Pathogen-induced Programmed Cell Death Research Articles

Polycomb Repressive Complex 2 and KRYPTONITE regulate pathogen-induced programmed cell death in Arabidopsis.

The Polycomb Repressive Complex 2 (PRC2) is well-known for its role in controlling developmental transitions by suppressing the premature expression of key developmental regulators. Previous work revealed that PRC2 also controls the onset of senescence, a form of developmental programmed cell death (PCD) in plants. Whether the induction of PCD in response to stress is similarly suppressed by the PRC2 remained largely unknown. In this study, we explored whether PCD triggered in response to immunity- and disease-promoting pathogen effectors is associated with changes in the distribution of the PRC2-mediated histone H3 lysine 27 trimethylation (H3K27me3) modification in Arabidopsis thaliana. We furthermore tested the distribution of the heterochromatic histone mark H3K9me2, which is established, to a large extent, by the H3K9 methyltransferase KRYPTONITE, and occupies chromatin regions generally not targeted by PRC2. We report that effector-induced PCD caused major changes in the distribution of both repressive epigenetic modifications and that both modifications have a regulatory role and impact on the onset of PCD during pathogen infection. Our work highlights that the transition to pathogen-induced PCD is epigenetically controlled, revealing striking similarities to developmental PCD.

EDS1-mediated activation of autophagy regulates Pst DC3000 (AvrRps4)-induced programmed cell death in Arabidopsis

Autophagy is a conserved intracellular process through which cytoplasmic components are degraded and recycled under stress conditions. In the innate immunity of higher plants, autophagy has either pro-survival or pro-death functions in pathogen-induced programmed cell death (PCD). In aged leaves, autophagy negatively regulates PCD by eliminating redundant salicylic acid. However, in young leaves, the specific pro-death mechanisms of autophagy and signaling pathways related to the autophagic process have not been elucidated. Here, we demonstrate that enhanced disease susceptibility 1 (EDS1) mediated the activation of autophagy and played a key role in the pro-death mechanism of autophagy during avirulent Pst DC3000 (AvrRps4) infection. The path through which autophagosomes enter the vacuole was blocked. Additionally, formation of the ATG12–ATG5 complex and the level of enzymatic activity associated with ATG8 cleavage decreased in eds1 mutants. The expression of EDS1 in atg5 mutants was also much lower than that in wild-type plants during pathogen-triggered PCD. These findings implied that EDS1 may regulate autophagy by affecting the activities of the two ubiquitin-like protein-conjugating pathways. Moreover, autophagy may regulate immunity-related PCD by affecting the expression of EDS1 in young plants. Our results provide important insights into the mechanisms of EDS1 in autophagy during infection with avirulent Pst DC3000 (AvrRps4) in Arabidopsis.

Deregulation of Plant Cell Death Through Disruption of Chloroplast Functionality Affects Asexual Sporulation of Zymoseptoria tritici on Wheat.

Chloroplasts have a critical role in plant defense as sites for the biosynthesis of the signaling compounds salicylic acid (SA), jasmonic acid (JA), and nitric oxide (NO) and as major sites of reactive oxygen species production. Chloroplasts, therefore, regarded as important players in the induction and regulation of programmed cell death (PCD) in response to abiotic stresses and pathogen attack. The predominantly foliar pathogen of wheat Zymoseptoria tritici is proposed to exploit the plant PCD, which is associated with the transition in the fungus to the necrotrophic phase of infection. In this study virus-induced gene silencing was used to silence two key genes in carotenoid and chlorophyll biosynthesis, phytoene desaturase (PDS) and Mg-chelatase H subunit (ChlH). The chlorophyll-deficient, PDS- and ChlH-silenced leaves of susceptible plants underwent more rapid pathogen-induced PCD but were significantly less able to support the subsequent asexual sporulation of Z. tritici. Conversely, major gene (Stb6)-mediated resistance to Z. tritici was partially compromised in PDS- and ChlH-silenced leaves. Chlorophyll-deficient wheat ears also displayed increased Z. tritici disease lesion formation accompanied by increased asexual sporulation. These data highlight the importance of chloroplast functionality and its interaction with regulated plant cell death in mediating different genotype and tissue-specific interactions between Z. tritici and wheat.

Nitric oxide, antioxidants and prooxidants in plant defence responses.

