OmpR Phosphorylation Research Articles

EnvZ/OmpR two-component system induces antibiotic resistance in Salmonella entericaSerovar Enteritidis in response to β-lactams

Abstract Outer membrane porins (OMPs) of Gram-negative bacteria including Salmonella entericaserovar Enteritidis allow the entry of small hydrophilic antibiotics. S. Enteritidis is a human pathogen causing food-borne illnesses, and infection by S.Enteritidis often results in severe invasive disease and requires antibiotic treatments. Although compositional modulation of OMPs is frequently observed in multidrug-resistant S.Enteritidis, little is known about the mechanisms by which the pathogen modulates OMP composition to enhance antibiotic resistance. Here, we found that the S.Enteritidis strain with an active state of EnvZ/OmpR two-component system is highly resistant to various antibiotics, especially β-lactams. Transcriptome analysis showed that the active state of EnvZ/OmpR induces differential expression of multiple OMP genes, including SEN1522, SEN2875, ompD, and ompW. Interestingly, the cellular level of response regulator OmpR determines the expression of the four OMP genes, and phosphorylation of OmpR is not necessary for the regulation of ompDand ompW. Phenotypic analysis revealed that ompDis a key OMP gene responsible for the EnvZ/OmpR-mediated antibiotic resistance in S.Enteritidis. Notably, EnvZ/OmpR responds to the presence of β-lactams and provides S.Enteritidis with direct benefits for survival. Altogether, this study suggests that EnvZ/OmpR remodels OMP composition of S.Enteritidis in response to β-lactams and enhances antibiotic resistance. This research was supported by Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea(NRF) funded by the Ministry of Education (NRF-2022R1A6A3A01086815).

CsgI (YccT) Is a Novel Inhibitor of Curli Fimbriae Formation in Escherichia coli Preventing CsgA Polymerization and Curli Gene Expression.

Curli fimbriae are amyloids-found in bacteria (Escherichia coli)-that are involved in solid-surface adhesion and bacterial aggregation during biofilm formation. The curli protein CsgA is coded by a csgBAC operon gene, and the transcription factor CsgD is essential to induce its curli protein expression. However, the complete mechanism underlying curli fimbriae formation requires elucidation. Herein, we noted that curli fimbriae formation was inhibited by yccT-i.e., a gene that encodes a periplasmic protein of unknown function regulated by CsgD. Furthermore, curli fimbriae formation was strongly repressed by CsgD overexpression caused by a multicopy plasmid in BW25113-the non-cellulose-producing strain. YccT deficiency prevented these CsgD effects. YccT overexpression led to intracellular YccT accumulation and reduced CsgA expression. These effects were addressed by deleting the N-terminal signal peptide of YccT. Localization, gene expression, and phenotypic analyses revealed that YccT-dependent inhibition of curli fimbriae formation and curli protein expression was mediated by the two-component regulatory system EnvZ/OmpR. Purified YccT inhibited CsgA polymerization; however, no intracytoplasmic interaction between YccT and CsgA was detected. Thus, YccT-renamed CsgI (curli synthesis inhibitor)-is a novel inhibitor of curli fimbriae formation and has a dual role as an OmpR phosphorylation modulator and CsgA polymerization inhibitor.

Mechanistic understanding of antibiotic resistance mediated by EnvZ/OmpR two-component system in Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis.

Outer membrane porins (OMPs) are a major route for the entry of small hydrophilic antibiotics. Thus, compositional modulation of OMPs is often accompanied by multidrug resistance in a human pathogen Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis. The role of EnvZ/OmpR two-component system in antibiotic resistance has not been established except that it regulates the expression of two OMPs, OmpC and OmpF. Here, we have gained mechanistic insight into EnvZ/OmpR-mediated antibiotic resistance in S. Enteritidis. The envZP248L and envZH243A strains, mimicking the S. Enteritidis strains with active and inactive states of EnvZ/OmpR, were used in this study. Antibiotic resistance was determined by the broth microdilution method and the spot plating assay. Transcriptomes of the S. Enteritidis strains were analysed by RNA-seq. Western blot, quantitative reverse transcription-PCR, electrophoretic mobility shift assays and β-galactosidase activity assays were performed. The active state of EnvZ/OmpR induced a differential expression of multiple OMP genes including SEN1522, SEN2875, ompD and ompW, enhancing resistance to β-lactams in S. Enteritidis. OmpR directly activated SEN1522 and SEN2875 but repressed ompD and ompW. Interestingly, an increased cellular level of OmpR determined the expression of the four OMP genes, and phosphorylation of OmpR was even not necessary for the repression of ompD and ompW. EnvZ/OmpR increased its own expression in response to β-lactams, decreasing outer membrane permeability and providing S. Enteritidis with benefits for survival upon exposure to the antibiotics. EnvZ/OmpR remodels OMP composition in response to β-lactams and thereby enhances antibiotic resistance in S. Enteritidis.

