Marine biogeochemical cycles are built on interactions between surface ocean microbes, particularly those connecting phytoplankton primary producers to heterotrophic bacteria. Details of these associations are not well understood, especially in the case of direct influences of bacteria on phytoplankton physiology. Here we catalogue how the presence of three marine bacteria (Ruegeria pomeroyi DSS-3, Stenotrophomonas sp. SKA14 and Polaribacter dokdonensis MED152) individually and uniquely impact gene expression of the picoeukaryotic alga Micromonas commoda RCC 299. We find a dramatic transcriptomic remodelling by M. commoda after 8 h in co-culture, followed by an increase in cell numbers by 56 h compared with the axenic cultures. Some aspects of the algal transcriptomic response are conserved across all three bacterial co-cultures, including an unexpected reduction in relative expression of photosynthesis and carbon fixation pathways. Expression differences restricted to a single bacterium are also observed, with the Flavobacteriia P. dokdonensis uniquely eliciting changes in relative expression of algal genes involved in biotin biosynthesis and the acquisition and assimilation of nitrogen. This study reveals that M. commoda has rapid and extensive responses to heterotrophic bacteria in ways that are generalizable, as well as in a taxon specific manner, with implications for the diversity of phytoplankton-bacteria interactions ongoing in the surface ocean.