Pathway-selective Ligands Research Articles

Highly biased agonism for GPCR ligands via nanobody tethering

Ligand-induced activation of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) can initiate signaling through multiple distinct pathways with differing biological and physiological outcomes. There is intense interest in understanding how variation in GPCR ligand structure can be used to promote pathway selective signaling (“biased agonism”) with the goal of promoting desirable responses and avoiding deleterious side effects. Here we present an approach in which a conventional peptide ligand for the type 1 parathyroid hormone receptor (PTHR1) is converted from an agonist which induces signaling through all relevant pathways to a compound that is highly selective for a single pathway. This is achieved not through variation in the core structure of the agonist, but rather by linking it to a nanobody tethering agent that binds with high affinity to a separate site on the receptor not involved in signal transduction. The resulting conjugate represents the most biased agonist of PTHR1 reported to date. This approach holds promise for facile generation of pathway selective ligands for other GPCRs.

Visible-Light Photoswitchable Benzimidazole Azo-Arenes as β-Arrestin2-Biased Selective Cannabinoid 2 Receptor Agonists.

The cannabinoid 2 receptor (CB2 R) has high therapeutic potential for multiple pathogenic processes, such as neuroinflammation. Pathway-selective ligands are needed to overcome the lack of clinical success and to elucidate correlations between pathways and their respective therapeutic effects. Herein, we report the design and synthesis of a photoswitchable scaffold based on the privileged structure of benzimidazole and its application as a functionally selective CB2 R "efficacy-switch". Benzimidazole azo-arenes offer huge potential for the broad extension of photopharmacology to a wide range of optically addressable biological targets. We used this scaffold to develop compound 10 d, a "trans-on" agonist, which serves as a molecular probe to study the β-arrestin2 (βarr2) pathway at CB2 R. βΑrr2 bias was observed in CB2 R internalization and βarr2 recruitment, while no activation occurred when looking at Gα16 or mini-Gαi . Overall, compound 10 d is the first light-dependent functionally selective agonist to investigate the complex mechanisms of CB2 R-βarr2 dependent endocytosis.

Mit sichtbarem Licht schaltbare Benzimidazol‐Azo‐Arene wirken als β‐Arrestin2 funktionell selektive Cannabinoid‐Rezeptor 2 Agonisten

AbstractDer Cannabinoid 2 Rezeptor (CB2R) besitzt großes therapeutisches Potential bei zahlreichen pathophysiologischen Prozessen wie z. B. der Neuroinflammation. Signalweg‐selektive Liganden werden benötigt, um mangelnden klinischen Erfolg zu überwinden und um die Zusammenhänge zwischen einzelnen Signalwegen und deren therapeutischen Effekten zu beleuchten. Hier berichten wir vom Design und der Synthese eines photoschaltbaren chemischen Gerüsts basierend auf der “privilegierten” Struktur des Benzimidazols und seiner Anwendung als funktionell selektiven CB2R “Wirksamkeitsschalter” (”efficacy switch”). Benzimidazol‐Azo‐Arene bieten großes Potential für eine breite Erweiterung der Photopharmakologie auf eine Vielzahl optisch adressierbarer biologischer Zielstrukturen. Wir haben dieses Gerüst verwendet, um Substanz 10 d zu entwickeln, ein “trans‐on” Agonist, der als molekulare Sonde dient, um den β‐Arrestin2 (βArr2) Signalweg am CB2R zu untersuchen. Die selektive Aktivierung des βΑrr2 Signalweges wurde mittels CB2R Internalisierung und βArr2 Rekrutierung nachgewiesen, während keine Aktivierung bei der Betrachtung von Gα16 oder mini‐Gαi auftrat. Insgesamt stellt Substanz 10 d den ersten Licht‐abhängigen funktionell selektiven Agonisten dar, mit dem die komplexen βArr2‐abhängigen Mechanismen der Endozytose am CB2R untersucht werden können.

