Parallel Cascade Selection Molecular Dynamics Research Articles

Preferential Door for Ligand Binding and Unbinding Pathways in Inhibited Human Acetylcholinesterase.

Rising global population and increased food demands have resulted in the increased use of organophosphate pesticides (OPs), leading to toxin accumulation and transmission to humans. Pralidoxime (2-PAM), an FDA-approved drug, serves as an antidote for OP therapy. However, the atomic-level detoxification mechanisms regarding the design of novel antidotes remain unclear. This is the first study to examine the binding and unbinding pathways of 2-PAM to human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) through three identified doors using an enhanced sampling method called ligand-binding parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (LB-PaCS-MD). Remarkably, LB-PaCS-MD could identify a predominant in-line binding mechanism through the acyl door at 63.79% ± 6.83%, also implicating it in a potential unbinding route (90.14% ± 4.22%). Interestingly, crucial conformational shifts in key residues, W86, Y341, and Y449, and the Ω loop significantly affect door dynamics and ligand binding modes. The LB-PaCS-MD technique can study ligand-binding pathways, thereby contributing to the design of antidotes and covalent drugs.

Development of Membrane Permeability Coefficient by Means of Novel Molecular Dynamics Methods

The membrane permeability, and its evaluation, is crucial factor in the process of uptake of compounds from outside to inside the cell and in the inhibition of the activity of disease-causing target proteins. Although molecular dynamics (MD) simulations have been shown to be able to reproduce the conformational changes of compounds occurring during membrane permeation, it is still challenging to extract the membrane permeability at an affordable computational workload solely by conventional MD. Indeed, the time scale accessible by MD is far below the one characterizing the actual permeation process. Phenomena occurring in living organisms escaping the reach of standard MD are generally referred to as biological rare events, and the membrane permeation process is one of them. To overcome this time-scale problem, several enhanced sampling methods have been proposed over the years to improve conformational sampling. In this review, a hybrid sampling method that combines the parallel cascade selection MD (PaCS-MD) and the outlier flooding method (OFLOOD), introduced and developed by our group, is proposed as a tool to study the membrane permeation from structural sampling (rare-event sampling). The obtained trajectories are used to estimate the free energy profiles for the membrane permeation and to compute the membrane permeation coefficients. Moreover, we present an example of application of the free energy reaction network method as a versatile way for incorporating explicitly into reaction coordinates the degrees of freedom related to internal motion.

Energetic and Kinetic Origins of CALB Interfacial Activation Revealed by PaCS-MD/MSM.

The conformational dynamics of Candida antarctica lipase B (CALB) was investigated by molecular dynamics (MD) simulation, parallel cascade selection MD (PaCS-MD), and the Markov state model (MSM) and mainly focused on the lid-opening motion closely related to substrate binding. All-atom MD simulation of CALB was conducted in water and on the interface of water and tricaprylin. CALB initially situated in water and separated by layers of water from the interface is spontaneously adsorbed onto the tricaprylin surface during MD simulation. The opening and closing motions of the lid are simulated by PaCS-MD, and subsequent MSM analysis provided the free-energy landscape and time scale of the conformational transitions among the closed, semiopen, and open states. The closed state is the most stable in the water system, but the stable conformation in the interface system shifts to the semiopen state. These effects could explain the energetics and kinetics origin of the previously reported interfacial activation of CALB. These findings could help expand the application of CALB toward a wide variety of substrates.

A Structural Refinement Technique for Protein-RNA Complexes Based on a Combination of AI-based Modeling and Flexible Docking: A Study of Musashi-1 Protein

Abstract An efficient structural refinement technique for protein-RNA complexes is proposed based on a combination of AI-based modeling and flexible docking. Specifically, an enhanced sampling method called parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (PaCS-MD) was extended to include flexible docking to construct protein-RNA complexes from those obtained by AI-based modeling (AlphaFold2). With the present technique, the conformational sampling of flexible RNA regions is accelerated by PaCS-MD, enabling one to construct plausible models for protein-RNA complexes. For demonstration, PaCS-MD constructed several protein-RNA complexes of the RNA-binding Musashi-1 (MSI1) family of proteins, which were validated by comparing a group of crucial residues for RNA-binding with experimental complexes. Our analyses suggest that PaCS-MD improves the quality of complex modeling compared to the standard protocol based on template-based modeling (Phyre2). Furthermore, PaCS-MD could also be a beneficial technique for constructing complexes of non-native RNA-binding to proteins.

