Peak Tibiofemoral Contact Forces Research Articles

Case study: The influence of Achilles tendon rupture on knee joint stress during counter-movement jump – Combining musculoskeletal modeling and finite element analysis

BackgroundPresently, the current research concerning Achilles tendon rupture repair (ATR) is predominantly centered on the ankle joint, with a paucity of evidence regarding its impact on the knee joint. ATR has the potential to significantly impede athletic performance and increase tibiofemoral contact forces in athletes. The purpose of this study was to prognosticate the distribution of stress within the knee joint during a countermovement jump through the use of a simulation method that amalgamated a musculoskeletal model of a patient who underwent Achilles tendon rupture repair with a finite element model of the knee joint. MethodsA male elite badminton player who had suffered an acute Achilles tendon rupture in his right leg one year prior was selected as our study subject. In order to analyze his biomechanical data, we employed both the OpenSim musculoskeletal model and finite element model to compute various parameters such as joint angles, joint moments, joint contact forces, and the distribution of knee joint stress. ResultsDuring the jumping phase, a significantly lower knee extension angle (p < 0.001), ankle dorsiflexion angle (p = 0.002), peak vertical ground reaction force (p < 0.001), and peak tibiofemoral contact force (p = 0.009) were observed on the injured side than on the uninjured side. During the landing phase, the ankle range of motion (ROM) was significantly lower on the injured side than on the uninjured side (p = 0.009), and higher peak vertical ground reaction forces were observed (p = 0.012). Additionally, it is logical that an injured person will put higher load on the uninjured limb, but the finite element analysis indicated that the stresses on the injured side of medial meniscus and medial cartilage were significantly greater than the uninjured side. ConclusionsAn Achilles tendon rupture can limit ankle range of motion and lead to greater joint stress on the affected area during countermovement jumps, especially during the landing phase. This increased joint stress may also transfer more stress to the soft tissues of the medial knee, thereby increasing the risk of knee injury. It is worth noting that this study only involves the average knee flexion angle and load after ATR in one athlete. Caution should be exercised when applying the conclusions, and in the future, more participants should be recruited to establish personalized knee finite element models to validate the results.

Association between foot posture and tibiofemoral contact forces during barefoot walking in patients with knee osteoarthritis

BackgroundAccumulating evidence indicates that abnormal foot posture are risk factors for knee osteoarthritis (OA). However, the relationship between foot posture and tibiofemoral contact force (CF) during habitual weight-bearing activities remains unclear. This study aimed to determine the association between tibiofemoral CF and foot posture while walking.MethodsIn total, 18 patients with knee OA and 18 healthy individuals participated in this cross-sectional study. Foot parameters were evaluated by Foot Posture Index (FPI), Staheli Arch Index (SAI), hallux valgus angle, calcaneus inverted angle relative to the floor as a static rearfoot posture, navicular height, and toe grip strength. In addition, all participants underwent kinetic and kinematic measurements during a self-selected speed gait. The measurement device used was the three-dimensional motion analysis system with a sampling rate of 120 Hz. The musculoskeletal model, which has 92 Hill-type muscle–tendon units with 23 degrees of freedom, was used to calculate tibiofemoral CF. Partial correlations was used to investigate the association between foot parameters and total, medial, and lateral tibiofemoral CF of the first and second peaks while controlling for gait speed.ResultsA significant negative correlation was observed between Walking SAI and first peak medial tibiofemoral CF in control participants (r = -0.505, p = 0.039). SAI was also significantly positively correlated with first peak medial tibiofemoral CF in patients with knee OA (r = 0.482, p = 0.042).ConclusionsOur findings revealed a correlation between the medial first peak tibiofemoral CF and the SAI. This study indicates that people with knee OA and flatfoot have excessive first medial tibiofemoral CF during walking.

Techniques to determine knee joint contact forces during squatting: A systematic review.

