Extensions to the first and second theorems of Pappus are presented, whereby the centroid of a surface or solid of revolution can be determined using only the geometric properties of the generating plane curve or figure and the arc of revolution. The derivations are well suited to first-year-level courses in mathematics and engineering. From a didactic perspective, the resulting formulas are simple to apply, especially since the required geometric properties are typically available in standard tables of plane sections or relatively routine to derive. Furthermore, the formulas provide a general scaffold for students to attempt problems involving axisymmetric bodies while also reinforcing and embedding their knowledge of the properties of the generating plane shapes. A selection of illustrative problems is discussed that are generally regarded to be challenging for introductory mechanics courses but for which the formulas derived in this article provide straightforward solutions.