In plant cells the free radical nitric oxide (NO) interacts both with anti- as well as prooxidants. This review provides a short survey of the central roles of ascorbate and glutathione—the latter alone or in conjunction with S-nitrosoglutathione reductase—in controlling NO bioavailability. Other major topics include the regulation of antioxidant enzymes by NO and the interplay between NO and reactive oxygen species (ROS). Under stress conditions NO regulates antioxidant enzymes at the level of activity and gene expression, which can cause either enhancement or reduction of the cellular redox status. For instance chronic NO production during salt stress induced the antioxidant system thereby increasing salt tolerance in various plants. In contrast, rapid NO accumulation in response to strong stress stimuli was occasionally linked to inhibition of antioxidant enzymes and a subsequent rise in hydrogen peroxide levels. Moreover, during incompatible Arabidopsis thaliana-Pseudomonas syringae interactions ROS burst and cell death progression were shown to be terminated by S-nitrosylation-triggered inhibition of NADPH oxidases, further highlighting the multiple roles of NO during redox-signaling. In chemical reactions between NO and ROS reactive nitrogen species (RNS) arise with characteristics different from their precursors. Recently, peroxynitrite formed by the reaction of NO with superoxide has attracted much attention. We will describe putative functions of this molecule and other NO derivatives in plant cells. Non-symbiotic hemoglobins (nsHb) were proposed to act in NO degradation. Additionally, like other oxidases nsHb is also capable of catalyzing protein nitration through a nitrite- and hydrogen peroxide-dependent process. The physiological significance of the described findings under abiotic and biotic stress conditions will be discussed with a special emphasis on pathogen-induced programmed cell death (PCD).

The LSD1-interacting protein GILP is a LITAF domain protein that negatively regulates hypersensitive cell death in Arabidopsis.

BackgroundHypersensitive cell death, a form of avirulent pathogen-induced programmed cell death (PCD), is one of the most efficient plant innate immunity. However, its regulatory mechanism is poorly understood. AtLSD1 is an important negative regulator of PCD and only two proteins, AtbZIP10 and AtMC1, have been reported to interact with AtLSD1.Methodology/Principal FindingsTo identify a novel regulator of hypersensitive cell death, we investigate the possible role of plant LITAF domain protein GILP in hypersensitive cell death. Subcellular localization analysis showed that AtGILP is localized in the plasma membrane and its plasma membrane localization is dependent on its LITAF domain. Yeast two-hybrid and pull-down assays demonstrated that AtGILP interacts with AtLSD1. Pull-down assays showed that both the N-terminal and the C-terminal domains of AtGILP are sufficient for interactions with AtLSD1 and that the N-terminal domain of AtLSD1 is involved in the interaction with AtGILP. Real-time PCR analysis showed that AtGILP expression is up-regulated by the avirulent pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 avrRpt2 (Pst avrRpt2) and fumonisin B1 (FB1) that trigger PCD. Compared with wild-type plants, transgenic plants overexpressing AtGILP exhibited significantly less cell death when inoculated with Pst avrRpt2, indicating that AtGILP negatively regulates hypersensitive cell death.Conclusions/SignificanceThese results suggest that the LITAF domain protein AtGILP localizes in the plasma membrane, interacts with AtLSD1, and is involved in negatively regulating PCD. We propose that AtGILP functions as a membrane anchor, bringing other regulators of PCD, such as AtLSD1, to the plasma membrane. Human LITAF domain protein may be involved in the regulation of PCD, suggesting the evolutionarily conserved function of LITAF domain proteins in the regulation of PCD.

The Hypersensitive Induced Reaction and Leucine-Rich Repeat Proteins Regulate Plant Cell Death Associated with Disease and Plant Immunity

Pathogen-induced programmed cell death (PCD) is intimately linked with disease resistance and susceptibility. However, the molecular components regulating PCD, including hypersensitive and susceptible cell death, are largely unknown in plants. In this study, we show that pathogen-induced Capsicum annuum hypersensitive induced reaction 1 (CaHIR1) and leucine-rich repeat 1 (CaLRR1) function as distinct plant PCD regulators in pepper plants during Xanthomonas campestris pv. vesicatoria infection. Confocal microscopy and protein gel blot analyses revealed that CaLRR1 and CaHIR1 localize to the extracellular matrix and plasma membrane (PM), respectively. Bimolecular fluorescent complementation and coimmunoprecipitation assays showed that the extracellular CaLRR1 specifically binds to the PM-located CaHIR1 in pepper leaves. Overexpression of CaHIR1 triggered pathogen-independent cell death in pepper and Nicotiana benthamiana plants but not in yeast cells. Virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) of CaLRR1 and CaHIR1 distinctly strengthened and compromised hypersensitive and susceptible cell death in pepper plants, respectively. Endogenous salicylic acid levels and pathogenesis-related gene transcripts were elevated in CaHIR1-silenced plants. VIGS of NbLRR1 and NbHIR1, the N. benthamiana orthologs of CaLRR1 and CaHIR1, regulated Bax- and avrPto-/Pto-induced PCD. Taken together, these results suggest that leucine-rich repeat and hypersensitive induced reaction proteins may act as cell-death regulators associated with plant immunity and disease.