Biased agonists at the human Y1 receptor lead to prolonged membrane residency and extended receptor G protein interaction.

Functionally selective ligands to address specific cellular responses downstream of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCR) open up new possibilities for therapeutics. We designed and characterized novel subtype- and pathway-selective ligands. Substitution of position Q34 of neuropeptide Y to glycine (G34-NPY) results in unprecedented selectivity over all other YR subtypes. Moreover, this ligand displays a significant bias towards activation of the Gi/o pathway over recruitment of arrestin-3. Notably, no bias is observed for an established Y1R versus Y2R selective ligand carrying a proline at position 34 (F7,P34-NPY). Next, we investigated the spatio-temporal signaling at the Y1R and demonstrated that G protein-biased ligands promote a prolonged localization at the cell membrane, which leads to enhanced G protein signaling, while endosomal receptors do not contribute to cAMP signaling. Thus, spatial components are critical for the signaling of the Y1R that can be modulated by tailored ligands and represent a novel mode for biased pathways.

Fulfilling the Promise of "Biased" G Protein-Coupled Receptor Agonism.

The fact that over 30% of current pharmaceuticals target heptahelical G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) attests to their tractability as drug targets. Although GPCR drug development has traditionally focused on conventional agonists and antagonists, the growing appreciation that GPCRs mediate physiologically relevant effects via both G protein and non-G protein effectors has prompted the search for ligands that can "bias" downstream signaling in favor of one or the other process. Biased ligands are novel entities with distinct signaling profiles dictated by ligand structure, and the potential prospect of biased ligands as better drugs has been pleonastically proclaimed. Indeed, preclinical proof-of-concept studies have demonstrated that both G protein and arrestin pathway-selective ligands can promote beneficial effects in vivo while simultaneously antagonizing deleterious ones. But along with opportunity comes added complexity and new challenges for drug discovery. If ligands can be biased, then ligand classification becomes assay dependent, and more nuanced screening approaches are needed to capture ligand efficacy across several dimensions of signaling. Moreover, because the signaling repertoire of biased ligands differs from that of the native agonist, unpredicted responses may arise in vivo as these unbalanced signals propagate. For any given GPCR target, establishing a framework relating in vitro efficacy to in vivo biologic response is crucial to biased drug discovery. This review discusses approaches to describing ligand efficacy in vitro, translating ligand bias into biologic response, and developing a systems-level understanding of biased agonism in vivo, with the overall goal of overcoming current barriers to developing biased GPCR therapeutics.

Structure-activity relationships of privileged structures lead to the discovery of novel biased ligands at the dopamine D₂ receptor.

Biased agonism at GPCRs highlights the potential for the discovery and design of pathway-selective ligands and may confer therapeutic advantages to ligands targeting the dopamine D2 receptor (D2R). We investigated the determinants of efficacy, affinity, and bias for three privileged structures for the D2R, exploring changes to linker length and incorporation of a heterocyclic unit. Profiling the compounds in two signaling assays (cAMP and pERK1/2) allowed us to identify and quantify determinants of biased agonism at the D2R. Substitution on the phenylpiperazine privileged structures (2-methoxy vs 2,3-dichloro) influenced bias when the thienopyridine heterocycle was absent. Upon inclusion of the thienopyridine unit, the substitution pattern (4,6-dimethyl vs 5-chloro-6-methoxy-4-methyl) had a significant effect on bias that overruled the effect of the phenylpiperazine substitution pattern. This latter observation could be reconciled with an extended binding mode for these compounds, whereby the interaction of the heterocycle with a secondary binding pocket may engender bias.

Predicting kinase activity in angiotensin receptor phosphoproteomes based on sequence-motifs and interactions.

