Plant-based Milk Alternatives Research Articles

Plant-based milk alternatives: assessing the occurrence of chemical and microbiological contaminants in soy, oat, rice and almond beverages from Italian market.

Plant-based milk alternatives: assessing the occurrence of chemical and microbiological contaminants in soy, oat, rice and almond beverages from Italian market.

Alkyl polyglycoside-assisted separation followed by smartphone-based digital image colorimetry for on-site determination of total phenolic content in plant-based milk alternatives

Alkyl polyglycoside-assisted separation followed by smartphone-based digital image colorimetry for on-site determination of total phenolic content in plant-based milk alternatives

Carbohydrate composition of cow's milk and plant-based milk alternatives

The prevalence of lactose intolerance is one of the factors driving consumers toward plant-based milk alternatives (PBMA). This study aimed to analyze the carbohydrate profile of cows' milk (regular and lactose-free from both pasteurized and UHT milks; n = 80) and PBMA (n = 60) by HPLC. The study revealed that there was no significant difference in the energy content and total carbohydrate content between regular milk and lactose-free milk. Although milk and PBMA are entirely different food matrices, some PBMA types, as soya and coconut, may have energy contents and total carbohydrate contents comparable to those of milk. Furthermore, the variability observed in total carbohydrate content, as well as in carbohydrate profile, both between PBMA types and within samples of the same type, arises not only from variations in raw materials but also from the number of dilutions of the vegetable extract and the addition of different types and levels of carbohydrates, such as sucrose, fructose, or sorbitol, during PBMA manufacture. Although, milk presents a regular carbohydrate composition, differing solely between presentations (regular/lactose-free), the PBMA differs significantly between types and among the same type, not being for that reason regarded as a milk substitute.

US household demand system analysis for dairy milk products and plant‐based milk alternatives

AbstractUsing the QUAIDS model, we analyze interrelationships among dairy milk and plant‐based milk alternatives (PBMA) for US households from 2018 to 2020 using NielsenIQ. We adopt the Shonkwiler–Yen methodology to account for censored observations. PBMA demand is inelastic, while milk products show elastic demand. PBMA substitutes for traditional white milk and organic milk. Traditional flavored milk and PBMA as well as lactose‐free and organic milk are complements. PBMA and lactose‐free milk are independent goods. Demographic factors like income, household size, and education significantly affect budget share, alongside women, infants, and children participation and the pandemic.

Effect of pilot-scale high-temperature short-time processing on the retention of key micronutrients in a fortified almond-based beverage: implications for fortification of plant-based milk alternatives.

The effect of thermal processing treatments on key micronutrients in fortified almond-based beverages has not been well characterized. An almond-based beverage was produced in a pilot plant, fortified with vitamin A palmitate, vitamin D2, riboflavin (vitamin B2), calcium carbonate, and zinc gluconate, and was processed using various high-temperature short-time (HTST) pasteurization treatments. Naturally present micronutrients in the base ingredients included several B vitamins (vitamin B1 [thiamin], total vitamin B3 [sum of nicotinamide and nicotinic acid], and total vitamin B6 [sum of pyridoxal, pyridoxamine, and pyridoxine]) and minerals (magnesium, phosphorus, and potassium). The prepared almond-based beverage was homogenized and thermally processed using HTST pasteurization with a temperature range from ~94 to 116°C for a constant time of 30 s. The samples were analyzed for vitamin A palmitate, vitamin D2, target B vitamins (thiamin, riboflavin, total vitamin B3, and total vitamin B6), and minerals (magnesium, phosphorus, potassium, calcium, and zinc). The results showed that amounts of vitamin A, vitamin D2, riboflavin, and total vitamin B6 did not significantly (p > 0.05) change after the HTST treatments, whereas thiamin significantly (p < 0.05) decreased by 17.9% after HTST treatment at 116°C. Interestingly, total vitamin B3 content significantly (p < 0.05) increased by 35.2% after HTST treatment at 116°C. There was no effect of processing on the minerals that were monitored. The results from this study indicate that the majority of key micronutrients assessed in this study are stable during HTST processing of an almond-based beverage and that fortification of plant-based milk alternatives may be a viable process to enhance the micronutrient content consumers receive from these products.

