Perinatal Quality Collaboratives Research Articles

The Ongoing U.S. Struggle with Maternal Mortality.

Despite significant efforts over the past two decades, the maternal mortality rate (MMR) in the United States remains at least double that of most other high-income countries (HICs). In addition, substantial racial disparities exist with MMRs among Black and American Indian/Alaska Native women two to three times higher than White, Hispanic, and Asian/Pacific Islander counterparts. Of the three surveillance systems currently in place, Maternal Mortality Review Committees (MMRCs) are widely considered to provide the highest quality data. MMRCs in combination with Perinatal Quality Collaboratives and other successful initiatives provide the best hope of reversing these concerning trends. The state of maternal health in the United States is at a critical juncture. To reach the ultimate goal of rendering the United States as one of the "safest countries in the world to give birth" will require greater coordination and consolidation of national efforts across the entire prenatal, perinatal, and postpartum continuum. The authors make suggestions to create a robust federal infrastructure to finally provide equitable high-quality maternal care and bring U.S. maternal mortality into alignment with other HICs. KEY POINTS: · U.S. MMRs are double that of other HICs.. · Black MMRs are two to three times higher than White MMRs.. · "Maternity care deserts" show a marked increase in maternal mortality.. · Listed strategies have shown success in reversing these trends..

How much can hospital‐level interventions improve maternal health? Evidence from state Perinatal Quality Collaboratives

AbstractOver the last 20 years, nearly all states have adopted Perinatal Quality Collaboratives (PQCs), which set guidelines for hospitals to provide higher standards of prenatal care. In this paper, I use individual‐level natality data from 1989 to 2019 and a stacked difference in differences design comparing maternal and infant health outcomes in US states that have recently established a PQC to those that have not yet established one. Estimates indicate that PQCs decrease eclampsia, with the effect driven by Black mothers. Evidence also shows that PQCs reduce intensive care unit admissions for mothers.

Increasing access to quality care for pregnant and postpartum people with opioid use disorder: Coordination of services, provider awareness and training, extended postpartum coverage, and perinatal quality collaboratives

IntroductionFifteen states participating in the Opioid Use Disorder, Maternal Outcomes, and Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome Initiative Learning Community (OMNI LC) developed action plan goals and activities to address the rise in opioid use disorder (OUD) among birthing persons. In a separate initiative, Perinatal Quality Collaboratives (PQCs) from 12 states participating in Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)-supported activities hosted trainings to improve the provision of OUD services and implement protocols for screening and treatment in delivery facilities. MethodsThis descriptive study synthesizes qualitative data extracted from 15 OMNI LC state action plans, excerpts from qualitative interviews conducted with OMNI LC state teams, and quantitative data from quarterly project performance monitoring reports from 12 CDC-funded PQCs implementing quality improvement activities to address clinical service gaps for pregnant and postpartum people with OUD. Qualitative data were deidentified, coded as barriers or facilitators, then aggregated into emergent themes. Count data are presented for quantitative results. ResultsThe OMNI LC states identified a lack of coordinated care among providers, stigma toward people with OUD, discontinued insurance coverage, and inconsistencies in screening and treating birthing people with OUD as barriers to accessing quality care. State-identified facilitators for access to quality care included: 1) improving engagement and communication between providers and other partners to integrate medical and behavioral health services post-discharge, and facilitate improved patient care postpartum; 2) training providers to prescribe medications for OUD, and to address bias and reduce patient stigma; 3) extending Medicaid coverage up to one year postpartum to increase access to and continuity of services; and 4) implementing screening, brief intervention, and referral to treatment (SBIRT) in clinical practice. PQCs demonstrated that increased provider trainings to treat OUD, improvements in implementation of standardized protocols, and use of evidence-based tools can facilitate access to and coordination of services in delivery facilities. ConclusionState-identified facilitators for increasing access to care include coordinating integrated services, extending postpartum coverage, and provider trainings to improve screening and treatment. PQCs provide a platform for identifying emerging areas for quality improvement initiatives and implementing clinical best practices to provide comprehensive, quality perinatal care for birthing populations.

Improving Health Care Responses to Obstetric Hemorrhage.

Obstetric hemorrhage is one of the most commonly encountered obstetrical complications. Decreases in maternal mortality and severe maternal morbidity have continued to be achieved despite the increasing incidence of obstetric hemorrhage over time through the diligent efforts of quality improvement initiatives. Approaches currently advocated to optimize the management of obstetrical hemorrhage are presented and discussed in this chapter focusing on readiness, recognition and prevention, clinical response, patient support, and tracking and monitoring outcome and performance measures over time. Readers are encouraged to access publicly available programs from state-based perinatal quality collaboratives and national programs designed to support and structure such efforts.