Role of EnvZ/OmpR Two‐component System in Antibiotic Resistance in Salmonella enterica Serovar Enteritidis

Outer membrane porins (OMPs) form water‐filled open channels and allow the entry of small hydrophilic antibiotics. Thus, compositional modulation of OMPs is frequently observed in multidrug‐resistant bacteria, including a human pathogen Salmonella enterica. However, the mechanism by which S. entericamodulates OMP composition to enhance antibiotic resistance has not been well elucidated. In this study, we found that the S. enterica serovar Enteritidis strain with an active state of EnvZ/OmpR is highly resistant to various antibiotics, especially β‐lactams. Transcriptome analysis discovered that the active state of EnvZ/OmpR induces differential expression of multiple OMP genes, including SEN1522, SEN2875, ompD, and ompW. Biochemical analyses identified that OmpR activates SEN1522 and SEN2875 but represses ompD and ompW by directly binding to their upstream regions. Interestingly, the cellular level of OmpR determines the expression of the four OMP genes, and particularly, the phosphorylation of OmpR is not required for the repression of ompD and ompW. Phenotypic analysis revealed that a decreased expression of ompD is responsible for the EnvZ/OmpR‐mediated resistance to β‐lactams in S. Enteritidis. Notably, EnvZ/OmpR represses the expression of ompD upon exposure to β‐lactams and presumably provides S. Enteritidis with benefits for survival. Altogether, this study suggests that EnvZ/OmpR remodels OMP composition in response to β‐lactams and thereby enhances resistance in S. Enteritidis to the antibiotics.

Chemoproteomic Profiling of Phosphoaspartate Modifications in Prokaryotes.

Phosphorylation at aspartic acid residues represents an abundant and critical post-translational modification (PTM) in prokaryotes. In contrast to most characterized PTMs, such as phosphorylation at serine or threonine, the phosphoaspartate moiety is intrinsically labile, and therefore incompatible with common proteomic profiling methods. Herein, we report a nucleophilic, desthiobiotin-containing hydroxylamine (DBHA) chemical probe that covalently labels modified aspartic acid residues in native proteomes. DBHA treatment coupled with LC-MS/MS analysis enabled detection of known phosphoaspartate modifications, as well as novel aspartic acid sites in the E. coli proteome. Coupled with isotopic labelling, DBHA-dependent proteomic profiling also permitted global quantification of changes in endogenous protein modification status, as demonstrated with the detection of increased E. coli OmpR phosphorylation, but not abundance, in response to changes in osmolarity.

Chemoproteomic Profiling of Phosphoaspartate Modifications in Prokaryotes

AbstractPhosphorylation at aspartic acid residues represents an abundant and critical post‐translational modification (PTM) in prokaryotes. In contrast to most characterized PTMs, such as phosphorylation at serine or threonine, the phosphoaspartate moiety is intrinsically labile, and therefore incompatible with common proteomic profiling methods. Herein, we report a nucleophilic, desthiobiotin‐containing hydroxylamine (DBHA) chemical probe that covalently labels modified aspartic acid residues in native proteomes. DBHA treatment coupled with LC‐MS/MS analysis enabled detection of known phosphoaspartate modifications, as well as novel aspartic acid sites in the E. coli proteome. Coupled with isotopic labelling, DBHA‐dependent proteomic profiling also permitted global quantification of changes in endogenous protein modification status, as demonstrated with the detection of increased E. coli OmpR phosphorylation, but not abundance, in response to changes in osmolarity.

