The trigeminocardiac reflex (TCR) is a common event during skull base surgery that can lead to intraoperative arterial hypotension and bradycardia. Arterial hypotension associated with TCR can be a negative prognostic factor for postoperative auditory function and ipsilateral tinnitus in patients undergoing surgery for vestibular schwannoma (VS). In this study, the contribution of TCR to postoperative auditory function in non-VS cerebellopontine angle (CPA) tumor surgery was investigated. From a consecutive series of 102 patients with CPA tumors, we studied the occurrence of TCR and its influence on postoperative auditory function in patients with non-VS tumors. Pre- and postoperative auditory function, pre- and intraoperative mean arterial blood pressure, as well as preoperative medication, tumor size, and occurrence of TCR were evaluated. Of the 35 patients evaluated, four developed intraoperative TCR, of whom one was preoperatively deaf. Preoperative functional hearing was detected in 30/35 patients (85.7%): preoperative deafness was documented in one patient in the TCR group and in four patients in the non-TCR group. Of the 30 patients with preoperative functional hearing, 1/3 (33.3%) patients in the TCR group and 23/27 (85.2%) patients in the non-TCR group had functional hearing postoperatively. When patients with large tumors and functional, hearing were considered, only 33.3% of patients in the TCR group and 77.8% of patients in the non-TCR group remained within the same hearing classes following surgical treatment ( p = 0.1573). TCR may be a negative prognostic factor for postoperative auditory function in patients with large, non-VS CPA tumors.