The immune response against dying tumor cells: avoid disaster, achieve cure

Metazoans are engaged in a constant combat against infectious microorganisms as well as in a perpetual strive for cohesion of the multicellular ensemble. Paradoxically, one of the most primitive antimicrobial responses consists of the sacrifice via programmed cell death (PCD) of infected cells; a response that is found in all metazoan phyla including plants (which do not possess any mobile cells and hence lack an immune system). In mammals, microbial invasion does not only trigger PCD of infected cells but also elicits an immune reaction, which is hierarchically organized in the first-line response by innate immune effectors (that is infiltrating phagocytes and killer cells) and later recruitment of cognate immune effectors (that is Tand B lymphocytes). Innate immune effectors recognize pathogens, pathogen-infected cells, as well as pathogen-induced cell stress and cell death to eliminate the pathogen (and the infected cell) and to generate a protective immunological memory. One major challenge for the regulation of the immune system (and its comprehension by immunologists) is to distinguish ‘normal’ PCD as it occurs in development and tissue homeostasis from pathogen-induced PCD. Homeostatic PCD should not cause inflammation and should not trigger a cognate immune response (because this would cause autoimmune disease), while pathogen-induced PCD must activate an immune response (first innate and then cognate) to avoid illness and organismal death. As a result, during evolution animals have accumulated a perplexing variety of receptors, which are expressed on the surface or within the cytoplasm of innate immune effectors. These receptors recognize the so-called pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs). As a simple equation, cell death without PAMPs fails to induce an immune response, while cell death that is accompanied by the activation of PAMP receptors, which detect microbial products, does alert the immune system. Nonetheless, the above equation is complicated by the fact that the immune system has an additional, frequently neglected function; it has to eliminate mutated, potentially tumorigenic cells, a process that is called ‘immunosurveillance’. Two major barriers usually avoid the malignant transformation of cells in the human body. First, activation of oncogenes (‘oncogenic stress’) often stimulates a DNA damage response that finally culminates in PCD (either through direct apoptosis or after senescence) and hence elimination of the mutated cells. Second, the immune system recognizes transformed cells, based on the tumor-specific expression of abnormal (mutated or ectopic) molecules, as well as on the abnormal behavior of (pre-)neoplastic cells that respond to oncogenic stress. This implies that, in addition to PAMPs, the so-called ‘danger-associated molecular patterns’ (DAMPs) can trigger the immune response. Efficient recognition of cell death associated with DAMPs is hence important for immunosurveillance. Recently, it has been discovered that chemotherapyinduced cell death can also, at least in some cases, elicit an immune response against dying tumor cells. This immune response is actually required for an optimal therapeutic effect of anticancer chemotherapy. At least in some malignancies, patients that bear major immune defects (including in receptors recognizing specific DAMPs) have a particularly negative prognosis. Thus, immune response elicited by tumor cells that spontaneously undergo apoptosis can abort incipient tumors during immunosurveillance. In addition, immune responses can be triggered by treatment-induced tumor cell deaths, thereby contributing to the therapeutic efficacy of chemotherapy or radiotherapy. The present series of reviews attempt to decipher the intricate interplay between tumor cell death (as it occurs spontaneously in response to chemotherapy or in response to immune effectors), the first-line response of phagocytic cells (in particular, macrophages and dendritic cells) to dying tumor cells, as well as the second-line response of lymphocytes that are instructed to mount a productive or abortive immune response. In this combinatorial game, PCD may affect the tumor cell, the phagocytic cells as well as the tumor-specific T lymphocyte, in a lethal waltz that ultimately determines the fate of the tumor-bearing host. This is the topic of this