Molecular Simulation to Investigate Open-Close Motion of a Flagellar Export Apparatus Protein FlhAC.

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation and parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (PaCS-MD) are widely used to investigate large-amplitude motions of proteins. PaCS-MD is an enhanced conformational sampling method consisting of cycles of parallel unbiased MD simulations combined with a selection of MD snapshots as the initial structures for the next cycle. In addition, free energy calculation can be achieved by the combination of PaCS-MD and the Markov state model (MSM). In this chapter, the protocols to investigate the open-close motion of a flagellar export apparatus protein, FlhAC, by MD and the combination of PaCS-MD and MSM are described.

Free-Energy Profiles for Membrane Permeation of Compounds Calculated Using Rare-Event Sampling Methods.

The free-energy profile of a compound is an essential measurement in evaluating the membrane permeation process by means of theoretical methods. Computationally, molecular dynamics (MD) simulation allows the free-energy profile calculation. However, MD simulations frequently fail to sample membrane permeation because they are rare events induced in longer timescales than the accessible timescale of MD, leading to an insufficient conformational search to calculate an incorrect free-energy profile. To achieve a sufficient conformational search, several enhanced sampling methods have been developed and elucidated the membrane permeation process. In addition to these enhanced sampling methods, we proposed a simple yet powerful free-energy calculation of a compound for the membrane permeation process based on originally rare-event sampling methods developed by us. Our methods have a weak dependency on external biases and their optimizations to promote the membrane permeation process. Based on distributed computing, our methods only require the selection of initial structures and their conformational resampling, whereas the enhanced sampling methods may be required to adjust external biases. Furthermore, our methods efficiently search membrane permeation processes with simple scripts without modifying any MD program. As demonstrations, we calculated the free-energy profiles of seven linear compounds for their membrane permeation based on a hybrid conformational search using two rare-event sampling methods, that is, (1) parallel cascade selection MD (PaCS-MD) and (2) outlier flooding method (OFLOOD), combined with a Markov state model (MSM) construction. In the first step, PaCS-MD generated initial membrane permeation paths of a compound. In the second step, OFLOOD expanded the unsearched conformational area around the initial paths, allowing for a broad conformational search. Finally, the trajectories were employed to construct reliable MSMs, enabling correct free-energy profile calculations. Furthermore, we estimated the membrane permeability coefficients of all compounds by constructing the reliable MSMs for their membrane permeation. In conclusion, the calculated coefficients were qualitatively correlated with the experimental measurements (correlation coefficient (R2) = 0.8689), indicating that the hybrid conformational search successfully calculated the free-energy profiles and membrane permeability coefficients of the seven compounds.

Inhibition of the hexamerization of SARS-CoV-2 endoribonuclease and modeling of RNA structures bound to the hexamer

Non-structural protein 15 (Nsp15) of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) forms a homo hexamer and functions as an endoribonuclease. Here, we propose that Nsp15 activity may be inhibited by preventing its hexamerization through drug binding. We first explored the stable conformation of the Nsp15 monomer as the global free energy minimum conformation in the free energy landscape using a combination of parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (PaCS-MD) and the Markov state model (MSM), and found that the Nsp15 monomer forms a more open conformation with larger druggable pockets on the surface. Targeting the pockets with high druggability scores, we conducted ligand docking and identified compounds that tightly bind to the Nsp15 monomer. The top poses with Nsp15 were subjected to binding free energy calculations by dissociation PaCS-MD and MSM (dPaCS-MD/MSM), indicating the stability of the complexes. One of the identified pockets, which is distinctively bound by inosine analogues, may be an alternative binding site to stabilize viral RNA binding and/or an alternative catalytic site. We constructed a stable RNA structure model bound to both UTP and alternative binding sites, providing a reasonable proposed model of the Nsp15/RNA complex.

