Plant Protease Inhibitors Research Articles

Putative protease inhibitor gene discovery and transcript profiling during fruit development and leaf damage in grapefruit (Citrus paradisi Macf.).

Seven putative protease inhibitor (PPI) cDNAs, representing four protein families, were isolated from a grapefruit (Citrus paradisi Macf. Cv. Marsh) immature fruit flavedo cDNA library. Cloned open reading frames encoded proteins with similarity to, and protein signatures for: legume Kuntiz inhibitors (lkiL-1, lkiL-2, lkiL-3), potato trypsin inhibitor I (ptiIL-1), serpins (serpL-1), cystatins (cystL-1), and gamma thionins (gthL-1). Response of transcript abundance to fruit development and leaf wounding was determined for all but lkiL-1 using real-time RT-PCR. Immature leaves had the highest transcript levels for all PPIs. The gthL-1 transcript in immature leaves was the most abundant transcript but was absent from healthy mature leaves. In fruit flavedo, transcripts for all PPIs were most abundant in youngest fruit (<15 mm dia. fruit), and declined during development, but displayed different patterns of developmental change. Mechanical or Diaprepes root weevil (DRW) feeding damage to leaves caused a <10-fold reduction or had no effect on transcript level with the exception of gthL-1 which, as a result of damage, increased >50-fold in mature leaves and decreased >1400-fold in immature leaves. This developmental control of transcript response to wounding in a woody perennial is opposite of what has been observed for defensive proteinase inhibitors (PIs) in other plants (typically herbaceous and/or annual plants), where younger leaves typically invoke a higher defensive proteinase inhibitor transcript accumulation than older tissues. Except for gthL-1, the PPI transcripts were minimally responsive or unresponsive to wounding. Changes in PPI transcript levels suggest diverse roles for the products of these genes in citrus, with only gthL-1 responding in a defense-like manner.

Expression of soybean proteinase inhibitors in transgenic sugarcane plants: effects on natural defense against Diatraea saccharalis

The introduction and expression of proteinase inhibitor encoding genes into sugarcane ( Saccharum officinarum L.) genome is an interesting strategy for conferring partial resistance to the sugarcane borer Diatraea saccharalis (Lepidoptera: Crambidae), the major insect pest of sugarcane in Brazil. To investigate the role of soybean ( Glycine max L.) Kunitz trypsin inhibitor (SKTI) and soybean Bowman–Birk inhibitor (SBBI) in the control of D. saccharalis, the cDNAs encoding these proteinase inhibitors were placed under the control of the maize ubiquitin promoter ( Ubi-1), and introduced into sugarcane callus using particle bombardment. Putative transgenic plants were initially identified after regeneration from callus growing in the presence of 30 mg l –1 geneticin, while molecular characterization of transgenic plants revealed that both genes were incorporated into the sugarcane genome and expressed. We also carried out insect feeding trials using D. saccharalis neonate larvae and leaf tissue excised from propagated transgenic and untransformed plants, and found that the growth of larvae feeding on leaf tissue from transgenic plants containing BBI and Kunitz inhibitors was significantly retarded as compared to larvae fed on leaf tissue from untransformed plants. In greenhouse trials with transgenic sugarcane plants infested with D. saccharalis neonates, we found that these plants still presented the ‘dead heart’ symptom typically observed in susceptible plants in the field, suggesting that the retardation of the growth of D. saccharalis observed in the laboratory-based feeding trials was not sufficient to prevent this type of damage.

The Role of Protease Inhibitors and Parasitoids on the Population Dynamics ofSitotroga cerealella(Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae)

