Risk of cardiovascular disease mortality rises in women after menopause. While increased cardiovascular risk is largely attributed to postmenopausal declines in estrogens, the molecular changes in the heart that contribute to risk are poorly understood. Disruptions in intracellular calcium handling develop in ovariectomized mice and have been implicated in cardiac dysfunction. Using a mouse model of menopause in which ovarian failure occurs over 120 days, we sought to determine if perimenopause impacted calcium removal mechanisms in the heart and identify the molecular mechanisms. Mice were injected with 4-vinylcyclohexene diepoxide (VCD) to induce ovarian failure over 120 days, mimicking perimenopause. Hearts were removed at 60 and 120 days after VCD injections, representing the middle and end of perimenopause. SERCA2a function was significantly diminished at the end of perimenopause. Neither SERCA2a nor phospholamban expression changed at either time point, but phospholamban phosphorylation at S16 and T17 was dynamically altered. Intrinsic SERCA inhibitors sarcolipin and myoregulin increased >4-fold at day 60, as did the native activator DWORF. At the end of perimenopause, sarcolipin and myoregulin returned to baseline levels while DWORF was significantly reduced below controls. Sodium-calcium exchanger expression was significantly increased at the end of perimenopause. These results show that the foundation for increased cardiovascular disease mortality develops in the heart during perimenopause and that regulators of calcium handling exhibit significant fluctuations over time. Understanding the temporal development of cardiovascular risk associated with menopause and the underlying mechanisms is critical to developing interventions that mitigate the rise in cardiovascular mortality that arises after menopause.