Dissociation Pathways of the p53 DNA Binding Domain from DNA and Critical Roles of Key Residues Elucidated by dPaCS-MD/MSM.

p53 is a transcriptional factor that regulates cell response to a variety of stresses. About a half of all human tumors contain p53 mutations, and the accumulation of mutations in the DNA binding domain of p53 (p53-DBD) can cause destabilization of p53 and its complex with DNA. To identify the key residues of the p53-DBD/DNA binding and to understand the dissociation mechanisms of the p53-DBD/DNA complex, the dissociation process of p53-DBD from a DNA duplex that contains the consensus sequence (the specific target of p53-DBD) was investigated by a combination of dissociation parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (dPaCS-MD) and the Markov state model (MSM). This combination (dPaCS-MD/MSM) enabled us to simulate dissociation of the two large molecules based on an all-atom model with a short simulation time (11.2 ± 2.2 ns per trial) and to analyze dissociation pathways, free energy landscape (FEL), and binding free energy. Among 75 trials of dPaCS-MD, p53-DBD dissociated first from the major groove and then detached from the minor groove in 93% of the cases, while 7% of the cases unbinding from the minor groove occurred first. Minor groove binding is mainly stabilized by R248, identified as the most important residue that tightly binds deep inside the minor groove. The standard binding free energy calculated from the FEL was -10.9 ± 0.4 kcal/mol, which agrees with an experimental value of -11.1 kcal/mol. These results indicate that the dPaCS-MD/MSM combination can be a powerful tool to investigate dissociation mechanisms of two large molecules. Analysis of the p53 key residues for DNA binding indicates high correlations with cancer-related mutations, confirming that impairment of the interactions between p53-DBD and DNA can be frequently related to cancer.

Ligand Binding Path Sampling Based on Parallel Cascade Selection Molecular Dynamics: LB-PaCS-MD.

Parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (PaCS-MD) is a rare-event sampling method that generates transition pathways between a reactant and product. To sample the transition pathways, PaCS-MD repeats short-time MD simulations from important configurations as conformational resampling cycles. In this study, PaCS-MD was extended to sample ligand binding pathways toward a target protein, which is referred to as LB-PaCS-MD. In a ligand-concentrated environment, where multiple ligand copies are randomly arranged around the target protein, LB-PaCS-MD allows for the frequent sampling of ligand binding pathways. To select the important configurations, we specified the center of mass (COM) distance between each ligand and the relevant binding site of the target protein, where snapshots generated by the short-time MD simulations were ranked by their COM distance values. From each cycle, snapshots with smaller COM distance values were selected as the important configurations to be resampled using the short-time MD simulations. By repeating conformational resampling cycles, the COM distance values gradually decreased and converged to constants, meaning that a set of ligand binding pathways toward the target protein was sampled by LB-PaCS-MD. To demonstrate relative efficiency, LB-PaCS-MD was applied to several proteins, and their ligand binding pathways were sampled more frequently than conventional MD simulations.

Independent Nontargeted Parallel Cascade Selection Molecular Dynamics (Ino-PaCS-MD) to Enhance the Conformational Sampling of Proteins.