The Angoumois grain moth, Sitotroga cerealella (Oliver), is one of the major storage pests of cereals, and no antibiotic resistance in wheat against this insect has been identified to date. Midgut proteases are vital to insects that digest food in the midgut and have been considered as targets for the control of insect pests. Protease inhibitors are attractive for their potential use in developing insect-resistant plant varieties via genetic engineering. Characterization of the midgut proteases of S. cerealella larvae revealed the major digestive proteases were trypsin-like and α-chymotrypsin-like serine proteases. The partial inhibition of proteolytic activity by pepstatin A, however, suggested the presence of another protease in the midgut sensitive to this inhibitor. The potential value of naturally occurring plant protease inhibitors as resistance factors for S. cerealella was assessed in bioassays using artificial seeds prepared by freeze-drying a flour paste in Teflon molds and then coating the seeds with gelatin. Soybean trypsin inhibitor (Kunitz inhibitor) had an adverse effect on the development of the insect and suggested a protease inhibitor might serve as a transgenic resistance factor. To evaluate the potential value of seed resistance in conjunction with an egg parasitoid on S. cerealella population dynamics a predictive model was developed. The model was directed toward grain storage in developing countries. While the model was hypothetical, outputs supported the use of resistant seed in conjunction with parasitoids to control the population growth of S. cerealella in a small seed storage room.

Effects of cysteine protease inhibitors on oviposition rate of the western flower thrips, Frankliniella occidentalis

Proteolytic activity in whole insect extracts of the western flower thrips, Frankliniella occidentalis, was found to belong predominantly to the class of cysteine proteases. The pH optimum of the general proteolytic activity was determined to be 3.5, which is low when compared to other insects using cysteine proteases for protein digestion. The proteinaceous cysteine protease inhibitors chicken cystatin, potato cystatin and sea anemone equistatin inhibited in vitro more than 90% of the protease activity. To test in vivo the biological effect of such inhibitors on the oviposition rate of western flower thrips, recombinant potato cystatin and equistatin were fed to adult females. A gradual reduction in oviposition rate to about 45% of control was observed when reared on these PIs for a period of 5 days, with no increase in mortality. These results are discussed in the light of the application of protease inhibitors in transgenic plants to control this insect pest.

Plant protease inhibitors in control of phytophagous insects

Plant proteinase inhibitors (PIs) have been well established to play a potent defensive role against predators and pathogens. Although diverse endogenous functions for these proteins has been proposed, ranging from regulators of endogenous proteinases to act as storage proteins, evidence for many of these roles is partial, or confined to isolated examples. On the other hand, many PIs have been shown to act as defensive compounds against pests by direct assay or by expression in transgenic crop plants, and a body of evidence for their role in plant defense has been accumulated consistently. The role and mechanism of action for most of these inhibitors are being studied in detail and their respective genes isolated. These genes have been used for the construction of transgenic crop plants to be incorporated in integrated pest management programmes. This article describes the classes of protease inhibitors, their regulation and genes used to construct transgenic plants against phytophagous insects.

PLANT-PIs: a database for plant protease inhibitors and their genes.

PLANT-PIs is a database developed to facilitate retrieval of information on plant protease inhibitors (PIs) and related genes. For each PI, links to sequence databases are reported together with a summary of the functional properties of the molecule (and its mutants) as deduced from literature. PLANT-PIs contains information for 351 plant PIs, plus several isoinhibitors. The database is accessible at http://bighost.area.ba.cnr.it/PLANT-PIs.

Identification of soybean elicitation competency factor, CF-1, as the soybean Kunitz trypsin inhibitor

The soybean defence responses that occur in cells immediately adjacent (proximal) to the hypersensitive response (HR) can be induced by the cell wall glucan elicitor (WGE) from Phytophthora sojae, but in some cultivars only in cells that have been pre-conditioned by endogenous competency factors associated with wounded or HR-dying cells. Competency factor, CF-1, causes a general amplification of phenylpropanoid responses to elicitor and greatly enhances the phenolic polymer response to elicitor. CF-1 activity, which is heat-labile and associated with a low speed centrifugal pellet of soybean tissues, can be partially mimicked by reduced glutathione (GSH). Here it is reported that GSH releases CF-1 activity into intercellular washing fluids, suggesting it is associated with the apoplast. Likewise, GSH can be used to enrich CF-1 activity greatly in extracts from low speed pellets. This enrichment allowed the purification of CF-1 to near homogeneity and its subjection to mass spectral and sequence analysis. CF-1 was identified as the soybean Kunitz trypsin inhibitor (SKTI). Although plant protease inhibitors have been implicated in insect and pathogen resistance, to the authors' knowledge this is the first suggestion of a regulatory role in activation of cellular defence responses. Protease inhibitors play a role in many signaling processes in eukaryotic systems, and SKTI has intriguing three-dimensional homologies to interleukin 1-α and 1-β and fibroblast growth factor.