Recent progress in the understanding of seven-transmembrane receptor (7TMR) signalling has promoted the development of a new generation of pathway selective ligands. The angiotensin II type I receptor (AT1aR) is one of the most studied 7TMRs with respect to selective activation of the β-arrestin dependent signalling. Two complimentary global phosphoproteomics studies have analyzed the complex signalling induced by the AT1aR. Here we integrate the data sets from these studies and perform a joint analysis using a novel method for prediction of differential kinase activity from phosphoproteomics data. The method builds upon NetworKIN, which applies sophisticated linear motif analysis in combination with contextual network modelling to predict kinase-substrate associations with high accuracy and sensitivity. These predictions form the basis for subsequently nonparametric statistical analysis to identify likely activated kinases. This suggested that AT1aR-dependent signalling activates 48 of the 285 kinases detected in HEK293 cells. Of these, Aurora B, CLK3 and PKG1 have not previously been described in the pathway whereas others, such as PKA, PKB and PKC, are well known. In summary, we have developed a new method for kinase-centric analysis of phosphoproteomes to pinpoint differential kinase activity in large-scale data sets.

A Structure–Activity Analysis of Biased Agonism at the Dopamine D2 Receptor

Biased agonism offers an opportunity for the medicinal chemist to discover pathway-selective ligands for GPCRs. A number of studies have suggested that biased agonism at the dopamine D2 receptor (D2R) may be advantageous for the treatment of neuropsychiatric disorders, including schizophrenia. As such, it is of great importance to gain insight into the SAR of biased agonism at this receptor. We have generated SAR based on a novel D2R partial agonist, tert-butyl (trans-4-(2-(3,4-dihydroisoquinolin-2(1H)-yl)ethyl)cyclohexyl)carbamate (4). This ligand shares structural similarity to cariprazine (2), a drug awaiting FDA approval for the treatment of schizophrenia, yet displays a distinct bias toward two different signaling end points. We synthesized a number of derivatives of 4 with subtle structural modifications, including incorporation of cariprazine fragments. By combining pharmacological profiling with analytical methodology to identify and to quantify bias, we have demonstrated that efficacy and biased agonism can be finely tuned by minor structural modifications to the head group containing the tertiary amine, a tail group that extends away from this moiety, and the orientation and length of a spacer region between these two moieties.

Emergent biological properties of arrestin pathway-selective biased agonism

Our growing appreciation of the pluridimensionality of G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) signaling, combined with the phenomenon of orthosteric ligand “bias”, has created the possibility of drugs that selectively modulate different aspects of GPCR function for therapeutic benefit. When viewed from the short-term perspective, e.g. changes in receptor conformation, effector coupling or second messenger generation, biased ligands appear to activate a subset of the response profile produced by a conventional agonist. Yet when examined in vivo, the limited data available suggest that biased ligand effects can diverge from their conventional counterparts in ways that cannot be predicted from their in vitro efficacy profile. What is currently missing, at least with respect to G protein and arrestin pathway-selective ligands, is a rational framework for relating the in vitro efficacy of a “biased” agonist to its in vivo actions that will enable drug screening programs to identify ligands with the desired biological effects.

Estrogen Receptor Dependent Inhibitors of NF-κB Transcriptional Activation-1 Synthesis and Biological Evaluation of Substituted 2-Cyanopropanoic Acid Derivatives: Pathway Selective Inhibitors of NF-κB, a Potential Treatment for Rheumatoid Arthritis

Pathway selective ligands of the estrogen receptor inhibit transcriptional activation of proinflammatory genes mediated by NF-kappaB. Substituted 2-cyanopropanoic acid derivatives were developed leading to the discovery of WAY-204688, an orally active, pathway selective, estrogen receptor dependent anti-inflammatory agent. This propanamide was shown to be orally active in preclinical models of inflammatory diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis, without the proliferative effect associated with traditional estrogens.

