Plant-derived Antibodies Research Articles

Plant Molecular Farming: An Emerging Opportunity For Biopharmaceuticals

Conventional drug production methods are costly. Now, it has been proved that plants are potentially a new source of pharmaceutical proteins, including vaccines, antibodies, blood substitutes, and other therapeutic entities. Unlike mammalian-derived rDNA drugs, plant-derived antibodies, vaccines, and other proteins are particularly advantageous since they are free of mammalian viral vectors and human pathogens. Plants made therapeutics are cheaper, safer, and can be abundantly produced and easily stored. Recombinant proteins and other metabolites are produced in transgenic plants for industrial or pharmaceutical purposes, which are known as molecular farming. Transgenic plants carry one or more foreign genes transferred through the techniques of transformation. Although initially these were produced only in a limited number of plant species (e.g., tobacco, petunia, tomato, etc.), later these could be produced in any plant species, including both dicots and monocots. Transgenic plants resistant to herbicides, insects, viruses, and a host of abiotic stresses have already been produced. These plants have also been produced for improved nutritional quality and are suitable for food processing. The aim of this review paper is to understand plant molecular farming, the advantages and limitations of the process, and biosafety concerns.

Production and N-glycan engineering of Varlilumab in Nicotiana benthamiana.

N-glycan engineering has dramatically evolved for the development and quality control of recombinant antibodies. Fc region of IgG contains two N-glycans whose galactose terminals on Fc-glycan have been shown to increase the stability of CH2 domain and improve effector functions. Nicotiana benthamiana has become one of the most attractive production systems for therapeutic antibodies. In this study, Varlilumab, a CD27-targeting monoclonal antibody, was transiently produced in fresh leaves of soil-grown and hydroponic-grown N. benthamiana, resulted in the yield of 174 and 618 µg/gram, respectively. However, the IgG produced in wild-type N. benthamiana lacked the terminal galactose residues in its N-glycan. Therefore, N-glycan engineering was applied to fine-tune recombinant antibodies produced in plant platforms. We further co-expressed IgG together with murine β1,4-galactosyltransferase (β1,4-GALT) to modify plant N-glycan with β1,4-linked Gal residue(s) and Arabidopsis thaliana β1,3-galactosylatransferase (β1,3-GALT) to improve galactosylation. The co-expression of IgG with each of GALTs successfully resulted in modification of N-glycan structures on the plant-produced IgG. Notably, IgG co-expressed with murine β1,4-GALT in soil-grown N. benthamiana had 42.5% of N-glycans variants having galactose (Gal) residues at the non-reducing terminus and 55.3% of that in hydroponic-grown N. benthamiana plants. Concomitantly, N-glycan profile analysis of IgG co-expressed with β1,3-GALT demonstrated that there was an increased efficiency of galactosylation and an enhancement in the formation of Lewis a structure in plant-derived antibodies. Taken together, our findings show that the first plant-derived Varlilumab was successfully produced with biantennary β1,4-galactosylated N-glycan structures.

Plant-derived single domain COVID-19 antibodies.

Data show a decrease in the risk of hospitalization and death from COVID-19. To date, global vaccinations for SARS-CoV-2 protections are underway, but additional treatments are urgently needed to prevent and cure infection among naïve and even vaccinated people. Neutralizing monoclonal antibodies are very promising for prophylaxis and therapy of SARS-CoV-2 infections. However, traditional large-scale methods of producing such antibodies are slow, extremely expensive and possess a high risk of contamination with viruses, prions, oncogenic DNA and other pollutants. The present study is aimed at developing an approach of producing monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) against SARS-CoV-2 spike (S) protein in plant systems which offers unique advantages, such as the lack of human and animal pathogens or bacterial toxins, relatively low-cost manufacturing, and ease of production scale-up. We selected a single N-terminal domain functional camelid-derived heavy (H)-chain antibody fragments (VHH, AKA nanobodies) targeted to receptor binding domain of SARS-CoV-2 spike protein and developed methods of their rapid production using transgenic plants and plant cell suspensions. Isolated and purified plant-derived VHH antibodies were compared with mAbs produced in traditional mammalian and bacterial expression systems. It was found that plant generated VHH using the proposed methods of transformation and purification possess the ability to bind to SARS-CoV-2 spike protein comparable to that of monoclonal antibodies derived from bacterial and mammalian cell cultures. The results of the present studies confirm the visibility of producing monoclonal single-chain antibodies with a high ability to bind the targeted COVID-19 spike protein in plant systems within a relatively shorter time span and at a lower cost when compared with traditional methods. Moreover, similar plant biotechnology approaches can be used for producing monoclonal neutralizing antibodies against other types of viruses.

