It is clearly true that the rate of development of heat in a conductor, whether an electrolyte or electrode, is a function of the (square of the) current that is passed. As mentioned earlier, however, the rate of development of heat — i.e., Joule heating — is not the same as the rate of increase of temperature in a conductor. Joule heating may, therefore, certainly occur in a permeation cell, or any electrochemical cell for that matter, but the temperature rise depends on the heat capacity of the material as well as on the rate of heat loss. We believe that in our studies the rate of temperature change and the corresponding increase in anodic current density that may be expected are not compatible with the observed transients. It is our view at this stage that the observed transients in nickel reflect transport of hydrogen predominantly by lattice diffusion in unstrained membranes and by dislocations in membranes deformed at a constant strain rate during cathodic charging. Of course, the point raised by Otsuka and Isaji cannot be dismissed in general without further study. What might perhaps prove convincing would be to examine a series of alloys, in some of which dislocation transport is considered to occur — for example, in nickel serrated yielding in hydrogen-charged single crystals indicates mobile dislocation-hydrogen interactions (26) — and others in which dislocation transport is considered less likely. It is interesting in the latter sense to cite the recent work of Berkowitz (27) in which electrolytic hydrogen permeation on straining electrodes of 4130 steel is found to decrease at the yield point in contrast to the work on nickel (1 and 3). This has been interpreted to reflect dislocation trapping of hydrogen rather than transport. Similar observations have been recently made in our laboratory on a 2 1 4 Cr-1Mo steel (28). In any case, it seems unlikely that Joule heating of the magnitude suggested (1) could account for the latter behavior. In short, we do acknowledge having certain reservations about the details of the analysis of permeation transients on straining electrodes. These have been under study in our laboratory. Joule heating was not one of these details. Our view is that while Joule heating may certainly occur when a current passes through a conductor, much of the phenomenology that we have observed on straining membranes (a grain size dependence, etc.) is best understood in terms of a hydrogen permeation process.
Read full abstract