In northeastern Pará, smallholder agriculture systems are still based on secondary forest fallows, nationally called “capoeira”, presumed to contain a remarkable amount of underutilized valuable woody species, for instance as supplementary forage for cattle. We tested five promising capoeira species, namely Phenakospermum guyannense, Cecropia palmata, Attalea maripa, Inga edulis, and Abarema jupunba by comparing its relative palatability—i.e., the palatability differences between the tested species and the reference forage legumes, forage grass, and between the other tested species-, heights, biomass production, and main nutritive values with the well-known tropical forage legumes Cratylia argentea and Flemingia macrophylla. Additionally, the locally common domesticated species Tithonia diversifolia, Mangifera indica, and Racosperma mangium were also included in the trial, all implemented in a randomized block design on a Brachiaria-pasture (n=2000 saplings, 8 replication blocks). After two years of establishment, four steers with an average body mass of 506kg browsed the trial (2 AU/ha). The relative palatability testing showed that A. jupunba, M. indica and also surprisingly R. mangium (all >20% of its respective total biomass) matched the consumed biomass of F. macrophylla, while C. palmata (>60%) even surpassed very palatable C. argentea. R. mangium also had the highest biomass production, while the other species showed just regular growth and establishing rates. Protein contents of all species were above 6%, most of them higher than 10% and in the case of T. diversifolia even above 20%. Thus, all tested species almost reached the quality of the reference legumes. However, as plant secondary compounds were not regarded in this trial, recommendations as supplementary forage plants can only be given with reservations. The results suggest that smallholders possess cheap forage supplement alternatives on their farms and even on their pasture plots, which simply have to be tolerated by just pruning them into accessible heights for animals. However, sapling transplantation from shady capoeiras on old slightly degraded pastures for biomass enrichment cannot be recommended.