Chemical- and Pathogen-Induced Programmed Cell Death in Plants

ABSTRACTThis review focuses on recent update in the understanding of programmed cell death regarding the differences and similarities between the diverse types of cell death in animal and plant systems and describes the morphological and some biochemical determinants. The role of PCD in plant development and stress response, the involvement of plant proteases with similarities to animal caspases and the role of oxidative stress and ethylene have been discussed as key players in plant suicidal machinery. Our contribution to chemical and pathogen-induced cell death in tomato cell culture in response to camptotecin and cadmium and in response to P. syringae pv. tabaci respectively has been described and discussed. Hypersensitive response has been reviewed as a form of plant PCD representing the defence against diseases and some of the major biochemical features of HR have been discussed. The importance of studies on HR in terms of manipulation the disease resistance in plants has been outlined. Studies on plant PCD have been demonstrated to provide a clue to better understanding the process in plants and to establish the evolutionary aspects of PCD similarities through animal and plant kingdoms.

A plant caspase-like protease activated during the hypersensitive response.

To test the hypothesis that caspase-like proteases exist and are critically involved in the implementation of programmed cell death (PCD) in plants, a search was undertaken for plant caspases activated during the N gene-mediated hypersensitive response (HR; a form of pathogen-induced PCD in plants) in tobacco plants infected with Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). For detection, characterization, and partial purification of a tobacco caspase, the Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirD2 protein, shown here to be cleaved specifically at two sites (TATD and GEQD) by human caspase-3, was used as a target. In tobacco leaves, specific proteolytic processing of the ectopically produced VirD2 derivatives at these sites was found to occur early in the course of the HR triggered by TMV. A proteolytic activity capable of specifically cleaving the model substrate at TATD was partially purified from these leaves. A tetrapeptide aldehyde designed and synthesized on the basis of the elucidated plant caspase cleavage site prevented fragmentation of the substrate protein by plant and human caspases in vitro and counteracted TMV-triggered HR in vivo. Therefore, our data provide a characterization of caspase-specific protein fragmentation in apoptotic plant cells, with implications for the importance of such activity in the implementation of plant PCD.

Transgenic tobacco plants with reduced capability to detoxify reactive oxygen intermediates are hyperresponsive to pathogen infection.

Reactive oxygen intermediates (ROI) play a critical role in the defense of plants against invading pathogens. Produced during the "oxidative burst," they are thought to activate programmed cell death (PCD) and induce antimicrobial defenses such as pathogenesis-related proteins. It was shown recently that during the interaction of plants with pathogens, the expression of ROI-detoxifying enzymes such as ascorbate peroxidase (APX) and catalase (CAT) is suppressed. It was suggested that this suppression, occurring upon pathogen recognition and coinciding with an enhanced rate of ROI production, plays a key role in elevating cellular ROI levels, thereby potentiating the induction of PCD and other defenses. To examine the relationship between the suppression of antioxidative mechanisms and the induction of PCD and other defenses during pathogen attack, we studied the interaction between transgenic antisense tobacco plants with reduced APX or CAT and a bacterial pathogen that triggers the hypersensitive response. Transgenic plants with reduced capability to detoxify ROI (i.e., antisense APX or CAT) were found to be hyperresponsive to pathogen attack. They activated PCD in response to low amounts of pathogens that did not trigger the activation of PCD in control plants. Our findings support the hypothesis that suppression of ROI-scavenging enzymes during the hypersensitive response plays an important role in enhancing pathogen-induced PCD.

Signals controlling the expression of cytosolic ascorbate peroxidase during pathogen-induced programmed cell death in tobacco.

In plants ascorbate peroxidase (APX) is an important H2O2-detoxifying enzyme. The expression of APX is rapidly induced in response to stresses that result in the accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). We have recently reported that the steady-state level of transcripts encoding cytosolic APX (cAPX) is dramatically induced during the hypersensitive response (HR) of tobacco plants infected with tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). Because cAPX expression is closely linked to the production of ROS in plant cells, studying the regulation cAPX mRNA can reveal some of the signal transduction events associated with ROS metabolism during the HR. Analysis of cAPX mRNA induction during the HR suggested that the expression of cAPX is under the control of the HR signal transduction pathway. The activation of cAPX expression followed signaling events such as changes in protein phosphorylation and induction of ion fluxes. Expression of cAPX was suppressed under conditions of low oxygen pressure, and could only be mimicked by enhancing the intracellular generation of ROS. Interestingly, salicylic acid (SA), which is thought to be involved in ROS metabolism during the HR, did not affect the induction of cAPX mRNA during TMV-induced HR. Using cAPX expression as a marker for the production of ROS, it is suggested that SA may not be involved in the formation of ROS during the HR of tobacco to TMV, and that ROS may not be involved in the induction of the pathogenesis-related protein, PR-1, during this process.