Estrogens and SERMs in coronary heart disease

Estrogen combines beneficial and harmful actions by affecting many intracellular pathways in a large number of target organs related to the cardiovascular system. In observational studies and large outcome trials, an improvement of serum lipid profile and reduction of cardiovascular event rate were reported, whereas thrombembolic complications and stroke rate increased. Recognition of the diversity and tissue selectivity of estrogen's effects prompted the development of selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs), which were subsequently used to dissect the different mechanisms of action. SERMs are estrogen receptor (ER) ligands that exert partial agonist or antagonist actions on the ER in a tissue-, pathway- or isoform-specific manner. As ER ligands, they trigger a large variety of effects, including extranuclear ER actions, which can be further modulated by coactivators, corepressors and potential novel estrogen-binding proteins/receptors. Thus, SERMs can display tissue- or pathway-specific effects, or a combination of these. Pharmacological and clinical data are available for the classical SERM prototypes raloxifene and tamoxifene, as well as for new SERMs in different stages of development, isotype-specific agonists and pathway-selective ligands. These compounds exert many different effects, including vasodilatation in coronary arteries, altered responses to ischemic damage, hypertrophy of the myocardium, and improvement in serum cholesterol and lipid profile. The development of future SERMs will focus on different indications, including hormone therapy or cardiovascular disease. However, they all should antagonize estrogen action in female reproductive organs, yet protect from bone loss and not interfere with the beneficial effects of estrogen in the brain.

Control of Chronic Inflammation with Pathway Selective Estrogen Receptor Ligands

The discovery of novel intervention points in the inflammatory pathway has been a focus of drug development in recent years. We have identified pathway selective ligands for the estrogen receptor (ER) that inhibit NF-kappaB mediated inflammatory gene expression causing a reduction of cytokines, chemokines, adhesion molecules and inflammatory enzymes. SAR development of a series of 4-(Indazol-3-yl)-phenols has led to the identification of WAY-169916 an orally active non-steroidal ligand with the potential use in the treatment of inflammatory diseases without the classical proliferative effects associated with non-selective estrogens.

THE ACTIVITY OF PATHWAY-SELECTIVE ESTROGEN RECEPTOR LIGANDS IN EXPERIMENTAL SEPTIC SHOCK

Estrogen receptors (ER) are widely expressed in multiple genital and nongenital tissues. Upon engagement of these receptors, multiple genes are affected in target tissues via estrogen response elements. Nonsteroidal pathway-selective ER ligands have recently been identified that inhibit NF-kappaB transcriptional activity and are devoid of conventional estrogenic activities on genital tissues. These pathway-selective ligands are potent anti-inflammatory agents in vivo and may prove to be of therapeutic utility in systemic inflammatory states. These pathway-selective ER ligands were tested in the murine listeriosis model, the neutropenic rat model, and the mouse cecal ligation and puncture model. WAY-204688 did not have any significant activity after systemic infection by Listeria monocytogenes. In the neutropenic rat model, WAY-204688 provided a significant survival benefit against an otherwise lethal challenge of Pseudomonas aeruginosa 12.4.4 compared with the control group (88% versus 25% survival; P < 0.05). Preservation of mucosal weight and prevention of histopathologic changes were observed with the administration of WAY-204688. Similar findings were observed in a cecal ligation and puncture model with WAY-204688 and a related compound WAY-169916. These results indicate that oral administration of these pathway-selective ER ligands preserved gastrointestinal barrier function and improve outcome in experimental models of systemic infection and inflammation. These agents may prove to be useful clinically as a novel treatment strategy for severe sepsis.

Synthesis and Activity of Substituted 4-(Indazol-3-yl)phenols as Pathway-Selective Estrogen Receptor Ligands Useful in the Treatment of Rheumatoid Arthritis

Pathway-selective ligands for the estrogen receptor (ER) inhibit NF-kappaB-mediated inflammatory gene expression causing a reduction of cytokines, chemokines, adhesion molecules, and inflammatory enzymes. SAR development of a series of 4-(indazol-3-yl)phenols has led to the identification of WAY-169916 an orally active nonsteroidal ligand with the potential use in the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis without the classical proliferative effects associated with estrogens.