Polymeric Gene Vectors Research Articles

Recent progress in polymeric gene vectors: Delivery mechanisms, molecular designs, and applications.

Gene therapy and gene delivery have drawn extensive attention in recent years especially when the COVID-19 mRNA vaccines were developed to prevent severe symptoms caused by the corona virus. Delivering genes, such as DNA and RNA into cells, is the crucial step for successful gene therapy and remains a bottleneck. To address this issue, vehicles (vectors) that can load and deliver genes into cells are developed, including viral and non-viral vectors. Although viral gene vectors have considerable transfection efficiency and lipid-based gene vectors become popular since the application of COVID-19 vaccines, their potential issues including immunologic and biological safety concerns limited their applications. Alternatively, polymeric gene vectors are safer, cheaper, and more versatile compared to viral and lipid-based vectors. In recent years, various polymeric gene vectors with well-designed molecules were developed, achieving either high transfection efficiency or showing advantages in certain applications. In this review, we summarize the recent progress in polymeric gene vectors including the transfection mechanisms, molecular designs, and biomedical applications. Commercially available polymeric gene vectors/reagents are also introduced. Researchers in this field have never stopped seeking safe and efficient polymeric gene vectors via rational molecular designs and biomedical evaluations. The achievements in recent years have significantly accelerated the progress of polymeric gene vectors toward clinical applications.

Design and Gene Delivery Application of Polymeric Materials in Cancer Immunotherapy

Immunotherapy has offered an alternative therapy method for cancer patients with metastatic tumors or who are not suitable for surgical resection. Different from traditional surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy, immunotherapy mainly restores the activity of the body’s own immune cells silenced in the tumor microenvironment to achieve anticancer therapy. Gene therapy which corrects abnormal expression of immune cells in tumor microenvironment by delivering exogenous genes to specific immune cells, is the most widely studied immunotherapy. Although most available gene delivery vectors are still viral vectors, the further application of viral vectors is still limited by the immunogenicity and mutagenesis. Based on this, cationic polymeric gene vectors with high flexibility, high feasibility, low cost and high safety have been widely used in gene delivery. The structural variability of polymers allows specific chemical modifications to be incorporated into polymer scaffolds to improve their physicochemical properties for more stable loading of genes or more targeted delivery to specific cells. In this review, we have summarized the structural characteristics and application potential in cancer immunotherapy of these polymeric gene vectors based on poly(L-lysine), poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid), polyethyleneimine, poly(amidoamine) and hydrogel system.

Systematic Study of Enzymatic Degradation and Plasmid DNA Complexation of Mucus Penetrating Star-Shaped Lysine/Sarcosine Polypept(o)ides with Different Block Arrangements.

8-Arm star polypep(o)ides comprising cationic polylysine and hydrophilic polysarcosine blocks with a degree of polymerization (DP) of 30 per block are synthesized. Two different block sequences with polylysine as the inner and polysarcosine as the outer block and vice versa are obtained in addition to a statistical copolymer. Analysis of the enzymatic hydrolysis by the proteolytic enzyme trypsin demonstrates a strong dependence on structural arrangements. While polypept(o)ide disintegration is detectible after 24h by Size Exclusion Chromatography (SEC), significant hydrolysis of the lysine blocks is only monitored after 48h by fluorescamine labeling of the produced lysine and clearly accelerated in structures with more accessible polylysine blocks. All structures are capable of complexing plasmid DNA and form gene nanomedicines at sizes around or below 200nm as determined by Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS), Nanoparticle Tracking Analysis (NTA), and Transition Electron Microscopy (TEM). The polyplex formation is slightly enhanced for both block structures over the random copolypept(o)ide. Moreover, it is demonstrated that the polyplexes can transport through mucus. The results highlight the importance of structural control in compartmentalized polymeric gene vector candidates with hydrophilic domains for potential mucosal delivery.

Small Molecule Modifications Significantly Increase the Transfection Efficiency of Low-Molecular Polymer.