Non-canonical activation of OmpR drives acid and osmotic stress responses in single bacterial cells

Unlike eukaryotes, bacteria undergo large changes in osmolality and cytoplasmic pH. It has been described that during acid stress, bacteria internal pH promptly acidifies, followed by recovery. Here, using pH imaging in single living cells, we show that following acid stress, bacteria maintain an acidic cytoplasm and the osmotic stress transcription factor OmpR is required for acidification. The activation of this response is non-canonical, involving a regulatory mechanism requiring the OmpR cognate kinase EnvZ, but not OmpR phosphorylation. Single cell analysis further identifies an intracellular pH threshold ~6.5. Acid stress reduces the internal pH below this threshold, increasing OmpR dimerization and DNA binding. During osmotic stress, the internal pH is above the threshold, triggering distinct OmpR-related pathways. Preventing intracellular acidification of Salmonella renders it avirulent, suggesting that acid stress pathways represent a potential therapeutic target. These results further emphasize the advantages of single cell analysis over studies of population averages.

OmpR phosphorylation regulates ompS1 expression by differentially controlling the use of promoters

The Salmonella enterica ompS1 gene encodes a quiescent porin that belongs to the OmpC/OmpF family. In the present work we analysed the regulatory effects of OmpR phosphorylation on ompS1 expression. We found that in vivo, OmpR in its phosphorylated form (OmpR-P) was important in the regulation of the two ompS1 promoters: OmpR-P activated the P1 promoter and repressed the P2 promoter in an EnvZ-dependent manner; expression occurs from the P2 promoter in an ompR mutant. In vitro, OmpR-P had a higher DNA-binding-affinity to the ompS1 promoter region than OmpR and OmpRD55A, showing an affinity even higher than that of equivalent DNA regions in the 5'-upstream regulatory sequence of the major porin-encoding genes ompC and ompF. By analysing different environmental conditions, we found that glucose and glycerol enhanced ompS1 expression in the wild-type strain. Interestingly the stimulation by glycerol was OmpR-dependent while the effect of glucose was still observed in the absence of OmpR. Acetyl phosphate produced by the AckA-Pta pathway did not influence ompS1 regulation. These data indicate the important role of the phosphorylation in the activity of OmpR on the differential regulation of both ompS1 promoters and its impact on the pathogenesis.

Comprehensive Analysis of OmpR Phosphorylation, Dimerization, and DNA Binding Supports a Canonical Model for Activation

The OmpR/PhoB family of response regulators (RRs) is the largest class of two-component system signal transduction proteins. Extensive biochemical and structural characterization of these transcription factors has provided insights into their activation and DNA-binding mechanisms. For the most part, OmpR/PhoB family proteins are thought to become activated through phosphorylation from their cognate histidine kinase partners, which in turn facilitates an allosteric change in the RR, enabling homodimerization and subsequently enhanced DNA binding. Incongruently, it has been suggested that OmpR, the eponymous member of this RR family, becomes activated via different mechanisms, whereby DNA binding plays a central role in facilitating dimerization and phosphorylation. Characterization of the rate and extent of the phosphorylation of OmpR and OmpR DNA-binding mutants following activation of the EnvZ/OmpR two-component system shows that DNA binding is not essential for phosphorylation of OmpR in vivo. In addition, detailed analyses of the energetics of DNA binding and dimerization of OmpR in both its unphosphorylated and phosphorylated state indicate that phosphorylation enhances OmpR dimerization and that this dimerization enhancement is the energetic driving force for phosphorylation-mediated regulation of OmpR–DNA binding. These findings suggest that OmpR phosphorylation-mediated activation follows the same paradigm as the other members of the OmpR/PhoB family of RRs in contrast to previously proposed models of OmpR activation.

Functional Assessment of EnvZ/OmpR Two-Component System in Shewanella oneidensis

EnvZ and OmpR constitute the bacterial two-component signal transduction system known to mediate osmotic stress response in a number of Gram-negative bacteria. In an effort to understand the mechanism through which Shewanella oneidensis senses and responds to environmental osmolarity changes, structure of the ompR-envZ operon was determined with Northern blotting assay and roles of the EnvZ/OmpR two-component system in response to various stresses were investigated with mutational analysis, quantitative reverse transcriptase PCR (qRT-PCR), and phenotype microarrays. Results from the mutational analysis and qRT-PCR suggested that the EnvZ/OmpR system contributed to osmotic stress response of S. oneidensis and very likely engaged a similar strategy employed by E. coli, which involved reciprocal regulation of two major porin coding genes. Additionally, the ompR-envZ system was also found related to cell motility. We further showed that the ompR-envZ dependent regulation of porin genes and motility resided almost completely on ompR and only partially on envZ, indicating additional mechanisms for OmpR phosphorylation. In contrast to E. coli lacking ompR-envZ, however, growth of S. oneidensis did not show a significant dependence on ompR-envZ even under osmotic stress. Further analysis with phenotype microarrays revealed that the S. oneidensis strains lacking a complete ompR-envZ system displayed hypersensitivities to a number of agents, especially in alkaline environment. Taken together, our results suggest that the function of the ompR-envZ system in S. oneidensis, although still connected with osmoregulation, has diverged considerably from that of E. coli. Additional mechanism must exist to support growth of S. oneidensis under osmotic stress.