Physiological response of Colorado potato beetle and beet armyworm larvae to depletion of wound-inducible proteinase inhibitors in transgenic potato plants

Larvae of Colorado potato beetle (CPB), Leptinotarsa decemlineata, and beet armyworm (BAW), Spodoptera exigua, reared on potato plants in which wound-induced accumulation of proteinase inhibitors (PIs) was largely reduced through antisense-mediated depletion of a specific lipoxygenase (LOX H3) had significantly larger weight gains than those fed on non-transformed plants. The midgut endoproteolytic activities of CPB larvae fed on non-transformed potato were significantly higher than those from larvae fed on LOX-H3-deficient plants. However, none of these proteolytic activities was inhibited by potato leaf extracts, regardless of the plant that they were fed on. Taken together, these data suggest that CPB, a leaf-feeding specialist of solanaceous plants, is largely adapted to the inducible PIs of potato, though the metabolic cost associated with the hyperproduction of digestive proteases may account for the 14–31% lower weight gain of larvae fed on non-transformed plants. The effect of LOX-H3 depletion on insect performance was more evident with larvae of the polyphagous BAW (52–63% higher weight gain and 73% higher fecundity when reared on LOX-H3-deficient plants). The poorer larval performance of BAW on non-transformed plants may be due to the susceptibility to inhibition by potato leaf tissues of most BAW digestive proteases. Indeed, BAW larvae fed on non-transformed potato showed a significant reduction in most endoproteolytic activities compared to larvae fed on LOX-H3-deficient plants, suggesting a that these insects deal poorly with induced plant defences in potato.

Protease inhibitors and directed evolution: enhancing plant resistance to nematodes.

Plant nematodes are agricultural pests, the control of which relies on chemical nematicides and fumigants that are among the most toxic and environmentally damaging of all agrochemicals. New approaches to control, based on transgenic resistance, would provide important health and environmental benefits. In this chapter we consider briefly some targets for engineering nematode resistance and discuss the use of plant protease inhibitors as anti-feedants. This approach has provided plants that display good levels of resistance against a range of nematode species. To enhance this defence strategy further we are investigating the value of directed evolution to improve the characteristics of protease inhibitors. We describe the approaches of DNA shuffling and phage display that are being used to create and screen variant libraries in the search for inhibitors with improved features.

Identification of six chymotrypsin cDNAs from larval midguts of Helicoverpa zea and Agrotis ipsilon feeding on the soybean (Kunitz) trypsin inhibitor

Lepidopteran insects like Helicoverpa zea and Agrotis ipsilon produce STI-insensitive trypsins in the midgut following ingestion of dietary plant proteinase inhibitors like STI [ Broadway, R. M., J. Insect Physiol. 43(9) (1997) 855–874]. In this paper, the effects of dietary STI on a related family of midgut serine proteinases, the chymotrypsins, were investigated. STI-insensitive midgut chymotrypsins were detected in larvae of H. zea and A. ipsilon feeding on diets containing 1% STI while STI-sensitive chymotrypsins were present in larvae feeding on diets containing 0% STI. These chymotrypsins were unaffected by TPCK, a diagnostic inhibitor of mammalian chymotrypsins but were fully inhibited by chymostatin. Four midgut cDNA libraries were constructed from larvae of each species fed either 0% STI or 1% STI diets. Six full-length cDNAs 1 GenBank Accessions # AF233728-AF233737 1 encoding diverse preprochymotrypsins were isolated (three from H. zea and three from A. ipsilon) with certain sequence motifs that set them apart from their mammalian counterparts. Northern blots showed that some chymotrypsin mRNA were detected at higher levels while others were down-regulated when comparing insects reared on 0% STI and 1% STI diets. Southern hybridizations suggested that (like mammals) both species contained several chymotrypsin genes. A full-length chymotrypsin gene 1 from H. zea was sequenced for the first time and the presence of four introns was deduced. A first time comparison of 5′ upstream regions 1 from three chymotrypsin genes and two trypsin genes of A. ipsilon indicated the presence of putative TATA boxes and regulatory elements. However a lack of consensus motifs in these upstream regions suggested the likelihood of multiple trans factors for regulation of genes encoding digestive proteinases and a complex response mechanism linked to ingestion of proteinase inhibitors.

