ABSTRACT The structural and environmental heterogeneity within southern Africa has given rise to many morphological forms of Psammophylax rhombeatus distributed throughout the country, with previous studies neglecting the associated molecular significance of these forms. The species’ widespread, generalist ecology coupled with the substantial phylogenetic structuring previously acknowledged within the species, makes P. rhombeatus the ideal candidate for phylogeographic analyses. Using 103 samples, representing the full distribution of the species, phylogenetic analyses retrieved four well-supported clades: south-eastern South Africa, south-western South Africa, north-eastern South Africa and western South Africa. Although not variable enough to warrant taxonomic re-evaluation, the clades are phylogenetically distinguishable, with relatively high intraspecific genetic divergence values separating them, irrespective of the small geographic distances separating populations. This is likely a product of the taxon’s habitat-generalist lifestyle, enabling them to bypass vicariant barriers that might otherwise cause speciation in less versatile species. The clades are also geographically distinct, with little overlap, indicating previous vicariance, a finding that is supported by the split of P. rhombeatus from P. ocellatus in the mid-Pliocene, followed by the diversification of P. rhombeatus into four clades throughout the Pleistocene. The genetic structuring observed in P. rhombeatus may be a product of population expansion following ancient refugial isolation (potentially Last Glacial Maximum). The morphological groupings highlighted in previous studies are loosely attributable to the molecular clades identified in the phylogenetic reconstruction, highlighting the complex interplay of genetic and morphological characteristics in the process of speciation, and their representation in systematic accounts.