This review article provides an overview of techniques used to determine human knee joint contact forces during squatting. The main two approaches are experimental and theoretical. Thigh calf contact has a significant effect on knee forces and should not be neglected. In this study, data were searched electronically and organized by techniques to find knee joint contact force during squatting theoretically and experimentally. There was a large variation in peak tibiofemoral (CV = 0.45) and patellofemoral (CV = 0.38) contact forces predicted theoretically. However, very little variation was observed between peak tibiofemoral contact forces (CV = 0.12) measured in vivo experimentally but measured knee joint force is available up to a limited knee flexion angle. There was a reduction in knee joint contact forces due to thigh calf contact. Literature of knee joint contact force prediction theoretically during squatting incorporating thigh calf contact force is very limited.

Between-Limb Symmetry in ACL and Tibiofemoral Contact Forces in Athletes After ACL Reconstruction and Clearance for Return to Sport.

Background:Current return-to-sport (RTS) criteria after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction (ACLR) include demonstrating symmetry in functional and strength tests. It remains unknown if at the time that athletes are cleared to RTS, they exhibit between-limb symmetry in ACL and tibiofemoral contact forces or if these forces are comparable with those in uninjured athletes.Purposes:To (1) examine ACL and tibiofemoral contact forces in athletes who underwent ACLR and were cleared to RTS and (2) compare the involved leg to the healthy contralateral leg and healthy controls during functional tasks.Study Design:Cross-sectional study; Level of evidence, 3.Methods:A total of 26 male athletes who underwent ACLR were tested at the time of RTS during tasks that included single-leg vertical, horizontal, and side jumps; cutting maneuvers; and high-intensity running. We used an electromyography-constrained musculoskeletal modeling workflow to estimate ACL and tibiofemoral contact forces and compared the results with those of 23 healthy male participants.Results:The ACLR group presented no differences in peak tibiofemoral contact forces in the involved limb compared with the control group. However, there were significant between-limb differences mainly due to higher contact forces in the uninvolved (healthy) limb of the ACLR group compared with the control group. In the ACLR group, ACL forces were significantly higher in the uninvolved limb compared with the involved limb during cutting and running. Lateral contact forces were lower in the involved compared with the uninvolved limb, with large effect sizes during cutting (d = 1.14; P < .001) and running (d = 1.10; P < .001).Conclusion:Current discharge criteria for clearance to RTS after ACLR did not ensure the restoration of symmetric loading in our cohort of male athletes. ACL force asymmetry was observed during cutting and running, in addition to knee loading asymmetries on several tasks tested.

On the impact force analysis of two-leg landing with a flexed knee

This article looks into the effects of the initial knee flexion angle at the contact time on the peak of the impulsive lower limb forces during landing, and how these effects are related to muscular activities. The impact dynamics of drop landing is studied via a musculoskeletal model with eight Hill-type lower-limb muscles. A method is proposed for the representation of two landing strategies: landing with high and low joint stiffness. Then, in each landing strategy, the effect of the initial knee flexion angle on the peak ground reaction force (GRF), the peak knee ligaments force and the peak tibiofemoral contact force is investigated by considering different initial contact postures. It is observed that while landing with a flexed knee decreases the peak GRF in both landing strategies, it decreases the peak tibiofemoral and knee ligaments forces only in landing with low joint stiffness. Specifically, by increasing the initial knee flexion from 0° to 70°, the peak tibiofemoral and knee ligaments forces decrease monotonically by 54% and 82%, in landing with low joint stiffness. For high joint stiffness, however, as the initial knee flexion increases from 10° to 70°, the peak tibiofemoral force is seen to increase monotonically by 42% and the peak knee ligaments force is seen to have a non-monotonic behavior, first decreasing by 42%, and then, increasing by 250%. These results can be considered in training landing strategies to reduce the risk of knee injury.