Gene vectors with high biocompatibility and transfection efficiency are critical for successful gene therapy. PEI 25K (Polyethyleneimine 25K) is a common polymeric gene vector that has been employed as a positive control material in gene transfection studies due to its good performance in endosome escape. PEI 25K's indegradability and abundance of positive charges, on the other hand, cause toxicity in cells, limiting its use. In this study, we developed the PEI-ER non-viral vector by adding an endoplasmic reticulum (ER) targeting ligand to low molecular weight PEI 1.8K. These small molecule modifications dramatically improved PEI transfection efficiency while barely interfering with compatibility. PEI-ER/DNA complexes were discovered to enter the cell via caveolin-mediated endocytosis, avoiding destruction in the endosome. We believe that this little chemical alteration is a simple solution to enhance the efficacy of cationic polymer vectors in gene transport, and it has a lot of medicinal applications.

Polymeric Nonviral Gene Delivery Systems for Cancer Immunotherapy

AbstractUnlike viral vectors with their undesired safety or immunogenicity concerns, biocompatible polymeric nonviral vectors as gene delivery systems are more promising in gene or cell therapy. Evidence has demonstrated that the rational design of polymeric nonviral gene vectors with optimal structure, charge density, biocompatibility, and stimulus responsiveness can deliver therapeutic genes or gene vaccines (in terms of deoxyribonucleic acid DNA or ribonucleic acid RNA) into tumor‐associated immunocytes (i.e., macrophages, T cells, or dendritic cells) in an effective and controllable manner for enhanced cancer immunotherapy. However, a timely and systematic summary of this subject is lacking. This review presents an overview of polymeric nonviral carriers with immune cell transfection ability and their potential applications in cancer immunotherapy; it also provides a tutorial for designing polymeric immune‐cell genetic modification vector, although there are still few vectors in the product pipeline. With the rapid growth of immunotherapy in cancer treatment and knowledge accumulation in vector structure design, polymeric nonviral gene delivery systems may provide new hope for tumor therapy.

ROS-responsive fluorinated polycations as non-viral gene vectors

Polycation carriers hold great potential in gene therapy. However, they usually suffer from obvious cytotoxicity and unsatisfactory transfection efficiency. In this report, a series of fluorobenzene substituted and thioacetal contained polycations (TAEA-S-xF) were prepared to explore novel alternatives for safe and efficient non-viral polymeric gene vectors. The reactive oxygen species (ROS)-responsive property of thioacetal moieties together with the fluorine effect were hope to bring the vector better performance in gene delivery process. These materials could efficiently condense DNA into nanoparticles with proper size and surface potential. The structure-activity relationship of these materials was systematically investigated, and the In vitro transfection results revealed that the amount of fluorine atoms on the linkage plays important role to ensure the transfection efficiency and serum tolerance. The ROS-responsive behavior was verified by NMR, gel electrophoresis experiment and dynamic light scattering (DLS) assay. Cytotoxicity assay results also suggest that these ROS-degradable polycations show good biocompatibility in response to higher ROS level in cancer cells. Among these fluorinated polymers, the one with the most fluorine atoms showed the best transfection efficiency, which was up to 54 times higher than polyethyleneimine (PEI) 25 kDa. Mechanism studies reveal that its better performance may come from good cellular uptake and endosome escape ability.

Dex-Aco coating simultaneously increase the biocompatibility and transfection efficiency of cationic polymeric gene vectors

Cationic polymeric vectors attracted plenty of attentions in gene therapy due to nonimmunogenicity, easy to synthesis and flexible properties. However, biocompatibility challenge such as nonspecific interactions with blood cells and serum proteins, may affect the delivery efficiency of cationic vectors; besides, inefficient endosomal escape causes low transfection efficiency. Herein, we synthesized an anionic coating polymer dextran-g-aconic anhydride (Dex-Aco, DA) through a simple esterification reaction, which can protect cationic polymer poly(cystamine-bis-acrylamide)-agmatine-histamine (PCAH, PC) constructed nanomedicine against interactions with blood cells and serum proteins, improving biocompatibility. Interestingly, DA coating significantly increased the transfection efficiency of cationic PC，not due to the increase of cellular uptake, nor functioning as a receptor ligand, but was associated to the change of endocytosis pathway. Finally, using programmed cell death protein 4 (PDCD4) as a functional gene, DA coating PC NPs showed improved therapeutic effect and biocompatibility on tumor bearing mice. We believe that this DA coating PC NPs provides a facile method to improve the performance of cationic polymer vectors in gene therapy and has great potential for clinical applications.