Modulation of inv gene expression by the OmpR two-component response regulator protein of Yersinia enterocolitica

To elucidate the physiological meaning of OmpR-dependent expression of invasin gene (inv) inhibition in Yersinia enterocolitica, the function of the EnvZ/OmpR regulatory pathway in osmoregulation of inv expression was analyzed in detail. The osmoregulation of inv expression was found to be a multifaceted process involving both OmpR-dependent and -independent mechanisms. Analysis of inv transcription in strains lacking OmpR or EnvZ proteins indicated that kinase EnvZ is not the only regulator of OmpR phosphorylation. Using the transcriptional inv::lacZ fusion in a heterologous system (Escherichia coli) we tried to clarify the role of OmpR in the inv regulatory circuit composed of negative (H-NS) and positive (RovA) regulators of inv gene transcription. We were able to show a significant increase in inv expression in E. coli ompR background under H-NS( Ecoli )-repressed condition. Moreover, H-NS-mediated inv repression was relieved when RovA of Y. enterocolitica was expressed from a plasmid. Furthermore, we showed that RovA may activate inv expression irrespective on the presence of H-NS protein. Using this strategy we showed that OmpR of Y. enterocolitica decrease RovA-mediated inv activation.

OmpR controls Yersinia enterocolitica motility by positive regulation of flhDC expression

Flagella and invasin play important roles during the early stages of infection by the enteric pathogen Yersinia enterocolitica. Our previous study demonstrated that OmpR negatively regulates invasin gene expression at the transcriptional level. The present study focused on the role of OmpR in the regulation of flagella expression. Motility assays and microscopic observations revealed that an ompR mutant strain exhibits a non-motile phenotype due to the lack of flagella. An analysis of flhDC::lacZYA chromosomal fusions demonstrated a decrease in flhDC expression in ompR mutant cells, suggesting a role for OmpR in the positive control of flagellar master operon flhDC, which is in contrast to the negative role it plays in Escherichia coli. Moreover, high temperature or osmolarity and low pH decreased flhDC expression and OmpR was not required for the response to these factors. Evidence from an examination of the DNA binding properties of OmpR in vitro indicated that the mechanism by which OmpR regulates flhDC is direct. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays confirmed that OmpR binds specifically to the flhDC promoter region and suggested the presence of more than one OmpR-binding site. In addition, phosphorylation of OmpR by acetyl-P appeared to stimulate the binding abilities of OmpR. Together with the results of our previous studies revealing the negative role of OmpR in the regulation of invasin expression, these findings support a model in which invasion and motility might be reciprocally regulated by OmpR.

Imaging OmpR Binding to Native Chromosomal Loci in Escherichia coli

Previously, an unexplained subcellular localization was reported for a functional fluorescent protein fusion to the response regulator OmpR in Escherichia coli. The pronounced regions of increased fluorescence, or foci, are dependent on OmpR phosphorylation and do not occupy fixed, easily identifiable positions, such as the poles or mid-cell. Here we show that the foci are due to OmpR-YFP (yellow fluorescent protein) fusion binding to specific sites in the chromosome. To identify positions of foci and quantify their fluorescence intensity, we used a simple system to tag virtually any chromosomal location with arrays of lacO or tetO. The brightest foci colocalize with the OmpR-regulated gene ompF, which is strongly expressed under our growth conditions. When we increased OmpR-YFP phosphorylation by stimulating the EnvZ/OmpR system with procaine, we observed a small increase in OmpR-YFP fluorescence at ompF and a significant increase at the OmpR-regulated gene ompC. This supports a model of hierarchical binding of OmpR to the ompF and ompC promoters. Our results explain the inhomogeneous distribution of OmpR-YFP fluorescence in cells and further demonstrate that for a transcription factor expressed at wild-type levels, binding to native sites in the chromosome can be imaged and quantified by fluorescence microscopy.

