Stress exerted by excess captured light energy in cyanobacteria is prevented by the photoprotective activity of the orange carotenoid protein (OCP). Under high light, the OCP converts from an orange, inactive form (OCPO) into the red form (OCPR) that binds to and quenches the phycobilisome (PBS). Structurally, the OCP consists of two domains: the N-terminal effector domain and a C-terminal regulatory domain. Structural analysis of the OCP-PBS complex showed that the N-terminal domains of an OCP dimer interact with the PBS core. These N-terminal OCP domains have single domain protein paralogs known as Helical Carotenoid Proteins (HCPs). Using phycobilisome quenching assays, we show that the HCP4 and HCP5 homologs efficiently quench PBS fluorescence in vitro, surpassing the quenching ability of the OCP. This is consistent with computational quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics results. Interestingly, when using a maximum quenching concentration of OCP with phycobilisomes, HCP5 addition further increases phycobilisome quenching. Our results provide mechanistic insight into the quenching capacity and roles of HCP4 and HCP5 in cyanobacteria, suggesting that they are more than simply functionally redundant to the OCP.