Evidence for the Role of a Second Fc-Binding Receptor in Placental IgG Transfer in Nonhuman Primates.

Transplacental transfer of maternal antibodies provides the fetus and newborn with passive protection against infectious diseases. While the role of the highly conserved neonatal Fc receptor (FcRn) in transfer of IgG in mammals is undisputed, recent reports have suggested that a second receptor may contribute to transport in humans. We report poor transfer efficiency of plant-expressed recombinant HIV-specific antibodies, including engineered variants with high FcRn affinity, following subcutaneous infusion into rhesus macaques close to parturition. Unexpectedly, unlike those derived from mammalian tissue culture, plant-derived antibodies were essentially unable to cross macaque placentas. This defect was associated with poor Fcγ receptor binding and altered Fc glycans and was not recapitulated in mice. These results suggest that maternal-fetal transfer of IgG across the three-layer primate placenta may require a second receptor and suggest a means of providing maternal antibody treatments during pregnancy while avoiding fetal harm. IMPORTANCE This study compared the ability of several human HIV envelope-directed monoclonal antibodies produced in plants with the same antibodies produced in mammalian cells for their ability to cross monkey and mouse placentas. We found that the two types of antibodies have comparable transfer efficiencies in mice, but they are differentially transferred across macaque placentas, consistent with a two-receptor IgG transport model in primates. Importantly, plant-produced monoclonal antibodies have excellent binding characteristics for human FcRn receptors, permitting desirable pharmacokinetics in humans. The lack of efficient transfer across the primate placenta suggests that therapeutic plant-based antibody treatments against autoimmune diseases and cancer could be provided to the mother while avoiding transfer and preventing harm to the fetus.

Application of Plantibodies, the Plant-MADE Vaccines

Various approaches are used to integrate the desired genes encoding the antigen protein for a given illness into the genome of plant tissues in plant-based vaccination technology. Gene transfer by agrobacterium and transformation via a genetically engineered plant virus are two typical approaches for producing efficient vaccinations. Antibodies are an important component of vertebrates' adaptive immune systems, and they may now be made by converting plants with antibody-coding genes from animals and humans. Despite the fact that plants do not produce antibodies naturally, plant-derived antibodies (plantibodies) have been proven to behave similarly to mammalian antibodies. However, as science and technology have progressed, new approaches have been created to improve the efficiency of older technologies including biolistic, electroporation, agroinfiltration, sonication, and polyethylene glycol treatment. Despite the fact that plant-based vaccinations have numerous advantages for the vaccine industry, there are still constraints that limit the rate at which these third-generation vaccines may be successfully manufactured. Despite these limitations, continued attempts are still underway to develop effective vaccines for a variety of human and animal diseases, owing to its enormous potential.

Plant-derived chimeric antibodies inhibit the invasion of human fibroblasts by Toxoplasma gondii.

The parasite Toxoplasma gondii causes an opportunistic infection, that is, particularly severe in immunocompromised patients, infants, and neonates. Current antiparasitic drugs are teratogenic and cause hypersensitivity-based toxic side effects especially during prolonged treatment. Furthermore, the recent emergence of drug-resistant toxoplasmosis has reduced the therapeutic impact of such drugs. In an effort to develop recombinant antibodies as a therapeutic alternative, a panel of affinity-matured, T. gondii tachyzoite-specific single-chain variable fragment (scFv) antibodies was selected by phage display and bioinformatic analysis. Further affinity optimization was attempted by introducing point mutations at hotspots within light chain complementarity-determining region 2. This strategy yielded four mutated scFv sequences and a parental scFv that were used to produce five mouse–human chimeric IgGs in Nicotiana benthamiana plants, with yields of 33–72 mg/kg of plant tissue. Immunological analysis confirmed the specific binding of these plant-derived antibodies to T. gondii tachyzoites, and in vitro efficacy was demonstrated by their ability to inhibit the invasion of human fibroblasts and impair parasite infectivity. These novel recombinant antibodies could therefore be suitable for the development of plant-derived immunotherapeutic interventions against toxoplasmosis.

Plantibodies in human and animal health: a review.

