Forced intercalation peptide nucleic acids (FIT-PNAs) are DNA mimics that act as RNA sensors. The sensing event occurs due to sequence-specific RNA hybridization, leading to a substantial increase in fluorescence. The fluorophore in the FIT-PNA is termed a surrogate base. This molecule typically replaces a purine in the PNA sequence. BisQ is a surrogate base that connects two quinolines via a monomethine bond. BisQ-based FIT-PNAs have excellent biophysical features that include high brightness and red-shifted emission (λem, max = 613 nm). In this report, we detail two chemical approaches that allow for the facile synthesis of the BisQ PNA monomer. In both cases, the key compound used for the synthesis of BisQ-CH2COOH is the tBu-ester-modified quinoline synthon (compound 5). Subsequently, one method uses the Alloc acid-protected PNA backbone, whereas the other uses the tBu ester-protected PNA backbone. In the latter case, the overall yield for BisQ acid (compound 7) and BisQ PNA monomer syntheses was 61% in six synthetic steps. This is a substantial improvement to the published procedures to date (7% total yield). Lastly, we have prepared an 11-mer FIT-PNA with either BisQ or thiazole orange (TO) and studied their photophysical properties. We find superior photophysical properties for the BisQ FIT-PNA in terms of the brightness and selectivity, highlighting the added value of using this surrogate base for RNA sensing.