Bioactive peptides have great pharmaceutical potential as nutraceuticals, diagnostics, and therapeutic drugs in several clinical areas. Thus, the search for novel lead peptides with a biological function has attracted renewed interest. Crude peptide material (i.e., ∼70% purity) of INSL6[151–161] (NH2-FRSLFWGNHSQ-COOH) was found to trigger a contractile response in guinea pig ileum longitudinal smooth muscle preparations using tissue–organ baths. However, the purified peptide (i.e., ⩾95% purity) had no effect on this model. Further investigation with crude materials from other suppliers, with purities ranging between 50% and 80%, indicated that the crude products gave a false-positive functional tissue–organ bath conclusion. These observations question the functionality conclusions when using crude-purity peptide materials; during the initial research or discovery phase, peptide quality is generally neglected, possibly leading to misinterpretation of biological results due to by-products from peptide synthesis and, thus, wrong fail/pass decisions. Therefore, we strongly recommend appropriate quality control testing before using any peptides for initial biomedical research or discovery purposes.