Plant proteinase inhibitors as polyfunctional proteins (a review)

Literature data on plant proteinase inhibitors as multifunctional proteins are reviewed. In addition to the direct inhibitory effect on enzymes, these proteins may function in other processes, particularly under biotic and environmental stressful conditions. A special section discusses the relationships of plant proteinase inhibitors and storage proteins.

Effect of plant protease inhibitors on digestive proteases in two fish species, Lutjanus argentiventris and L. novemfasciatus

This work provides a comparative study of the inhibitory effect of several plant protein sources on digestive proteases of two snappers: yellow snapper (Lutjanus argentiventris) and dog snapper (Lutjanus novemfasciatus). Seed extracts did not affect gastric proteases whereas they significantly inhibit intestinal proteases. Inhibition of alkaline proteases showed that pancreatic proteases of L. argentiventris were more sensitive to seed protease inhibitors than those of L. novemfasciatus. Legume seeds showed the highest inhibitory capacity on alkaline proteases causing inhibition higher than 50% in total proteolytic activity. Protease inhibition on digestive extracts was assessed using different relative concentration of seed extracts and represented by constructing dose response curves. In order to reduce the inhibitory effect, seed extracts were acid-treated before the inhibition assay. Results showed that acid treatment did not affect the inhibitory capacity of seeds on alkaline proteases in both species. However, when the action of gastric enzymes was simulated on seed extracts, the inhibitory capacity was reduced significantly, mainly in the case of L. novemfasciatus. The responses of fish enzymes to heat-treated seed extracts were also tested. Only higher temperatures were capable of reducing the inhibitory capacity of seed, with the specific response to the snapper species. The use of biochemical assays allows us to quantify the action of inhibitors on total proteolytic activity. In addition, zymograms obtained by substrate-SDS-PAGE provided qualitative information about the number and type of proteases affected by each inhibitor. Each seed extract produces a characteristic profile of inhibition on alkaline protease. The results obtained are important for future formulation of feeds for these snapper species.

Accumulation of a maize proteinase inhibitor in response to wounding and insect feeding, and characterization of its activity toward digestive proteinases of Spodoptera littoralis larvae.

The mpi gene encodes a maize proteinase inhibitor (MPI) protein whose mRNA accumulates in response to mechanical wounding. In this study, mpi gene expression in response to different types of damage was investigated. In mechanically damaged leaves of maize (Zea mays L.), mpi mRNA accumulation was affected by the degree of damage inflicted on the leaf. Consecutive wounds resulted in higher levels of mpi transcripts. The MPI protein was expressed in Escherichia coli and purified. Polyclonal antibodies were then produced and used to study MPI accumulation in insect-wounded and mechanically wounded maize leaves. When larvae of the lepidopteran insect Spodoptera littoralis were fed on maize leaves, MPI accumulated in tissues adjacent to the wound site. The level of inhibitor accumulation was higher in leaves chewed by larvae than in leaves that had been damaged mechanically. Longer feeding periods also resulted in higher levels of MPI accumulation. Additionally, the inhibitory properties of MPI toward mammalian and insect digestive serine proteinases were determined. Contrary to the majority of the plant proteinase inhibitors described, MPI is an inhibitor of mammalian elastase that only weakly inhibits mammalian chymotrypsin. However, both elastase and chymotrypsin-like activities from the larval midgut of S. littoralis were effectively inhibited by MPI. We discuss these results with regard to the function and evolution of plant proteinase inhibitors. The availability of a plant proteinase inhibitor which is able to inhibit the two types of insect digestive proteinase, elastase and chymotrypsin, might be useful for engineering protection against lepidopteran insect pests in transgenic plants.

