post-Minkowskian Approximation Research Articles

Reconstruction of gravitational waveforms of coalescing spinless binaries in EOB theory based on PM approximation

We present a study of improving the gravitational waveforms of the coalescing spinless binaries in effective-one-body theory based on the post-Minkowskian approximation. The original ‘plus’ and ‘cross’ waveform modes of the gravitational wave generated by coalescing spinless black-hole binaries are extracted from the solution of the null tetrad component of the gravitational perturbed Weyl tensor in the effective spacetime. To enhance the accuracy of the gravitational waveforms, after Damour et al, the waveforms are factored into five components which are the Minkowskian leading factor , the source , the tail effect , the phase factor , and the residual term . In the equal mass ratio case, we find that the reconstructed waveform is closer to the five post-Newtonian result than the original waveform, while the resummation method gives the better results.

Multipole expansion of gravitational waves: memory effects and Bondi aspects

In our previous work, we proposed an algorithm to transform the metric of an isolated matter source in the multipolar post-Minkowskian approximation in harmonic (de Donder) gauge to the Newman-Unti gauge. We then applied this algorithm at linear order and for specific quadratic interactions known as quadratic tail terms. In the present work, we extend this analysis to quadratic interactions associated with the coupling of two mass quadrupole moments, including both instantaneous and hereditary terms. Our main result is the derivation of the metric in Newman-Unti and Bondi gauges with complete quadrupole-quadrupole interactions. We rederive the displacement memory effect and provide expressions for all Bondi aspects and dressed Bondi aspects relevant to the study of leading and subleading memory effects. Then we obtain the Newman-Penrose charges, the BMS charges as well as the second and third order celestial charges defined from the known second order and novel third order dressed Bondi aspects for mass monopole-quadrupole and quadrupole-quadrupole interactions.

All Order Gravitational Waveforms from Scattering Amplitudes.

Waveforms are classical observables associated with any radiative physical process. Using scattering amplitudes, these are usually computed in a weak-field regime to some finite order in the post-Newtonian or post-Minkowskian approximation. Here, we use strong-field amplitudes to compute the waveform produced in scattering of massive particles on gravitational plane waves, treated as exact nonlinear solutions of the vacuum Einstein equations. Notably, the waveform contains an infinite number of post-Minkowskian contributions, as well as tail effects. We also provide, and contrast with, analogous results in electromagnetism.

Self-consistent effective-one-body theory for spinning binaries based on post-Minkowskian approximation

This paper extends the research on the self-consistent effective-one-body theory of a real spinless two-body system based on the post-Minkowskian approximation (Science China, 65, 100411, (2022)) to the case of a binary system for the spinning black holes. An effective rotating metric and an improved Hamiltonian for the spinning black hole binaries were constructed. The decoupled equation for the null tetrad component of the gravitational perturbed Weyl tensor $\psi^B_{4}$ in the effective rotating spacetime is found with the help of the gauge transform characteristics of the Weyl tensors. The decoupled equation is then separated between radial and angular variables in the slowly rotating background spacetime, and a formal solution of $\psi^B_{4}$ is obtained. On this basis, the formal expressions of the radiation reaction force and the waveform for the ``plus'' and ``cross'' modes of the gravitational wave are presented. These results, obtained in the same effective spacetime, constitute a self-consistent effective-one-body theory for the spinning black hole binaries based on the post-Minkowskian approximation.

First post-Minkowskian approach to turbulent gravity

We compute the metric fluctuations induced by a turbulent energy-matter tensor within the first order Post-Minkowskian approximation. It is found that the turbulent energy cascade can in principle interfere with the process of black hole formation, leading to a potentially strong coupling between these two highly nonlinear phenomena. It is further found that a power-law turbulent energy spectrum $E(k) \sim k^{-n}$ generates metric fluctuations scaling like $x^{n-2}$, where $x$ is a four-dimensional distance from an arbitrary origin in spacetime. This highlights the onset of metric singularities whenever $n <2$, meaning that $2d$ fluid turbulence ($n=3$) yields smooth %(differentiable) metric fluctuations, scaling like $x$, while $3d$ turbulence ($n=5/3$) yields a weakly singular metric $x^{-1/3}$and purely random fluctuations, $n=1$, generate a stronger $1/x$ singularity. Finally, the effect of metric fluctuations on the geodesic motion of test particles is also discussed as a potential technique to extract information on the spectral characteristics of fluctuating spacetime.