Towards more sustainable, nutritious, and affordable plant‐based milk alternatives: A critical review

AbstractThe consumer market has seen a surge in various types of plant‐based milk alternatives (PBMAs), driven by factors such as sustainability, ethics, and the availability of diverse options. However, the global adoption of PBMAs is still hindered by potential nutritional concerns and cost‐ineffectiveness. It is therefore paramount to understand the status and challenges of these alternatives, encompassing production, stabilization strategies, nutrition and health, digestion, and environmental impacts. This review provides a comprehensive examination of these aspects. We begin by scrutinizing the production processes and formulation strategies of PBMAs, followed by an exploration of fundamental stabilization aspects, including homogenization, emulsification, thickening, and quantitative measurements of stabilization. Additionally, we discuss their nutrition facts and potential health benefits, as well as potential differences in the digestion of nutrients from PBMAs. Importantly, their challenges and future directions are discussed individually, highlighting the need for a fundamental understanding and effective food technologies to develop sustainable, nutritious, tasty, and affordable PBMAs. For example, several critical aspects involve maximizing the use of plant materials (e.g., proteins, fibers, and bioactive compounds) and using reliable and unified life cycle analyses to guide the development. This review offers valuable insights for researchers, food technologists, and consumers seeking to navigate and develop the landscape of PBMAs effectively.

Factors Influencing Consumption of Animal-Based Dairy and Plant-Based Milk Alternatives in Australia

In the transition to more environmentally sustainable food systems, the production and consumption of resource-intensive animal-based dairy foods (ABD) remains a talking point. Given the power of consumer choice in transforming food systems, understanding consumer priorities surrounding ABD consumption and their plant-based counterparts is fundamental. Using data from 3271 unique survey respondents, the objectives of this study were to examine the consumption frequencies of ABD and plant-based milk (PBM) in Australia over time (2019–2022) and determine the psychosocial and sociodemographic factors associated with distinct consumer segments. Multivariate analysis identified sociodemographic and food choice factors associated with three consumer segments: ‘exclusive PBM consumers’, ‘exclusive ABD consumers’, and ‘mixed consumers’ (consumers of both product types). Despite the growing availability of plant-based milk alternatives, exclusive PBM consumption remains relatively uncommon compared to mixed plant and animal dairy consumption. ‘Exclusive ABD consumers’ had a higher probability of being older and less likely to prioritise health and nutrition than ‘mixed consumers’. ‘Exclusive PBM consumers’ were more likely to prioritise food tolerance and restrictions and less likely to prioritise product taste than ‘exclusive ABD consumers’. We report sociodemographic and motivational factors influencing animal-based dairy and plant-based milk choices. The outcomes are of interest to sustainable food systems development stakeholders, with potential applications in the public health and commercial food promotion sectors.

Growth, persistence and toxin production of pathogenic bacteria in plant-based drinking milk alternatives.

The present study investigated the microbiological safety of the increasingly popular plant-based milk alternatives. No (10/27) or only very low microbial counts (17/27) were detected in the tested products. These were mainly identified as spore formers via MALDI-ToF-MS. Three products contained Bacillus cereus group isolates, which were able to form considerable amounts of enterotoxins and exhibited cytotoxicity towards CaCo-2 cells. Preliminary tests showed good growth of B. cereus, Listeria monocytogenes, and Salmonella enterica in all tested products (maximum bacterial counts: 5×1012 cfu/mL). These experiments also revealed strain-, time-, and temperature-, but especially product-specific enterotoxin production of B. cereus. In propagation and persistence tests according to DIN EN ISO 20976-1:2019-09, rapid bacterial proliferation was also detected in all products. B. cereus generally showed lower bacterial counts (106-107 cfu/mL) compared to L. monocytogenes and S. enterica (108-109 cfu/mL), but was detectable in a larger number of products over the test period of 6 weeks. pH values decreased (20/27) over time and visual and/or olfactory alterations (24/27) were observed. The present study provides information on the occurrence, growth and persistence of pathogenic bacteria in plant-based drinking milk alternatives. It also points out that the accompanying changes in pH, odor, and appearance are not necessarily recognizable to the consumer. PRACTICAL APPLICATION: The present study contributes to the understanding of the microbial risk related to plant-based drinking milk alternatives. It is crucial that the manufacturer ensures that particularly spore formers have been effectively eliminated from the products. Among them, especially toxin-producing bacteria can pose a risk to the consumer, as these products promote proliferation and persistence of the bacteria.