Antibodies are essential part of vertebrates' adaptive immune system; they can now be produced by transforming plants with antibody-coding genes from mammals/humans. Although plants do not naturally make antibodies, the plant-derived antibodies (plantibodies) have been shown to function in the same way as mammalian antibodies. PubMed and Google search engines were used to download relevant publications on plantibodies in medical and veterinary fields; the papers were reviewed and findings qualitatively described. The process of bioproduction of plantibodies offers several advantages over the conventional method of antibody production in mammalian cells with the cost of antibody production in plants being substantially lesser. Contrary to what is possible with animal-derived antibodies, the process of making plantibodies almost exclusively precludes transfer of pathogens to the end product. Additionally, plants not only produce a relatively high yield of antibodies in a comparatively faster time, they also serve as cost-effective bioreactors to produce antibodies of diverse specificities. Plantibodies are safe, cost-effective and offer more advantages over animal-derived antibodies. Methods of producing them are described with a view to inspiring African scientists on the need to embrace and harness this rapidly evolving biotechnology in solving human and animal health challenges on the continent where the climate supports growth of diverse plants.

NMR-based structural validation of therapeutic antibody produced in Nicotiana benthamiana.

We successfully developed a method for metabolic isotope labeling of recombinant proteins produced in transgenic tobacco. This enabled assessment of structural integrity of plant-derived therapeutic antibodies by NMR analysis. A variety of expression vehicles have been developed for the production of promising biologics, including plants, fungi, bacteria, insects, and mammals. Glycoprotein biologics often experience altered folding and post-translational modifications that are typified by variant glycosylation patterns. These differences can dramatically affect their efficacy, as exemplified by therapeutic antibodies. However, it is generally difficult to validate the structural integrity of biologics produced using different expression vehicles. To address this issue, we have developed and applied a stable-isotope-assisted nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy method for the conformational characterization of recombinant antibodies produced in plants. Nicotiana benthamiana used as a vehicle for the production of recombinant immunoglobulin G (IgG) was grown in a (15)N-enriched plant growth medium. The Fc fragment derived from the (15)N-labeled antibody thus prepared was subjected to heteronuclear two-dimensional (2D) NMR measurements. This approach enabled assessment of the structural integrity of the plant-derived therapeutic antibodies by comparing their NMR spectral properties with those of an authentic IgG-Fc derived from mammalian cells.

How can plant genetic engineering contribute to cost-effective fish vaccine development for promoting sustainable aquaculture?

Aquaculture, the fastest growing food-producing sector, now accounts for nearly 50 % of the world’s food fish (FAO in The state of world fisheries and aquaculture. FAO, Rome, 2010). The global aquaculture production of food fish reached 62.7 million tonnes in 2011 and is continuously increasing with an estimated production of food fish of 66.5 million tonnes in 2012 (a 9.4 % increase in 1 year, FAO, www.fao.org/fishery/topic/16140). Aquaculture is not only important for sustainable protein-based food fish production but also for the aquaculture industry and economy worldwide. Disease prevention is the key issue to maintain a sustainable development of aquaculture. Widespread use of antibiotics in aquaculture has led to the development of antibiotic-resistant bacteria and the accumulation of antibiotics in the environment, resulting in water and soil pollution. Thus, vaccination is the most effective and environmentally-friendly approach to combat diseases in aquaculture to manage fish health. Furthermore, when compared to >760 vaccines against human diseases, there are only about 30 fish vaccines commercially available, suggesting the urgent need for development and cost-effective production of fish vaccines for managing fish health, especially in the fast growing fish farming in Asia where profit is minimal and therefore given high priority. Plant genetic engineering has made significant contributions to production of biotech crops for food, feed, valuable recombinant proteins etc. in the past three decades. The use of plants for vaccine production offers several advantages such as low cost, safety and easy scaling up. To date a large number of plant-derived vaccines, antibodies and therapeutic proteins have been produced for human health, of which a few have been made commercially available. However, the development of animal vaccines in plants, especially fish vaccines by genetic engineering, has not yet been addressed. Therefore, there is a need to exploit plant biotechnology for cost effective fish vaccine development in plants, in particular, edible crops for oral fish vaccines. This review provides insight into (1) the current status of fish vaccine and vaccination in aquaculture, (2) plant biotechnology and edible crops for fish vaccines for oral administration, (3) regulatory constraints and (4) conclusions and future perspectives.

Rapid High-Level Production of Functional HIV Broadly Neutralizing Monoclonal Antibodies in Transient Plant Expression Systems