Post-Transcriptional Suppression of Cytosolic Ascorbate Peroxidase Expression during Pathogen-Induced Programmed Cell Death in Tobacco

Post-Transcriptional Suppression of Cytosolic Ascorbate Peroxidase Expression during Pathogen-Induced Programmed Cell Death in Tobacco

Post-transcriptional suppression of cytosolic ascorbate peroxidase expression during pathogen-induced programmed cell death in tobacco.

As a means to eliminate pathogen-infected cells and prevent diseases, programmed cell death (PCD) appears to be a defense strategy employed by most multicellular organisms. Recent studies have indicated that reactive oxygen species, such as O2.- and H2O2, play a central role in the activation and propagation of pathogen-induced PCD in plants. However, plants contain several mechanisms that detoxify O2.- and H2O2 and may inhibit PCD. We found that during viral-induced PCD in tobacco, the expression of cytosolic ascorbate peroxidase (cAPX), a key H2O2 detoxifying enzyme, is post-transcriptionally suppressed. Thus, although the steady state level of transcripts encoding cAPX was induced during PCD, as expected under conditions of elevated H2O2, the level of the cAPX protein declined. In vivo protein labeling, followed by immunoprecipitation, indicated that the synthesis of the cAPX protein was inhibited. Although transcripts encoding cAPX were found to associate with polysomes during PCD, no cAPX protein was detected after in vitro polysome run-off assays. Our findings suggest that viral-induced PCD in tobacco is accompanied by the suppression of cAPX expression, possibly at the level of translation elongation. This suppression is likely to contribute to a reduction in the capability of cells to scavenge H2O2, which in turn enables the accumulation of H2O2 and the acceleration of PCD.

Pathogen-induced programmed cell death in tobacco.

Sacrificing an infected cell or cells in order to prevent systemic spread of a pathogen appears to be a conserved strategy in both plants and animals. We studied some of the morphological and biochemical events that accompany programmed cell death during the hypersensitive response of tobacco plants infected with tobacco mosaic virus. Certain aspects of this cell death process appeared to be similar to those that take place during apoptosis in animal cells. These included condensation and vacuolization of the cytoplasm and cleavage of nuclear DNA to 50 kb fragments. In contrast, internucleosomal fragmentation, condensation of chromatin at the nuclear periphery and apoptotic bodies were not observed in tobacco plants during tobacco mosaic virus-induced hypersensitive response. A unique aspect of programmed cell death during the hypersensitive response of tobacco to tobacco mosaic virus involved an increase in the amount of monomeric chloroplast DNA. Morphological changes to the chloroplast and cytosol of tobacco cells and increase in monomeric chloroplast DNA occurred prior to gross changes in nuclear morphology and significant chromatin cleavage. Our findings suggest that certain aspects of programmed cell death may have been conserved during the evolution of plants and animals.

Pathogen-induced programmed cell death in plants, a possible defense mechanism.

As much as the definition of life may be controversial, the definition of death also may prove problematic. In recent years it became apparent that the death of a living cell may follow more than one possible scenario: it may result from an externally applied physical injury (an accidental death), or it may be the outcome of activating an internal pathway for cell suicide (a programmed death). That cells can participate in their own execution may indicate that certain types of cell deaths that were previously considered to be caused by foreign agents such as pathogens or drugs may actually result from the activation of a programmed cell death pathway that is normally latent in cells. Here, we describe the activation of such a cell suicide pathway in plant cells upon the recognition of an invading pathogen. We discuss the possible use of this pathway as a defense mechanism against infection and the possibility that in many ways the use of this type of cell death in plants is functionally analogous to that used by mammalian cells in response to infection by pathogens.

Sacrifice in the face of foes: pathogen-induced programmed cell death in plants.

Inhibition of pathogen growth during the defense of plants is thought to involve a rapid process of cell death localized to the site of invasion. Recent studies suggest that the death of plant cells during this 'hypersensitive response' process is likely to result from the activation of a programmed cell death pathway.