Bioactive (Poly)phenol Concentrations in Plant-Based Milk Alternatives in the US Market.

Plant-based milk alternatives (PBMAs) are increasingly consumed as a dairy alternative [Olson, S. Milk and Non-Dairy Milk - US - 2021, 2021.]. Plant foods are rich sources of (poly)phenols, but concentrations of these bioactive phytochemicals in processed PBMAs are not well documented. We procured twenty-seven PBMA products of 6 types (almond, coconut, oat, pea, rice, and soy) for (poly)phenol analysis. Samples were analyzed via ultra high-performance liquid chromatography-diode array with mass spectrometry. The (poly)phenol content of PBMAs varies and is dependent on plant source, brand, and added flavorings. Soy milk had the highest concentration and rice milk had the lowest (91.9 ± 2.7 and 0.9 ± 0.2 mean mg ± SD/cup serving, respectively). Almond milk, the most widely consumed PBMA, averaged 12.1 ± 8.2 mg/cup serving, but the majority of (poly)phenols are derived from added flavorings. PBMAs contain a wide range of potentially bioactive (poly)phenols and may contribute significantly to overall dietary (poly)phenol intake with the potential to impact health outcomes.

Lipid Profile of Plant-Based Milk Alternatives (PBMAs) and Cow's Milk: A Comparison.

Some consumers are replacing cow's milk with plant-based milk alternatives (PBMAs). The present study aimed to characterize the lipid profiles of cow's milk (n = 60) and PBMA types (soya, oat, rice, almond, coconut, and hazelnut; n = 10 per type). Significant differences were found in the fatty acid (FA) profiles of PBMAs and milk, particularly in FA diversity (15 FAs in PBMAs vs 54 FAs in milk) and the proportion of prime FA groups. The FA profile of coconut was dominated by saturated FAs (SFA), whereas monounsaturated FAs (MUFA) or polyunsaturated FAs (PUFA) were dominant in the remaining PBMA types. Cholesterol was not detected in any PBMA type. The FA profile of milk FAs was dominated by SFA; however, different individual SFA have varying health outcomes. Additionally, milk contains some FA groups with health-promoting properties, such as methyl-branched-chain FAs (BCFA) and conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), both of which are absent in PBMAs.

A comparison of the quality of UHT milk and its plant-based analogs

The aim of this study was to compare selected physical (density) and physicochemical (color, pH, titratable acidity) properties and the fatty acid profile of dairy UHT milk and its plant-based analogs, i.e., almond, soy, rice, oat, and coconut beverages. Ten products of each type were analyzed in each group. UHT milk was characterized by higher values of color lightness (L*) and titratable acidity than all plant-based milk alternatives, higher yellowness (b*) than rice drink, higher density than almond drink, and higher pH than rice and coconut drinks. In comparison with UHT milk, all plant-based beverages were characterized by higher redness (a*), soy drink was characterized by higher values of b* and chroma (C*), and almond and soy drinks had higher pH values. In the group of non-dairy beverages, the values of b* and C* were highest in soy drink, and the value of a* was highest in almond drink. Almond drink had the highest pH value, and soy and coconut drinks had the highest titratable acidity. Rice drink had higher density than oat, soy and almond drinks. The indicators characterizing the nutritional value of fat were considerably lower in coconut drink and dairy milk than in the remaining products. The values of UFA/SFA, MUFA/SFA, and DFA/OFA ratios and the indicator of nutritional value were highest in rice drink. The PUFA/SFA ratio and the total content of EFAs were highest in soy drink, and the n-6/n-3 PUFA ratio was highest in almond drink.