Glycopolymers/PEI complexes as serum-tolerant vectors for enhanced gene delivery to hepatocytes

Serum stability is a crucial factor for ideal polymeric gene vectors. In this work, a series of serum-tolerant and low-toxicity glycopolymers/poly(ethyleneimine) (PEI) complexes were designed for gene delivery. Atomic transfer radical polymerization (ATRP) was used to synthesize the comb-shaped random copolymers dextran-g-poly(2-dimethylaminoethyl methacrylate-co-2-lactobionamidoethyl methacrylate) (DDrL). Then DDrLs/PEI were investigated for their use as plasmid DNA (pDNA) vectors, which can completely condense the pDNA into nanoparticles. The DDrLs/PEI/pDNA complexes in serum-containing media showed better stability than PEI/pDNA complexes. in vitro gene transfection studies showed that DDrLs/PEI exhibited a remarkable transfection efficiency enhancement in the presence of serum compared to that in serum-free conditions. Moreover, the transfection level of DDrLs/PEI were two orders of magnitude higher than that of PEI alone in the presence of 30% serum. DDrLs/PEI complexes with galactose enhanced pDNA delivery to hepatocytes, with higher protein expression in ASGPr-presenting HepG2 than in HeLa cells, which lack the receptor. All of the DDrLs/PEI/pDNA complexes had lower cytotoxicity than PEI/pDNA.

Thiolactone Chemistry-Based Combinatorial Methodology to Construct Multifunctional Polymers for Efficacious Gene Delivery.

Hydrophobic segments and amino moieties in polymeric nonviral gene vectors play important roles in overcoming a cascade of barriers for efficient gene delivery. However, it remains a great challenge to facilely construct well-defined multifunctional polymers through optimization of the amino and hydrophobic groups. Herein, we choose thiolactone chemistry to perform the ring opening reaction of varying hydrophobic groups-modified thiolactones by various amines to generate mercapto groups for further Michael addition reaction with poly[2-(acryloyloxy)ethyl methacrylate] (PAOEMA). Based on the combinatorial methodology, a series of multifunctional polymers were prepared and screened. The polymer (P3D) from tetraethylenepentamine and heptafluorobutyric acid-functionalized thiolactone is the most efficacious one with significantly higher gene transfection efficiency and lower cytotoxicity compared with polyethylenimine (PEI) (branched average Mw ∼ 25 000 Da) and Lipofectamine 2000. Cellular uptake and intracellular distribution studies indicate that P3D complexes show high-efficiency endocytosis and excellent endosomal escape. Accordingly, thiolactone chemistry-based combinatorial methodology allows for facile integration of multifunctional groups to prepare simultaneous efficacious and low-cytotoxic gene delivery vectors.

Ring-opening polymerization of diepoxides as an alternative method to overcome PEG dilemma in gene delivery

Gene therapy has shown great potential in the treatment of various diseases, and the development of low-toxic and efficient gene carriers is still one of the burning issues for gene therapy. PEGylation is generally regarded as an efficient strategy to improve the biocompatibility of non-viral vectors. However, PEGylation also led to several problems such as lower cellular uptake, difficult endosomal escape and much reduced transfection efficiency, which was described as “PEG dilemma”. We herein devote to the development of polymeric gene vectors that can overcome such dilemma via diepoxide ring-opening polymerization (DEROP) of low molecular weight PEI, and unmodified PEI and PEG-grafted PEI were used for comparison. Transfection experiments with various concentrations of serum revealed that the DEROP polymers gave much higher transfection efficiency together with better serum tolerance than PEI and PEGylated ones. Protein adsorption and flow cytometry assays further proved their better serum resistance. Besides, confocal microscopy suggested that the polyplexes formed from these polymers could escape from endosome/lysosome more efficiently than those derived from PEGylated material. In vivo biochemical studies also reflect good biocompatibility of the DEROP polymers. Results demonstrate that such polymer construction strategy gave cationic materials with both high transfection efficiency and improved biocompatibility, and afforded an effective way to overcome PEG dilemma.