New self-consistent effective one-body theory for spinless binaries based on the post-Minkowskian approximation

The effective one-body theories, introduced by Buonanno and Damour, are novel approaches to constructing a gravitational waveform template. By taking a gauge in which ψ B1 and ψ B3 vanish, we find a decoupled equation with separable variables for ψ B4 in the effective metric obtained in the post-Minkowskian approximation. Furthermore, we set up a new self-consistent effective one-body theory for spinless binaries, which can be applicable to any post-Minkowskian orders. This theory not only releases the assumption that v/c should be a small quantity but also resolves the contradiction that the Hamiltonian, radiation-reaction force, and waveform are constructed from different physical models in the effective one-body theory with the post-Newtonian approximation. Compared with our previous theory [Sci. China-Phys. Mech. Astron. 65, 260411 (2022)], the computational effort for the radiation-reaction force and waveform in this new theory will be tremendously reduced.

Kerr-Newman black hole lensing of relativistic massive particles in the weak-field limit

The gravitational lensing of relativistic neutral massive particles caused by a Kerr-Newman black hole is investigated systematically in the weak-field limit. Based on the Kerr-Newman metric in Boyer-Lindquist coordinates, we first derive the analytical form of the equatorial gravitational deflection angle of a massive particle in the third post-Minkowskian approximation. The resulting bending angle, which is found to be consistent with the result in the previous work, is adopted to solve the popular Virbhadra-Ellis lens equation. The analytical expressions for the main observable properties of the primary and secondary images of the particle source are thus obtained beyond the weak-deflection limit, within the framework of standard perturbation theory. The observables include the positions, magnifications, and gravitational time delays of the individual images, the differential time delay, and the total magnification and centroid position. The explicit forms of the correctional effects induced by the deviation of the initial velocity of the massive particle from the speed of light on the observables of the lensed images are then achieved. Finally, serving as an application of the formalism, the supermassive black hole at the Galactic Center, Sagittarius ${\mathrm{A}}^{*}$, is modeled to be a Kerr-Newman lens. The magnitudes of the velocity-induced correctional effects on the practical lensing observables as well as the possibilities to detect them in this scenario are also analyzed.

Self-consistent effective-one-body theory for spinless binaries based on post-Minkowskian approximation I: Hamiltonian and decoupled equation for $$\psi _4^{\rm{B}}$$

To build a self-consistent effective-one-body (EOB) theory, in which the Hamiltonian, radiation-reaction force and waveform for the "plus" and "cross" modes of the gravitational wave should be based on the same effective background spacetime, the key step is to look for the decoupled equation for $\psi^B_{4}=\ddot{h}_{+}-i\ddot{h}_{\times}$, which seems a very difficult task because there are non-vanishing tetrad components of the tracefree Ricci tensor for such spacetime. Fortunately, based on an effective spacetime obtained in this paper by using the post-Minkowskian (PM) approximation, we find the decoupled equation for $\psi^B_{4}$ by dividing the perturbation part of the metric into the odd and even parities. With the effective metric and decoupled equation at hand, we set up a frame of self-consistent EOB model for spinless binaries.

Constraining energy-momentum-squared gravity by binary pulsar observations

In this paper, we introduce the post-Minkowskian approximation of Energy-Momentum-Squared Gravity (EMSG). This approximation is used to study the gravitational energy flux in the context of EMSG. As an application of our results, we investigate the EMSG effect on the first time derivative of the orbital period of the binary pulsars. Utilizing this post-Keplerian parameter, the free parameter of the EMSG theory, $f_0'$, is estimated for six known binary pulsars. Taking the binaries that have the most accurate observations, it turns out that $-6\times 10^{-37}\text{m}\,\text{s}^2\text{kg}^{-1}<f_0'<+10^{-36}\text{m}\,\text{s}^2\text{kg}^{-1}$. This bound is in agreement with the precedent studies.

Reaction force of gravitational radiation in an effective-one-body theory based on the post-Minkowskian approximation

Effective-one-body (EOB) theory based on the post-Newtonian (PN) approximation presented by Buonanno and Damour plays an important role in the analysis of gravitational wave signals. Based on the post-Minkowskian (PM) approximation, Damour introduced another novel EOB theory which will lead to theoretically improved versions of the EOB conservative dynamics and might be useful in the upcoming era of high signal-to-noise-ratio gravitational-wave observations. Using the 2PM effective metric obtained by us recently, in this paper we study the radiation reaction force experienced by the particle with the help of the energy-loss-rate, which is an important step to construct the EOB theory based on the PM approximation.