Integration of oleaginous yeast-produced lipids into plant-based milk alternatives

In this study, the production of a novel oleaginous yeast-based milk powder alternative is presented. Three formulations, comprising yeast oil, oleaginous yeast cell lysate, and whole cells, were analyzed and compared to a reference formulation, covering the entire process from fermentation to powder analysis. The whole cell formulation exhibited highest encapsulating efficiency and low surface lipid content, indicating improved stability. Moreover, the formulation with cell lysate and whole cells showed larger oil droplet sizes in emulsions and spray-dried particles, and higher viscosity in rheological studies compared to the reference formulation. Electron microscopic images revealed morphological differences in spray-dried particles, emphasizing the impact of yeast oil integration. Concluding, formulations using oleaginous yeast present a complex system with diverse components. While this research pioneers oleaginous yeast integration into milk alternatives, further experiments are essential for a comprehensive understanding of observed effects and unlocking the full potential of these innovative and novel formulations.

Dairy milk: There are alternatives but no equivalents.

Dairy milk is a core food in many food-based guides to healthy eating. However, plant-based milk alternatives are becoming increasingly available as substitutes. While these products serve a subset of the population unable or unwilling to consume milk, plant-based milk alternatives can be perceived by consumers as direct equivalents, or even more healthful alternatives to dairy milk. This commentary addresses the significant differences in nutrient content that may have implications for the intake of key nutrients in the case of direct substitutions. Furthermore, while there is a significant body of knowledge demonstrating the significant health benefits associated with dairy milk consumption and a small number of potentially negative associations, there is a paucity of data on the health benefits of plant-based milk alternatives directly. A "health halo" may exist based on matching individual nutrients through fortification, lower energy levels, and the health properties of the unprocessed raw characterizing ingredients of plant-based milk alternatives. This may mislead consumers regarding healthfulness. Similarly, environmental attributes based on volumes of production, without considering contribution to nutrients, may also skew consumer perception. Positioning of plant-based milk alternatives in food-based dietary guidelines, marketing, and personal recommendations should acknowledge the differences in nutritional, bioactive, and health properties between plant-based milk alternatives and dairy milk to ensure appropriate adaptations are made to account for shortfalls in nutrients.

Milking the Alternatives: Understanding Coffee Consumers' Preferences for Non-Dairy Milk.

Consumer interest in plant-based milk alternatives is growing, despite extra charges in coffeehouses. While much research exists on non-dairy alternatives, plant-based milks in coffee drinks remain understudied. This study examines consumer preferences and behaviors regarding milk alternatives in coffee, using the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) and the Behavior Change Wheel (BCW). A survey of 200 participants from 19 countries explored demographics, coffee habits, attitudes towards non-dairy milk charges, and marketing awareness. Market insights showed taste as the main reason for coffee choice, with a preference for cow's milk and local cafes for quality. Many opposed the extra charges for non-dairy options, citing lactose intolerance or allergies, especially among Gen Z and Millennials. Regional variations included stronger opposition in the UK and Germany compared to the UAE and USA. The marketing for non-dairy milk was less memorable than general coffee advertisements. Regression analysis confirmed that viewing non-dairy milk as a dietary staple increased consumption, aligning with the TDF's "Beliefs about Consequences" domain. Finally, within the BCW framework, the intervention strategies centered on training and coercion were discussed. Implementing these approaches could encourage the wider adoption of non-dairy milk options in coffee shops, fostering inclusivity, health awareness, and supporting environmental sustainability efforts.