Digestive proteolytic activity in larvae of tomato moth, Lacanobia oleracea; effects of plant protease inhibitors in vitro and in vivo

Three distinct digestive protease activities, with strongly alkaline pH optima, were identified in the gut of tomato moth ( Lacanobia oleracea) larvae, and characterised using specific synthetic substrates and inhibitors. These were; a trypsin-like activity, a chymotrypsin-like activity specific for substrates and inhibitors containing more than one amino acid residue, and an elastase-like activity, accounting for 40%, 30% and 20% of overall proteolysis respectively. The protease activities differed in their sensitivities to inhibition by different plant protein protease inhibitors (PIs), as estimated by I 50 values. Soya bean Kunitz trypsin inhibitor (SKTI) was the only plant PI tested to inhibit all three digestive protease activities at concentrations <40 μg/ml (approx. 5×10 −6M). Incorporation of SKTI into a potato leaf-based artificial diet at 2% of total protein, decreased larval survival and growth (by approx. 33% and 40% respectively after 21 days) and retarded development (by approx. 2 days). However, when SKTI was expressed in transgenic potato plants at approx. 0.5% of total protein, only marginal effects on L. oleracea larvae were observed, which decreased with time. Whilst the presence of SKTI in artificial diet increased endogenous larval trypsin-like activity by up to four-fold, no effects on this activity were observed in larvae feeding on transgenic plants.

Protein similarities beyond disulphide bridge topology

Structural superimposition is an important procedure to analyse the relationships between proteins. A new approach and program, KNOT-MATCH, has been developed for automated structural superimposition of proteins by means of their disulphide bridge topology. As a result of the superimposition, regular secondary structures, loops and clusters of residues become correctly aligned. This fact allows us to find out important structural overlaps of residues, sometimes with functional significance, not only among proteins belonging to the same family but also between apparently non-related proteins. Different disulphide-rich protein families, such as EGF-like, defensin-like and plant protease inhibitors, have been self or cross analysed with this approach. Some amino acids that have been experimentally determined to be structural and/or functional key residues for these proteins are conserved in the three-dimensional space after superimposition by KNOT-MATCH. The program can be very useful for finding relationships among proteins that would be hidden to the current alignment methods based on sequence and on main-chain topology.

Characterization of Helicoverpa armigera gut proteinases and their interaction with proteinase inhibitors using gel X-ray film contact print technique.

Since Helicoverpa armigera is a devastating pest, an attempt was made to separate its gut proteinases and assess their diversity. Gelatin coating present on the X-ray film was used as a substrate to detect electrophoretically separated proteinases of H. armigera gut extract on native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE), sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-PAGE and isoelectric focusing gels. The method involves electrophoresis, followed by washing the gel with Triton X-100 in case of SDS-PAGE, equilibration of the gel in proteinase assay buffers, overlaying the gel on X-ray film followed by washing the film with hot water to remove hydrolyzed gelatin revealing bands of proteinase activity. Using this protocol, at least six different proteinase isoforms were detected in H. armigera gut contents while three isoproteinases were identified in a commercial bacterial proteinase preparation. Adoption of the technique facilitated characterization of the H. armigera gut proteinases (HGP) and provided an easy tool to study the properties of the individual proteinases without purification. The approximate molecular masses of HGP as determined by SDS-PAGE were: 172.9, 59.3, 54.9, 47.6, 44.1 and 41.6 kDa, and of bacterial proteinases: 180.7, 127.3 and 95.3 kDa. The isoelectric point (pI) values of HGP and bacterial proteinase were in the range of 5.1-7.1 and 3.5-7.7, respectively. Some of the HGP isoforms were found to be highly pH-sensitive and showed activity only at pH 10.0. The major HGPs were inhibited by phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride but not by (4-amidinophenyl)-methanesulfonyl fluoride. Incubation of HGP-resolved electrophoretic gel strips in chickpea or winged bean proteinase inhibitor solution permitted identification of specific inhibitors of individual proteinases and revealed that the major HGPs were insensitive to chickpea inhibitors whereas winged bean inhibitors effectively inhibited all the HGPs. Our results suggest that considerable variability exists among the isoproteinases of H. armigera gut with respect to their pH optima and sensitivity towards chemical and plant proteinase inhibitors. Such diversity is of immense biological significance as it explains the polyphagous nature of the insect which imparts unique adaptability to it against the defensive proteinase inhibitors of its wide range of host plants.

