Performance Comparison Of Filters Research Articles

In-line flocculation–filtration as pre-treatment to reverse osmosis desalination

In this paper the performance of single and dual media filters with in-line flocculation have been examined as pretreatment to seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO). A comparison of filter performance was made between single medium filter (80 cm) consisting of sand or anthracite, and dual media filter consisting of sand (40 cm at the bottom) and anthracite (40 cm on top). Short term (6 hours) experiments were conducted with in-line coagulation followed by direct filtration. Filtration velocities of 5 m/h and 10 m/h were used. The performances of these filters were assessed in terms of turbidity removal, head loss build-up, and organic compound removal in terms of molecular weight distribution (MWD). The efficiency of the filter as pretreatment was evaluated in terms of silt density index (SDI) and modified fouling index (MFI). It was found that the turbidity removal was high and all the filters produced more or less same quality water. There was a slower buildup of head loss for coarser filter medium. A post treatment of reverse osmosis after an inline-flocculation-dual media filtration showed lower normalized flux decline ( J/ J 0) (0.35 to 0.22 during the first 20 hours operation) while, seawater without any pretreatment showed steeper flux decline (0.18 to 0.11 at first 20 hours operation) in RO.

Performance comparison of filters with different aggregates

Unplanted upflow filters, which were filled with different filter media (natural zeolite, blast furnace granulated slag, ceramsite, and walnut shells), were operated to assess their nutrient removal performances. Different preprocessing methods involving aerobic and anaerobic sludges were applied to the filters to accelerate the treatment processes. The results indicated that preprocessing enhanced the soluble chemical oxygen demand (SCOD) removal, but had no obvious influence on the total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) removal efficiencies. Filters containing blast furnace granulated slag were independent with respect to SCOD loading rate variations in the range between 100 and 900 mg/d. A linear velocity equation was used to determine the nutrient removal velocities of blast furnace granulated slag-filled filters. The removal velocities were rapid, and highest for TP and lowest for TN. Compared with other filters, blast furnace granulated slag-filled filters performed best concerning nutrient removal and retention. Walnut shell-filled filters performed worst. © 2008 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Environ Prog, 2009