Large medial proximal tibial angles cause excessively medial tibiofemoral contact forces and abnormal knee kinematics following open-wedge high tibial osteotomy

BackgroundRecurrent varus deformity and poor outcome sometimes occur following open-wedge high tibial osteotomy, but the mechanism remains unclear. The hypothesis of this study was that an excessively large medial proximal tibial angle with lateral joint surface inclination can worsen postoperative knee biomechanics. MethodsA computer-simulated knee model was validated based on a volunteer knee. Osteotomy models with medial proximal tibial angles ranging from 90° to 97° in 1° increments were developed. Varus alignment correction of the distal femur was performed in each model to maintain identical coronal alignment passing through a point 62.5% lateral to the tibial plateau. The peak tibiofemoral contact forces and knee kinematics were compared in each model during walking and squatting. FindingsAll the osteotomy models demonstrated higher peak contact forces on the lateral tibiofemoral joints than on the medial tibiofemoral joints during walking. However, larger medial proximal tibial angles caused excessive increases in medial tibiofemoral contact forces, and the dominant tibiofemoral contact forces shifted to the medial side. Increased medial proximal tibial angles also caused progressive medial collateral ligament tension in knee flexion, but partial medial collateral ligament release effectively reduced medial tibiofemoral contact forces. Models with large medial proximal tibial angles showed nonphysiological roll-forward of the lateral femoral condyle during squatting and no screw-home movement around knee extension. InterpretationExcessively large medial proximal tibial angles following open-wedge high tibial osteotomy resulted in increased medial tibiofemoral contact forces and abnormal knee kinematics during knee flexion due to medial joint line elevation and ligament imbalance.

Effect of exercise on knee joint contact forces in people following medial partial meniscectomy: A secondary analysis of a randomised controlled trial

BackgroundArthroscopic partial meniscectomy may cause knee osteoarthritis, which may be related to altered joint loading. Previous research has failed to demonstrate that exercise can reduce medial compartment knee loads following meniscectomy but has not considered muscular loading in their estimates. Research questionWhat is the effect of exercise compared to no intervention on peak medial tibiofemoral joint contact force during walking using an electromyogram-driven neuromusculoskeletal model, following medial arthroscopic partial meniscectomy? MethodsThis is a secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial (RCT). 41 participants aged between 30–50 years with medial arthroscopic partial meniscectomy within the past 3–12 months, were randomly allocated to either a 12-week, home-based, physiotherapist-guided exercise program or to no exercise (control group). Three-dimensional lower-body motion, ground reaction forces, and surface electromyograms from eight lower-limb muscles were acquired during self-selected normal- and fast-paced walking at baseline and follow-up. An electromyogram-driven neuromusculoskeletal model estimated medial compartment contact forces (body weight). Linear regression models evaluated between-group differences (mean difference (95% CI)). ResultsThere were no significant between-group differences in the change (follow-up minus baseline) in first peak medial contact force during self-selected normal- or fast-paced walking (0.07 (−0.08 to 0.23), P = 0.34 and 0.01 (−0.19 to 0.22), P = 0.89 respectively). No significant between-group difference was found for change in second peak medial contact force during normal- or fast-paced walking (0.09 (−0.09 to 0.28), P = 0.31 and 0.02 (−0.17 to 0.22), P = 0.81 respectively). At the individual level, variability was observed for changes in first (range −26.2% to +31.7%) and second (range −46.5% to +59.9%) peak tibiofemoral contact force. SignificanceThis is the first study to apply electromyogram-driven neuromusculoskeletal modelling to an exercise intervention in a RCT. While our results suggest that a 12-week exercise program does not alter peak medial knee loads after meniscectomy, within-participant variability suggests individual-specific muscle activation patterns that warrant further investigation.

Chronic Ankle Instability Does Not Influence Tibiofemoral Contact Forces During Drop Landings Using a Musculoskeletal Model.

