To the Editor: Although sevoflurane anesthesia has been shown not to cause nephrotoxicity in adults with normal renal function, its effect in patients with impaired renal function or in the elderly has not been thoroughly investigated. Recently, urinary albumin has gained attention as a marker of postanesthetic renal injury in surgical patients [1], but there is no agreement on how the results of studies should be interpreted. At our institution, we have investigated the effects of inhaled anesthetics on renal function in elderly patients. We present the data of our study, in which urinary albumin, alpha1 microglobulin (MG), beta2 MG, and N-acetyl- beta-D-glucosaminidase (NAG) were used as markers of renal injury in elderly patients anesthetized with sevoflurane. Thirteen patients aged >or=to70 yr undergoing gastrectomy were randomly assigned to receive either sevoflurane anesthesia (n = 7; mean age 77.6 yr) or isoflurane anesthesia (n = 6; mean age 78.5 yr). We used routine anesthetic techniques for our institution in this study, i.e., local epidural anesthesia combined with inhaled anesthesia (3 L/min air, 2 L/min oxygen, and either sevoflurane or isoflurane). A urine sample was collected via a catheter before anesthesia, and cumulative urine samples were then collected during and after anesthesia (immediately before surgery; 2 h after the start of surgery; at the end of surgery; and 3 h and Days 1, 3, and 7 after anesthesia). There were no significant differences in patient demographics. The mean minimum alveolar anesthetic concentration-hour was 5.1 for the sevoflurane group and 3.7 for the isoflurane group. The mean urinary albumin excretion was 65.0 mg/g creatinine (gCr) and 44.4 mg/gCr before anesthesia, which significantly increased to 147.9 mg/gCr and 196.9 mg/gCr 2 h after the start of surgery, sustained similar values 3 h after anesthesia, and returned to close to the preanesthetic values on Postanesthesia Day 1 in the sevoflurane group and the isoflurane group, respectively. No significant difference was found between the two groups, and the increase in urinary albumin excretion indicated that transient glomerular injury occurred with both anesthetics. The mean urinary alpha1 and beta2 MG levels were 9.3 mg/gCr and 0.81 mg/gCr in the sevoflurane group and 7.4 mg/gCr and 0.70 mg/gCr in the isoflurane group before anesthesia, showed a gradual but significant increase in both groups during anesthesia, and reached 31.4 mg/gCr and 6.20 mg/gCr in the sevoflurane group and 44.1 mg/gCr and 10.9 mg/gCr in the isoflurane group by 3 h after anesthesia. The values of alpha (1) and beta2 MG then temporally dropped on Postanesthesia Day 1, but they increased again on Day 3 in both groups and decreased again on Day 7 (cause unknown). The mean urinary NAG also began to increase during anesthesia to significantly higher levels than the preanesthetic values (18.9 mg/gCr in the sevoflurane group and 16.9 mg/gCr in the isoflurane group), reached a peak 3 h after anesthesia (40.6 mg/gCr in the sevoflurane group and 35.7 mg/gCr in the isoflurane group), but returned to almost the preanesthetic values on Postanesthesia Day 1. The changes in the urinary enzyme levels indicated the presence of transient renal tubular injury in both groups. In conclusion, using urinary markers, we found that sevoflurane and isoflurane anesthesia in combination with epidural anesthesia resulted in similar degrees of mild, transient, glomerular, and tubular functional impairment in elderly surgical patients undergoing gastrectomy. Kokichi Hase, MD Kazuko Meguro, MD Takako Nakamura, MD Department of Anesthesiology; Tokyo Metropolitan Geriatric Hospital; Tokyo 173-0015, Japan
Read full abstract