Histone-inspired biomimetic polymeric gene vehicles with excellent biocompatibility and enhanced transfection efficacy

Histone-inspired biomimetic polymeric gene vectors show great biocompatibility and enhanced transfection efficacy.

Biodegradable Three-Layered Micelles and Injectable Hydrogels.

Polymeric micelles have found a growing interest as gene vectors due to the serious safety concerns associated with viral vectors. In particular, the cationic polymer polyethylene imine (PEI) has shown relatively high condensation and transfection efficiencies. Additionally, polyethylene glycol (PEG) modification of polymeric gene vectors has dramatically improved their biological properties, including enhanced biocompatibility, prolonged circulation time, and increased bio-distribution. However, PEG grafting of PEI for subsequent condensation of nucleic acids (NAs) does not necessarily result in the formation of a PEI/NAs core with a PEG corona. But often times, the presence of PEG interferes with PEI's electrostatic interaction with NAs. We describe here a facile method to prepare multilayered biodegradable micelles which address some of the critical drawbacks associated with current PEI-based systems. The polyplex micelles have superb stability and stealth properties. Moreover, we describe a method to prepare fully biodegradable and biocompatible injectable hydrogels for use in localized gene therapy.

Fluorination on polyethylenimine allows efficient 2D and 3D cell culture gene delivery.

Polyethylenimine (PEI) is one of the most promising polymeric gene vectors, however its applications are limited by serious cytotoxicity and moderate transfection efficacy. Fluorination is an efficient strategy to improve the transfection efficacy of cationic polymers while reducing their cytotoxicity. Here we grafted different fluoroalkyl chains to PEI via oxirane and anhydride reactions. The fluorinated PEIs show superior transfection efficacy on both 2D and 3D cell cultures to unmodified PEI. These fluorinated polymers allow efficient gene transfection at relatively low nitrogen to phosphorus ratios and thereby ensure low cytotoxicity on the transfected cells. Fluorinated PEIs prepared via the oxirane reaction are much more stable in aqueous solutions than the ones prepared by the anhydride reaction and show reproducible gene transfection during a period of 6 months. This study extends the applicable scope of fluorination on improving the transfection efficacy of polymers and generates a list of gene vectors for efficient 2D and 3D cell culture gene transfection.

Gene transfection in complex media using PCBMAEE-PCBMA copolymer with both hydrolytic and zwitterionic blocks

Safety and high efficacy of vectors are essential requirements for gene therapy. To address these challenges, poly(carboxy betaine methacrylate ethyl ester)-poly(carboxy betaine methacrylate) (PCBMAEE-PCBMA) diblock copolymers were synthesized to form core–shell vector for gene delivery. The hydrophobic PCBMAEE segment, a polyzwitterionic precursor, can condense plasmid DNA (pDNA) into a hydrophobic core, which improves pDNA protection from nuclease attack and maintains the condensed structure against dilution. Moreover, the hydrolysis of PCBMAEE in uptaken gene vectors can enhance the pDNA release and reduce the cytotoxicity caused by the cationic polymer accumulation in the host cells. The PCBMA segment, zwitterionic fouling resistant material, is utilized to stabilize the gene vector in the complex medium and reduce the interference from serum proteins without impeding the endocytosis of DNA vector like PEG protection layer. Results showed that the complex formed by PCBMAEE50-PCBMA14 with luciferase or pEGFP gene exhibit higher transfection efficacy of pDNA than that formed by PEI 25 kDa or Lipofectamine® 2000 in tested cell lines (COS-7, HepG-2, HeLa, and HUVEC), especially, in difficult-to-transfect ones, such as HeLa and HUVEC. The luciferase expression level infected by the vectors of PCBMAEE50-PCBMA14/pGL-4 at N/P = 20/1 is 27 times of the branched PEI 25 kDa in COS-7 cells and 16 times of Lipofectamine® 2000 in HUVEC. Furthermore, the complex formed by PCBMAEE50-PCBMA14 also show advantages in transfection rate, dosage effectiveness and preservation of transfecting activity in serum contained growth medium. The luciferase expression of the vectors of PCBMAEE50-PCBMA14/pGL-4 at N/P = 20/1 is 230 times higher than that of PEI complex at low vector dosage (the 5% standard dosage). And the transfection rate is 25 times higher than that of PEI complex in 10% serum contained growth medium. In short, all these results indicated that the polymeric gene vector, consisted of convertible hydrophobic polyzwitterionic precursor and fixed polyzwitterionic fouling resistant segment, is a promising candidate for high and stable gene transfection in complex growth medium.

