Anthropogenic fire exclusion has contributed to forest structural and compositional shifts, resulting in the encroachment of shade-tolerant, often fire-sensitive and/or opportunistic species throughout forest ecosystems. In the central and eastern U.S., encroaching species often exhibit fire-suppressing leaf litter and crown traits, reducing prescribed fire efficacy to restore and maintain fire-dependent mixed pine (Pinus spp.) and oak (Quercus spp.) forests. Despite fire’s natural role in these forests, management using prescribed fire alone is unlikely to reverse encroachment impacts due to the degree of forest change since fire exclusion. Consequently, additional management techniques (e.g., chemical, mechanical) are often combined with fire to ensure persistence of pine-oak mixtures and their associated ecosystem services. In current-day degraded pine-oak mixtures in the southeastern U.S., where no one species represents > 75% dominance by stand basal area, encroaching species (e.g., Liquidambar styraciflua, Quercus nigra) commonly form a dense midstory and occupy overstory positions. To quantify how encroaching species in degraded mixed pine-oak forests impact fuels, canopy cover, and seasonal fire behavior, we thinned the midstory (<20 cm DBH) of all non-pyrophytic species in 12 0.10-ha blocks within a mixed pine-oak stand at the Mary Olive Thomas Demonstration Forest (Auburn, Alabama, USA) in July 2021. Midstory thinning reduced basal area by 6.7 m2 ha−1 and canopy cover by 9.1%. In general, midstory thinning reduced shrub and fine woody debris fuel loads while having no impact on herbaceous, leaf litter, and duff fuel loads. When compared to pre-treatment levels, midstory thinning increased the relative proportion of pine leaf litter contribution to the fuelbed by 10.9% while reducing that of encroaching species by 11.4%. Despite changes to residual basal area, canopy cover, and leaf litter contribution, midstory thinning had no statistical impact on fire behavior, regardless of burn season. Early (January) and late dormant season (April) experimental fires had higher fireline intensities, consumed more surface fuels, had faster rates of spread, and higher average maximum temperatures compared to growing season (September) fires. We also noted an increase in these fire parameters with increased pine litter contribution to the fuelbed. In degraded pine-oak mixtures where encroaching species now occupy overstory canopy positions, we recommend investigating the efficacy of more intense thinning treatments that remove overstory individuals with known fire-suppressing traits to have a larger impact on canopy openness, fuels, and fire behavior.
Read full abstract