Evolving a robust signal transduction pathway from weak cross‐talk

We have evolved a robust two-component signal transduction pathway from a sensor kinase (SK) and non-partner response regulator (RR) that show weak cross-talk in vitro and no detectable cross-talk in vivo in wild-type strains. The SK, CpxA, is bifunctional, with both kinase and phosphatase activities for its partner RR. We show that by combining a small number of mutations in CpxA that individually increase phosphorylation of the non-partner RR OmpR, phosphatase activity against phospho-OmpR emerges. The resulting circuit also becomes responsive to input signal to CpxA. The effects of combining these mutations in CpxA appear to reflect complex intragenic interactions between multiple sites in the protein. However, by analyzing a simple model of two-component signaling, we show that the behavior can be explained by a monotonic change in a single parameter controlling protein–protein interaction strength. The results suggest one possible mode of evolution for two-component systems with bifunctional SKs whereby the remarkable properties and competing reactions that characterize these systems can emerge by combining mutations of the same effect.

The cysteine 354 and 277 residues ofSalmonella entericaserovar Typhi EnvZ are determinants of autophosphorylation and OmpR phosphorylation

An initial biochemical characterization of the Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi (S. Typhi) EnvZ sensor protein and several mutant derivatives was performed. Autophosphorylation levels were higher for Escherichia coli EnvZ, intermediate for S. enterica serovar Typhimurium EnvZ and very low for S. Typhi EnvZ, in spite of their high amino acid sequence identity. Consequently, OmpR phosphorylation was related to EnvZ autophosphorylation. Among the mutant derivatives, a C354G mutation in S. Typhi EnvZ resulted in a substantial increase in autophosphorylation, while mutation of its other cysteine residue at position 277 to L or S decreased the EnvZ autophosphorylation level. Upon heterodimerization, the S. Typhi C354G mutant complemented the wild type in vitro, increasing the EnvZ-P yield of both monomers, in accordance with the model where EnvZ autophosphorylation occurs in trans, indicating that dimer formation is a dynamic process. Hence, the C354 and the C277 residues are fundamental in determining the particular intrinsic biochemical characteristics of EnvZ.

Amino Acids Important for DNA Recognition by the Response Regulator OmpR

Response regulators undergo regulated phosphorylation and dephosphorylation at conserved aspartic acid residues in bacterial signal transduction systems. OmpR is a winged helix-turnhelix DNA-binding protein that functions as a global regulator in bacteria and is also important in pathogenesis. A detailed mechanistic picture of how OmpR binds to DNA and activates transcription is lacking. We used NMR spectroscopy to solve the solution structure of the C-terminal domain of OmpR (OmpR(C)) and to analyze the chemical shift changes that occur upon DNA binding. There is little overlap in the interaction surface with residues of PhoB that were reportedly involved in protein/protein interactions in its head-to-tail dimer. Multiple factors account for the lack of overlap. One is that the spacing between the OmpR half-sites is shorter than observed with PhoB, requiring the arrangement of the two OmpR molecules to be different from that of the PhoB dimer on DNA. A second is the demonstration herein that OmpR can bind to its high affinity site as a monomer. As a result, OmpR(C) appears to be capable of adopting alternative orientations depending on the precise base composition of the binding site, which also contributes to the lack of overlap. In the presence of DNA, chemical shift changes occur in OmpR in the recognition alpha-helix 3, the loop between beta-strand 4 and alpha-helix 1, and the loop between beta-strands 5 and 6. DNA contact residues are Val(203) (T), Arg(207) (G), and Arg(209) (phosphate backbone). Our results suggest that OmpR binds to DNA as a monomer and then forms a symmetric or asymmetric dimer, depending on the binding site. We propose that during activation OmpR binds to DNA and undergoes a conformational change that promotes phosphorylation of the N-terminal receiver domain, the receiver domains dimerize, and then the second monomer binds to DNA. The flexible linker of OmpR enables the second monomer to bind in multiple orientations (head-to-tail and head-to-head), depending on the specific DNA contacts.