The effect of fluorination on the transfection efficacy of surface-engineered dendrimers

Dendrimers have shown great promise in the design of high efficient and low cytotoxic gene vectors. In this study, we synthesized a list of fluorobenzoic acid-modified dendrimers by a facile synthetic route and explored their potential applications as non-viral gene vectors. Fluorination on the aromatic rings significantly improves the transfection efficacy of benzoic acid-modified dendrimers. The transfection efficacy increases with increasing number of fluorine atoms on the aromatic rings of the conjugated benzoic acid. The most efficient conjugate shows superior efficacy to polymer-based commercial reagents such as SuperFect and PolyFect, and comparable efficacy to lipid-based commercial reagents such as Lipofectamine 2000. In addition, the fluorobenzoic acid-modified dendrimers show low cytotoxicity on the transfected cells. The improved transfection efficacy of fluorobenzoic acid-modified dendrimers is due to enhanced cellular uptake and/or easier DNA unpacking behavior compared to non-modified dendrimers. These results provide a new fluorination strategy to generate a library of highly efficient and non-cytotoxic polymeric gene vectors.

Mitochondrial targeting dendrimer allows efficient and safe gene delivery.

Cationic dendrimers are promising tools in the introduction of nucleic acids into mammalian cells, however, present dendrimer-based gene vectors have modest transfection efficacy and significant toxicity. Here, we synthesized triphenylphosphonium (TPP) conjugated dendrimers and used them as polymeric gene vectors. TPP-conjugated dendrimers can effectively target mitochondria and showed efficient transfection efficacy on HeLa and COS-7 cells with low cytotoxicity on the transfected cells. These materials achieved much higher efficacy than the commercial transfection reagent SuperFect and comparable efficacy with Lipofectamine 2000. This study provides a new insight into the design of efficient and biocompatible gene vectors using dendrimers as scaffolds.

Versatile functionalization of gene vectors via different types of zwitterionic betaine species for serum-tolerant transfection

For ideal polymeric gene vectors, their serum stability is of crucial importance. Polycation vectors usually suffer from colloidal aggregation, which makes them easily cleared from the bloodstream. Recently, we reported a comb-shaped vector (DPD) consisting of a dextran backbone and disulfide-linked cationic poly((2-dimethyl amino)ethyl methacrylate) side chains for efficient gene delivery. In this work, versatile functionalization of DPD (as a model gene vector) was proposed via the introduction of different types of zwitterionic carboxybetaine and sulfobetaine species for improving biophysical properties. The incorporation of zwitterionic betaine did not destroy the DNA condensation capability of vectors. All the zwitterionic betaine-functionalized DPD vectors exhibited lower cytotoxicities than the pristine DPD. The DPD-b-polycarboxybetaine block copolymer (DPDbPC) exhibited better gene delivery abilities than the corresponding DPD-r-polycarboxybetaine random copolymer (DPDrPC). Moreover, in the serum case with a high concentration (30%) of fetal bovine serum, the DPD-b-polysulfobetaine block copolymer (DPDbPS) produced much higher gene transfection efficiencies than DPDbPC. Cellular internalization results indicated that the incorporation of zwitterionic betaine could benefit serum stabilities of vectors and enhance cellular uptake. The present study demonstrated that proper incorporation of zwitterionic betaine into gene carriers was an effective method to produce serum-tolerant transfection vectors.