Assessing Sustainability of State-Led Action Plans for the Opioid Use Disorder, Maternal Outcomes, and Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome Initiative Learning Community, 2018-2021.

Objective(s): The opioid crisis affects the health and health care of pregnant and postpartum people and infants prenatally exposed to substances. A Learning Community (LC) among 15 states was implemented to improve services for these populations. States drafted action plans with goals, strategies, and activities. Materials and Methods: Qualitative data from action plans were analyzed to assess how reported activities aligned with focus areas each year. Year 2 focus areas were compared with year 1 to identify shifts or expansion of activities. States self-assessed progress at the LC closing meeting, reported goal completion, barriers and facilitators affecting goal completion, and sustainment strategies. Results: In year 2, many states included activities focused on access to and coordination of quality services (13 of 15 states) and provider awareness and training (11 of 15). Among 12 states participating in both years of the LC, 11 expanded activities to include at least one additional focus area, adding activities in financing and coverage of services (n = 6); consumer awareness and education (n = 5); or ethical, legal, and social considerations (n = 4). Of the 39 goals developed by states, 54% were completed, and of those not completed, 94% had ongoing activities. Barriers to goal completion included competing priorities and pandemic-related constraints, whereas facilitators involving use of the LC as a forum for information-sharing and leadership-supported goal completion. Sustainability strategies were continued provider training and partnership with Perinatal Quality Collaboratives. Conclusion: State LC participation supported sustainment of activities to improve health and health care for pregnant and postpartum people with opioid use disorder and infants prenatally exposed to substances.

The impact of being Black while living with a chronic condition: Inpatient perspectives.

The impact of being Black while living with a chronic condition: Inpatient perspectives.

A survey of patient-centered practices in perinatal quality collaboratives.

SynopsisPerinatal quality collaboratives must incorporate patient and community member preferences in the design and evaluation of quality improvement initiatives to achieve truly patient‐centered maternity care.

How State Perinatal Quality Collaboratives Can Improve Rural Maternity Care.

Perinatal Quality Collaboratives (PQCs) are now present in nearly all states and provide important tools and strategies for improving maternal outcomes. State PQCs can focus their strengths to address rural maternal health challenges using support groups of rural hospitals, of tertiary facilities that network with them, and of other PQCs to share best practices for rural hospitals to: (1) Support networks of care and telehealth; (2) Support remote education and training; (3) Implement rural appropriate versions of National Safety Bundles; (4) Engage and support providers beyond obstetricians; and (5) Engage community members and resources.

Perinatal quality collaboratives and birth equity.

The purpose of this review is to discuss how state perinatal quality collaboratives are addressing birth equity to reduce disparities in maternal morbidity and mortality. Perinatal quality collaboratives are adopting core practices to advance birth equity, reduce disparities and confront racism and bias in obstetric care including securing leadership commitments to equity, providing education on the causes of inequities and mitigation strategies, collecting accurate race/ethnicity data, addressing social determinants of health, and integrating patient and community knowledge, experiences, and narratives in the quality improvement work. Inequities in maternal morbidity and mortality particularly affecting Black birthing people are driven by racism, inequities in the social determinants of health, and variations in care practices and quality. Perinatal quality collaboratives are an important resource for driving improvement changes to mitigate these factors and improve outcomes. Mason CL, Collier CH, Penny SC. Perinatal Quality Collaboratives and Birth Equity. Produced by CLMB Productions for use in this publication. January 10, 2022, http://links.lww.com/COAN/A86.

Quality Improvement and Participation in Perinatal Quality Collaboratives Promote Patient Safety.

Kathleen Rice Simpson is a Perinatal Clinical Nurse Specialist in St. Louis, MO, and the Editor-in-Chief of MCN. Dr. Simpson can be reached via email at [email protected] The author declares no conflicts of interest.

After Childbirth: Better Data Can Help Align Postpartum Needs with a New Standard of Care.

After Childbirth: Better Data Can Help Align Postpartum Needs with a New Standard of Care.

Supporting Success: ASTHO's Strategies for Reducing Maternal Mortality and Morbidity.

Supporting Success: ASTHO's Strategies for Reducing Maternal Mortality and Morbidity.

Evaluation of State-Led Surveillance of Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome - Six U.S. States, 2018-2021.