Transcription Regulation of ompF and ompC by a Single Transcription Factor, OmpR

The ompF and ompC genes of Escherichia coli are reciprocally regulated by a single transcription factor, phosphorylated OmpR (OmpR-P), depending upon medium osmolarity. This regulation involves activation of ompF and its repression with concomitant activation of ompC. This occurs through OmpR-P binding to four (F1, F2, F3, and F4) and three (C1, C2, and C3) sites located upstream of the ompF and ompC promoters, respectively, through a novel mechanism. Here we show that there is a distinct OmpR-P binding hierarchy within F1, F2, and F3 sites as well as within C1, C2, and C3 sites. Each of these sites contains two tandem 10-bp OmpR-P-binding subsites, a-site and b-site (from 5' to 3' direction). OmpR-P has higher affinity to the downstream b-site than to the upstream a-site in each case. Six OmpR-P molecules bind to F and C sites two-by-two in a discontinuous "galloping" manner. We propose that this tight hierarchical binding of a transcription factor, OmpR, allows distinct stepwise regulation of ompF and ompC transcription, which minimizes their overlapping expression upon changes in the medium osmolarity to achieve the reciprocal expression of ompF and ompC.

Signal-dependent Binding of the Response Regulators PhoP and PmrA to Their Target Promoters in Vivo

Low Mg2+ promotes phosphorylation of the response regulators PhoP and PmrA and transcription of their activated genes in Salmonella enterica. Using chromatin immunoprecipitation, we have now determined that the PhoP and PmrA proteins are recruited to the regulatory region of their target genes when bacteria experience low Mg2+ but not when they are grown in high Mg2+. Even when the PhoP protein was artificially produced at 4-fold higher levels than the wild-type strain, promoter occupancy required the low Mg2+ signal. Substitution of the predicted phosphorylation site Asp-52 with a valine residue abolished phosphorylation of the PhoP protein, resulting in loss of PhoP binding to target promoters and transcription of PhoP-activated genes. Our results indicate that the promoter binding ability of the PhoP and PmrA proteins occurring in low Mg2+ is correlated with phosphorylation of these proteins in vivo.

Delineation of upstream signaling events in the salmonella pathogenicity island 2 transcriptional activation pathway.

Survival and replication in the intracellular environment are critical components of the ability of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium to establish systemic infection in the murine host. Intracellular survival is mediated by a number of genetic loci, including Salmonella pathogenicity island 2 (SPI2). SPI2 is a 40-kb locus encoding a type III secretion system that secretes effector molecules, which permits bacterial survival and replication in the intracellular environment of host cells. A two-component regulatory system, ssrAB, is also encoded in SPI2 and controls expression of the secretion system and effectors. While the environmental signals to which SPI2 responds in vivo are not known, activation of expression is dependent on OmpR and can be stimulated in vitro by chelation of cations or by a shift from rich to acidic minimal medium. In this work, we demonstrated that SPI2 activation is associated with OmpR in the phosphorylated form (OmpR-P). Mutations in envZ and ackA-pta, which disrupted two distinct sources of OmpR phosphorylation, indicated that SPI2 activation by chelators or a shift from rich to acidic minimal medium is largely dependent on functional EnvZ. In contrast, the PhoPQ pathway is not required for SPI2 activation in the presence of OmpR-P. As in the case of in vitro stimulation, SPI2 expression in macrophages correlates with the presence of OmpR-P. Additionally, EnvZ, but not acetyl phosphate, is required for maximal expression of SPI2 in the intracellular environment, suggesting that the in vitro SPI2 activation pathway is the same as that used in vivo.

Robustness and the cycle of phosphorylation and dephosphorylation in a two-component regulatory system.

The EnvZ/OmpR system in Escherichia coli, which regulates the expression of the porins OmpF and OmpC, is one of the simplest and best-characterized examples of two-component signaling. Like many other histidine kinases, EnvZ is bifunctional; it phosphorylates and dephosphorylates the response regulator OmpR. We have analyzed a mathematical model of the EnvZ-mediated cycle of OmpR phosphorylation and dephosphorylation. The model predicts that when EnvZ is much less abundant than OmpR, as is the case in E. coli, the steady-state level of phosphorylated OmpR (OmpR-P) is insensitive to variations in the concentration of EnvZ. The model also predicts that the level of OmpR-P is insensitive to variations in the concentration of OmpR when the OmpR concentration is sufficiently high. To test these predictions, we have perturbed the porin regulatory circuit in E. coli by varying the expression levels of EnvZ and OmpR. We have constructed two-color fluorescent reporter strains in which ompF and ompC transcription can be easily measured in the same culture. Using these strains we have shown that, consistent with the predictions of our model, the transcription of ompC and ompF is indeed robust or insensitive to a wide range of expression levels of both EnvZ and OmpR.