Passive immunotherapy using anti-HIV broadly neutralizing monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) has shown promise as an HIV treatment, reducing mother-to-child-transmission (MTCT) of simian/human immunodeficiency virus (SHIV) in non-human primates and decreasing viral rebound in patients who ceased receiving anti-viral drugs. In addition, a cocktail of potent mAbs may be useful as mucosal microbicides and provide an effective therapy for post-exposure prophylaxis. However, even highly neutralizing HIV mAbs used today may lose their effectiveness if resistance occurs, requiring the rapid production of new or engineered mAbs on an ongoing basis in order to counteract the viral resistance or the spread of a certain HIV-1 clade in a particular region or patient. Plant-based expression systems are fast, inexpensive and scalable and are becoming increasingly popular for the production of proteins and monoclonal antibodies. In the present study, Agrobacterium-mediated transient transfection of plants, utilizing two species of Nicotiana, have been tested to rapidly produce high levels of an HIV 89.6PΔ140env and several well-studied anti-HIV neutralizing monoclonal antibodies (b12, 2G12, 2F5, 4E10, m43, VRC01) or a single chain antibody construct (m9), for evaluation in cell-based viral inhibition assays. The protein-A purified plant-derived antibodies were intact, efficiently bound HIV envelope, and were equivalent to, or in one case better than, their counterparts produced in mammalian CHO or HEK-293 cells in both neutralization and antibody dependent viral inhibition assays. These data indicate that transient plant-based transient expression systems are very adaptable and could rapidly generate high levels of newly identified functional recombinant HIV neutralizing antibodies when required. In addition, they warrant detailed cost-benefit analysis of prolonged incubation in plants to further increase mAb production.

Purification of the therapeutic antibody trastuzumab from genetically modified plants using safflower Protein A-oleosin oilbody technology

Production of therapeutic monoclonal antibodies using genetically modified plants may provide low cost, high scalability and product safety; however, antibody purification from plants presents a challenge due to the large quantities of biomass that need to be processed. Protein A column chromatography is widely used in the pharmaceutical industry for antibody purification, but its application is limited by cost, scalability and column fouling problems when purifying plant-derived antibodies. Protein A-oleosin oilbodies (Protein A-OB), expressed in transgenic safflower seeds, are relatively inexpensive to produce and provide a new approach for the capture of monoclonal antibodies from plants. When Protein A-OB is mixed with crude extracts from plants engineered to express therapeutic antibodies, the Protein A-OB captures the antibody in the oilbody phase while impurities remain in the aqueous phase. This is followed by repeated partitioning of oilbody phase against an aqueous phase via centrifugation to remove impurities before purified antibody is eluted from the oilbodies. We have developed this purification process to recover trastuzumab, an anti-HER2 monoclonal antibody used for therapy against specific breast-cancers that over express HER2 (human epidermal growth factor receptor 2), from transiently infected Nicotiana benthamiana. Protein A-OB overcomes the fouling problem associated with traditional Protein A chromatography, allowing for the development of an inexpensive, scalable and novel high-resolution method for the capture of antibodies based on simple mixing and phase separation.

Edible Vaccine: A New Platform for the Development of Malaria Vaccine

The plasmodium vivax is the most prevalent malaria parasite. The world essentially needs a malaria vaccine to alleviate the human suffering associated with the parasitic disease that kills more than one million people annually. The use of plants for the expression of the proteins of disease-causing vehicle in transgenic plants has been increasingly used in the development of experimental vaccines, largely oriented to the improvement of edible vaccines. Currently, through modern biotechnology, there has been a revival in obtaining a new edible vaccine against the malaria parasite from plant sources. Through genetic alteration, it is now recognized that plants are potentially a new source of recombinant proteins including vaccines, antibodies, blood substitutes, and other therapeutic entities. Plant-derived antibodies and other proteins are mostly valuable since they are free of mammalian viral vectors and human pathogens. Although significant progress has been achieved in the research for edible vaccine in Plasmodium falciparum, limited progress has been made in the Plasmodium vivax component that might be eligible for edible vaccine development. We describe the overall strategy recommended by plants, which include high biomass production and low cost of cultivation, relatively fast "gene to protein" time, low capital and operating costs, outstanding scalability, eukaryotic posttranslational modifications, and a relatively high protein yield.

Overview of Plant-Derived Vaccine Antigens: Dengue Virus

This review highlights the advantages and current status of plant-derived vaccine development with special reference to the dengue virus. There are numerous problems involved in dengue vaccine development, and there is no vaccine against all four dengue serotypes. Dengue vaccine development using traditional approaches has not been satisfactory in terms of inducing neutralizing antibodies. Recently, these issues were addressed by showing a very good response to inducing neutralizing antibodies by plant-derived dengue vaccine antigens. This indicates the feasibility of using plant-derived vaccine antigens as a low-cost method to combat dengue and other infectious diseases. The application of new methods and strategies such as dendritic cell targeting in cancer therapy, severe acute respiratory syndrome, tuberculosis, human immune deficiency virus, and malaria might play an important role. These new methods are more efficient than traditional protocols. It is expected that in the near future, plant-derived vaccine antigens or antibodies will play an important role in the control of human infectious diseases.