The purpose of the study was to compare the tibiofemoral contact forces of participants with chronic ankle instability versus controls during landings using a computer-simulated musculoskeletal model. A total of 21 female participants with chronic ankle instability and 21 pair-matched controls performed a drop landing task on a tilted force plate. A 7-camera motion capture system and 2 force plates were used to test participants' lower-extremity biomechanics. A musculoskeletal model was used to calculate the tibiofemoral contact forces (femur on tibia). No significant between-group differences were observed for the peak tibiofemoral contact forces (P = .25-.48) during the landing phase based on paired t tests. The group differences ranged from 0.05 to 0.58 body weight (BW). Most participants demonstrated a posterior force (peak, ∼1.1BW) for most duration of the landing phase and a medial force (peak, ∼0.9BW) and large compressive force (peak, ∼10BW) in the landing phase. The authors conclude that chronic ankle instability may not be related to the increased tibiofemoral contact forces or knee injury mechanisms during landings on the tilted surface.

Muscle contributions to peak tibiofemoral contact forces in anterior cruciate ligament reconstructed females during a sidestep cut

Muscle contributions to peak tibiofemoral contact forces in anterior cruciate ligament reconstructed females during a sidestep cut

Impact of antagonistic muscle co-contraction on in vivo knee contact forces

BackgroundThe onset and progression of osteoarthritis, but also the wear and loosening of the components of an artificial joint, are commonly associated with mechanical overloading of the structures. Knowledge of the mechanical forces acting at the joints, together with an understanding of the key factors that can alter them, are critical to develop effective treatments for restoring joint function. While static anatomy is usually the clinical focus, less is known about the impact of dynamic factors, such as individual muscle recruitment, on joint contact forces.MethodsIn this study, instrumented knee implants provided accurate in vivo tibio-femoral contact forces in a unique cohort of 9 patients, which were used as input for subject specific musculoskeletal models, to quantify the individual muscle forces during walking and stair negotiation.ResultsEven between patients with a very similar self-selected gait speed, the total tibio-femoral peak forces varied 1.7-fold, but had only weak correlation with static alignment (varus/valgus). In some patients, muscle co-contraction of quadriceps and gastrocnemii during walking added up to 1 bodyweight (~ 50%) to the peak tibio-femoral contact force during late stance. The greatest impact of co-contraction was observed in the late stance phase of stair ascent, with an increase of the peak tibio-femoral contact force by up to 1.7 bodyweight (66%).ConclusionsTreatment of diseased and failed joints should therefore not only be restricted to anatomical reconstruction of static limb axes alignment. The dynamic activation of muscles, as a key modifier of lower limb biomechanics, should also be taken into account and thus also represents a promising target for restoring function, patient mobility, and preventing future joint failure.Trial registrationGerman Clinical Trials Register: ID: DRKS00000606, date: 05.11.2010.

Immediate effects of valgus knee bracing on tibiofemoral contact forces and knee muscle forces

Background Valgus knee braces have been reported to reduce the external knee adduction moment during walking. However, mechanistic investigations into the effects of valgus bracing on medial compartment contact forces using electromyogram-driven neuromusculoskeletal models are limited.Research question What are the immediate effects of valgus bracing on medial tibiofemoral contact forces and muscular loading of the tibiofemoral joint?Methods Sixteen (9 male) healthy adults (27.7 ± 4.4 years) performed 20 over-ground walking trials at self-selected speed both with and without an Ossür Unloader One® brace. Assessment order (i.e., with or without brace) was randomised and counterbalanced to prevent order effects. While walking, three-dimensional lower-body motion, ground reaction forces, and surface electromyograms from eight lower-limb muscles were acquired. These data were used to calibrate an electromyogram-driven neuromusculoskeletal model of muscle and tibiofemoral contact forces (N), from which muscle and external load contributions (%) to those contact forces were determined.Results Although walking with the brace resulted in no significant changes in peak tibiofemoral contact forces at the group-level, individual responses were variable and non-uniform. At the group-level, wearing the brace resulted in a 2.35% (95% CI 0.46–4.24; p = 0.02) greater relative contribution of muscle to lateral compartment contact loading (54.2 ± 11.1%) compared to not wearing the brace (51.8 ± 12.1%) (p < 0.05). Average relative contributions of muscle and external loads to medial compartment loading were comparable between brace and no brace conditions (p ≥ 0.05).Significance Wearing a valgus knee brace did not immediately reduce peak tibiofemoral contact forces in healthy adults during normal walking. It appears this population may modulate muscle activation patterns to support brace-generated valgus moments, thereby maintaining normal walking knee moments and tibiofemoral contact forces. Future investigations are warranted to better understand effects of valgus knee brace in people with medial knee osteoarthritis using an electromyogram-driven neuromusculoskeletal model.

