It has been documented that sweetpotato (Ipomoea batatas L.) cultivars vary in morphological and physiological adaptations to low phosphorus (P) availability but knowledge of the underlying molecular mechanisms is largely unknown. The objective of this research was to generate cultivar-specific information about phosphate starvation response (PSR) genes to variations in inorganic phosphate (Pi) availability at the onset of storage root formation among sweetpotato cultivars. Cultivars Bayou Belle (BB), Evangeline (EV), and Orleans (OR) were grown under varying Pi levels: 0 mg·L−1 (low Pi), 15 mg·L−1 (Pi-sufficient), and 31 mg·L−1 (high Pi). Reverse transcriptase quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) analysis of PSR genes IbPHR1, IbSPX1, IbSPX3, IbPHT1;4, IbPHT1;5, and IbNLA was performed at 5 and 10 days after planting (DAP), corresponding to adventitious root system establishment and the onset of storage root formation, respectively. The cultivar BB grown under low Pi showed significantly higher expression of all genes except IbPHR1. The cultivar OR grown in both low and high Pi exhibited upregulation of IbPHR1. On the other hand, EV grown under low Pi revealed no response for all genes investigated. Exposure of BB to high Pi resulted in a decrease in expression for all genes except IbNLA. The cultivar EV grown in high Pi conditions showed increase in expression for IbSPX1, IbPHT1;5, and IbNLA. Expression pattern difference among cultivars relative to Pi levels corroborates field observations showing that BB, EV, and OR have different Pi requirements. The increased activity of BB PSR genes grown under low Pi supports the hypothesis that BB requires low P fertilizer input relative to OR and EV. Results from this study corroborate findings from well-characterized crop species and model systems and pave the way for the development of tools and practices to increase phosphorus use efficiency in sweetpotato.