Biological functions are related to long-time protein dynamics (rare events) that are induced over microseconds. Such protein dynamics can be investigated using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. However, the detection of rare events remains challenging using conventional MD (cMD) since the accessible timescales of cMD are shorter than those of the biological functions. Recently, the parallel cascade selection MD (PaCS-MD) has been proposed to detect such rare events, wherein transition paths are generated between a given reactant and product. As an extension, the nontargeted PaCS-MD (nt-PaCS-MD) has been proposed to predict the transition paths without requiring reference to any product. Thus, as a further extension, we herein propose independent nt-PaCS-MD, namely, Ino-PaCS-MD, wherein multiple walkers are launched from a set of different starting configurations. Each walker repeats a cycle of restarting short-time MD simulations from configurations with high potentials for making transitions to neighboring metastable states. To further enhance the sampling ability, Ino-PaCS-MD temporarily stops the conformational search and periodically resets the starting configurations so that they are uniformly distributed in a conformational subspace, thereby preventing a given protein from being trapped in one of the metastable states. As a demonstration, Ino-PaCS-MD successfully detects rare events of a maltose-binding protein as open-close transitions with a nanosecond-order simulation time, although a microsecond-order cMD simulation failed to detect these rare events, showing the high sampling efficiency of Ino-PaCS-MD.

Binding free energy of protein/ligand complexes calculated using dissociation Parallel Cascade Selection Molecular Dynamics and Markov state model.

We recently proposed a computational procedure to simulate the dissociation of protein/ligand complexes using the dissociation Parallel Cascade Selection Molecular Dynamics simulation (dPaCS-MD) method and to analyze the generated trajectories using the Markov state model (MSM). This procedure, called dPaCS-MD/MSM, enables calculation of the dissociation free energy profile and the standard binding free energy. To examine whether this method can reproduce experimentally determined binding free energies for a variety of systems, we used it to investigate the dissociation of three protein/ligand complexes: trypsin/benzamine, FKBP/FK506, and adenosine A2A receptor/T4E. First, dPaCS-MD generated multiple dissociation pathways within a reasonable computational time for all the complexes, although the complexes differed significantly in the size of the molecules and in intermolecular interactions. Subsequent MSM analyses produced free energy profiles for the dissociations, which provided insights into how each ligand dissociates from the protein. The standard binding free energies obtained by dPaCS-MD/MSM are in good agreement with experimental values for all the complexes. We conclude that dPaCS-MD/MSM can accurately calculate the binding free energies of these complexes.

Erratum: "Edge expansion parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics simulation for investigating large-amplitude collective motions of proteins" [J. Chem. Phys. 152, 225101 (2020)

First Page

The Folding of Trp-cage is Regulated by Stochastic Flip of the Side Chain of Tryptophan

Abstract Trp-cage is an artificial 20-residue protein and forms a hydrophobic core at its central cage upon folding. In the present study, the folding of Trp-cage was addressed by parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (PaCS-MD). Our results of PaCS-MD indicate that flip of the side chain of tryptophan (W6) was correlated with the overall folding. In conclusion, flip of stochastic side chain of W6 regulates the folding into the native or mis-folded states of Trp-cage.

Enhanced Conformational Sampling Method Based on Anomaly Detection Parallel Cascade Selection Molecular Dynamics: ad-PaCS-MD.

In the present study, we propose a rare-event sampling method called anomaly detection parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (ad-PaCS-MD). The original PaCS-MD was designed to generate conformational transition pathways from a given reactant to a product when the latter is known a priori. As an extension of the original method, ad-PaCS-MD has been designed to efficiently search transition pathways from a given reactant without referring to a given product. In ad-PaCS-MD, rarely occurring but essential states (configurations) of proteins for the transitions are identified based on the degrees of an anomaly. In more detail, ad-PaCS-MD adopts an algorithm called an anomaly detection generative adversarial network (anoGAN) as a measure for detecting rarely occurring states to be resampled. Here, the essential configurations with higher degrees of the anomaly are selected with anoGAN and intensively resampled by restarting short-time MD simulations from the selected configurations. By repeating the detections and resampling of configurations with the higher degrees of the anomaly, ad-PaCS-MD automatically and efficiently promotes the rare events and gives a wide range of the free energy landscape by combining with the Markov state model construction. As demonstrations, open-closed transitions of two globular proteins (T4 lysozyme and maltose-binding protein) were promoted with ad-PaCS-MD by referring only to the given starting configurations. In each demonstration, ad-PaCS-MD promoted the large-amplitude open-closed transitions with nanosecond-order simulation times. In conclusion, our demonstrations showed a higher conformational sampling efficiency for ad-PaCS-MD than conventional MD (CMD) because CMD required computational costs of more than microsecond-order simulation times to promote the rare events.