Three-dimensional knee joint contact forces during walking in unilateral transtibial amputees

Individuals with unilateral transtibial amputations have greater prevalence of osteoarthritis in the intact knee joint relative to the residual leg and non-amputees, but the cause of this greater prevalence is unclear. The purpose of this study was to compare knee joint contact forces and the muscles contributing to these forces between amputees and non-amputees during walking using forward dynamics simulations. We predicted that the intact knee contact forces would be higher than those of the residual leg and non-amputees. In the axial and mediolateral directions, the intact and non-amputee legs had greater peak tibio-femoral contact forces and impulses relative to the residual leg. The peak axial contact force was greater in the intact leg relative to the non-amputee leg, but the stance phase impulse was greater in the non-amputee leg. The vasti and hamstrings muscles in early stance and gastrocnemius in late stance were the largest contributors to the joint contact forces in the non-amputee and intact legs. Through dynamic coupling, the soleus and gluteus medius also had large contributions, even though they do not span the knee joint. In the residual leg, the prosthesis had large contributions to the joint forces, similar to the soleus in the intact and non-amputee legs. These results identify the muscles that contribute to knee joint contact forces during transtibial amputee walking and suggest that the peak knee contact forces may be more important than the knee contact impulses in explaining the high prevalence of intact leg osteoarthritis.

Clinically-relevant measures associated with altered contact forces in patients with anterior cruciate ligament deficiency

BackgroundKnee joint contact forces are altered after anterior cruciate ligament injury during walking and may be related to clinically-relevant measures of impairments or self-reported function. The purpose of this study was to investigate the association of several clinically-relevant measures with altered knee contact forces in patients with anterior cruciate ligament injury. MethodsData for this study represent a cross-sectional observational analysis of thirty-seven (23 M, 14 F) patients with complete unilateral anterior cruciate ligament injury. Gait analysis with electromyography was used to obtain estimates of tibiofemoral joint contact force using an electromyography-driven musculoskeletal model. Multivariable linear regression was used to identify measures associated with tibiofemoral joint contact force. FindingsInvolved knee extensor muscle strength and patient-reported knee function on the Global Rating Scale of perceived function were significantly associated with peak tibiofemoral contact force for the involved limb. Patients who were stronger and who perceived higher knee function walked with greater contact forces on their involved knees. After controlling for walking speed, involved extensor strength explained 8.9% of the variance in involved peak tibiofemoral contact force and score on the Global Rating Scale explained an additional 9.4% of the variance. InterpretationImprovements in involved quadriceps strength and overall function as measured by patient self-report may be important for increasing involved limb contact forces, thereby restoring loading symmetry in these patients who demonstrate decreased involved limb loading after injury. These results highlight the potential value of studying the recovery of strength, self-reported function and joint loading symmetry in patients with anterior cruciate ligament injury.