Multipole expansion of gravitational waves: from harmonic to Bondi coordinates

We transform the metric of an isolated matter source in the multipolar post-Minkowskian approximation from harmonic (de Donder) coordinates to radiative Newman-Unti (NU) coordinates. To linearized order, we obtain the NU metric as a functional of the mass and current multipole moments of the source, valid all-over the exterior region of the source. Imposing appropriate boundary conditions we recover the generalized Bondi-van der Burg-Metzner-Sachs residual symmetry group. To quadratic order, in the case of the mass-quadrupole interaction, we determine the contributions of gravitational-wave tails in the NU metric, and prove that the expansion of the metric in terms of the radius is regular to all orders. The mass and angular momentum aspects, as well as the Bondi shear, are read off from the metric. They are given by the radiative quadrupole moment including the tail terms.

Energy map and effective metric in an effective-one-body theory based on the second-post-Minkowskian approximation

Effective-one-body (EOB) theory was originally proposed based on the post-Newtonian (PN) approximation and plays an important role in the analysis of gravitational wave signals. Recently, the post-Minkowskian (PM) approximation has been applied to the EOB theory. The energy map and the effective metric are the two key building blocks of the EOB theory, and in PN approximation radial action variable correspondence is employed to construct the energy map and the effective metric. In this paper, we employ the PM approximation up to the second order, and use the radial action variable correspondence and the precession angle correspondence to construct the energy map and the effective metric. We find that our results based on the radial action variable correspondence, are exactly the same with those obtained based on the precession angle correspondence. Furthermore, we compare the results obtained in this work to the previous existing ones.

Probing the post-Minkowskian approximation using recursive addition of self-interactions

We address the problem of deriving the post-Minkowskian approximation, widely used in current gravitational wave literature by investigating a possible deduction out of the recursive N\"other coupling approach, from the Pauli-Fierz spin-2 theory in flat spacetime. We find that this approach yields the post-Minkowskian approximation correctly to the first three orders, without invoking any weak-field limit of general relativity. This connection thus establishes that the post-Minkowskian approximation has a connotation independent of a weak-field expansion of general relativity, which is the manner usually presented in the literature. As a consequence, a link manifests between the recursive N\"other coupling approach to deriving general relativity from a linear spin-2 theory in flat spacetime and theoretical analyses of recent detection of gravitational wave events.

Analytic approximations in GR and gravitational waves

Analytic approximation methods in general relativity play a very important role when analyzing the gravitational wave signals recently discovered by the LIGO and Virgo detectors. In this contribution, we present the state of the art and some recent developments in the famous post-Newtonian (PN) or slow-motion approximation, which has successfully computed the equations of motion and the early inspiral phase of compact binary systems. We discuss also some interesting interfaces between the PN and the gravitational self-force (GSF) approach based on black-hole perturbation theory, and between PN and the post-Minkowskian (PM) approximation, namely a nonlinearity expansion valid for weak field and possibly fast-moving sources.

Ultra-relativistic gravity has properties associated with the strong force

The equations of motion, as well as the potential energy V of a self-gravitating N-body system in the first post-Minkowskian approximation have recently been derived. Here, for the particular case of two equal masses, the ultra-relativistic limit of these equations is analysed. It is shown that the requirement that the component of the gravitational force along the vector connecting the two particles is attractive, implies that the ultra-relativistic gravitational force acting on these two particles has properties usually associated with the strong force, namely, confinement and asymptotic freedom. This surprising result may have implications in particle physics: if the typical length of the system is of the order of the size of the pion, and if the mass of each particle is of the order of the mass of a light quark, then the magnitude of the above force is of the order of the magnitude of the strong force, whereas the bound state of this two equal masses body system yields a particle of mass of the order of the mass of the pion.

Equations of motion of self-gravitatingN-body systems in the first post-Minkowskian approximation

We revisit the problem of the equations of motion of a system of $N$ self-interacting massive particles (without spins) in the first post-Minkowskian (1PM) approximation of general relativity. We write the equations of motion, gravitational field and associated conserved integrals of the motion in a form suitable for comparison with recently published post-Newtonian (PN) results at the 4PN order. We show that the Lagrangian associated with the equations of motion in harmonic coordinates is a generalized one, and compute all the terms linear in $G$ up to 5PN order. We discuss the Hamiltonian in the frame of the center of mass and exhibit a canonical transformation connecting it to previous results directly obtained with the Hamiltonian formalism of general relativity. Finally we recover the known result for the gravitational scattering angle of two particles at the 1PM order.

