Abstract Standard of care treatment for virtually all glioma subtypes starts with maximal safe resection. However, resections that result in motor deficits can negate any survival benefit from surgery and diminish quality of life. Because current evidence on functional outcomes following glioma resection often conflicts and is limited to a small number of case series, retrospective analyses, and reviews, here we performed the first PRISMA-compliant systematic review and meta-analysis of currently published data to identify factors related to permanent and temporary motor deficits after surgery. We searched Ovid Medline, Scopus, Web of Science, CINAHL/EBSCO, PsychInfo, Cochrane and Wiley for studies reporting motor outcomes following surgical resection of glioma. Outcomes were stratified by patient/tumor characteristics, pre-operative condition, and intra-operative factors for both permanent (≥3 months postop) and temporary (<3 months postop) motor deficits. Generalized estimating equations were used to generate odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals. A total of 1,162 titles and abstracts were reviewed for eligibility resulting in the evaluation of 211 full-text articles. Data were extracted from 55 studies including 1,801 patients with 223 (12%) permanent postoperative motor deficits, 428 (24%) temporary motor deficits, and the remaining 1,150 (64%) without motor deficit. Pre-operative deficit was the strongest predictor of permanent post-operative motor deficit (OR 10.56, CI 5.20-21.45, p=7.2E-11), while high pre-operative Karnofsky Performance Scale (KPS) (OR 0.98, CI 0.97-0.99, p=0.036) and subcortical tumor location (OR 0.15, CI 0.025-0.90, p=0.038) were associated with no permanent deficit. Supratotal resection was significantly associated with temporary motor deficits (OR 3.54E+12, CI 3.53+E13-3.56E+17, p<2E-16), and asleep craniotomies were associated with no deficit (OR 1.68E-01, CI 4.93E-02–5.71E-01, p=0.0043). Ultimately, this study represents the largest analysis of motor outcome data in glioma surgery to date.
Read full abstract