Purification of Plant-Derived Antibodies through Direct Immobilization of Affinity Ligands on Cellulose

Plants possess enormous potential as factories for the large scale production of therapeutic reagents such as recombinant proteins and antibodies. A major factor limiting commercial advances of plant-derived pharmaceuticals is the cost and inefficiency of purification. As a model system, we have developed a simple yet robust method for immobilizing affinity capture ligands onto solid supports by interfacing the secreted expression and coupling of a chimeric fusion protein in Pichia pastoris to microcrystalline cellulose in a single step. The fusion protein, which consisted of antibody-binding proteins L and G fused to a cellulose-binding domain (LG-CBD), was tethered directly onto cellulose resins added to P. pastoris cultures and subsequently used for antibody purification. Both the antibody-binding protein L and protein G domains were functional, as demonstrated by the ability of cellulose-immobilized LG-CBD to purify both a scFv antibody fragment from yeast and a human IgG1 monoclonal antibody from transgenic tobacco. Furthermore, combining two P. pastoris strains expressing LG-CBD and scFv with CP-102 cellulose in a single culture allowed for easy recovery of biologically active scFv. Direct immobilization of affinity purification ligands, such as LG-CBD, onto inexpensive support matrices such as cellulose is an effective method for the generation of functional, single-use antibody purification reagents. Straightforward preparation of purification reagents will help make antibody purification from genetically modified crop plants feasible and address one of the major bottlenecks facing commercialization of plant-derived pharmaceuticals.

Production of an anti-mouse MHC class II monoclonal antibody with biological activity in transgenic tobacco

To produce a monoclonal antibody specific to a mouse major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II protein, we synthesized the complementary DNAs for the heavy and light chains of a monoclonal antibody by PCR amplification. These cDNAs were then introduced separately into tobacco plant cells. After performing Northern blot analysis to confirm the expression of each of the chain genes in the transformed plants, we constructed transgenic plants expressing both the heavy and light chains by sexual crossing. The expression of the heavy and light chain genes in the sexually crossed plant was confirmed by Northern and Western blot analyses, respectively. Fluorocytometric analysis showed that the plant-derived antibodies, which we purified using a protein G affinity column, bound specifically to target cells that expressed the cognate MHC class II molecules on their cell surfaces. The results of this study demonstrate that a monoclonal antibody against mouse MHC class II proteins can be expressed in transgenic plants. They also show the specific binding activity of plant-derived antibodies to cognate antigens.

Virus-like particles production in green plants

Viruses-like particles (VLPs), assembled from capsid structural subunits of several different viruses, have found a number of biomedical applications such as vaccines and novel delivery systems for nucleic acids and small molecules. Production of recombinant proteins in different plant systems has been intensely investigated and improved upon in the last two decades. Plant-derived antibodies, vaccines, and microbicides have received great attention and shown immense promise. In the case of mucosal vaccines, orally delivered plant-produced VLPs require minimal processing of the plant tissue, thus offering an inexpensive and safe alternative to more conventional live attenuated and killed virus vaccines. For other applications which require higher level of purification, recent progress in expression levels using plant viral vectors have shown that plants can compete with traditional fermentation systems. In this review, the different methods used in the production of VLPs in green plants are described. Specific examples of expression, assembly, and immunogenicity of several plant-derived VLPs are presented.

Standardization and validation of an alkaline phosphatase-linked immunoassay to quantify a plant-derived antibody directed against the hepatitis B virus surface antigen

Immunopurification is one of the most effective chromatography steps to purify the hepatitis B surface antigen, which have successfully been used as an active pharmaceutical ingredient of hepatitis B vaccines. Plant-derived antibodies could be an appropriated ligand for such purposes because plants are the most cost-effective production systems and have the additional advantage that plant viruses cannot infect humans. In this work, a polyclonal antibody alkaline phosphatase-linked immunoassay was standardized and validated to quantify a plant-derived antibody directed against the HBsAg. The validation of an immunoassay to quantify plantibodies is a relatively complex task due to the complexity of the plant extract, the low level of expression of this molecule, and the potential interferences of endogenous peroxidases contributed by plants. These results allow estimating the plant-derived antibody concentration up to 3.81 ng/mL with high specificity, precision, and repeatability. The working range of the standard curve was between 3.81 and 60 ng/mL, and the intra- and inter-variation coefficients were between 10% and 20% in a production process’s sample dependent way. This enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay is considered valuable to improve the design of the purification process and also to obtain a better estimation of the antibody expression level and process’s recovery.

International symposium on: plant-derived vaccines and antibodies: potential and limitations

International symposium on: plant-derived vaccines and antibodies: potential and limitations