A polymeric multimode waveguide, characterized by a pioneering spoon-shaped geometry, was herein proposed for the first time to devise Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) biochemical sensors. The plasmon excitation was enabled by layering a gold nanofilm of ∼60 nm onto the spoon-waveguide. As a consequence of the waveguide’s extra-ordinary geometry, two distinct sensing regions were identified: a planar one, located on the spoon’s neck, and a concave one on the bowl, with angled surfaces. The bulk sensitivity (Sn) is correlated both to the way the light was launched in/collected from the sensor (parallel or orthogonal to the main axis of the waveguide) and to the sensing area interrogated (planar-neck or angled-bowl), indicating that the sensor’s performance can be conveniently tuned, depending on the chosen measuring configuration. The SPR sensor's characterization showed Sn equal to 750 nm/RIU for the neck and to 950 nm/RIU for the bowl. To further inspect the peculiar sensing-features and assess the application niches, the spoon-shaped waveguide was functionalized with two kinds of receptors, both specific for human serum albumin (HSA): an antibody on the bowl region (high Sn); molecularly imprinted nanoparticles (nanoMIPs) on the neck region (low Sn). The experimental results showed a limit of detection (LOD) for the immune-sensor of 280 pM and an LOD for the nanoMIP-sensor of 4.16 fM. The overall response of the HSA multi-sensor encompassed eight orders of magnitude, suggesting that the spoon-shaped waveguide’s provides multi-scale detection and holds potential to devise multi-analyte sensing platforms.