Gravitational spin-orbit coupling in binary systems at the second post-Minkowskian approximation

We compute the rotations, during a scattering encounter, of the spins of two gravitationally interacting particles at second-order in the gravitational constant (second post-Minkowskian order). Following a strategy introduced in Phys. Rev. D {\bf 96}, 104038 (2017), we transcribe our result into a correspondingly improved knowledge of the spin-orbit sector of the Effective One-Body (EOB) Hamiltonian description of the dynamics of spinning binary systems. We indicate ways of resumming our results for defining improved versions of spinning EOB codes which might help in providing a better analytical description of the dynamics of coalescing spinning binary black holes.

Scattering of two spinning black holes in post-Minkowskian gravity, to all orders in spin, and effective-one-body mappings

We demonstrate equivalences, under simple mappings, between the dynamics of three distinct systems—(i) an arbitrary-mass-ratio two-spinning-black-hole system, (ii) a spinning test black hole in a background Kerr spacetime, and (iii) geodesic motion in Kerr—when each is considered in the first post-Minkowskian (1PM) approximation to general relativity, i.e. to linear order G but to all orders in 1/c, and to all orders in the black holes’ spins, with all orders in the multipole expansions of their linearized gravitational fields. This is accomplished via computations of the net results of weak gravitational scattering encounters between two spinning black holes, namely the net changes in the holes’ momenta and spins as functions of the incoming state. The results are given in remarkably simple closed forms, found by solving effective Mathisson–Papapetrou–Dixon-type equations of motion for a spinning black hole in conjunction with the linearized Einstein equation, with appropriate matching to the Kerr solution. The scattering results fully encode the gauge-invariant content of a canonical Hamiltonian governing binary-black-hole dynamics at 1PM order, for generic (unbound and bound) orbits and spin orientations. We deduce one such Hamiltonian, which reproduces and resums the 1PM parts of all such previous post-Newtonian results, and which directly manifests the equivalences with the test-body limits via simple effective-one-body mappings.

Dark-matter-like solutions to Einstein’s unified field equations

Einstein originally proposed a nonsymmetric tensor field, with its symmetric part associated with the spacetime metric and its antisymmetric part associated with the electromagnetic field, as an approach to a unified field theory. Here we interpret it more modestly as an alternative to Einstein-Maxwell theory, approximating the coupling between the electromagnetic field and spacetime curvature in the macroscopic classical regime. Previously it was shown that the Lorentz force can be derived from this theory, albeit with deviation on the scale of a universal length constant $\ell$. Here we assume that $\ell$ is of galactic scale and show that the modified coupling of the electromagnetic field with charged particles allows a non-Maxwellian equilibrium of non-neutral plasma. The resulting electromagnetic field is "dark" in the sense that its modified Lorentz force on the plasma vanishes, yet through its modified coupling to the gravitational field it engenders a nonvanishing, effective mass density. We obtain a solution for which this mass density asymptotes approximately to that of the pseudo-isothermal model of dark matter. The resulting gravitational field produces radial acceleration, in the context of a post-Minkowskian approximation, which is negligible at small radius but yields a flat rotation curve at large radius. We further exhibit a family of such solutions which, like the pseudo-isothermal model, has a free parameter to set the mass scale (in this case related to the charge density) and a free parameter to set the length scale (in this case an integer multiple of $\ell$). Moreover, these solutions are members of a larger family with more general angular and radial dependence. They thus show promise as approximations of generalized pseudo-isothermal models, which in turn are known to fit a wide range of mass density profiles for galaxies and clusters.

Gravitational spin-orbit coupling in binary systems, post-Minkowskian approximation, and effective one-body theory

A novel approach for extracting gauge-invariant information about spin-orbit coupling in gravitationally interacting binary systems is introduced. This approach is based on the "scattering holonomy", i.e. the integration (from the infinite past to the infinite future) of the differential spin evolution along the two worldlines of a binary system in hyperboliclike motion. We apply this approach to the computation, at the first post-Minkowskian approximation (i.e. first order in $G$ and all orders in $v/c$), of the values of the two gyrogravitomagnetic ratios describing spin-orbit coupling in the Effective One-Body formalism. These gyrogravitomagnetic ratios are found to tend to zero in the ultrarelativistic limit.