Fecal contamination threatens human health and contributes to the eutrophication of water resources. In Oklahoma, approximately 75% of assessed stream miles in the state are listed as impaired for fecal indicator bacteria (FIB). We tested the performance of seven microbial source tracking (MST) markers in six Northeast Oklahoma streams. All samples were tested with human (HF183), bovine (COWM2, COWM3), porcine (Pig-2-Bac), avian (Av4143), Escherichia coli, and Enterococcus markers using digital PCR (dPCR), as well as culturable assays for E. coli (Colisure) and Enterococcus (Enterolert). Rural and agricultural land uses were characterized by bovine sources of bacterial contamination. Human fecal contamination was found to be prominent in developed landscapes with several indicators for chronic human fecal pollution in an urban stream. All the streams met the criterion for Enterococcus impairment in 2019 and 2020; however, we found no relationships between culturable Enterococcus and the MST markers except in the urban stream, which had chronic human fecal pollution issues. The urban stream met the criterion for E. coli impairment, and E. coli was significantly correlated with the dominant MST markers in both rural and urban streams. We find that the culturable Enterococcus assay is not specific enough to be used for FIB water quality standards. We support the continued use of culturable E. coli assays to monitor for fecal contamination, and we recommend following-up with MST to verify fecal sources so informed mitigative actions can be taken to improve stream water quality.
Read full abstract