Abstract Background Subaortic pannus formation complicates bioprosthetic aortic valve(AV) replacement. We report an extreme case in a continuous-flow left-ventricular-assist-device(LVAD) patient. Case Summary A 49-year-old Caucasian female with dilated cardiomyopathy was bridged-to-transplant with a HeartWare ventricular-assist-device(HVAD). Duration of support was prolonged, 6-years and 7-months, due to allosensitisation requiring desensitisation. Pump thrombosis occurred 2-years and 4-months post-LVAD requiring alteplase thrombolysis. The patient underwent bioprosthetic AV replacement 3-years and 10-months post-LVAD for symptomatic aortic incompetence. Transthoracic echocardiography(TTE) performed 1-year and 2-years post-bioprosthetic AV replacement repeatedly demonstrated an AV closed during all cardiac cycles without incompetence and nil flow through the left-ventricular-outflow-tract(LVOT). Following transplant, analysis of explanted heart revealed a fused AV. A pannus adherent to the underside of the AV had formed across the entire AV outlet, with complete obliteration of LVOT. This subaortic pannus was not visualised on previous TTE. Histologically, the pannus consisted of hypocellular fibrous tissue with chronic inflammatory cells, spindle histiocytes and myofibroblasts scattered throughout the loose fibromyxoid stroma, the latter highlighted on CD68 immunohistochemical stain(IHC). Partial endothelialisation on the pannus surface was highlighted on ERG & CD31 IHC. Neither calcification, nor signs of acute inflammation were noted. In contrast to previous cases, there was no evidence of associated thrombus macroscopically or microscopically. Discussion Prolonged LVAD support may facilitate subaortic pannus following bioprosthetic AV replacement due to AV closure and altered transvalvular flow. Due to the parallel LVAD circulation, subaortic pannus may develop asymptomatically, without haemodynamic compromise, allowing progression to total LVOT obstruction. This requires consideration prior to LVAD explantation in bridge-to-recovery patients.