Rearrangements of Water Molecules in Parallel Cascade Selection Molecular Dynamics Enhance Structural Explorations of Proteins

Abstract Biological events of proteins are too infrequent to observe with molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, though they are strongly related to the biological functions. To detect such rare events, several enhanced sampling methods have been proposed. Recently, as one of the enhanced sampling methods, we have developed parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (PaCS-MD). PaCS-MD performs short-time MDs repeatedly from initial structures selected by a given rule as a function of arbitrary reaction coordinates. In the present study, the conventional PaCS-MD is extended as UCHMZ-PaCS-MD, where water coordinates are rearranged before restarting the short-time MDs, which perturb a given system by generating a variety of initial configurations. The restart of short-time MDs from the perturbed systems enables us to further enhance the conformational search. As a demonstration, UCHMZ-PaCS-MD was applied to folding of Chignolin and efficiently identified several metastable states including the intermediate, the misfolding, and the native ones. Furthermore, as a demonstration for globular proteins, large-amplitude domain motions of T4 lysozyme and adenylate kinase were efficiently detected with UCHMZ-PaCS-MD. Additionally, the generated transition pathways were analyzed with Markov state models (MSMs), enabling us to calculate broader free energy landscapes compared with the conventional PaCS-MD.

Efficient Conformational Sampling of Collective Motions of Proteins with Principal Component Analysis-Based Parallel Cascade Selection Molecular Dynamics.

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation has become a powerful tool because it provides a time series of protein dynamics at high temporal-spatial resolution. However, the accessible timescales of MD simulation are shorter than those of the biologically rare events. Generally, long-time MD simulations over microseconds are required to detect the rare events. Therefore, it is desirable to develop rare-event-sampling methods. For a rare-event-sampling method, we have developed parallel cascade selection MD (PaCS-MD). PaCS-MD generates transition pathways from a given source structure to a target structure by repeating short-time MD simulations. The key point in PaCS-MD is how to select reasonable candidates (protein configurations) with high potentials to make transitions toward the target structure. In the present study, based on principal component analysis (PCA), we propose PCA-based PaCS-MD to detect rare events of collective motions of a given protein. Here, the PCA-based PaCS-MD is composed of the following two steps. At first, as a preliminary run, PCA is performed using an MD trajectory from the target structure to define a principal coordinate (PC) subspace for describing the collective motions of interest. PCA provides principal modes as eigenvectors to project a protein configuration onto the PC subspace. Then, as a production run, all the snapshots of short-time MD simulations are ranked by inner products (IPs), where an IP is defined between a snapshot and the target structure. Then, snapshots with higher values of the IP are selected as reasonable candidates, and short-time MD simulations are independently restarted from them. By referring to the values of the IP, the PCA-based PaCS-MD repeats the short-time MD simulations from the reasonable candidates that are highly correlated with the target structure. As a demonstration, we applied the PCA-based PaCS-MD to adenylate kinase and detected its large-amplitude (open-closed) transition with a nanosecond-order computational cost.

Regenerations of Initial Velocities in Parallel Cascade Selection Molecular Dynamics (PaCS-MD) Enhance the Conformational Transitions of Proteins

Parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (PaCS-MD) is a rare event sampling method. PaCS-MD repeats cycles of resampling from important initial structures based on short-time MD simulations. When restarting the short-time MD simulations, regenerations of the initial velocities play an essential role in creating perturbations to promote conformational transitions. Therefore, we addressed the conformational sampling efficiencies of PaCS-MDs with and without the regenerations of initial velocities by modeling the folding of a mini-protein (Chignolin) in explicit water. In the present letter, we confirmed that the regenerations of initial velocities increased the conformational sampling efficiency of PaCS-MD.