Nutritional, anti-nutrient, stability and organoleptic characterisation of plant-based milk alternatives derived from adzuki bean (Vigna angularis) and mung bean (Vigna radiata)

Adzuki bean (Vigna angularis) and mung bean (Vigna radiata) were investigated for their potential as plant-based milk alternatives. Their nutritional, anti-nutrient, stability, and organoleptic characteristics were compared with commercial soymilk and bovine milk. Results showed that both adzuki bean milk (ABM) and mung bean milk (MBM) demonstrated lower protein (ABM: 2.19 ± 0.10 %; MBM: 1.63 ± 0.05 %) and carbohydrate contents compared to soymilk. Additionally, they exhibited magnesium contents similar to bovine milk and iron levels comparable to both soymilk and bovine milk. While total amino acid content was lower in ABM and MBM, their phytic acid and purine contents were significantly lower than in soymilk. Fewer volatile compounds associated with beany flavours were also present in ABM and MBM, and ABM emerged as a palatable choice from the sensory analysis. These findings suggest that ABM and MBM have the potential to offer diverse and palatable plant-based milk options for consumers.

Assessing the Nutrient Content of Plant-Based Milk Alternative Products Available in the United States

BackgroundConsumption of plant-based milk alternatives is increasing. Current dietary guidance primarily relies on dairy milk as a source of key nutrients of public health concern including calcium and vitamin D. ObjectiveTo compare the nutritional content of plant-based milk alternatives between categories (eg, soy, almond, and oat) and with dairy milk. DesignThis study presents an evaluation of the nutritional content of 219 plant-based milk alternatives from 21 brands available in the US marketplace using data from the University of Minnesota Nutrition Coordinating Center’s database. Main outcome measuresNutrients of focus include those identified as nutrients of public health concern in the Dietary Guidelines for Americans or used by the US Department of Agriculture as criteria for determining whether a plant-based milk is a suitable substitute for dairy milk. Statistical analyses performedMost data are presented as percent Daily Values. Nutrients and food components were compared using means, medians, IQRs, and ranges. Statistical tests for significance were not used to evaluate between category differences because the plant-based milk alternatives included are a full census of the products from 21 brands available in the marketplace. Because data are a census, differences can be understood to be true differences. ResultsFortified soy-based products most closely mimic the nutrient content of dairy milk. High variability was present in all the nutrients and food components. Plant-based milk alternatives were generally lower in protein and saturated fatty acids than dairy milk, with high variability in added sugars content. Approximately 70% were fortified with both calcium and vitamin D. ConclusionsThese results indicate that most plant-based milk alternative products are not nutritionally equivalent to dairy milk, and there is high nutritional variability between and within product types. These findings highlight the importance of communicating the nutritional differences between plant-based milk alternatives and dairy milk to consumers.

Characterisation of Pea Milk Analogues Using Different Production Techniques.

Among legumes, peas are characterised by their high protein content, low glycaemic index and exceptional versatility. However, their potential as a food is often compromised by their undesirable off-flavour and taste. Hence, this study focuses on minimising off-flavours through simple pretreatments with the aim of improving the potential for the production of pea milk analogues. Pea milk analogues are a burgeoning type of plant-based milk alternatives in the growing plant-based market. Pea seeds were subjected to different pretreatments: (i) dry milling, (ii) blanching followed by soaking in alkaline solution and subsequent dehulling and (iii) vacuum. Typical physicochemical properties such as pH, viscosity, colour, titratable acidity and yield were measured to obtain a brief overview of the products. Consumer acceptance test, descriptive sensory analysis, gas chromatography-mass spectrometry and gas chromatography-olfactometry were used to map the complete sensory profile and appeal of the pea milk substitutes. The L* values of the pea milk analogues were significantly lower than those of cow's milk, while a*, b*, viscosity and pH were similar. In the descriptive sensory analysis, sweet, astringent, pea-like, cooked, hay-like, boiled corn and green notes received relatively higher scores. The vacuum-treated pea milk analogues received higher scores for flavour and overall acceptability in the consumer acceptance test. The pretreatments resulted in significant changes in the volatile profiles of the pea milk analogues. Some volatiles typically associated with off-flavour, such as hexanal, were found in higher concentrations in blanched pea milk analogues. Among the applied pretreatments, vacuum proved to be the most effective method to reduce the content of volatile off-flavour compounds. This study stands out as a rare investigation to characterise pea milk analogues and to evaluate the impact of simple pretreatments on the improvement of their sensory properties. The results of this study could contribute to the development of milk alternatives that offer both high nutritional value and strong appeal to consumers.

