This Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) study, informed by the application of queer theory, examined eleven parents’ narratives about raising Transgender and Gender Expansive (TGE) children. The subjective experiences of these parents’ transcendence into parenting a TGE child informed one superordinate theme, the impact of living in a conventional society on the unique parenting experiences of raising TGE children. Evoked by the superordinate theme, the subtheme socio-cultural-political influences, encompasses preconceived ideas and assumptions experienced by each parent as they navigate raising a TGE child within a conventional society. Other subthemes include internalizing cishet norms and safety concerns, cishet language and cognitions on gender, and protective feelings and reactions to family and community judgments which demonstrate the multiple realities of each participant. The final subtheme, peer-led play support group, embodies these parents’ involvement in an affirming space. This data, and the meaning made from it, align with the realities of each participant and their experiences as a collective to inform this paper, which concludes with implications for supporting parents of TGE children and considerations for future research.