Mechanical deformation of skin creates variations in fluid chemical potential, leading to local changes in hydrostatic and osmotic pressure, whose effects on mechanobiology remain poorly understood. To study these effects, we investigate the specific influences of hydrostatic and osmotic pressure on primary human dermal fibroblasts in three-dimensional hydrogel culture models. Cyclic hydrostatic pressure and hyperosmotic stress enhanced the percentage of cells expressing the proliferation marker Ki67 in both collagen and PEG-based hydrogels. Osmotic pressure also activated the p38 MAPK stress response pathway and increased the expression of the osmoresponsive genes PRSS35 and NFAT5. When cells were cultured in two-dimension (2D), no change in proliferation was observed with either hydrostatic or osmotic pressure. Furthermore, basal, and osmotic pressure-induced expression of osmoresponsive genes differed in 2D culture versus 3D hydrogels, highlighting the role of dimensionality in skin cell mechanotransduction and stressing the importance of 3D tissue-like models that better replicate in vivo conditions. Overall, these results indicate that fluid chemical potential changes affect dermal fibroblast mechanobiology, which has implications for skin function and for tissue regeneration strategies.