Verwendung pflanzenbasierter Milchalternativen bei Kindern

Verwendung pflanzenbasierter Milchalternativen bei Kindern

Effect of pulsed electric field processing on microbial and enzyme inactivation in blended plant-based milk alternatives: A case study on a microbial challenge test for a non-presterilized oat-based beverage enriched with pea protein

Microbial and enzyme inactivation by pulsed electric field (PEF) treatment was assessed in a blended plant-based milk alternative (PBMA) containing oats and pea protein without the application of presterilization. This was conducted to investigate a novel approach that permits PEF process validation for PBMA containing heat-labile components (protein and starch). Continuous PEF processing at moderate field strengths (9–10 kV/cm) combined with mild preheating (30–45 °C) for 25 s was applied over a range of specific energy inputs (77–245 kJ/L). Selective plating permitted bacterial enumeration of inoculated surrogate organisms, despite the presence of natural microbial contaminants in the non-presterilized product. A minimum 5-log reduction of inoculated surrogates Escherichia coli and Listeria innocua alongside native microbiota was identified after preheating to 35–45 °C followed by PEF at 192–215 kJ/L. α-amylase activity was reduced by up to 89% during a similar PEF treatment (205 kJ/L, 40 °C preheating). Overall, continuous PEF combined with mild preheating temperature was shown to achieve microbial inactivation in the pea protein enriched PBMA in compliance with current food safety regulations. Industrial relevancePresterilization is typically applied prior to conducting microbial challenge testing on food products to validate novel pasteurization treatments according to current regulatory requirements that a minimum 5-log reduction of relevant inoculated food pathogens must be achievable. However, for a variety of blended PBMA containing heat-labile proteins, presterilization is not advisable as the occurrence of irreversible changes in the product quality linked to protein coagulation and phase separation will affect the inactivation efficacy during subsequent microbial challenge testing. Hence, an alternative approach is presented utilizing a non-presterilized PBMA and thorough microbiological analysis, combining non-selective and selective plating techniques. This allows an identification of PEF treatment parameter with a minimum 5-log reduction of inoculated surrogate organisms alongside naturally present microbial contaminants. This may serve as a valuable guideline for stakeholders in the food industry when addressing the efficacy of novel preservation treatments such as PEF in PBMA products with similar heat-induced product stability challenges.

Leave the Milk for the Calf and Spread the Word: Exploring Factors Determining US Consumers’ Willingness to Try Plant-Based Milk Alternatives and Their Word-of-Mouth Sharing about Plant-Based Milk Alternatives

Plant-based milk alternatives are important beverages in US consumer markets. Sustainability, consumer awareness, lifestyle changes, and other value-based reasons are why these beverages are increasing in popularity. The present study is focused on plant-based milk alternatives. It builds on an online consumer survey that explores the factors explaining US consumers’ willingness to try plant-based milk alternatives and their word-of-mouth sharing about these beverages. Animal welfare concerns, environmental concerns, health consciousness, and dairy preferences are the factors under investigation. Results show that animal welfare, dairy preference, environmental concerns, and plant-based milk enthusiasm are significant predictors for willingness to try plant-based milk alternatives. Dairy preferences, environmental concerns, and plant-based milk enthusiasm predict the word-of-mouth factors. Overall, plant-based milk enthusiasm is the strongest driver for both consumer behaviours. Best practice recommendations address marketers in the US food and beverage industry and provide suggestions on how to target different consumer groups based on nutritional preferences and needs and on value-based product characteristics.