomes were compared between the two groups. Results. There were no differences between the two groups regarding the outcomes at each time of voice analysis. Group A showed a decrease of maximum frequency 2 weeks after surgery but showed no difference after 1 month. Group B showed a mild decrease in maximum frequency 2 weeks after surgery, but the difference was not significant. Conclusion. Partial cutting of ST muscle during thyroidectomy is useful to expose the superior pole without significant negative impact on postoperative outcomes of vocal analysis.

Effect of Vocal Fold Injury Location on Vibratory Parameters in Excised Canine Larynges

To investigate the effect of vocal fold injury location on vibratory amplitude and lateral phase difference. Repeated measures with each excised canine larynx serving as own control. Basic science study conducted in university laboratory. Vocal fold vibration of excised canine larynges was recorded with a high-speed camera before and after inducing vocal fold injury at 1 of 5 locations: anterior, middle, posterior, medial, or superior. Medial and superior injuries were created within the middle third of the vocal fold. Five larynges were used for each of the 5 injury locations. Kymography was performed at the midpoint of the vocal folds for each video. Pre- and postinjury vibratory amplitude and lateral phase difference were compared for each location. The anterior and medial injuries produced consistent decreases in vibratory amplitude. Middle and posterior injuries might slightly decrease amplitude. Superior injuries seemed to have no effect on amplitude. Anterior and medial injuries induced phase asymmetry between the right and left vocal folds. Middle injuries appeared to affect phase difference slightly, whereas posterior and superior injuries had no effect. Injury to the anterior or medial portions of the vocal fold may be most likely to cause abnormal vocal fold vibration. Using caution in these locations during phonosurgery may favor superior postoperative vocal outcomes.

Comparative Study of Vocal Outcomes with Silicone versus Gore-Tex Thyroplasty

We examined vocal outcomes of patients who underwent type I thyroplasty for unilateral vocal fold paralysis. Specifically, the vocal outcomes were compared between 15 patients whose thyroplasties were performed with silicone and 15 patients whose thyroplasties were performed with Gore-Tex. The examined clinical characteristics did not differ significantly between the groups. The vocal outcomes were evaluated by aerodynamic and acoustic measurements. Aerodynamic examination indicated significant postoperative improvements in the maximum phonation time and mean flow rate in both groups. Shimmer was significantly improved only in the Gore-Tex group. A direct comparison between groups showed no significant difference in the degree of improvement of the vocal parameters, except for a significant improvement in the noise-to-harmonics ratio in the Gore-Tex group. The duration of surgery was significantly less in the Gore-Tex group than in the silicone group. Gore-Tex thyroplasty is considered to be comparable to silicone thyroplasty in terms of postoperative vocal outcomes. Gore-Tex thyroplasty enables a less invasive procedure with a shorter surgical duration and easier adjustment of medialization due to its flexibility.

Phonosurgery after endoscopic cordectomies

Treatment of glottic cancer by CO(2) laser endoscopic cordectomies can be associated with poor vocal outcome when the excision is extended beyond the superficial part of the thyro-arytenoid muscle. Different phonosugical techniques have been described in order to improve postoperative vocal outcome in patients undergoing this type of surgery. We herein present a new device for augmentation of residual vocal cord by video-endoscopic assisted primary intracordal autologous fat injection (PIAFI) performed at the end of transmuscular cordectomy. Twenty-four patients underwent transmuscular cordectomy and PIAFI for Tis and T1a glottic cancer. Eight cc of abdominal fat were obtained during the endoscopic procedure and processed. Infusion of intact parcels of fat tissue was performed to maximally reduce its resorption. PIAFI was performed in the residual vocal cord obtaining its immediate medialization, using a new device that permitted modulated (0.5 cc per click) injection. Fourteen patients were submitted to postoperative voice evaluation including subjective, perceptual, and objective assessment. The results were compared with those of 24 patients treated by transmuscular (Type III) cordectomy without subsequent PIAFI. No complications were observed as a result of PIAFI and the procedure did not significantly prolong overall surgical time. All patients were discharged the day after surgery. Comparison of vocal outcomes according to the Mann-Whitney and Wilcoxon tests showed a positive trend for patients submitted to PIAFI in terms of subjective and objective analysis. By contrast, a statistically significant improvement was reached in terms of perceptual analysis when comparing patients treated by Type III cordectomy alone with those submitted to this kind of procedure followed by PIAFI.

Functional Outcomes of Reduced Hyaluronan in Acute Vocal Fold Scar

To examine the functional effects of hyaluronan and collagen alterations in acute vocal fold scar, we injured 15 pig larynges by vocal fold mucosa stripping. At 3, 10, and 15 days after operation, we performed excised larynx experiments to measure phonation threshold pressure (PTP) and vocal economy (an acoustic output-cost ratio; OCR), and then performed hyaluronan and collagen assays. Five uninjured larynges were used as excised controls. Hyaluronan was reduced in the scarred vocal folds through 15 days of wound healing. Collagen was increased at day 15. The PTP was increased and OCR was decreased in scarred larynges, indicating decreased vocal efficiency and ease of phonation. Thus, PTP and OCR were sensitive to the biomolecular changes in acute vocal fold scar. Hyaluronan was more susceptible than collagen to acute tissue ultrastructural alterations. These findings may provide a rationale for increasing hyaluronan in acute vocal fold scar to improve postoperative vocal outcomes.

NEW PROCEDURES FOR PARALYTIC DYSPHONIA: Adduction Arytenopexy, Goretex* Medialization Laryngoplasty, and Cricothyroid Subluxation

Laryngoplastic phonosurgery has evolved to be a dominant treatment modality for paralytic dysphonia. The postoperative vocal outcome from the combined use of adduction arytenopexy, Goretex medialization laryngoplasty, and cricothyroid subluxation is such that most patients will have a normal phonation time and more than two octaves of dynamic range with minimal acoustic perturbation. With the addition of the adduction arytenopexy and cricothyroid subluxation procedures to the armamentarium of the phonosurgeon, all parameters for static reconstruction of the paralyzed vocal fold have been addressed.

Phonomicrosurgical treatment of early glottic cancer and carcinoma in situ

In recent years, transoral resection of early glottic cancer has developed into a phonomicrosurgical approach that resulted from the convergence of microlaryngoscopic surgical technique theory with body cover mucosal wave theory of voice production. The vocal outcome from these procedures has improved by minimizing the deep resection margin and thereby maximizing the preservation of the vocal folds' normal layered microstructure (laminae propria and epithelium). Recurrence and cure rates from this narrow-margin approach were examined. The phonomicrosurgical resection approach is composed of four basic procedures in which there is an increasing depth of resection to accommodate a narrow-field deep cancer margin. This approach was employed to treat 13 T1 cancers and 7 with carcinoma in situ (CIS). No patients who underwent a cancer resection developed a recurrence. Minimum follow-up on these patients was 2 years and the mean follow-up was 42 months. In the group with CIS, 2 patients developed microinvasive carcinoma despite en bloc excision of the CIS. Both were successfully treated; 1 was resected transorally and the other underwent radiation therapy. This study indicates that the phonomicrosurgical approach, which incorporates a narrow deep cancer margin to enhance the postoperative vocal outcome, resulted in standard control and cure of early glottic neoplasia.