Opioid use disorder (OUD) is a significant public health problem in the United States, which affects children as well as adults. During 2010-2017, maternal opioid-related diagnoses increased approximately 130%, from 3.5 to 8.2 per 1,000 hospital deliveries, and neonatal abstinence syndrome (NAS) increased 83%, from 4.0 to 7.3 per 1,000 hospital deliveries (1). NAS, a withdrawal syndrome, can occur among infants following in utero exposure to opioids and other psychotropic substances (2). In 2018, a study of six states with mandated NAS case reporting for public health surveillance (2013-2017) found that mandated reporting helped quantify NAS incidence and guide programs and services (3). To review surveillance features and programmatic development in the same six states, a questionnaire and interview with state health department officials on postimplementation efforts were developed and implemented in 2021. All states reported ongoing challenges with initial case reporting, limited capacity to track social and developmental outcomes, and no requirement for long-term follow-up in state-mandated case reporting; only one state instituted health-related outcomes monitoring. The primary surveillance barrier beyond initial case reporting was lack of infrastructure. To serve identified needs of opioid- or other substance-exposed mother-infant dyads, state health departments reported programmatic successes expanding education and access to maternal medication for opioid use disorder (MOUD), community and provider education or support services, and partnerships with perinatal quality collaboratives. Development of additional infrastructure is needed for states aiming to advance NAS surveillance beyond initial case reporting.

Are perinatal quality collaboratives collaborating enough? How including all birth settings can drive needed improvement in the United States maternity care system.

Are perinatal quality collaboratives collaborating enough? How including all birth settings can drive needed improvement in the United States maternity care system.

Maternal Heart Failure.

Heart failure (HF) remains the most common major cardiovascular complication arising in pregnancy and the postpartum period. Mothers who develop HF have been shown to experience an increased risk of death as well as a variety of adverse cardiac and obstetric outcomes. Recent studies have demonstrated that the risk to neonates is significant, with increased risks in perinatal morbidity and mortality, low Apgar scores, and prolonged neonatal intensive care unit stays. Information on the causal factors of HF can be used to predict risk and understand timing of onset, mortality, and morbidity. A variety of modifiable, nonmodifiable, and obstetric risk factors as well as comorbidities are known to increase a patient's likelihood of developing HF, and there are additional elements that are known to portend a poorer prognosis beyond the HF diagnosis. Multidisciplinary cardio‐obstetric teams are becoming more prominent, and their existence will both benefit patients through direct care and increased awareness and educate clinicians and trainees on this patient population. Detection, access to care, insurance barriers to extended postpartum follow‐up, and timely patient counseling are all areas where care for these women can be improved. Further data on maternal and fetal outcomes are necessary, with the formation of State Maternal Perinatal Quality Collaboratives paving the way for such advances.

Effects of a Multi-site Expansion of Group Prenatal Care on Birth Outcomes.

Objectives Perinatal Quality Collaboratives across the United States are initiating projects to improve health and healthcare for women and infants. We compared an evidence-based group prenatal care model to usual individual prenatal care on birth outcomes in a multi-site expansion of group prenatal care supported by a state-wide multidisciplinary Perinatal Quality Collaborative. Methods We analyzed 15,330 pregnant women aged 14-48 across 13 healthcare practices in South Carolina (2013-2017) using a preferential-within cluster matching propensity score method and logistic regression. Outcomes were extracted from birth certificate data. We compared outcomes for (a) women at the intent-to-treat level and (b) for women participating in at least five group prenatal care visits to women with less than five group visits with at least five prenatal visits total. Results In the intent-to-treat analyses, women who received group prenatal care were significantly less likely to have preterm births (absolute risk difference -3.2%, 95% CI -5.3 to -1.0%), low birth weight births (absolute risk difference -3.7%, 95% CI -5.5 to -1.8%) and NICU admissions (absolute risk difference -4.0%, 95% CI -5.6 to -2.3%). In the as-treated analyses, women had greater improvements compared to intent-to-treat analyses in preterm birth and low birth weight outcomes. Conclusions for Practice CenteringPregnancy group prenatal care is effective across a range of real-world clinical practices for decreasing the risk of preterm birth and low birth weight. This is a feasible approach for other Perinatal Quality Collaboratives to attempt in their ongoing efforts at improving maternal and infant health outcomes.

Severe Maternal Morbidity, A Tale of 2 States Using Data for Action-Ohio and Massachusetts.