Synthesis and characterization of novel brush copolymers with biodegradable polyphosphoester side chains for gene delivery

AbstractA novel kind of pH‐sensitive brush copolymer [poly(2‐hydroxyethyl methacrylate)‐graft‐poly(ethylethylene phosphate)]‐block‐poly[2‐(dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate] [(PHEMA‐g‐PEEP)‐b‐PDMAEMA] with biodegradable polyphosphoester as the side chains, and its self‐assembled aggregates were developed for nonviral gene delivery. The brush copolymers were synthesized via a combination of single‐electron transfer living radical polymerization and ring‐opening polymerization. The chemical structures of these brush copolymers were characterized by FTIR, 1H NMR, and 31P NMR measurements. The critical aggregation concentration values of (PHEMA‐g‐PEEP)‐b‐PDMAEMA in pH 7.4 buffer solution were determined by the fluorescence probe technique. The interaction of (PHEMA‐g‐PEEP)‐b‐PDMAEMA and DNA was studied by agarose gel retardation assay, and the formed complexes were further investigated by means of zeta potential, dynamic light scattering, and transmission electron microscopy measurements. In addition, the in vitro cytotoxicity and transfection tests indicated that these brush copolymers showed low toxicity and favorable transfection efficiency to HeLa cells. All these results demonstrated that these biocompatible brush copolymers may be a promising candidate as nonviral polymeric gene vector. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem, 2013

The neurotoxicity of gene vectors and its amelioration by packaging with collagen hollow spheres

Over the last twenty years there have been several reports on the use of nonviral vectors to facilitate gene transfer in the mammalian brain. Whilst a large emphasis has been placed on vector transfection efficiency, the study of the adverse effects upon the brain, caused by the vectors themselves, remains completely overshadowed. To this end, a study was undertaken to study the tissue response to three commercially available transfection agents in the brain of adult Sprague Dawley rats. The response to these transfection agents was compared to adeno-associated viral vector (AAV), PBS and naked DNA. Furthermore, the use of a collagen hollow sphere (CHS) sustained delivery system was analysed for its ability to reduce striatal toxicity of the most predominantly studied polymer vector, polyethyleneimine (PEI). The size of the gross tissue loss at the injection site was analysed after immunohistochemical staining and was used as an indication of acute toxicity. Polymeric vectors showed similar levels of acute brain toxicity as seen with AAV, and CHS were able to significantly reduce the toxicity of the PEI vector. In addition; the host response to the vectors was measured in terms of reactive astrocytes and microglial cell recruitment. To understand whether this gross tissue loss was caused by the direct toxicity of the vectors themselves an in vitro study on primary astrocytes was conducted. All vectors reduced the viability of the cells which is brought about by direct necrosis and apoptosis. The CHS delivery system reduced cell necrosis in the early stages of post administration. In conclusion, whilst polymeric gene vectors cause acute necrosis, administration in the brain causes adverse effects no worse than that of an AAV vector. Furthermore, packaging the PEI vector with CHS reduces surface charge and direct toxicity without elevating the host response.

Single Cyclized Molecule Versus Single Branched Molecule: A Simple and Efficient 3D “Knot” Polymer Structure for Nonviral Gene Delivery

The large research effort focused on enhancing nonviral transfection vectors has clearly demonstrated that their macromolecular structure has a significant effect on their transfection efficacy. The 3D branched polymeric structures, such as dendrimers, have proved to be a very effective structure for polymeric transfection vectors; however, so far the dendritic polymers have not delivered on their promise. This is largely because a wide range of dendritic polymer materials with tailored multifunctional properties and biocompatibility required for such applications are not yet accessible by current routes. Herein, we report the design and synthesis of new 3D "Single Cyclized" polymeric gene vectors with well-defined compositions and functionalities via a one-step synthesis from readily available vinyl monomers. We observe that this polymer structure of a single chain linked to itself interacts differently with plasmid DNA compared to conventional vectors and when tested over a range of cell types, has a superior transfection profile in terms of both luciferase transfection capability and preservation of cell viability. This new knotted structure shows high potential for gene delivery applications through a combination of simplicity in synthesis, scalability, and high performance.