Subject-specific knee joint geometry improves predictions of medial tibiofemoral contact forces

Estimating tibiofemoral joint contact forces is important for understanding the initiation and progression of knee osteoarthritis. However, tibiofemoral contact force predictions are influenced by many factors including muscle forces and anatomical representations of the knee joint. This study aimed to investigate the influence of subject-specific geometry and knee joint kinematics on the prediction of tibiofemoral contact forces using a calibrated EMG-driven neuromusculoskeletal model of the knee. One participant fitted with an instrumented total knee replacement walked at a self-selected speed while medial and lateral tibiofemoral contact forces, ground reaction forces, whole-body kinematics, and lower-limb muscle activity were simultaneously measured. The combination of generic and subject-specific knee joint geometry and kinematics resulted in four different OpenSim models used to estimate muscle–tendon lengths and moment arms. The subject-specific geometric model was created from CT scans and the subject-specific knee joint kinematics representing the translation of the tibia relative to the femur was obtained from fluoroscopy. The EMG-driven model was calibrated using one walking trial, but with three different cost functions that tracked the knee flexion/extension moments with and without constraint over the estimated joint contact forces. The calibrated models then predicted the medial and lateral tibiofemoral contact forces for five other different walking trials. The use of subject-specific models with minimization of the peak tibiofemoral contact forces improved the accuracy of medial contact forces by 47% and lateral contact forces by 7%, respectively compared with the use of generic musculoskeletal model.

Minimum detectable change for knee joint contact force estimates using an EMG-driven model

Adequate test–retest reliability of model estimates is a necessary precursor to examining treatment effects or longitudinal changes in individuals. PurposeThe purpose of this study was to establish thresholds for minimal detectable change (MDC) for joint contact forces obtained using a patient specific EMG-driven musculoskeletal model of the knee. DesignA sample of young, active individuals was selected for this study, and subjects were tested on 2 separate days. Three-dimensional motion analysis with electromyography (EMG) was used to obtain data from each subject during gait for model input. An EMG-driven modeling approach was used to estimate joint contact forces at each session. ResultsMDC's for contact force variables ranged from 0.30 to 0.66BW. The lowest MDC was for peak medial compartment force (0.30BW) and the highest was for peak tibiofemoral contact force (0.66 BW). Test–retest reliability coefficients were also reported for comparison with previous work. ConclusionsUsing the present model, changes in joint contact forces between baseline and subsequent measurements that are greater than these MDCs are greater than typical day-to-day variation and can be identified as real change.

Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury: Compensation during Gait using Hamstring Muscle Activity

Previous research has shown that an increase in hamstring activation may compensate for anterior tibial transalation (ATT) in patients with anterior cruciate ligament deficient knee (ACLd); however, the effects of this compensation still remain unclear. The goals of this study were to quantify the activation of the hamstring muscles needed to compensate the ATT in ACLd knee during the complete gait cycle and to evaluate the effect of this compensation on quadriceps activation and joint contact forces. A two dimensional model of the knee was used, which included the tibiofemoral and patellofemoral joints, knee ligaments, the medial capsule and two muscles units. Simulations were conducted to determine the ATT in healthy and ACLd knee and the hamstring activation needed to correct the abnormal ATT to normal levels (100% compensation) and to 50% compensation. Then, the quadriceps activation and the joint contact forces were calculated. Results showed that 100% compensation would require hamstring and quadriceps activations larger than their maximum isometric force, and would generate an increment in the peak contact force at the tibiofemoral (115%) and patellofemoral (48%) joint with respect to the healthy knee. On the other hand, 50% compensation would require less force generated by the muscles (less than 0.85 of maximum isometric force) and smaller contact forces (peak tibiofemoral contact force increased 23% and peak patellofemoral contact force decreased 7.5% with respect to the healthy knee). Total compensation of ATT by means of increased hamstring activity is possible; however, partial compensation represents a less deleterious strategy.

An optimal control model for determining articular contact forces at the human knee during rising from a static squat position

A two-dimensional dynamic model of the knee joint was incorporated into a four-segment, eight-muscle model of the human body to determine the muscle, ligament, and articular contact forces transmitted at the knee as humans stand up from a static squatting position. Our optimal control model predicted peak tibiofemoral contact forces 8 times as high as body weight. Furthermore, ligament forces, especially those in the anterior-cruciate, were nearly body weight as knee flexion approached 90 degrees. Ligament and tibiofemoral contact loads were dominated by the forces exerted by muscles during the movement.