Purpose Describe how Ohio and Massachusetts explored severe maternal morbidity (SMM) data, and used these data for increasing awareness and driving practice changes to reduce maternal morbidity and mortality. Description For 2008-2013, Ohio used de-identified hospital discharge records and International Classification of Diseases, 9th Revision, Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM) codes to identify delivery hospitalizations. Massachusetts used existing linked data system infrastructure to identify delivery hospitalizations from birth certificates linked to hospital discharge records. To identify delivery hospitalizations complicated by one or more of 25 SMMs, both states applied an algorithm of ICD-9-CM diagnosis and procedure codes. Ohio calculated a 2013 SMM rate of 144 per 10,000 delivery hospitalizations; Massachusetts calculated a rate of 162. Ohio observed no increase in the SMM rate from 2008 to 2013; Massachusetts observed a 33% increase. Both identified disparities in SMM rates by maternal race, age, and insurance type. Assessment Ohio and Massachusetts engaged stakeholders, including perinatal quality collaboratives and maternal mortality review committees, to share results and raise awareness about the SMM rates and identified high-risk populations. Both states are applying findings to inform strategies for improving perinatal outcomes, such as simulation training for obstetrical emergencies, licensure rules for maternity units, and a focus on health equity. Conclusion Despite data access differences, examination of SMM data informed public health practice in both states. Ohio and Massachusetts maximized available state data for SMM investigation, which other states might similarly use to understand trends, identify high risk populations, and suggest clinical or population level interventions to improve maternal morbidity and mortality.

349: System improvements associated with reduced time-to-treatment for maternal hypertension in a statewide quality improvement Initiative

The Illinois Perinatal Quality Collaborative (ILPQC)’s Maternal Hypertension (HTN) initiative increased the percentage of new onset severe HTN (BP ≥160/110) cases treated within 60 minutes from 41.5% to 85.0% at 110 hospitals through collaborative learning, rapid-response data, and quality improvement (QI) support. We aim to identify which hospital system improvements facilitated by the initiative were associated with reduced time to treatment (T2T) given the importance of T2T in severe maternal morbidity and mortality associated with severe maternal HTN. Participating hospitals reported T2T for all cases of severe maternal HTN during the QI initiative (April 2016-December 2017). Status of key system improvements were reported quarterly. A mixed effects generalized linear model was used to estimate the association between achievement of system improvements and T2T. Odds ratios were adjusted for hospital characteristics: birth volume, location (urban / rural), and patient mix (race and Medicaid status) in 2014. Hospitals that created standard protocols for early warning signs, diagnostic criteria, monitoring, and treatment had 1.43 the odds of treating a severe maternal HTN case in <60 minutes, compared with hospitals that did not (p=0.02). Unit education of providers and nurses (aOR: 1.37, p=0.01), rapid access to IV antihypertensive medications on antepartum/postpartum floors (aOR: 1.45, p=0.02), and multidisciplinary reviews (aOR: 1.40, p=0.02) were also associated with improved efficacy in reducing T2T of severe maternal HTN (Table 1). Implementation of four hospital system improvements (protocols for management of severe maternal HTN, unit education, rapid access to antihypertensive medications, and multidisciplinary case reviews) were significantly associated with reduced T2T of severe maternal HTN, regardless of hospital characteristics. Further investigation into the overall effect of other system improvements will clarify their role in reducing T2T. Identifying key hospital system improvements can inform future perinatal quality collaboratives and hospital-level QI initiatives to reduce T2T and improve outcomes for pregnant and postpartum women with severe HTN.

The National Network of Perinatal Quality Collaboratives

The National Network of Perinatal Quality Collaboratives

The National Network of State Perinatal Quality Collaboratives: A Growing Movement to Improve Maternal and Infant Health.

State Perinatal Quality Collaboratives (PQCs) are networks of multidisciplinary teams working to improve maternal and infant health outcomes. To address the shared needs across state PQCs and enable collaboration, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), in partnership with March of Dimes and perinatal quality improvement experts from across the country, supported the development and launch of the National Network of Perinatal Quality Collaboratives (NNPQC). This process included assessing the status of PQCs in this country and identifying the needs and resources that would be most useful to support PQC development. National representatives from 48 states gathered for the first meeting of the NNPQC to share best practices for making measurable improvements in maternal and infant health. The number of state PQCs has grown considerably over the past decade, with an active PQC or a PQC in development in almost every state. However, PQCs have some common challenges that need to be addressed. After its successful launch, the NNPQC is positioned to ensure that every state PQC has access to key tools and resources that build capacity to actively improve maternal and infant health outcomes and healthcare quality.