Edge expansion parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics simulation for investigating large-amplitude collective motions of proteins.

We propose edge expansion parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (eePaCS-MD) as an efficient adaptive conformational sampling method to investigate the large-amplitude motions of proteins without prior knowledge of the conformational transitions. In this method, multiple independent MD simulations are iteratively conducted from initial structures randomly selected from the vertices of a multi-dimensional principal component subspace. This subspace is defined by an ensemble of protein conformations sampled during previous cycles of eePaCS-MD. The edges and vertices of the conformational subspace are determined by solving the "convex hull problem." The sampling efficiency of eePaCS-MD is achieved by intensively repeating MD simulations from the vertex structures, which increases the probability of rare event occurrence to explore new large-amplitude collective motions. The conformational sampling efficiency of eePaCS-MD was assessed by investigating the open-close transitions of glutamine binding protein, maltose/maltodextrin binding protein, and adenylate kinase and comparing the results to those obtained using related methods. In all cases, the open-close transitions were simulated in ∼10 ns of simulation time or less, offering 1-3 orders of magnitude shorter simulation time compared to conventional MD. Furthermore, we show that the combination of eePaCS-MD and accelerated MD can further enhance conformational sampling efficiency, which reduced the total computational cost of observing the open-close transitions by at most 36%.

High pressure inhibits signaling protein binding to the flagellar motor and bacterial chemotaxis through enhanced hydration

High pressure below 100 MPa interferes inter-molecular interactions without causing pressure denaturation of proteins. In Escherichia coli, the binding of the chemotaxis signaling protein CheY to the flagellar motor protein FliM induces reversal of the motor rotation. Using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and parallel cascade selection MD (PaCS-MD), we show that high pressure increases the water density in the first hydration shell of CheY and considerably induces water penetration into the CheY-FliM interface. PaCS-MD enabled us to observe pressure-induced dissociation of the CheY-FliM complex at atomic resolution. Pressure dependence of binding free energy indicates that the increase of pressure from 0.1 to 100 MPa significantly weakens the binding. Using high-pressure microscopy, we observed that high hydrostatic pressure fixes the motor rotation to the counter-clockwise direction. In conclusion, the application of pressure enhances hydration of the proteins and weakens the binding of CheY to FliM, preventing reversal of the flagellar motor.

Nontargeted Parallel Cascade Selection Molecular Dynamics Based on a Nonredundant Selection Rule for Initial Structures Enhances Conformational Sampling of Proteins.

Nontargeted parallel cascade selection molecular dynamics (nt-PaCS-MD) is a method for enhanced conformational sampling of proteins. To search a broad conformational subspace, nt-PaCS-MD repeats cycles of conformational resampling from relevant initial structures. Generally, the conformational sampling efficiency of nt-PaCS-MD depends on a selection rule for the initial structures. In the original nt-PaCS-MD, the initial structures were selected by referring to structural distributions of protein configurations generated by conformational resampling (multiple short-time MD simulations). However, their structural redundancy among the initial structures was neglected for the cycles of conformational resampling, indicating that similar protein configurations might be frequently specified and resampled in every cycle in the original nt-PaCS-MD. To reduce the possibility of resampling from redundant initial structures, we propose an alternative selection rule that accounts for structural similarity among the initial structures. Specifically, a pairwise root-mean-square deviation (RMSD) is defined for all of the initial structures selected for all of the past cycles. Then a set of protein configurations with a larger pairwise RMSD is sequentially specified and resampled in the next cycle, which is regarded to as a history-dependent selection of initial structures by considering a profile of the past specified initial structures. The present scheme, termed extended nt-PaCS-MD, prevents us from resampling a set of redundant protein configurations. To check the conformational sampling efficiency of the extended nt-PaCS-MD, we used a middle-sized protein, T4 lysozyme, in explicit water. Through the assessment, this extended nt-PaCS-MD identified the open-closed transitions of T4 lysozyme more efficiently than the original nt-PaCS-MD.