Solution structure of robustoxin, the lethal neurotoxin from the funnel-web spider Atrax robustus

The solution structure of robustoxin, the lethal neurotoxin from the Sydney funnel-web spider Atrax robustus, has been determined from 2D 1H NMR data. Robustoxin is a polypeptide of 42 residues cross-linked by four disulphide bonds, the connectivities of which were determined from NMR data and trial structure calculations to be 1–15, 8–20, 14–31 and 16–42 (a 1–4/2–6/3–7/5–8 pattern). The structure consists of a small three-stranded, anti-parallel β-sheet and a series of interlocking γ-turns at the C-terminus. It also contains a cystine knot, thus placing it in the inhibitor cystine knot motif family of structures, which includes the ω-conotoxins and a number of plant and animal toxins and protease inhibitors. Robustoxin contains three distinct charged patches on its surface, and an extended loop that includes several aromatic and non-polar residues. Both of these structural features may play a role in its binding to the voltage-gated sodium channel.

Plant Proteinase Inhibitors Are Potential Anticereal Aphid Compounds

Trials were conducted to identify new compounds that may be useful in the control of cereal aphids on wheat, Triticum aestivum (L.). Five plant proteinase inhibitors were tested for their ability to control 3 species of cereal aphids in feeding trials. The proteinase inhibitors were tested against the Russian wheat aphid, Diuraphis noxia (Mordvilko), the green bug, Schizaphis graminum (Rondani), and the bird cherry-oat aphid, Rhoalosiphum padi (L.). Two of these compounds, potato proteinase inhibitors I and II, increased mortality among late instar aphids and reduced production of nymphs in feeding trials. Potato carboxypeptidase inhibitor and soybean trypsin inhibitor showed variable effects ranging from significant to nonsignificant abiosis, depending on the species of aphid examined. The lima bean proteinase inhibitor showed little effect on any of the 3 species. Though the effectiveness of the inhibitors varied, it appears that the proteinase inhibitors from potato are potentially effective proteins for the control of these species.

Size of Internal Organs and Forage Quality of Herbivores: Are There Differences between Cycle Phases in Microtus Voles?

We studied the possible role of food quality in cyclic vole populations by using the size of internal organs as an indicator of forage quality. We trapped field (Microtus agrestis) and sibling (M. rossiaemeridionalis) voles during two increase and two decline phases of the 3-yr population cycle in western Finland, recorded total body mass and weighed their pancreas and liver. There were no obvious differences in the relative size of organs related to phase of the cycle, which suggests voles from declining populations do not exhibit pancreatic hypertrophy. These results do not support the hypothesis that proteinase inhibitors in food plants that have adverse effects on metabolic processes of herbivores, and which are induced by grazing, cause regular cycles in small rodent populations.

Differentially regulated inhibitor-sensitive and insensitive protease genes from the phytophagous insect pest, Helicoverpa armigera, are members of complex multigene families

Ingestion of soybean Kunitz trypsin inhibitor (SKTI) by larvae of the phytophagous insect pest Helicoverpa armigera induced production of inhibitor-insensitive protease activity. The induced activity was not due to proteolytic enzymes of different mechanistic classes, but rather to variants of the existing enzymes. Characterization of cDNAs showed that sequences encoding proteins of the serine protease family were abundant in gut tissue of both control and SKTI-fed insects. The majority of serine protease family cDNAs encode enzymes closely homologous to trypsin and chymotrypsin; comparison of these sequences shows variation in amino acid residues within the region which would be in contact with a protein protease inhibitor. More diverged sequences which may not encode active proteases are also present. All the cDNAs examined were found to derive from multigene families; at least 28 different genes are present in the serine protease family. Chronic ingestion of SKTI results in some serine protease-encoding mRNA species increasing in level, whereas others decrease. Chymotrypsin-encoding mRNAs tend to increase in level as a result of SKTI ingestion, but no clear trend is shown by trypsin-encoding mRNAs. It is suggested that multiple, varying protease-encoding genes are an adaptive mechanism for reducing the deleterious effects of plant protease inhibitors.